9 ms·
U.S. Postal Service Logging All Mail for Law Enforcement (2013)
- bediger4000 12y agoThis deserves a lot more attention than it's gotten so far. Why isn't this data used to do something for good, rather than for what we can safely presume to be evil? For instance, I'm sure we could use this data to track down every evil junkmailing sub-human "direct mail marketing" moron, publicize their contact info, and let's see how they like getting nothing but poop in their mailboxes?
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoFirst-class mail doesn't pay the bills at the USPS; junk mail does. The junk mailers are the customer, and as the saying goes about online services, "If you're not paying you're the product."
- bediger4000 12y agoI think you (and the folks making the same point below) misunderstand. The USPS is indeed part of the problem. They would also be utterly incapable of carrying out the kind of "enhanced" treatment of direct marketing "people" that's required. Since the USPS is only the instrument, giving all the postal covers to the FBI, I say let the FBI/CIA/NSA/NRO have a shot at the direct marketeers. Those organizations have demonstrated a willingness to "deviate" from the usual behaviors in the defense of Truth, Justice and The American Way. They're just the sort of folks you'd want to "handle" the Direct Marketing Association.
- pessimizer 12y agoBecause direct mail campaigns aren't crimes, and are crucial to the current funding model of USPS? They'd sooner decide to stop carrying mail from individuals, and only deliver mail from customers large enough to drop ship their mail to the local BMC in palletized presorted bundles.
- smacktoward 12y agoWe could always drop the (ridiculous) expectation that the USPS should show a profit and just fund mail delivery through our tax dollars, of course. We did things that way for nearly 200 years -- the current quasi-private incarnation of the postal service only goes back to 1970 (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_Reorganization_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_Reorganization_Act) -- and it worked pretty well. It's always amusing to hear people complaining about the USPS putting junk mailers before the rest of us. The reason the USPS does that is because we forced them to. If you take a public service and turn it into a for-profit corporation, you shouldn't be surprised when it starts looking out for the interests of those it can make the biggest profits off of.
- srs0001 12y agoUnfortunately, those direct mailers are the U.S. Postal Service's customers. There is a rather inflammatory statement from the Postmaster General in the story about the demise of Outbox. “You mentioned making the service better for our customers; but the American citizens aren’t our customers—about 400 junk mailers are our customers. Your service hurts our ability to serve those customers.” http://www.insidesources.com/outbox-vs-usps-how-the-post-office-killed-digital-mail/ http://www.insidesources.com/outbox-vs-usps-how-the-post-off...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y ago> For instance, I'm sure we could use this data to track down every evil junkmailing sub-human The USPS and junkmailers are friends. They are losing money delivering legitimate mail. Their profits come from junk mail. The USPS is the largest spammer in the world. Which makes it ironic that all the college hippies are groaning and crying that it might go under. We should just get rid of the pony express. These are the fuckholes that killed Outbox, after all.
- EricaJoy 12y ago"Mailers use Standard Mail to send: Printed matter, flyers, circulars, advertising. Newsletters, bulletins, and catalogs. Small parcels." (via http://pe.usps.com/businessmail101/classes/standard.htm http://pe.usps.com/businessmail101/classes/standard.htm) USPS Q2 FY2014 Revenue from Standard Mail: 4,228,705 USPS Q2 FY2014 Total Revenue: 16,732,651 (via http://about.usps.com/who-we-are/financials/revenue-pieces-weight-reports/fy2014-q2.pdf http://about.usps.com/who-we-are/financials/revenue-pieces-w...) Junk mail accounts for a quarter of USPS revenue. I don't suppose the USPS wants to encourage harassment of junk mailers.
- yeukhon 12y agoTo be fair, some of your information are public because they are required by laws. For example, your home ownership. As soon as my parents bought a home, a mail came to my new home address addressed to my family. Most people who actually send junk mail to us are via agency, and these people are small business owners. Also, some junk mail are delivered via cheap labor, actually walking to people's home and drop off (local supermarket for example), not via USPS. So that's another "direct mail marketing" and yet a lot of people enjoy them! I just throw junk mail away. My philosophy is that as long as they don't kill me I am giving these small business owner the opportunity to grow. The only kind of junk mail I don't want to receive is the annual yellow page book.
- judk 12y agoMost postal advertising is for scams -- misleading afs for mortgage refis, carpet ornduct cleaners that harass you for upsells once they have you cornered in your house. And a few bad restaurants. Legitimate businesses don't need mail adverting to reach new customers.
