14 ms·
Kingston and PNY using cheaper components after good reviews
- fridek 12y agoI've seen a similar situation about five years ago when I was testing USB pendrives for a local paper. It turned out it was close to impossible to get two pieces with the same specs and performance, even though they were branded with the same name. I've heard similar stories about HDDs having different controllers, number of discs and so on. Luckily in EU one can return within two weeks anything ordered online, so a simple solution is to order, test and return if it doesn't match expectations.
- ciupicri 12y agoReturn something that was taken out of the box and used?!
- maaaats 12y agoIn my country (Norway in Europe, but not EU member): Yes. But you cannot "use the product as your own", just open it and test that it meets your expectations.
- atopal 12y agoYes, indeed, with certain limitations, but it's quite common to order things online and send them back within two weeks – if you change your mind – usually without any penalties.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 12y agoHere are the English laws - the Consumer Protection (Distance Selling) Regulations https://www.gov.uk/online-and-distance-selling-for-businesses https://www.gov.uk/online-and-distance-selling-for-businesse... http://www.out-law.com/page-430 http://www.out-law.com/page-430
- barrkel 12y agoYes; in UK, it's Distance Selling Regulations (DSR). You're better protected if you buy online than in a store, ironically. PS: I looked it up, and actually the DSR has been superseded as of yesterday (!) by Consumer Contracts Regulations, which ups the UK protection from 7 days to 14 days, bringing it into line with EU directives.
- tomp 12y ago> You're better protected if you buy online than in a store, ironically. It's the only thing that makes sense, particularly if you want to instil trust in customers that buying online is "safe" and not prone to scams.
- SpaceRaccoon 12y agoThose damn socialists, amirite?
- briandh 12y agoI'm not sure about online purchases -- except on Amazon, which is very liberal in what it accepts, in my experience -- but brick and mortar retailers in the US are often very open to accepting open goods for returns (and the Target I usually go to, for instance, often has returned, opened electronics in the clearance section). In my experience, it's not particularly unusual for grocery stores to take back open food, even. I have heard personally once, and online many times, from foreigners marvelling at how readily many US retailers will take returns, even for silly reasons. I am not aware of any regulations mandating such practices, though I suppose they could exist.
- mikeash 12y agoI don't think it's required by law, since there are sellers with much less friendly return policies. But some sellers have learned that liberal return policies earn more business than the money they cost. Some just sort of unofficially try to keep customers happy, but some are up-front about it. Costco, for example, lets you return almost anything almost any time for any reason, or no reason. Electronics are limited to 90 days, but others have no limit. Bought some fruit that doesn't taste quite right, possibly because you left it in your car for two weeks? Just bring the moldy remains back. In the world of clothing, LL Bean and Lands' End are two examples where they take pretty much anything, any time. Lands' End even has an amusing story that they use to promote their crazy return policy, about a man who bought a collectible car from them as part of some promotion, and his widow returned it 20 years later after he died. (Two decades of inflation no doubt ate away at the true value of the refund, but still.) LL Bean will go out of their way to remind you of their policy. I had a button break on some pants and when I asked if I could get a replacement button somehow, they told me nope, just return them and we'll send you a new pair.
- fridek 12y agoIndeed, as long as it doesn't show any signs of usage. And as someone has mentioned, it works only when ordered and delievered - picking up something at the store makes return impossible (since one had a chance to see and evaluate the item).
- judk 12y agoBut for electronics you can't test the item in store.
- agumonkey 12y agoI've heard about HDD by recovery professionals trying to swap internals with hard time. But, even though it could look like some kind of voluntary lock in, to me it was normal production practice. Some batches of hdd with certain chipsets and later switching suppliers because of life means different chips.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoIs this something the storage industry is particularly notorious for? I recall that Seagate and Western Digital's (knowingly) substandard drives nearly bankrupted Amstrad.
