18 ms·
Not So Much ‘New York Poor’ as ‘Pittsburgh Rich’
- kcovia 12y agoThe quality of life is really great here in Pittsburgh. I have a huge 1 bedroom, back yard, front porch, in a great safe neighborhood, a block from major bus lines. All for $600/month. It'd run me at least triple that in somewhere like SF or NYC. Sure, you can't get some of the things you'd get in those cities, but quite frankly, you can come close. There are dozens of ethic restaurants a block away, 10+ museums and galleries within 5-10 miles, and best of all, it's cheap enough to actually have time to visit them.
- JohnBooty 12y agoAt one point, I looked into living in NYC, and the sheer cost of living in that city was intimidating. Salaries are often higher to match, so it balances out somewhat, but I like my space and I don't think I'd be okay with paying $1,800 for a studio apartment no matter how much somebody was paying me. For those who do enjoy the biggest cities, I'm not knocking your choices. A lot of people are energized by living in such a hustling and bustling place. I totally get it.
- johnward 12y agoI live close to Pittsburgh but in the middle of nowhere, OH. I Work in Squirrel Hill sometimes but mostly from home. I have a 4bedroom 3bath house with a 2 car garage on 15 acres that costs me ~900 per month. You couldn't rent a small apartment in some cities for that. However, you give up the convenience of being in the city and all the activities if that's the lifestyle you want to live. I personally love my fortress of solitude.
- theandrewbailey 12y agoThere's also fiber optic internet (verizon FIOS).
- JohnBooty 12y agoI felt a little more sane after reading that article. I understand that a lot of people want to do their art in vibrant cities like NYC, and that makes sense for people pursuing careers like theater that you can't realistically pursue while living alone in a cabin in the woods. (Whether you can even realistically pursue it in NYC is another story, but it's at least theoretically possible) But a lot of us (though certainly not all of us) writers and programmers and other such types would rather live somewhere cheaper and less claustrophobic. I know it's certainly what I chose. It's not without its downsides but I like the upsides.
- weeksie 12y agoI think if I was a bit younger and a bit less thoroughly ruined by living in New York for the past six years (I really couldn't live anywhere else in the US long term)—I'd go to Detroit. It's cheap, a bit dangerous, and drawing a shitload of artists and writers. Not being near the ocean would drive me batty, but it would be an awesome excursion for a few years. I recently did the classic Manhattan to Brooklyn move and I'm thrilled. Perhaps I have Stockholm Syndrome but I love that it's possible to up and move to a different town and still be in New York City. But, to each their own. Some writers thrive on isolation and some thrive on socialization.
- benburton 12y agoAs a software engineer, and recent Pittsburgh transplant coming from NYC, I think it's ok here. The only part that's hitting me pretty hard is food... it's pretty much incomparable. I have been trying to find decent Indian food, for example, but have been coming up short. Pittsburgh does have very good modern-American cuisine, but "ethnic" food is a bit lacking. Going out drinking is insanely cheap by comparison. You can get a good craft beer draft for as low as $2, whereas in NYC the best I'd find would be around $4 (and that would be pretty lucky). There's plenty to do culturally, and the rent/housing prices are very good. EDIT: Thanks for all the Indian food recommendations. I've got some eating to do!
- osterwood 12y agoGood indian? You need to check out Udipi: http://udipicafepittsburgh.com http://udipicafepittsburgh.com It's out in Monroeville next to a concrete factory -- but fantastic south indian food. Definitely worth the drive.
- benburton 12y agoThanks for the recommendation. I'll definitely check it out!
- kibwen 12y agoAh, I'm glad someone beat me to suggesting Udipi! Everything there is lovely, and I've never seen anyone else make puri (the fried balloon bread) as spectacularly large as they do. Probably the best Indian food that I've had in Pittsburgh, though Tamarind (http://www.urbanspoon.com/r/23/271746/restaurant/Oakland/Tamarind-Flavor-of-India-Pittsburgh http://www.urbanspoon.com/r/23/271746/restaurant/Oakland/Tam...) in Oakland has an amazingly affordable lunch buffet.
- machinshin_ 12y agoUdupi's south indian (mainly Tamil) food, it's only one small piece of the gigantic puzzle :)
- cfallin 12y ago
- dgabriel 12y agoThis is totally off-topic, but I've known Wammo for years&years via the music & poetry scene, and it's very strange to see him turn up on Hacker News.
- mbillie1 12y agoAs a software engineer working remote, I live in Salt Lake City (not a mormon; like to ski/hike/climb), and I would never move back to NYC. For what I paid for a studio apartment in Astoria, I rent a full 3/2 house with a view of 11,000' mountains out here. There's something to be said for relative wealth.
