5 ms·
Xiph needs to start a public prototyping playground that extends unpatented video and image codec research to create islands of techniques that are not patentab
by sitkack 12y ago
Xiph needs to start a public prototyping playground that extends unpatented video and image codec research to create islands of techniques that are not patentable. They don't hav e to work, just be an idea.
Like if I said, "I'd like to use cellular automata and voronoi segmentation to do multiscale texture extraction and motion representation."
Someone else could possibly do a 500-1000 line python program that implemented something like that.
Create a 1000 of those ideas drop them into the public domain (we need something like the GPL for ideas) so that there is a large body of techniques and work that is unpatentable.
- e12e 12y agoI'm afraid the existing body of software patents dictates not placing such ideas in the public domain, but rather as a form of "patent left" foundation that can force cross licensing access.
- higherpurpose 12y agoCan you elaborate? Why would putting the technologies in the public domain not work?
- sitkack 12y agoI think because everyone is free to extend the public domain via patents. So a researcher at Panasonic or Bosch could tweak something in the codec corpus and patent the tweak.
- e12e 12y agoIt would work for future patents, but I'm afraid it wouldn't work for future software -- the theory being that any non-trivial software will likely infringe on any number of patents. A collection of patents might help force cross-licensing, and so protect new (Free or not) software against existing patents (the assumption being that also holders of non-trivial software patents develop new software, and might infringe on one or more patents in the collection).
- vanderZwan 12y ago> "I'd like to use cellular automata and voronoi segmentation to do multiscale texture extraction and motion representation." Are you a mindreader? I've been thinking about using Adrian Secord's stippling work[0] in a motion picture context for years, but more for fun than anything serious. [0] http://cs.nyu.edu/~ajsecord/stipples.html http://cs.nyu.edu/~ajsecord/stipples.html