- acdha 12y agoIt's common in any commodity industry where the differences aren't obvious to the casual buyer. In older industries we've had regulation requiring things like standard labels, sealed packaging, etc. to prevent abuses like selling food with inferior ingredients or lying about a car's fuel economy. I suspect it's only a matter of time before this happens in the tech industry since the market pressures give a strong incentive to cheat. Bunnie Huang had a fascinating, disturbing post about what the MicroSD market is like in China, eventually disassembling some dodgy Kingston cards: http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?page_id=1022 http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?page_id=1022
- jws 12y agoJust yesterday motor oil, transmission fluid, and antifreeze came up in a similar lawsuit. Not a lot of details, but interested parties could start here: http://fox2now.com/2014/06/13/mo-attorney-general-suing-five-local-retailers-for-bogus-products/ http://fox2now.com/2014/06/13/mo-attorney-general-suing-five...
- darksim905 12y agoThe unfortunate thing is there are probably so many people who just buy that shit because they need it. My initial reaction was that piece wasn't necessary & is more due to companies coming up with shit products & flooding the market, which happens in IT too.
- poolpool 12y agoDell has also been caught doing this with monitors.
- aet 12y agoWere they good to start with?
- Argorak 12y agoDell makes very good flat-screens for an affordable price, e.g. the U2311H was a really nice one.
- justathrow2k 12y agoDid you not read the article in this post? Or are you just being daft and trying to say something snide about Dell? The article itself is about switching out quality components for cheaper ones after your first batch gets good reviews. So yes, if Dell is doing the same thing, it follows that yes, they were at one point good, and then they started swapping out for cheaper components.
- mkhalil 12y agoPretty sure he wasn't asking a normal question, he was obviously implying they he didn't believe there monitors were good in the first place. Which is wrong. They have their good monitors and their bad ones.
- justathrow2k 12y agoRight, so the latter, he was just being daft and trying to say something snide about Dell.
- skj 12y agoIt's called the internet. Dell's feelings weren't hurt.
- 12y ago
- raverbashing 12y agoGood to know Kingston seemed to be a nice brand some 10 years ago, but nowadays it's mostly hype
- judk 12y agoKingston was always the dodgy cheap brand.
- smacktoward 12y agoThis sort of thing isn't unique to the storage business. In the auto industry, they call it "decontenting": http://www.autoweek.com/car-shopping/articles/2012/01/decontenting--what-does-it-mean-for-car-shoppers.html http://www.autoweek.com/car-shopping/articles/2012/01/decont... ... but it works pretty much the same way: early models of a particular car, the ones that make that car's reputation, come loaded with all sorts of nice touches. Then as time passes the manufacturer slowly strips those touches out, replacing them with cheaper alternatives or just dropping them altogether. The price of the car stays the same, though, so the manufacturer gets to keep the difference as extra profit. (Or the price actually goes up, when the dropped features that used to be standard become optional add-ons instead.)
- mikeash 12y agoInteresting note at the end: "Don't think decontenting is limited to just cars. Next time you're at the grocery store, stop by the freezer case and check out your favorite carton of ice cream. Most brands have quietly gone from a half-gallon (two-quart) container to 1.75 quarts--without changing the price." I'm pretty sure I've seen the higher-end brands dropping to 1.5 quarts now. Sodas are pushing 1.25L and 1.5L containers when it used to just be purely 2L. There are a lot of four-packs in the beer aisle. A fair number of meats are being sold in fixed-sized packages, invariably less than one pound per package, rather than being sold by the pound. At least it's clear enough if you look for it. In the SSD case, it sounds like they're making important alterations to things that aren't discussed in the specs. Of course, you shouldn't buy something depending on anything that isn't listed in the specs, but if all the manufacturers have the same crappy set of incomplete specs, you don't have a lot of choice.
- profquail 12y agoWorse yet, some ice-cream brands (e.g., Breyer's) are also reformulating their recipes to use cheaper ingredients -- meaning they no longer meet the standard to be called "ice cream", but instead must be called "frozen dairy dessert": http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/17/dining/remembering-when-breyers-ice-cream-was-you-know-ice-cream.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/17/dining/remembering-when-br...