- micro_cam 12y agoI'm doing the same thing for the same reason but in rural Montana near granite big walls and powder covered peaks and I suspect there are many more of us out there. Just bought a large farm house on 3.4 acres with a stream a couple miles from the trailheads and crags for less then a condo in Seattle. I can't imagine moving back to a city for any reason. This area (the missoula+bitterroot valley area) also has a surprising number of startups, both software and hardware including a utility bike manufacture that is stealing contracts from the Chinese and various biotechs and big data focussed companies. I think that cheap space and low cost of living are ingredients that are too often overlooked in YC style startups. I'm primarily a software/machine learning guy but now that I've got a garage i've already got small machine shop set up for various hardware projects and experiments and now that we have guest rooms and space I'll be inviting various collaborators out for coding/hiking/climbing/skiing retreats.
- mrfusion 12y agoSounds amazing. What's the climate like? Are winters unbearable?
- micro_cam 12y agoAs a skier I look forward to the winters, we get both Pacific and Arctic weather so the winters are cold enough to keep deep powder around in the mountains but warm enough to stabilize the snowpack and reduce avalanche danger for backcountry skiing. The climate is actually reasonably mild in the valley (3,500'), it snows but it usually melts within days or weeks if it is a very cold spell. I'm able to run outside all winter long wearing a light fleece layer and occasionally using microspikes for traction if it is icy. The local ski area is in a pass at 7k feet and closes if it gets much bellow 0 F which only happened a couple of days this year. Missoula and the Flathead vallies to the north get inversions causing haze in the valley bottoms much of the winter but the bitterroot gets more sunny winter days.
- Tiktaalik 12y agoThe author chooses his quote from Florida poorly. Florida is talking about Pittsburgh from when he worked there in the "early 2000s" (and presumably earlier). That's a decade or more ago. Cities can change remarkably in a decade. Florida doesn't make any statement about what Pittsburgh is like today.
- robg 12y agoI did my graduate work in Pittsburgh. $20k a year sustained me quite well. Rent for a large two-bedroom blocks from my office was $680/month. I know people who bought homes and paid a mortgage for less. Food is decent, kind people, public transportation is pretty good.
- andrewljohnson 12y agoWhen I was in college in Pittsburgh (1999-2003), I rented rooms in share houses for $75-150/month, in nice parts of Shadyside and Squirrel Hill (after figuring out the dorms were obscenely expensive). I could have probably gotten by on around $20K/year, feeling very comfortable.
- jcdavis 12y agoIts definitely more expensive now, when I rented in 2009-2010 rooms in similar places were more like $300-400/month. Still a pretty affordable place regardless.
- nilkn 12y agoOn the topic of less popular cities: My parents live in St. Louis. It's a wonderful place. The city was hit hard by de-industrialization, which is probably the reason why it's so affordable. It has Wash U, which is a really excellent private university. The campus is next to Forest Park and a thriving collegetown-type area. There are some gorgeous historic neighborhoods nearby as well which have been maintained over the decades, like Parkview. The city is so affordable that it's not terribly uncommon for upper middle class folks like doctors to have vacation homes, usually lakehouses. And I imagine there's a lot of really awesome office space available for rent in downtown at affordable rates for would-be startups; not to mention there's undoubtedly a lot of fantastic local CS talent coming out of Wash U which is largely untapped by the city. Missouri is fully seasonal as well. It's sometimes breathtaking to see everything in bloom in the spring and early summer, and there are plenty of opportunities to play in the snow in winter. The only thing it's lacking, of course, is an abundance of well-paying stable jobs in technology.
- brational 12y agoShowed this to a friend of mine that works for a start up out west: http://downtowntrex.com/officespace/ http://downtowntrex.com/officespace/ Office space is jaw-droppingly cheap.
- nilkn 12y agoSounds like a killer deal for someone working remotely. Live in a great urban neighborhood without the insane cost, rent your own office downtown so you have a physically distinguished working space, and enjoy life. I'd seriously consider doing it if I were more confident in the stability and longevity of remote work.
- akilism 12y agoLived in PGH for 10 years and now I'm on year 9 of NYC. I definitely miss the cost of living but I'm making much more money that I ever did in Pittsburgh. I love it there though I day dream of moving to back and living in a nice big house in the east end.
- gw 12y agoThis rings really true, and it's not just for artists or authors. I moved to Pittsburgh so I could take a year off and just work on free software. I had about $10k in savings and it lasted the whole year. You can get even cheaper rent if you're willing to live a bit outside the city.