- eli 12y agoEvery business needs advertising.
- adventured 12y agoThe comedy to that is, the biggest junk mail service provider is the US Postal Service. In fact the only junk mail I get is from them selling access to my address and PO Box.
- eli 12y ago"Sub-human"? Gimmie a break. If you don't want junk mail, you can opt out of nearly all of it here: https://www.dmachoice.org https://www.dmachoice.org
- 4ad 12y agoWhy should I need to opt-out? What about people who want this having to opt-in? Wait, that wouldn't work because nobody wants this junk.
- Crito 12y agoIf you are getting junk mail that you do not want, then file a Form 1500 with the USPS: https://about.usps.com/forms/ps1500.pdf https://about.usps.com/forms/ps1500.pdf It is supposed to be used when you are receiving sexually oriented mail that you consider to be offensive. However, the USPS does not have the right to decide if something you consider to be sexually orientated and offensive is or is not in fact sexual in nature, or offensive (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rowan_v._U.S._Post_Office_Dept http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rowan_v._U.S._Post_Office_Dept. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibitory_Order http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibitory_Order). Personally, I consider credit card offers to be sexually obscene.
- lucaspiller 12y ago> Why isn't this data used to do something for good, rather than for what we can safely presume to be evil Why do you presume them to be doing evil, and why do you not consider breaking up organised crime and catching attempted murderers as good?
- dan_bk 12y ago> Why isn't this data used to do something for good Maybe because that would expose this program to the public, thereby raising opposition (as might happen now).
- mpyne 12y agoI'm sure someone at the USPS has to be quite amused at receiving a lecture on an activity that "we can safely presume to be evil" from a person who in the very next sentence refers literally to untermensch.
- sfrank2147 12y agoI don't think this is comparable to recent NSA actions. The Post Office is a government agency. It's not reasonable to expect the government not to keep track of the mail it delivers.
- judk 12y agoPlease explain your reasoning. It is not obvious.
- sage_joch 12y agoIt's also not reasonable for the public to be excluded from the conversation of how that data is handled.
- r00fus 12y agoThe Post Office is a private company that happens to receive a monopoly on your mail box and some mandated legislation, but otherwise is not funded by tax dollars.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoI suspected this months ago, and I pointed out how trivial it would be to log addresses on reddit. I was called a conspiracy theory nutcase. I'll go one further: the high-speed sorting machines for envelopes could easily be modified to photograph the interior of envelopes and that this is already happening. You only need to shine a light through them to do this.
- harry8 12y agoI suspected it months ago too. In July last year, when the NYT published the story. :-)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jqm 12y agoRight? I thought the guy in story looked familiar. Sure enough, same article from a year ago.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- giardini 12y agoThat would be one way. But perhaps the tears in wfunction's envelopes are used to insert a light/camera and the contents of the documents therein scanned. I wouldn't think it difficult to design a device to automatically scan most mailed documents in this manner.
- pascalo 12y agoThe Stasi did mail tracking on a massive scale in the GDR before the wall came down. Funny/Sad how things seem to go in circles.
- SilasX 12y agoExcept they had to do it all old-school: no modern databases, no quick lookup and correlation of geographic info, no optical character recognition.
- XorNot 12y agoAnd they also kicked in doors and murdered people routinely. Which funny enough is also happening in the US, but has nothing to do with mail tracking and everything to do with approval of no-knock police raids and general apathy to ever doing something about obvious corruption and brutality by people like Arpaio. Who in turn has absolutely no access to any of said surveillance infrastructure to start with...
- contingencies 12y agoHey, someone's got to stand for freedom and democracy, right? Now let me rendition you to a situation of torture and solitary confinement without trial.
- pascalo 12y agoBut a serious amount of tech for their time and era/system. They had industrial scale rooms with steamers to open up envelopes and the likes. Also the great east berlin telephone line distribution node: 50 wires coming in, 100 going out ... only 50 of those were for households. All of this can be seen in the Berlin Communications Museum.
- phea 12y agoThe DDR use to steam open all the mail, we've not yet come to that.
- GabrielF00 12y agoThe outside of a letter is public information - when you give the letter to a postal worker you know that a series of people who you will never meet are going to have to look at that address in order to route it to the right place. It's not clear to me how you can have a reasonable expectation of privacy.