- pling 12y agoAnd this is why I always buy Crucial. Cruial and Micron are the same company and micron actually make the chips rather than just assemble them. They have control over the entire process end to end and no motivation to pick up chips anywhere else as they already have the best deal. Over the last 10-12 years I've bought about 2000-3000 sticks of RAM from them. Not one failure or problem ever. I used to buy vendor provided RAM (mainly IBM and Sun back then) and just got ripped off every time. Zero failures on Sun stuff but the ECC stuff hurts. IBM sold us crap lots of times. Only pain is you can't get an 8Mb EDO SIMM anymore for embedded stuff so its off to a dealer to be shafted repetitively for stuff like that.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> They have control over the entire process end to end How is that supposed to protect you from a completely intentional shady business tactic? Because that's what this is. "We looked the other way and our supplier screwed us over" is a flimsy excuse at the best of times (quality control and penalties should be built into the contract in the first place), but in the Kingston/PNY example it isn't even that.
- bluedino 12y agoPNT's other choice is to pay more for better quality NAND or controllers and then pass the cost along to the consumer.
- kourt 12y agoPresumably because semiconductor manufacturing has massive setup costs, so changing anything in the middle of a production run is likely to be uneconomical. But an assembler can simply switch parts or suppliers.
- pling 12y agoWell the supplier and the manufacturer are the same for Micron. They wouldn't screw themselves over. That's illogical.
- 12y ago
- kevingadd 12y agoI had this problem with PNY with one of their other products - I bought a mid-tier video card from them (GeForce GTX 570), and after a hardware failure, sent it in for an RMA. Over the course of multiple RMA mailings, at various times they would send back a visibly physically damaged 'replacement' card, a 'replacement' card that was a different size/shape (and obviously a different model), and in one case my broken card, that I sent them initially. It was as if they had a pile of 'works well enough to boot Windows' cards and RMAs that weren't totally broken got put into the pile, while they pulled other cards out of the pile to ship to customers. It was pretty impressive to be able to watch shady cost-cutting in action. Too bad it cost me around $120 in UPS shipping fees.
- hemaljshah 12y agoI hate hearing about these stories from manufactures, it totally kills their rep for me to ever trust them again. Why do companies go against just building solid products, even if it costs a little more money. It's exactly how Apple has gotten away with charging premium dollars for similar hardware - build quality always wins.
- Omniusaspirer 12y agoNothing is more aggravating than planned obsolescence in appliances. Just sell me a good product that will last 30+ year with basic maintenance. I'll happily pay literally up to 5x the price you charge for your 5 year lifetime (if I'm lucky) piece of shit. Hell, I'll probably buy the replacement parts from you besides so it's not like you're completely losing my business.
- bitJericho 12y agoBecause nobody buys 100 dollar toasters.
- Omniusaspirer 12y agoI would if it came with an assurance/warranty for the next 30 years from a company I didn't think would go bankrupt before then.
- bitJericho 12y agoIf that were actually true they would be making them. (And they do make them, they're commercial quality equipment and they're easy to find. Consumer's don't want to pay the big bucks for this stuff. Not even you, or you'd go find it.)
- Omniusaspirer 12y agoI have looked into these things, sadly commercial dishwashers aren't viewed as being suitable for residential purposes. Toasters perhaps, I'll confess to having not looked into those yet. Washing machine and dryer I do plan to buy commercial most likely as soon as the need arises and I don't live in a place with laundry provided. I'm not exaggerating when I say I'm fine with paying for these things, I've learned time and time again that I'm better off paying more for a quality product than getting the cheapest thing I can possibly find.
- saltyknuckles 12y agoIf you're going to buy a SSD go with Samsung or Intel
- izzydata 12y agoI was going to say the same thing. These seems to yield the least unhappy customers and return rates. Intel more than anyone seems to care about the quality of their SSDs.
- wmf 12y agoPeople shouldn't have bought those brands to begin with since they add no value: http://www.storagereview.com/it_s_game_over_for_most_consumer_ssd_companies http://www.storagereview.com/it_s_game_over_for_most_consume... BTW, Apple does the same thing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7689180 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7689180
- sjwright 12y agoThat's not the same thing.
