7 ms·
Social Psychology Is A Flamethrower
- gravity13 12y ago| The best research in social psychology is as well-supported as anything in physics or biology Nope.
- mikevm 12y agoI am not sure why you are being downvoted, as the author himself first says: The best research in social psychology is as well-supported as anything in physics or biology, and much more intuitively comprehensible. And then he follows it up with: Social psychology experiments in the laboratory tend to throw up spectacular mind-boggling effects. Many of these fail to replicate and are later discredited. The ones that do replicate are not always generalizable – sometimes an even slightly different situation will remove the effect or create exactly the opposite effect. The effects that remain robust in the laboratory may be too short-lasting or too specific to have any importance in real life. And the ones that do matter in real life may respond unpredictably or even paradoxically to attempts to control them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- taber 12y agoHe was downvoted due to lack of evidence and his casual dismissal of a point in the article. This isn't reddit, as easy as it is to see an unsubstantiated point in the OP and reply with an equally baseless retort, it doesn't help any of us learn more. Your comment, on the other hand does point out apparent contradictions in the OP, and thus is useful
- WalterSear 12y agoFormer social scientist here. Can confirm.
- postnihilism 12y agoOn HN yes, but if this were reddit you might negate.
- cinquemb 12y agoMost people are not consequentialists, but most people feel implicitly uncomfortable making moral arguments on non-consequentialist grounds. “Stop what you’re doing, it disgusts and offends me” is less noble than “stop what you’re doing, it will hurt people who can’t stand up for themselves”. I hear "arguments" like this all the time against data-mining public information and crowd sourcing and making it open on our site (and through an API) through our feedback and they make me chuckle seeing how they had to engage and co-opt a multitude of psychological/behavioral theories not drafted by themselves to say such things. Even more funnier is when the things they are protesting has been done in "private" for a very long time. Kind of reminds me of how the whole Snowden thing plays out on HN and in the general culture at large, despite the mumblings of such since the very beginning… quite amusing to say the least…
- forgottenpass 12y agoquite amusing to say the least… Ah, yes, quite droll that people who don't make money from the thing I make money from have different moral opinions on it. Very amusing indeed. Because, of course, they're obviously wrong. And they use other people's words when arguing their point? I'd point out that this is how just how ideas pass through society, but I'll settle for laughing at the fact you see unaware that you're also doing exactly that in your post.
- cinquemb 12y agoOnly if we all could conflate stating observed interactions with arguing a point like you just did exactly in your post, we all could laugh at ourselves more. :D I guess those who think they are morally right can just give themselves a big round of applause while they continue to engage in behaviors that act against such moral beliefs, whether they are willing to admit that to themselves or not and I'll just keep exploring the infinite. :D
- TeMPOraL 12y agoSo a friend of mine just shared a survey from a student of social sciences on Facebook. The survey is concerned with stress levels of kids between age of 13 and 16, and is targeted to them. The data is to be used as a basis for a bachelor's thesis. The first thing I learned is that my friend actually took part in the survey by "putting herself in the mindframe of a 13-year-old and filling it in as the kid would". After a short discussion about how doing so turns the whole thesis into pile of nonsense, she (herself a graduate from a liberal arts college) told me that the survey author was actually one of the better student in that she actually made the survey - as most people fill the surveys themselves or just make the data up. So things like these give me trust issues with all the "soft sciences". I do consider most of the sociology nonsense, because I seriously doubt that people who make up data for their thesis will suddenly turn into honest researchers after graduation. Yes, the "best research in social psychology" might be "as well-supported as anything in physics or biology", but I doubt it's more than a small part of research done, and mostly research from first principles (so there isn't much chance that the research you're basing your paper on is crap).
- judk 12y agoAn undergraduate's non-publishable homework assignment doesn't undermine a field's credibility. Plenty of physics students like myself bluffed lab data when we fried our experimental apparatus.
- hagbardgroup 12y agoActually, this also undermines the credibility of the institution that you attended. You can say "that's a small sample size," but it's indicative of larger problems at the institution that the honor code was not so internalized that bluffing the data would result in social ostracism. The 'hard' sciences in the US are developing as much of a credibility problem as its 'soft' sciences. Institutional science may not be working out for us as well as has been hoped. It's a recent establishment and may not survive without a reversal in the decay of standards.