- keehun 12y ago$10k for an entire year sounds really amazing. Did it feel like $10k? Mind sharing a rough expenses/budget? Even with a $100k salary, saving/investing $90k annually would be amazing...
- gw 12y agoCurrently I'm living about 20 minutes outside the city on $450/mo rent, utilities included except gas. I eat really cheaply by buying in bulk from Sam's Club, though about once a week I go out drinking/eating. I don't pay any cable bill -- I just tether off of my phone for internet. I also don't have any student loans anymore, so that helps.
- NDizzle 12y agoHow are the K-12 public schools in Pittsburgh? Everyone seems interested to move somewhere and rent a one bedroom.
- fixermark 12y agoThey are decent, but there's some high variance. It's worth doing your homework. Anecdotally, some of my coworkers moved here expressly to raise their families; they liked the school system options here better than the larger cities they came from. I don't have children of my own, so I haven't done the research.
- jimbokun 12y agoI send my kids to a Catholic school. That said, I know several people who have gotten their kids into Pittsburgh charter schools and seem to be happy with that. If we go the public school route for high school, my kids would feed into Allderdice, and I hear their advanced program is outstanding, with many kids going into Ivies from there. Also, there's the Pittsburgh Promise. https://pittsburghpromise.org/earn.php https://pittsburghpromise.org/earn.php "The Pittsburgh Promise scholarship is a big idea and a real commitment: if you live in the city and attend Pittsburgh Public schools from 9th grade on, up to a $40,000 Promise scholarship will be waiting for you at graduation." Only applies to PA schools, but still, an impressive program.
- bmj 12y agoAllderdice is one of the consistently better high schools in the city, assuming your kids get into the advanced program. Personally, I'm a product of Central Catholic, but many of my friends (who went on to Ivies) came out of Allderdice.
- fixermark 12y agoFrustratingly, when I think "high variance," Allerdice is precisely what comes to mind. I volunteer for the FIRST Robotics program in Pittsburgh. A couple of years ago, I was chatting with some of the students from Allerdice who also volunteer and were away from school that day due to their team being in the competition---at about the same time that a few miles away, the police were breaking up a large-group fight in Allerdice itself. Allerdice (last time I checked) is a good school with some real problems. But it's a good school.
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoPittsburgh has always been a great city to be "from" and only recently has become a good city to be "in". My hometown (grew up in Hazelwood/Greenfield) is still a city very much in transition. If you stay in your designated neighborhoods like Oakland, Shadyside, Squirrel Hill, etc. you'll be blissful in your little bubble of it being a great town on the upswing. Get ten minutes out of town in almost any direction (sans the southern 376 corridor to the airport) and you'll feel like you are on a different planet. Sometimes even taking the wrong street will have you wind up in areas that are dilapidated, poverty stricken, and villainous. The Consol Energy Center is a stone's throw from one of the historically worst neighborhoods in the country. Knowing that, Pittsburgh has radically changed in a very short amount of time. Medical was always big there; but the dotcom boom incubated a wonderful technology center that surrounds Carnegie Mellon and the other fine schools in the area. I wouldn't hesitate for a second moving back to Pittsburgh...just so long as I get to live in a place of my own choosing and not my old neighborhood :)
- jimbokun 12y agoI live in Greenfield now. Able to easily afford a big house for very little money. Easy access to all of the neighborhoods you mention, as well as downtown. I walk to work in Squirrel Hill, for example. Just to say, some of us actually like your old neighborhood. :)
- chiph 12y agoI've been in Austin almost 4-1/2 years, and it's changed significantly in that time. Fewer hippies, more yuppies. It's common now to hear of cash offers on houses that are $10k above the asking price.
- jimbokun 12y agoPittsburgh is also an outstanding place to raise children. Our first child was born in Brooklyn, second in New Jersey, but my wife and I are originally from the Pittsburgh area. Returned to Pittsburgh while our kids were still in pre-school. The Carnegie Library system is outstanding. The Squirrel Hill and Oakland branches (most convenient locations to us) have large, comfortable children's sections. With their loan system, can request pretty much any book you can think of and pick up in a few days in the branch closest to you. My kids understand the system and use it to get books by authors they like. Children's Museum, Phipp's Conservatory, and Carnegie museum are all great for kids. Generally, if you go more than once a yearly membership pays off, and a lot of these are connected (membership in one gives you admission to others). A few years older now, we got season passes to Kennywood and Sandcastle. Kennywood has fantastic roller coasters, especially the older ones. Schenley and Frick parks are immense. With the Pittsburgh topography, you can walk through trails and feel totally removed from the city. In many neighborhoods, you can own suburb sized homes for cheaper than the suburbs, with access to all the city amenities. My kids walk 3 blocks to school. I could go on. Pittsburgh is a great place to raise a family.