- khuey 12y agoQuantity has a quality all its own.
- scrollaway 12y agoIt's not so much about expecting things to be private, but more of expecting things not to end up in databases, virtually forever. As programmers, we tend to view the world in a very "black and white" fashion, similar to our security model: If it's public, there is no expectation of privacy. But the world is not like this ... shouldn't be like this. While there should be both technical and legal mechanisms in place to prevent privacy abuses, it does not mean that, if they're not there, we should simply expect governments to do as they please, log everything, put us in all sorts of databases, make those databases accessible to all sorts of people, etc.
- Agnogenic 12y agoI have to agree. The issue is isn't about the USPS having access to the information on the outside of mail, but that they are cataloging it. When I send a letter, I am providing my information for a service to be fulfilled and not for it to be put in long-term storage. In some sense, I think this is comparable to email. If Google was giving out a record of the addresses I've sent email to and received email from, I would consider it an invasion of my privacy. Services need to be upfront about what is being done with our data--anything else is dishonest. When I know what is being done with my information, I can make an informed decision on what services to use.
- nfoz 12y ago> If Google was giving out a record of the addresses I've sent email to and received email from, I would consider it an invasion of my privacy. Yet you're sending this in cleartext over the internet...
- dylanrw 12y agoThe EU's right to be forgotten laws are sounding very attractive...
- bla2 12y agoThe EU's right to be forgotten says that you can ask search engines to remove search results about you. It has nothing to do with government surveillance.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y agoThat's actually not true. There isn't even any actual "right to be forgotten", there just are data protection directives and laws and the like, which were the basis for the ECJ decision that got called the "right to be forgotten" which happened to be about search engines, Google in particular. The same laws do apply to the processing of personally identifiable information in any company, and that in principle should include postal service companies in the EU, as well as to the government itself, though sometimes with limitations. That does not mean that postal services in the EU don't do the same thing for various reasons, but the legality is questionable.
- GoofballJones 12y agoThe EU has it out for Google in particular. Why don't they go after the sites that have the information in the first place? Regardless, if you have a news story about you, that you did something, it should be there as information forever. If the story is correct, then it's there. 20 years from now, you shouldn't have the right to say to some search engine that just happens to index it that you don't want it indexed anymore. The facts are still the same. The news story is still accurate. The site that has the news story still has it. Just because it may paint you in a negative light 20 years ago still doesn't mean you get the right to expunge that from the public record. The implications of this are just chilling and far reaching.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y ago
- jmadsen 12y agoThis is the biggest danger we face - the slow deterioration of our privacy to the point where when things like this emerge, a large part of the population's reaction is "why didn't you expect this?" In fact, I would NOT expect the post office to spend millions in technology to track letters. They shouldn't have any INTEREST in doing that - it isn't important to their main function of delivering mail. I expected them to use tech to better be able read zip codes & route more efficiently, and to count mail to better place people and resources where most needed.It should stop at that. Simply because something is public does not mean the govt should be spending resources tracking and storing it
- theworst 12y agoI'm curious about exploring your perspective, if you don't mind indulging me. Suppose, in the course of their everyday routing systems, the USPS were tracking the information in question. Pretend it were free to transfer that data to the law enforcement authorities. Would you have an issue with it, if it were free as part of doing business?
- Retric 12y agoProactive mass surveillance does not work. So even if the USPS is not spending money other parts of the government is going to waste money dealing with this crap. Sure, we can get into a debate about the ethics of surveillance, but as long as there is zero benefit it seems pointless. As to why it fails, there is simply to many false positives.
- theworst 12y agoWhile I tend to agree with your overall point, I was asking the question for a different reason. I find it useful to examine my opinions from different perspectives, even ones I disagree with, in order to better understand the crux of the issue. Again, while I personally agree with what you say, I think it's a bit assertive to say "proactive mass surveillance does not work". I know several people who would argue just as strongly that their work is critical to national security. This is a bit nitpicky on my part, but your statement "as long as there is zero benefit it seems pointless" is a tautology. I think the argument is regarding whether there is zero benefit. Again, I don't mean to criticize your beliefs; I'm just interested in openly exploring different perspectives to try and understand the situation better.