- barry-cotter 12y ago
- iskander 12y ago>If I were a demon from Hell, charged by my infernal masters with increasing rape as much as possible, I literally could not think of a better strategy than talking about rape culture all the time. I don't understand the proposed alternative. There is a widespread disconnect between the ethical view of consent ("enthusiastic yes") and the equally common disregard of consent ("well, she only said no the first time but then got real quiet...seemed OK"). Families and friend circles often fail to support rape victims or confront rapists. We're facing a structural cultural problem, and the solution is to...not talk about it?
- Dylan16807 12y agoFirst, the proposal doesn't suggest a solution. It only suggests that one approach is flawed. Second, you can explain proper consent without lecturing on issues like lax enforcement and prevalence of rape.
- DanBC 12y agoOne alternative (which appears to work with alcohol problem drinking) is to tell people what other people like them are doing. Thus, all the newspapers and tv programmes talking about the perils of binge drinking and how everyone is drinking too much and how it's harmful to them and the nation - that just makes people think that excessive drinking is just what people do. But if you tell university students that people their age tend to drink about 8 units a week (or whatever the actual real average is) then they realise that they drink a lot more than that and start to cut down. Telling men that "most men think drunk consent is not consent" would be in line with this, and is I think what the article is talking about.
- mrgriscom 12y agoI remember those binge drinking proclamations in college and reading a few years later that they basically didn't work at all. People construct their social norms based on the behavior of those they observe around them, and particularly the people they care most about: their friends and their friends' friends, not some vague model citizen they were told about in some quasi-propagandist fashion. And if I recall the article correctly, the average they quoted wasn't even real, so in effect it was propaganda.
- DanBC 12y ago> and studies on child porn show pedophilia is less common where it’s more accessible. There's no link to the research. Does anyone have any links? I'd be interested to know of this is just more lack of reporting of crime in a country that doesn't do much about that crime.
- gwern 12y agoI don't know all the studies Yvain might have in mind, but at least one of them is "Pornography and sex crimes in the Czech Republic" http://www.researchgate.net/publication/49644341_Pornography_and_sex_crimes_in_the_Czech_Republic/file/79e415111ced447bf5.pdf http://www.researchgate.net/publication/49644341_Pornography... - one of a few papers exploiting various lapses in nations' child porn laws and observing not an increase in child sex crimes but rather decreases. You can probably find more studies by looking at related papers (http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=14325274059754433423&as_sdt=20000005&sciodt=0,21&hl=en http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=14325274059754433423...) and reverse citations (http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=related:j-vH2duYzcYJ:scholar.google.com/&hl=en&as_sdt=0,21 http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=related:j-vH2duYzcYJ:sch...) of that paper. (This is broadly similar to other correlations you may've heard about with more regular porn: porn seems to substitute for sex crimes, and not increase crimes like rape.)
- gopalv 12y agoThe issue with psychology is that double blind experiments are prone to observer effect. The behaviour often have nothing to do with reality - when measured, everything tends towards the ideal. And the experiments can often result in the results you want if the double blinds are removed. I always fall back onto the Survey from "Yes Minister" to explain how that works https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0ZZJXw4MTA#t=30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0ZZJXw4MTA#t=30s
- gwern 12y ago> The issue with psychology is that double blind experiments are prone to observer effect. You mean, 'non double blind' experiments?
- pkinsky 12y ago>Social psychology experiments in the laboratory tend to throw up spectacular mind-boggling effects. Many of these fail to replicate and are later discredited. The ones that do replicate are not always generalizable – sometimes an even slightly different situation will remove the effect or create exactly the opposite effect. Generator-based tests (as in Haskell's Quickcheck) could help here. Standard unit tests run assertions with hardcoded input values such as [0, 1, -1]. Generator based tests instead try to show that properties hold over randomly generated inputs, by replacing 1 with a generator of positive integers, -1 with a generator of negative integers, etc. Imagine if social psychologists ran generator-based studies as a hedge against unknown unknowns. The biggest challenge would be generating and executing valid permutations of the original experiment. Perhaps ad network AB-testing could be repurposed to run experiments as ads with randomly generated values.
- adrianN 12y agoThe biggest challenge would be to get funding to run many slight variations of the same experiment without clear indications that this will produce many publishable results. Getting data from humans costs many orders of magnitude more than getting data from your code.