- benburton 12y agoThis is the main reason my wife and I moved from NYC to Pittsburgh. The people I know who still live in NYC end up spending much of their salary hiring people to watch their kids, and then there's the competitive nature of getting kids into preschools, kindergarden, etc. and all the costs associated with those.
- burnte 12y agoI was born and raised in Pittsburgh, and yes, it's a great place to raise kids. but it's not a great place to be when you're starting out your life. I love Pgh and always will, but they city has a serious problem thinking ahead and finding ways to grow. It tried being a financial city in the 80s, then a tech city in the 90s, all the while it was growing as a medical city. It's still the best place to get sick for nearly anything, the medical facilities are second to none. But aside from education and hospitals, there's no nearly enough industry there, not nearly enough new-world accoutrements. I, and many people like me, moved away after high school and college because the city can feel small, constrained, and too old fashioned. I don't think it doesn't need to lose that to grow, but I don't know what else it does need. I hope it finds it.
- rwhitman 12y agoFolks miss out on why major cultural centers attract people. In history it was because of the opportunities from ports and trade, today its still pretty much the same. Pittsburgh is not currently an airline hub for any airline. Meaning if you want to go anywhere other than Philadelphia you need a connection. Its also not adequately driveable or train distance from any city worth going to - Cleveland is your only neighbor, and getting to Philly from Pittsburgh is considerably more painful than Los Angeles to San Francisco (have done both runs routinely I would take the 5 through the central valley over the turnpike in winter anyday). Its also not a city that anyone passes through on a regular basis without making it the destination. I can take a meeting with even international clients in NYC without ever leaving. They come here. If you're in art, yes you want to go where you can live cheap, but if you want to make a splash you need to be somewhere where there is sufficient disposable income and a big enough transient population to support viral awareness of your art. Pittsburgh doesn't have enough of those things. I think Pittsburgh is a wonderful city, filled with great parks, cheap beer and good folks. But I haven't visited there in years and there is a reason why
- fixermark 12y agoIf you haven't visited in years, you may have missed a lot of the changes. Depends on how many years. Pittsburgh may not have an airline hub or access to the ocean, but it's been a transit nexus for decades; it's the last major city anything going from the New York / Philadelphia area along I-76 will hit before crossing the Alleghenies. As such, it sees a good assortment of art events and shows as they tour; theater tours (especially with significant technical needs) tend to be convoy-of-trailers affairs. To drill in on the arts specifically: I've seen Wicked, Addams Family, and Mary Poppins without having to plan a weekend for the event. There's also a Tony-award-winner-producing college in the city, which creates some excellent local shows as a side-effect. You also may be under-estimating the effect of real estate value in a world where people can make a productive input without needing to physically geo-locate with the rest of their company. Pittsburgh is a growing location for software and other engineering. Apple, Disney, and Google all have offices in the city. Ports still matter, but not as much as they did in the days where the only meaningful value was in goods; in a service economy, things are more distributed.
- 12y ago
- badman_ting 12y agoI left Pittsburgh, like all my friends except for one. It's been discussed as an up-and-coming city for years now, but I'm still not sure it's somewhere I would want to live. I remember when people pointed to the Google office that was built there, as an indicator that things were changing. At the time, that office had 25 employees, not sure about now. I guess I'm saying that I'm not sure how much of that narrative is actually happening for people in Pittsburgh. As far as raising kids, I could definitely see that. Your real-estate dollar goes pretty far. The weather sucks ass, though -- even Paul Graham says so! I really wouldn't want to have to deal with that again. (Also, the bit about "why should I pay a bunch in rent to live near some nice parks" is such a dumb way of thinking about NYC. But if you really do think that way you definitely should not go to New York.)
- quesodd 12y agoGoogle is doing well. They have 4 floors at BakerySquare and just bought a significant portion of some new construction.
- johnward 12y agoand constantly have positions open
- fixermark 12y agoYou aren't wrong about the weather. Which is, ironically, why I live here... I hate sunny weather, I burn easily (even with sunscreen) and it's easier for me to add clothing to guard against the cold than to shed layers to avoid the heat. I'm also allergic to the pollen of a whole host of plants that simply aren't hardy enough to survive the winters here; my childhood summers were a miserable annual struggle through one respiratory infection after another, but nowadays I just pop a Zyrtec a few months out of the year and I'm good to go. Pittsburgh is a great fit for me climate-wise, but given that I'd move to Alaska for the climate, I'm probably an outlier. ;)
- badman_ting 12y agoWell, in my opinion it's not just the cold, the summers are hot and gross too. Not much "open-window weather", as my mom says. But then, if pollen is a consideration that would make sense for you. I live in the Pacific NW now, which is much milder year-round.