- greg5green 12y ago> Together, the two programs show that postal mail is subject to the same kind of scrutiny that the National Security Agency has given to telephone calls and e-mail. Uhh, I'm pretty sure the NSA scrutiny included the bodies of said calls and emails. I'm slightly offended by an agency tracking who I'm in contact with, but I've very offended by an agency knowing why I'm in contact with said person.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y agoYou should also be very offended by the metadata tracking. Metadata is much easier to process and more often than not does reveal why you are in contact anyhow. It's one of "their" propaganda tricks to make you believe that it's "just" the metadata, while it actually (a) tells you much more than you initially think about the content of the communication (after all, they don't just see the connections, but also the timing and direction, and that tells you a lot about the relationship between people) and (b) at least for the time being is much easier to process anyhow.
- aviv 12y agoI'm surprised the article did not raise the point that the US government effectively maintains a huge database of everybody's handwriting.
- saraid216 12y agoDoes anyone besides the government actually use someone's handwriting as an identification tool?
- ryanmim 12y agoIf you have enough written content that you've placed online, the US government can identify you anyway. A person's writing style and specific use of function words is their handwriting for the digital time. Creepy/cool linguistics.
- wfunction 12y agoReminds me: anyone know why envelopes delivered by USPS sometimes have small (< 1cm long) and consistent tears along their edges sometimes? Why does the post office do this?
- Bluestrike2 12y agoLife for a letter can be a bit rough. Most likely, those are just from automated sorting machines.
- OnionPost 12y agoI was thinking of starting a free 'service' where anyone can send me letters and I will remove the outer layer and re-post what is inside. Of course you'd have to put postage on the inner envelope as well and you would be paying double. That would be very similar to the way Tor works, where you could have multiple hops. How many people would be interested in this? My mailbox is in Europe.
- delbel 12y agoI live out in a rural area and our post office is horrible. When I moved into town, I didn't receive mail for 8 months even after approaching them numerous times and complaining. At one point I opened a mail box in a neighboring town. UPS and FedEx had no problem delivering packages. I actually bragged to my neighbors that "I don't get mail" at one point. Anyway I finally complained big time after not receiving some USPS package from aliexpress, and they started to deliver. I wish I could opt-out, I have never given out my address before, officially, and only receive junk mail. Makes me think of the Seinfeld skit, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hox-ni8geIw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hox-ni8geIw
- zaroth 12y agoThis is just a single good example of an extremely wide reaching pattern of large scale data acquisition, processing, storage, and data mining. License plate capture, facial recognition, mail and email envelopes, contact lists, credit card receipts, CCTV, social network trawling... soon enough drones will capture and store 24/7 aerial video of all major cities. I take it for granted that the government will know everyone I know, know everywhere I go, and know everything that I buy, sell, earn, and save. Pretty much the only thing left you have a chance at keeping private is the content of your conversations, and good luck with that.
- VonGuard 12y agoThat's why the library is the only civil service you can trust. They delete your records when you return books, unless you opt-out.
- schoen 12y agoNot necessarily true of every library system. (I know it's true of SFPL, but I believe not everywhere else.)
- higherpurpose 12y agoIt's like they don't care at all about the Constitution anymore.
- notastartup 12y agoI'm just sick and tired of the herd mentality quick to say "but I have nothing to hide therefore they can spy on me." This is extremely short sighted response and one which the government well expect. This is why they are able to get away with this gross violation of civil right to freedom and privacy, pillars of the free world which is attacked. The terrorists have simply one. To cause this kind of paranoia and overreaction from the government which attacks every one of our rights as human beings, is clearly a win for the terrorists and also for those in power, and keep their power.
- aburan28 12y agoThe fact of the matter is that until our legal system and laws drastically change we cannot allow this level of surveillance. We have too many people wasting away in prisons for personal drug use, disproportionate sentences, and a increasingly alarming for profit prison industry. Until that is fixed we cannot allow this kind of power.
- dan_bk 12y ago> “I’m no terrorist,” he said. “I’m an activist.” Same treatment the "Occupy" people got (i.e. raids before they had even done anything). This is a pattern now.
- j4kp07 12y agoSadly, this is old news. This article is a year old and I've read of other cases that go back 4-5 years.
- DanBC 12y agoI thought everyone knew this was happening and that it started shortly after 911 when there were some Anthrax postal attacks in the US - hence all the insistance on people including a return address on all mail and mailrooms being cautious about mail with no return address.
- stretchwithme 12y agoAmazing. Orwell was just wrong about WHEN we'd all be under government surveillance. OK, maybe its not that bad yet. But when we realize its as bad as he predicted, it will be too late. Relax, chicken. The hot tub you are in isn't boiling you yet.
