8 ms·
This sort of thing isn't unique to the storage business. In the auto industry, they call it "decontenting": http://www.autoweek.com/car-shopping/articles/2012/
by smacktoward 12y ago
This sort of thing isn't unique to the storage business. In the auto industry, they call it "decontenting":
http://www.autoweek.com/car-shopping/articles/2012/01/decontenting--what-does-it-mean-for-car-shoppers.html http://www.autoweek.com/car-shopping/articles/2012/01/decont...
... but it works pretty much the same way: early models of a particular car, the ones that make that car's reputation, come loaded with all sorts of nice touches. Then as time passes the manufacturer slowly strips those touches out, replacing them with cheaper alternatives or just dropping them altogether. The price of the car stays the same, though, so the manufacturer gets to keep the difference as extra profit. (Or the price actually goes up, when the dropped features that used to be standard become optional add-ons instead.)
- mikeash 12y agoInteresting note at the end: "Don't think decontenting is limited to just cars. Next time you're at the grocery store, stop by the freezer case and check out your favorite carton of ice cream. Most brands have quietly gone from a half-gallon (two-quart) container to 1.75 quarts--without changing the price." I'm pretty sure I've seen the higher-end brands dropping to 1.5 quarts now. Sodas are pushing 1.25L and 1.5L containers when it used to just be purely 2L. There are a lot of four-packs in the beer aisle. A fair number of meats are being sold in fixed-sized packages, invariably less than one pound per package, rather than being sold by the pound. At least it's clear enough if you look for it. In the SSD case, it sounds like they're making important alterations to things that aren't discussed in the specs. Of course, you shouldn't buy something depending on anything that isn't listed in the specs, but if all the manufacturers have the same crappy set of incomplete specs, you don't have a lot of choice.
- profquail 12y agoWorse yet, some ice-cream brands (e.g., Breyer's) are also reformulating their recipes to use cheaper ingredients -- meaning they no longer meet the standard to be called "ice cream", but instead must be called "frozen dairy dessert": http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/17/dining/remembering-when-breyers-ice-cream-was-you-know-ice-cream.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/17/dining/remembering-when-br...
- rhizome 12y agoAn upshot of this is that staples like ice cream, mayonnaise, and cheese are some of the most label-regulated industries. The existence of terms like "processed cheese food" is a good thing.
- Jedd 12y agoIce cream, mayo and cheese are staples? I'm guessing you're based in North America. :)
- JetSpiegel 12y agoMaybe that fake cheese they eat on pizzas and the like.
- alphapapa 12y agoCan't pass up that chance to take a cheap shot at an entire continent of people! After all, everyone knows that people who live in North America are all fat, lazy, and too stupid to know it!
- maxerickson 12y agoThat's a case of the labeling law working nicely though. I like it when package prices have to be shown next to sensible unit prices, it really simplifies the comparison, regardless of any psychology that has been built into the packaging.
- mikeash 12y agoThis really makes me hate the half-assed use of the metric system in the US. It seems like my local stores go out of their way to use different imperial units for different products, making it harder to compare. Unit prices are great, but when one package is $/oz and another is $/gallon, it defeats much of the purpose.
- WalterBright 12y ago
- rhizome 12y agoConsumerist has been tracking this for years: http://consumerist.com/category/grocery-shrink-ray/ http://consumerist.com/category/grocery-shrink-ray/
- darksim905 12y agohttp://www.mouseprint.org/ http://www.mouseprint.org/
- patcon 12y agoI remember noticing this as an 10-year-old with bags of chips -- $0.79 bags would become bigger $0.99 "big grab" bags with a big exclamatory balloon, then the size would later go down to before, but the price would stay the same. Even as a kid, it seemed kinda sleazy
- rmckayfleming 12y agoI agree, but I think it's just a way for the producers to mask inflation. My gut feeling is that people are more likely to consciously notice a price increase of 20% than a 20% decrease in volume/weight.
- jamesbritt 12y agoI've seen this with assorted products offered in "new and improved" packaging that offers less than before, while the price stays the same. The new "E-Z pour" bottle is an excuse to reduce the contents.