- steveklabnik 12y agoI spent the first 25 years of my life in Pittsburgh, the last two in California (18 months LA, 6 months SF), and _just_ moved to Brooklyn two weeks ago. Pittsburgh is wonderful. There's a lot wrong with it, but a lot of right too. It is certainly very cheap to live, and there's a lot going on. We even have a Techstars-affiliated incubator, which used to offer a really, really good deal. My first startup, CloudFab, went through it years ago. That said, SF is still the best place in the world to do a startup: every city says "We may not be SF, but we have X!" X is _never_ enough to make up for not being SF. I said it when I lived there too, and now that I've lived in SF, I know that's just deeply, deeply wrong. That doesn't mean you _can't_ do it, but it's a handicap. However, living in a place is very rarely about 'economic sense.' I have a _need_ to live in NYC. I've gotten more work done in the two weeks I've lived here than I did in the entire six months I lived in SF, and maybe about a third of what I did in LA. The hustle, bustle, and opportunities are endless. Last night I woke up at ten am, did my laundry, then went to a juice bar, worked for a few hours, walked around, ended up literally coding on a bar while watching the US. vs. Ghana game, then took the train over to Herald Square and coded in the park. It was a beautiful evening. Around midnight, walked up to Times Square to squeak in some power before all the stores closed, then worked in another park until 3am, and took the train home. You can't really do that anywhere else, at least in the states. Oh, and I'm saving about 25% on my rent by moving to Brooklyn from San Francisco, and I'd be saving 60% if I had still lived in the Mission when I left.
- imc 12y agoIt's great seeing you happy again, Steve.
- steveklabnik 12y ago<3
- xienze 12y ago> Last night I woke up at ten am, did my laundry, then went to a juice bar, worked for a few hours, walked around, ended up literally coding on a bar while watching the US. vs. Ghana game, then took the train over to Herald Square and coded in the park. It was a beautiful evening. Around midnight, walked up to Times Square to squeak in some power before all the stores closed, then worked in another park until 3am, and took the train home. You can't really do that anywhere else, at least in the states. So your gold standard is "a city where I code in bars and parks until the middle of the night?" Yeah, I think there's more than one place in the US where you can do that.
- forgotAgain 12y agoMy daughter has lived in Brooklyn since she graduated from an Ivy, class of 2011. She has a liberal arts degree. She found a job where she started in the mid 30’s. After two and a half years she’s broken 40 but not by much. She works about 60 hours a week. Her last review made her a manager so she gets no overtime. She works in an industry that caters to luxury so the company is setting income records. The money is all flowing to the top. It’s an employers market and the starting salary the company now offers is lower then it was when she started because there are so many college graduates looking for anything resembling a job. She lived in Park Slope for the first two years, sharing a two bedroom, fifth floor walkup, attic apartment. The entire apartment was maybe 20 x 20 ft with a good part of it of limited use due to the slant of the roof. Rent was $1,500 a month including utilities. It was a great neighborhood though and she really enjoyed her time there. The apartment building was sold to a luxury developer and the rent was raised to $2,300 a month. The new owners really just wanted the building empty so they could gut it and change it to luxury apartments. We walked by there this past weekend and the place was boarded up. Her new apartment is a legitimate two bedroom in a clean but very old building on the edges of Boerum Hill. The neighborhood is okay but you need to be aware that two blocks away it starts get dodgy very quickly. The rent is $2,200 + utilities. Her and her apartment mate looked for two months to find the apartment. It was the only thing they could find that was affordable but wasn’t a filthy dump. The leases on the old and new places overlapped by a month and a half but they had to look early because the inventory is so limited. Real estate in NYC has gone crazy. Manhattan prices are driven by international buyers looking for a place that’s safe. One bedroom apartments in Manhattan for less than a million are becoming scarce according to the NYT. Brooklyn is priced at what Manhattan was a couple of years ago. The downtown area of Brooklyn has been very popular because of the availability of mass transit to get people into their jobs in Manhattan. As you move out from downtown Brooklyn the commute time increases quickly as subway lines spread out and express trains make less frequent stops. Two to three hours a day on a subway commute becomes old very quickly. NYC is a great place but unless you have some equity in the place you work you’re very likely not going to be able to afford to have the life you think is waiting for you there.
- wil421 12y agoI am paying about $1400 in rent/utilities a month outside Atlanta for a 3/2 plus 2 living rooms on over a acre of fenced in land with a storage shed. Its right in one of the best school districts and one of the top High Schools in the state. A friend of mine recently visited from NYC and remarked about how he is paying $3000 for a place in Manhattan with one room. I couldnt imagine living in a building taking an elevator to my place. Cant have pets and he can barely have people over to sit down. From the stories I hear about SF and NYC, I am probably never going to move to either.