- orbitingpluto 12y agoI purchased an ASUS Notebook X550DP-DS101-CA with a resolution of 1920x1080 last year. Exact same model #, 1366x768 at some stores, 1920x1080 at others. (Same store franchise.) I was run around three stores until I managed to get the "real model" that I was looking for. Caveat emptor.
- jrockway 12y agoLenovo did this with the last Thinkpad I ever bought.
- WalterBright 12y ago> The Cadillac DTS initially came with standard heated leather seats. In 2009, that feature became an option. "However, the price of the car didn't change," he said. The price actually dropped, due to inflation.
- mzarate06 12y agoDell does this with their monitors [1], first by shipping certain models with IPS panels, then with cheaper PVA panels after good reviews are published. That bit me w/their 2007wfp, which was a great monitor mostly for 1 reason: it was IPS at a great price point. Overwhelmingly positive reviews convinced me to purchase 2 of them. Then buyers started noticing picture quality issues not described in previous positive reviews. After some research, it was found Dell had silently started shipping the 2007wfp with cheaper PVA panels, not IPS. After noticing similar issues with the 2 I purchased, I eventually confirmed they were PVA monitors. I was fairly upset. There's a good thread on Hard Forum about all of this here.[2] And despite very frustrated customers, Dell never acknowledged any problem. In fact, a Dell rep can be quoted: "... a 2007WFP is a 2007WFP ... It does not matter what panel is installed." [3] I stopped buying Dell products after this experience. [1] http://en.community.dell.com/f/3529/t/18107050.aspx http://en.community.dell.com/f/3529/t/18107050.aspx [2] http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1111100 http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1111100 [3] http://en.community.dell.com/f/3529/t/18286693.aspx http://en.community.dell.com/f/3529/t/18286693.aspx
- mikeash 12y agoOn the one hand, that's awful. On the other hand, if you only discovered that you got the inferior version well after you purchased, did it really matter for you?
- mzarate06 12y agoGood question, but indeed it did, for a couple reasons. For one, I only purchase IPS monitors. Even before I found out about everything, I had already noticed slightly less picture quality compared to other IPS monitors I used; lesser viewing angle, colors shifting, etc. Part of what caught my attention regarding the customer complaints I found is their symptoms were apparent on the 2 I purchased. So despite not knowing I had a PVA panel, there was a noticeable quality difference that mattered. The customer complaints supplemented, rather than created, my initial concerns. Second, I was cheated. The monitor they delivered was inferior to the one advertised (at the time, the 2007wfp was advertised with an IPS panel, a detail later removed). That's lying. What's worse, is a customer support department trying to sweep it under the rug.
- general_failure 12y agoJust get Intel ssds. They are the best
- brador 12y agoSamsung too. Evo 240gb, Half the benchmarked read/write iops on newer SSDs. We returned 6 before going with a different brand.
- swinglock 12y agoDo you have a source for that? I'm looking to buy, that or the Crucial MX100.
- aklemm 12y agoI've always wondered how this maneuver isn't considered a major free market failure.
- dbg31415 12y agoWhat a bunch of cunts.
- Sami_Lehtinen 12y agoHardly new stuff. We had horrible problems in production 10 years ago. After analyzing the situation, we found out that the new servers had same memory as older ones from Kingston. But when you watched closely, you noticed that even if the Kingston label with all type information was exactly the same, the chips on the DIMM weren't. So no new news here. If you work in the IT department, you'll also probably know, that when ordering 300 "similar" computers: Changes are quite low that you're really getting those delivered. After going through the delivery, it's quite likely that you got at least 10 different computer series in that delivery. Different power source, different memory, possibly different motherboard, hard drive, power source cooling fan, cpu cooler etc. That's just normal unfortunately. That's why many supplier leave the specification quite open on purpose, so it doesn't matter what they deliver as long as it's something meeting the specification.