- vonuebelgarten 12y agoSometimes these shrinkings are (accidentally) synchronized. In the early 2000s almost everything available from big manufacturers in Brazilian groceries shrunk while keeping the same prices (e.g. cookie bags going from 300g to 290g). Last year and a half yogurt not only shrunk but started vanishing from the malls, being replaced by almost identically-looking bottles of "fermented milk", as the new formulation did not met the mandatory labeling standards to be called "yogurt". Of course, the prices were kept or raised. That's everywhere.
- mikeash 12y agoIntellectually, I know that "fermented milk" is a perfectly accurate way to describe cheese, yogurt, and similar products, but I don't know if I could bring myself to buy and eat something that had it right on the label....
- wolf550e 12y agoHow about fermented grape juice or fermented grain?
- mikeash 12y agoOddly, I have no problem with those. Something about fermented milk specifically sounds bad. Even though I'll happily eat all sorts of cheese.
- mikeash 12y agoFor what it's worth, I decided this might be because I've had far too much experience with disgusting sour milk that sat in the refrigerator too long, while my only experience with rotten grain or grapes is with the nicely packaged kind where it was done on purpose.
- magila 12y agoAt least in that case they only make changes in a new model year. In the electronics industry substitutions are often made while retaining the the exact same SKU. So even savvy consumers have no way of knowing exactly what they are going to get. For example sellers of blank optical media will sometimes switch to a different supplier and the only way to tell is to check the MID after you have purchased them. Hard drive manufactures will will also switch to a totally different "cost reduced" design while retaining the same model number. Then there's the infamous panel lottery when buying a monitor from certain unscrupulous companies. I'm mildly surprised there hasn't been a high profile class action lawsuit over these practices.
- magila 12y agoI also forgot about consumer routers which sometimes ship totally different hardware under the same model number.
- kentonv 12y agoSamsung has been known to ship Android tablets containing completely different SoCs under the same model. For example, the new Galaxy Tab S might contain an Exynos SoC or a Qualcomm SoC. They're essentially two completely different tablets with the same name and exterior. Though, my understanding is that in their case it's not so much a bait-and-switch as a supply chain issue: they actually want to sell more units than any one SoC provider can deliver. Big pain for developers, though, when they're trying to track down a user-reported bug on one of these things.
- tartuffe78 12y agoAnother reason is 4G, for awhile (still maybe?) Samsung wasn't building any Exynos Chipsets with 4G radios, so markets where that mattered (US, etc.) they used Qualcomm
- dagw 12y agoMy understanding is that it's due to the Exynos SoC not supporting 4G, while the Qualcomm does. If you buy the 4G version you'll always get the Qualcomm version, and if you buy the wifi version you always get the Exynos version. So it's not like it's completely random what SoC you end up with.
- higherpurpose 12y agoIntel sort of does it, too. Like they have started calling some of their Atom CPU's "Celeron", while they still serve more powerful Haswell Celerons on the market, and the naming is just slightly different (a letter). They don't exactly replace it in the same model, though, so I guess they are not quite that bad yet, but they try to be misleading about it, too.
- yuhong 12y agoAnd I think Atoms has gotten better since the old days too.
- bipin-nag 12y agoWell that sucks. It should not happen, yet it does. And it should not definitely spread to more industries. But that really is no argument. I am sure the car manufacturers did not downgrade the car so that it runs at half its speed/milage. Then they came up with a fake benchmark to prove to the world that it actually does (even if it does not). Come on that is an insult to one's intelligence. These guys are ripping their customers. Whatever reviews for the product exist are based on the specs that no longer are. That is pure evil. What can someone do to stop this ? Besides not buying their products.
- jeroen 12y agoThat article first claims that prices stay the same, but then contains this: "They're grateful that the Jetta's base price is down $1,740." Then you're just getting less value for less money, which seems fair to me.
- marcosdumay 12y agoIt's only fair if you know you are getting less value. Otherwise it's false advertising.
- Dwolb 12y agoThis isn't always a 'gotcha' scenario in which the OEM acts in bad faith to the customer. In hardware, when you're under a lot of pressure to be deliver products on time, teams will be risk averse and over design to meet timing. As time goes on, engineering learns of the over design, or over capacity, and corrects the issue to save cost or optimize performance. This becomes an issue when teams trade off performance for cost.
- phillc 12y agoI'm currently trying to buy a pair of shoes on amazon, and many reviewers are calling out the fact that after giving the shoes a five star, they go to buy a second pair of the same shoe to find that it is completely different and of terribly quality.