- LordKano 12y agoI'm a Pittsburgh area native and I still react with shock when I find out what my friends and relatives in other cities pay for housing. Over $1,000/month for a little apartment and $300/month for a parking space. You could buy two houses in the Pittsburgh suburbs for that much money. A nice 3 bedroom house in a clean, low crime suburb can be had for under $100k. Smaller houses, fixer-uppers and houses in less than ideal neighborhoods can be purchased for under $50k.
- jaegerpicker 12y agoI made a very similar choice as the article highlights. I'm a experienced Software engineer, particularly with the back end of web systems but also iOS and Android apps. I could live in nearly any city in the western Hemisphere and have a large choice of jobs. I found a GREAT place to work in Portland Maine and I couldn't be happier. I'm originally from the Rust belt (2 hours from Pittsburgh and about 1.5 hours from Cleveland) and we thought long and hard about either of those two cities as a good place to move but Portland and the Ocean were just too big of a draw. Portland is much cheaper than other East Coast cities but has an amazing food screen, great outdoor activities on it's doorstep, and a thriving art screen. It's also only 90 minutes from Boston and a day trip drive from NYC. We also considered NYC and SF, to me there was no way to justify the expense vs Portland. It's one reason why I don't think there will be another Silicon Valley, I think the next rise of tech companies are going to be far spread out and in places that it's easy to attract great engineers to.
- morgante 12y agoI think there's a pretty strong argument for moving to a Pittsburgh on sabbatical, but while I'm working I'd definitely stay in NYC/SF. Salaries here are substantially higher (I doubt devs make $150k+ in Pittsburgh, in NYC that's very achievable), and that makes a huge difference in accumulating savings. Yes, living expenses are proportionally higher here as well so I'm still only left with a small percentage of my paycheck. But that small percentage means a lot more because it can be spent on global goods like travel or savings. Spending a couple grand on a vacation is basically a rounding error in a NYC budget, but it'd be a decent chunk of a Pittsburgh salary. Similarly, saving just a bit of my income in NYC for a few years makes it easy to build up a large nest egg for a down payment on a beautiful house somewhere like Pittsburgh. If I'm way off base, someone please let me know. If it's actually possible to make $150k+ in a cheap area, or with remote work, I'd be interested to hear.
- badman_ting 12y agoThat has been my way of thinking too. Another consideration is student loans - if you pay $500 a month in loans, that will be a smaller portion of an NYC salary. Same for any purchase or bill which is unrelated to cost of living.
- steveklabnik 12y ago"Pittsburgh" has an "h" at the end, and Pittsburghers will get really annoyed by this. You almost made my eye start twitching. ;) Sorry, I don't mean to be a jerk. Just wanted to let you know.
- benburton 12y ago> Sorry, I don't mean to be a jagoff. Fixed that for you ;)
- steveklabnik 12y agoHa! As someone who grew up half an hour _outside_ the city, it's been interesting to see which chunks of Pittsburghese I picked up, and which ones I didn't. Some if it is also age: my grandfather speaks with a more significant amount of it than I do, even though his home was half a mile from my childhood one.
- phrasemix 12y agoI recently moved back to Durham, North Carolina after 10 years of living in bigger cities (Tokyo, then NYC). I expected that the rent would be cheaper but that I'd miss out in terms of culture, food, and the quality of people I met. What I'm finding is 1) The culture that is available here is easier to appreciate and digest because there's less paradox of choice 2) The food is a little more limited but overall better 3) The people that I meet are just as smart and interesting. I often forget that I'm back in the South and not in Brooklyn.
- johnward 12y agoI really liked the RTP area when I was down there. Plus they seem to have a pretty good tech scene. It's kind of like Pittsburgh with decent weather.
- _delirium 12y agoAny tips on cool parts of the RTP area? I was at a conference in downtown Raleigh for a week two years ago, and was kind of surprised that the downtown is super-small. Had two nice coffee shops, but didn't feel like the downtown of a 500,000 person city; almost the kind of 5-block downtown you'd expect for a town 1/10 of that size. I might go again this year, and am hoping to find somewhere to stay where there's more stuff going on, but am not quite sure where that is.
- johnward 12y agoI was in Raleigh too. It seemed like a much smaller town than half a million people and maybe that's why I liked it. My wife and I were only there for a weekend so we didn't do much exploring. The downtown area just seemed clean and safe compared to other places. I'm not really the kind of person that looks for things to do in town so I'm probably not the best to ask. It seems like they had some decent outdoor activities and they are only a few hour from the beach which is something I enjoy. It kind of reminded me of a bigger version of my hometown (Wheeling, WV) with much nicer weather.