- sampo 12y ago"Earth Liberation Front, a radical environmental group labeled eco-terrorists by the Federal Bureau of Investigation." In 2001, Earth Liberation Front firebombed a Center for Urban Horticulture at the University of Washington, so they really were eco-terrorists. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Washington_firebombing_incident http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Washington_firebo...
- zymhan 12y agoThat's a distinction worth noting. Monitored not for political leanings, but for membership in a violent organization.
- wuliwong 12y agoI don't think it is that important. The important issue is that they are suggesting that millions of USPS customer's mail is being monitored in this way. And certainly, they aren't all members of violent organizations.
- eli 12y agoELF isn't really an organization, there aren't really members and non-members. People did actions in the name of the organization, but I don't think there was much broader coordination.
- pizza234 12y agoThis is base concept upon which the legal abuse is built. Earth Liberation Front, intentionally, never killed anybody. Their actions have been judged though, as if they were intentionally trying to kill people. Terrorism is a vague concept, but the laws are well-defined, and the government intentionally applies them with double standards, exactly as it does with software patents, which are meant to cover a very precise idea, while they are applied in the vaguest possible terms, in order to extort money from the victims. So here's where the hypocrisy starts: On the lack of deaths from ELF attacks, the FBI's deputy assistant director for counterterrorism has said, "I think we're lucky. Once you set one of these fires they can go way out of control." This is true, but why the government doesn't limit mass-spying of people, then? It actually did go out of control already. By the way, don't forget that the government condoned HSBC, which factually supports real terrorists.
- tokenadult 12y agoThis has been submitted before, so I've had time to think about this issue. I have lived in a country (Taiwan under its previous dictatorial regime in the early 1980s) where I assumed that all my postal mail, domestic or foreign, was read by the ruling party's secret police as part of the delivery process. The postal service in Taiwan was always awesomely efficient when I lived there, with residential mail delivery twice a day all days of the week, year-round except for a brief set of holidays for Chinese New Year. Because I assumed that all my mail would be read, I set up procedures to check whether any of it was seized. My dad and I would write weekly letters to each other, numbered consecutively. The course of post between Taiwan and Minnesota in those days was a week or less, so after a while each weekly letter would take the form of including a phrase like "This is letter number 12, replying to your letter number 10, which I received on [date]" and so on. As far as I can ascertain, all the letters I wrote and all the letters addressed to me were delivered, but I assumed that they were read by the secret police. Foreign magazines and newspapers were sometimes seized and not delivered to subscribers, usually when they included articles about domestic politics in Taiwan. (I learned to respect The Economist as a news source by observing how often it was seized in delivery, either in entirety, or with blacking out of particular articles.) Local people who could read English could pay their hard-earned money to subscribe to (rather expensive, in those days) publications like The Economist or the Asian edition of the Wall Street Journal, but they couldn't count on receiving all of what they paid for. The dictatorship in Taiwan eventually fell, after a largely peaceful people power revolution that forced a transformation to an open political system. Along the way, people I know, including the father of one my children's godparents, were imprisoned for leading peaceful protests urging free and fair elections and a stop to censorship. Most people don't have the courage to go to prison--especially prisons like those in Taiwan at the time. But courage is what it takes to undermine a dictatorship. A successful movement for greater freedom requires great courage, and a degree of social trust among the movement participants that is not easy to find. Allow me to repeat advice I have shared here on Hacker News before. If you really want to be an idealistic but hard-headed freedom-fighter, mobilizing an effective popular movement for more freedom wherever you live, I suggest you read deeply in the publications of the Albert Einstein Institution, http://www.aeinstein.org/downloads/ http://www.aeinstein.org/downloads/ remembering that the transition from dictatorship to democracy described in those publications is an actual historical process with recent examples around the world that we can all learn from. Practice courage and practice collective action. We have to be courageous. We also have to be grounded in facts. There is still no indication that any of my postal mail or any of my telephone calls are being listened in on by anyone in the United States. The program described in the submitted article looks at the OUTSIDE of mail pieces. I had to assume I was under continuous surveillance when I lived in Taiwan in the 1980s, and that nothing I said or did was private. I still expressed support for the freedom and democracy movement there. I was not afraid. There is even less to be afraid of today in the United States, but I will still keep speaking up for freedom, just in case.