5 ms·
I'm hoping this produces some good smoking guns. At least we'll know what's going on as opposed to having to infer it. I mean if Netflix is paying Comcast $2k/
by MBCook 12y ago
I'm hoping this produces some good smoking guns. At least we'll know what's going on as opposed to having to infer it.
I mean if Netflix is paying Comcast $2k/month to fix the issue that's stupid but not very bad. If it's $2m/month that's a huge problem.
- wmf 12y agoNetflix has "multiple terabits" of bandwidth to Comcast, so slightly under $1M/month wouldn't be a bad guess.
- MBCook 12y agoI fully expect it to cost more than that amount of bandwidth normally would on the open market.
- wmf 12y agoExcept Netflix already said that Comcast is charging them less than market transit rates.
- eggnet 12y agoI would hope so, Comcast isn't providing transit services.
- MichaelGG 12y agoWhy would Netflix pay more for single network peering than full transit? Presumably Netflix could, hire a better ISP than Cogent and actually get the capacity they're trying to buy.
- diminoten 12y agoCogent isn't the problem, from a technical standpoint. The issue is that the last-mile ISPs have hardware that gets overloaded by the responses to the requests their clients are making, e.g. Bob sends out 10 packets to Cogent, and Cogent sends 10 million packets in response. The last-mile ISP isn't prepared to deal with those 10 million packets all at once.
- msandford 12y agoThen the last mile ISP is fucking right up because they've advertised that they can. Full stop. http://www.comcast.com/internet-service.html http://www.comcast.com/internet-service.html If they advertise they can provide the service then they should be held accountable. If they say they can't provide the service, then they should not be allowed to advertise that they can. This is quite literally a "have a cake and eat it too" type of situation.
- jsz0 12y ago> This is quite literally a "have a cake and eat it too" type of situation. How is NetFlix any different? They make the choice to lower the cost to deliver their service by choosing a CDN with inadequate existing peering relationships with ISPs. They also severely limit client side functionality because it makes their service cheaper/easier to support on a wide range of devices. NetFlix collects this data about ISP performance so why don't they say 'oh hey sorry ISP X user. We can't let you sign up because you'll have poor performance!' -- instead they happily take the money.
- washadjeffmad 12y agoISPs aren't stopping people from signing up for Netflix because they won't allow the maximum performance subscribers' service plans specify. Accepting pay for service isn't dishonest. Accepting pay for service you don't provide is. Netflix has Internet Connection Speed Recommendations (https://help.netflix.com/en/node/306 https://help.netflix.com/en/node/306). ISPs offer service plans that cost more for higher maximum speeds. Is it Netflix's responsibility to ensure particular subscribers receive particular qualities of content, without regard for the contents' source qualities, the subscriber's bandwidth, the policies of their ISP, or any other range of factors in the last mile? Netflix is offering content, not quality. It doesn't sell differently priced subscriptions based on "maximum video quality", it offers a range of bitrates at a flat rate and sends the one that allows the best experience for your bandwidth. Although, that's sort of the issue, isn't it? It's not "your" bandwidth that determines that now. It's not the plan you're paying your ISP for that's the limiting factor, it's the ISPs particular traffic shaping policies. Netflix isn't slowing its traffic down or decreasing video quality prejudicially based on your ISP or internet plan. It's the opposite, but they're being asked to pay, rightfully or not, so that some of their subscribers won't have their bandwidth throttled by their own ISPs.
- MBCook 12y agoBecause Comcast controls (possibly exclusive) access to X% of their customers (where X is decidedly non-trivial).
- eck 12y ago> Why would Netflix pay more for single network peering than full transit? Because the interconnection between your transit provider and Comcast is frequently saturated and Comcast is not going to fix it since they would prefer to be paid.
- ColinDabritz 12y agoI don't care at all how much money is being paid. So long as content providers are paying any amount, it's unequal, and needs to stop. Net Neutrality would be a good step. Common carrier status would be better.
- diminoten 12y agoWho the hell are you to tell me how and who I peer with? It's my network, you shouldn't be able to force me to peer with actors who will flood me.
- wmf 12y agoI agree that nobody should be forced to peer. But if a content provider is "flooding" an ISP, refusing to peer will just cause those packets to arrive via more-expensive transit. How bad do you want to spite Netflix?
- diminoten 12y agoRefusing to peer won't cause those packets to arrive at nearly the rate they were arriving previously, which means my network won't flood, which is less expensive for me. I don't want to spite Netflix at all, I just don't want my network flooded. (I probably also shouldn't have promised folks I could deliver all of these packets, either, but that's another issue)
- aaronblohowiak 12y ago>I don't want to spite Netflix at all, I just don't want my network flooded. You have different incentives than people trying to protect their transactional VOD content businesses.
- msandford 12y agoYou've got that backwards. From this very high level the Internet is PULL ONLY. Netflix doesn't start streaming data to customers just to waste bandwidth and fuck up your network with a flood. That's a DoS/DDoS attack. The "flood" is actually your paying customers who thought that you were telling the truth when you promised them X/Y internet service. They are trying to utilize the service they have paid for and you are preventing them from doing so. To not provide them with the service that was promised could be construed as fraud informally if not legally. I'm sure there is plenty of language in an ISPs retail contract that says that customers can fuck right off for any and all reasons and no matter what the ISP is not at fault. But while it might be legal it's definitely dishonest.