- eshvk 12y agoI know that someday I will be moving to a small city. However, there are huge pros and cons. I have lived for the past few years in San Francisco and New York. Both are massive cities; San Francisco is a huge tech echo-chamber. It can get nauseating at times. New York has people who can be complete assholes to strangers. Just because. Yet, every time, I leave the cities to travel elsewhere, I am reminded of why I pay the expensive amounts to live here. - Food: Walk out of your house. Go a few blocks. You will find ethnic food of your choice in New York or San Francisco. Hell, I live in the UWS in New York. Even here, in the midst of high residential nirvana, you can find random restaurants open at all hours of the night. Austin was a great city when I lived there. Except that the closest restaurant ( a subway) was 5 miles away. Ever want to do something crazy, like celebrate a birthday of a friend during thanksgiving. Not a chance. Everything is shutdown. This is not just an American phenomenon. I have been in Stockholm for the past few weeks. It is sunday afternoon and you want food? Nope, it is sunny out there so every restaurant owner in a five block radius wants to close his place and go hang out. - Transport: If you want to live in an American city and not drive a car, I haven't found better cities to live than the two. It is ridiculous how well a city like Austin is designed for the four wheeled population. To the extent that pavements are an afterthought, sandwiched between lawns and tarmac. - Culture: This is not going to be an issue for most people making the move. However, as a person who is a perpetual immigrant, I prefer cities that are filled with people from varying different backgrounds. New York is the most non American, American city that I have ever lived in. I wish I could say the same for San Francisco, but it really is a city of three major clusters.
- potatolicious 12y agoThis reflects my thoughts on NYC perfectly. Even though every time I leave the city I end up complaining about how my apartment is the size of somebody's living room, when push comes to shove I wouldn't dream of trading my Manhattan shoebox for a big house in the suburbs. The culture part really rings true for me. I was born in Asia, immigrated to Canada at a very young age, and now I'm in the US. I find it difficult and oftentimes annoying to live in places without this sort of diversity. I've been to, for lack of a better term, "whiter" parts of the US and have always been a bit uncomfortable. I've met very few hostile "real" racists, but in these parts of the country I feel like every time I meet someone I have to first break through the stereotypes attached to my skin color. "Where are you from?" "Canada" (I speak with no trace of an Asian accent) "No, where are you REALLY from?" In NYC the answer is "Cool, which part of Canada?" Nevermind the people who just have to sneak in the "good at math" joke somewhere in there. Nobody ever means any harm, but it is profoundly annoying to go through life being the "other". In big cities this is never a problem - when I meet new people I'm treated as an individual first, not the sum perceptions of my race.
- geebee 12y agoThese stories keep popping up, and they're all very encouraging. There was a post a while back about a startup in St Louis, another about Baltimore. There are a lot of excellent cities out there, and SF really is just too expensive (NY, too, but we're talking about tech). I'm reminded of a quote by Patty Smyth: "New York has closed itself off to the young and the struggling. But there are other cities. Detroit. Poughkeepsie. New York City has been taken away from you. So my advice is: Find a new city." http://gothamist.com/2010/05/03/patti_smith_suggests_finding_anothe.php# http://gothamist.com/2010/05/03/patti_smith_suggests_finding.... I really do think that tech needs to embrace the need to branch out. I understand SF is a great place to fund tech companies, and that VCs (and often CEOs) appear to prefer it. But it is frustrating to see tech elites (I'm talking about the sort of people who get to pick up the phone and vent a bit to the elected leader of the world's largest military about their company's hiring woes) insist that there is a severe shortage of tech workers when they continue to create 110k a year jobs in a city where the median 3br house costs 1.1mil. I agree that SF should build more, but this isn't going to be the solution. If you're offering 110K a year for developers in Detroit, Poughkeepsie, Baltimore, St Louis, Minneapolis and you can't find anyone, ok, maybe we can start talking about why and how the government can help. But if you're creating 110K a year jobs in a place where two full time workers are looking at roughly 50k in child care costs and a 1.1 mil bill for the median 3br house, well of course you're having trouble finding workers!