- vacri 12y agoThey found violent movies decreased crime 5% or more on their opening weekends, and that each violent movie that comes out probably prevents about 1000 assaults. Further, there’s no displacement effect – the missing crimes don’t pop back the following week, they simply never occur. This is a very naive view of the idea that violent movies increase violence in the population - the author is acting a little surprised that the results actually show that crime goes down a little on opening weekend and doesn't change from normal in the weeks before and after. It makes no long-term analysis of the baseline; the culture of having violent movies so prominent affecting levels of violence in the population. It just shows that violent people like to go to violent movies, not that the baseline violence is increased or decreased from those movies. Reading over it again, the author is just guilty of bad journalism. The article he's quoting for this section is "Does opening weekend of violent films have an effect on violence rates?", which is a really very specific view, but is painted by the author as an incredibly broad "Violence In The Media Prevents Violent Crime". The irony is that it's the very first example given after a screed about how sloppy the field is.
- gipp 12y agoThat's the whole point of the article. He's showing that research can easily be twisted to support one conclusion or the other, and that the standards for what conclusions are acceptable to draw from social sciences research is far too low. It is not that the stuff listed there is in any way the "absolute truth".
- vacri 12y agoExcept that he does imply in the conclusion to the article that they are reasonable conclusions to make. It's not just "twist to meet a predetermined conclusion", the author is actually saying that these are reasonable and plausible arguments. I'm saying that the first example isn't plausible because the quoted study is not representative of the argument being made. It's more a comment on spin-doctoring than quality of social psych research.
- ddp26 12y agoThe author prefaces the six arguments by saying that "I think some of the arguments below will be completely correct, others correct only in certain senses and situations, and still others intriguing but wrong."
- Paradigma11 12y agoAs someone who has written his thesis in social psychology i have to say that social psychology is fundamentally broken, kaput. If you had a worker who fixed the pipes in your apartment the same way your toilet and kitchen would explode. But because we call social psychology a science we accept it somehow and hope for progress. Issues i have: 1.) What would the practical consequences be if social psychology and it's knowledge would be erased. Not many that i can think of. Considering that the area has immense potential applications this is pretty telling. 2.) What have been the most important research breakthroughs of the last 20-30 years? There are new fads for sure (behavioral economics, neuroeconomics and evolutionary psych i look at you) but they all coexist peacefully. No falsification is happening, just new profs need new theories for publication. 3.) There is NO theoretical rigor. If you do have tons of theories you would suppose that there is much theoretic work going on clarifying and contrasting this theories to enable empirical tests of their validity. Not here. The more theories the merrier. Why? Every researcher needs his own theory or not crowded field so he doesn't rock the boat. That has lead to the development that one experiment is done by two grad students and a significant result in one direction is interpreted by one theory and in the other direction by another theory. Basically you give a sample of students a questionnaire and if it goes one way it proves that XY gave an evolutionary advantage to the prehistoric people if it went the other way it proves that the utility curves cringle on the right side. Both ways the researcher has something to publish. I do think that the 2 theories per experiment limitation is rather arbitrary and inefficient tough. There is definite room for improvement here. 4.) Many recent work try to address this by going theory free. All this different effects are the result. This is also practical because there is always room for more effects to research and if you happen to need one to explain a particular fact then there are always a ton to choose from. 5.) Cargo cult use of statistics. You could make an argument that most social science researchers are not able to understand the whys and hows of statistics and decision theory so giving them recipes to follow is better than the alternative. Might be. It just does not work. It really does not. Also the imperative of the researcher is not to generate knowledge but publishable significant results. Basically i do think that we have to start over and scrap the work done so far. And no, i do not have a better alternative at hand. That is not necessary to see that the current process is broken and produces nothing useful and binds intellectual potential, tough.
- autokad 12y agoI went to a guest lecture by Michael Macy on network autocorrelation. its not fair for me to tell you what he was saying (so look him up if you want), but I will summarize. there is a lot of research done with surveys, and most of these surveys have an inherent assumption: that the people live on an island and are not autocorrelated. so he created a false network of people with random fake political views, etc and added network autocorrelation. they found that random views would cluster with demographics and were very statistically significant - but the views were random. in a similar experiment, a music sharing website to collect data on its users separated users into 'worlds'. users could see what songs were downloaded by other users within the world. and each world had its own popular songs despite being made up of random people. problem with networks (people) is that even a few missing nodes makes analyzing the network almost useless.