- JPKab 12y agoI wonder how much of SF's growth is forced by VCs, like what happened to my friend who recently got funded. He was DC based, and as a requirement from his VC he had to move to San Fran for a minimum of a year. His conversations with me have been interesting, with the main point being that he has to pay WAY more for talent, space, everything. His main frustration is he doesn't need the mythical "10X" developers. He just needs people who can deliver, and has to fight for talent with dozens of apps which have premises so silly that he can't believe they are funded. I got an offer the other day for 120k in SF. I did the math, and said no. I'd be better off taking a job for 85k in Austin. And regarding Austin getting more expensive: There is a huge differentiator here. Austin has a booming housing market AND a booming development market. There is tons of new housing being built, and a lot of it is very interesting, moderate density in-fill development relatively close to the downtown core. There's one company building neo-traditional development neighborhoods in old strip mall locations where the houses all have solar panels and uber modern designs. They go for 270k for a 3 bedroom. Hardly exorbitant.
- mimighost 12y agoStudying in Pittsburgh for my master's...I like this city in general, but it is just...felt old, stuck in 90s.
- dreamweapon 12y ago“Knowing there are people on this planet who think their sandwiches are worth $10 apiece bothers me immensely.” It's not that the sandwiches are "worth" $10; it's that they're pegged to the square foot rent of the shop which sells them (and of the wages + salaries of the people who make them and provide them for sale; and hence, the rents of the spaces they live in, also). That's just economics, and the same principles apply in NYC as anywhere else (with different rent figures plugged in).
- ruigomes 12y agoIs it realistic for a fresh graduate (with a masters) in Informatics and Computing Engineering from Portugal to go straight to NYC and be able to live alone (as in not sharing rooms) and actually have some money saved by the end of the year? I would absolutely love to experience NY, since I'm a passionate web developer.. There's so many companies in this field over there that I feel that my career would grow so much faster than if I stay here in Europe (at least in Portugal). I would personally prefer NY over SF since it's way closer to "home". Any thoughts on actually being able to financially live in NYC as a fresh grad?
- ceras 12y agoBy "alone" do you mean not sharing just bedrooms or any rooms? Most new grads share an apartment with roommates but have their own bedroom. I know many recent grads living in New York (myself included), mostly earning from $60k to $120k, and it's not a problem for any of us. What's tough is settling down with a family. But as a single person - especially with the additional savings you get by not owning a car - it's fine for tech salaries. To make it more concrete, here's a budget: $70k starting salary (low for NYC tech) -$24,500 taxes (overestimated at 35% to be safe) -$18,000 (1500*12) Manhattan rent + utilities -$18,000 careless youth living expenses ($1.5k/month subway, eating out, bars, museums, music, traveling, etc) ______ $9,500 left over per year for saving. So even underestimating salary, overestimating taxes, not choosing a super cheap apartment, and not being frugal in the slightest on monthly living expenses, you still net $9,500 per year.
- Mz 12y agoI am in California. The cost of housing here is galling. But I am here for my health and the cost of housing here is less galling than what my health problems are supposed to cost. Living here helps me stay off medication and out of the ER and out of surgery. I wish I could go move someplace cheap. Honest, I do. But, for me, staying healthy is the cheap choice. Those kinds of quality of life issues are sometimes very, very hard to adequately quantify. These articles often do a poor job of addressing that. Price of housing is not the be all and end all of one's life.
- qwerta 12y agoNot sure why you are in California. Health care is bloody expensive there, somewhere else you could afford house AND hospital. And other states offer many outdoor activities as well.
- Mz 12y agoI am here for the climate. If I don't need medical care because I can breathe without medication, then it matters little what local doctors cost.
- m0llusk 12y agoRichard Florida's research is solid and continues to reflect what is going on with economic growth and opportunity. Jim Russell demonstrates bad attitude and a lack of reading comprehension. The places where new graduates go still tend to rate well in what Richard Florida calls the three T's: Tolerance, Technology, and Talent. Unfortunately, Jim Russell has so little interest in the subject material that he didn't even bother to look at the metrics that Richard Florida is justly famous for documenting with rigorous empirical research. It is possible to rent a modest suburban home in Vallejo for $1200/month and commute into San Francisco. Similarly while some of of the Pittsburgh metropolitan area is doing well nowadays other parts are less fortunate. The Penn Hills suburb has so many vacant buildings and lots that the subdivision is at risk of simply disappearing. The Rise of the Creative Class was published in 2002, more than ten years ago. If promising and talented young people were still doing the same things and migrating along the same paths as they were at that time then that would be a remarkable thing. It is common even in relatively good times for fashions to change in ten years or less, and things have been chaotic since that time.
- qwerta 12y agoI think best way with startup is to choose cheap base to stay permanently and travel a bit. I just returned from New York, planning trip to Berlin next month and hike in Anatolia after that. In between I will enjoy summer house on Greek beach, I also rent permanent apartment in Athens. My total (including travel) expenses are less than NY rent would be. And did I mention I support wife and kid?