6 ms·
Pro-Tesla electric car bill advances in NJ Assembly
- dave1619 12y agoThe bill hasn't passed yet. It was approved by the Assembly Consumer Affairs Committee but still needs to be voted on by the legislature. According to http://www.engadget.com/2014/06/06/tesla-resume-sales-new-jersey/ http://www.engadget.com/2014/06/06/tesla-resume-sales-new-je... : "The bill will need to pass a few more of New Jersey's legislative processes to become law, but things are looking up for Tesla." Poor reporting job by TechCrunch (http://techcrunch.com/2014/06/06/tesla-wins-back-the-right-to-sell-direct-to-consumers-in-new-jersey/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/06/06/tesla-wins-back-the-right-t...). They made it seem like the bill was voted into law.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- maratd 12y agoNot only has the bill not been brought to the floor, it would need to be approved by both legislative bodies and then signed by the governor. The probability that the dealer lobby will sit idly by and let this pass ... is unlikely. Regardless, you can buy a Tesla in New York, Pennsylvania, or online. If you go to a Tesla showroom now, you'll see a huge sign that says "pay 0% sales tax", which makes sense if you buy it online. Why would I want to pay 7% more even if I had the option? All of this is just bullshit, on both sides. The dealers already lost. They lost when buying cars over the internet became a viable option.
- cpwright 12y agoThe pay 0% sales tax is surprising to me. At least in New York whenever you register a vehicle, you pay the sales tax; no matter what state you bought it in. Even if you didn't have to pay the tax to register, my guess is that the NJ law would be written as a sales and use tax; and you would be responsible for it anyway. It wouldn't exactly be hard for the state to figure out who has a Tesla with registration records, but who had neglected to pay the sales tax and slap them with additional fines and penalties.
- lectrick 12y agoJust paid 8.25% sales tax on a Tesla in NY (Long Island). OUCH. (vs. 0% in NJ!)
- hnnewguy 12y ago>The dealers already lost. They lost when buying cars over the internet became a viable option. It will be a long time before people are comfortable buying a car online. I just purchased a new car; the process is unbelievably anachronistic, but it still exists and prospers for a reason. There's very much a "this is how it's done attitude". That's because the majority of the world doesn't accept "technology" liker the denizens of HackerNews.
- dang 12y agoUrl changed from http://techcrunch.com/2014/06/06/tesla-wins-back-the-right-to-sell-direct-to-consumers-in-new-jersey/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/06/06/tesla-wins-back-the-right-t..., which points to http://www.engadget.com/2014/06/06/tesla-resume-sales-new-jersey/ http://www.engadget.com/2014/06/06/tesla-resume-sales-new-je..., which points to this.
- DiabloD3 12y agoThe original techcrunch url didnt point to engadget when I submitted it, but thanks to the mod who changed it to the nj.gov url.
- afternooner 12y agoWhy can the government force a middle man to exist in the first place, that doesn't seem in line with capitalism at all?
- dodders 12y agoAny form of government intervention in the markets is out of line with pure capitalism, e.g. farm subsidies; import taxes; bailouts of the auto and finance industries; medicare; medicaid; social security... one could make an argument for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as well. That's not to say that the above are not reasonable policies for an advanced western economy, just not that they could reasonably be considered purely capitalist.
- esbranson 12y agoNo, there is no "purely capitalist". You confuse "laissez-faire capitalism" with "capitalism". If what you say is true, "laissez-faire" would be a superfluous adjective, like calling it "capitalist capitalism".
- lifeformed 12y agoThere's no American law stating "the US economy must be capitalist." "Capitalism" is just the rough description we assign to the US economy. The principles are there, but there are many exceptions.
- geofffox 12y agoThis seems like a 'one off' deal. Tesla can come in, zero emissions exception, but conventional competition against the franchised dealer model is still prohibited. This is solely because of embarrassment, but it doesn't right the real wrong.
- bsilvereagle 12y agoIf I remember correctly, a lot of deals Tesla has struck with other states are "one off" deals just for Tesla.
- stephen_g 12y agoHmmm... Surely it would be better to do something like "a car manufacturer can not have a store within x miles of a franchised dealer licensed to sell that manifacturer's cars" rule, so Telsa can come in and do what they do (since there are no dealers to protect), dealers are happy because they are still protected (which I think is wrong, but their lobby groups are probably to strong and hopefully this way does pave the way to dealers dying out because of market forces)
- afternooner 12y agoQuestion for those who understand this, why can the government force a middle man to exist in the first place? It seem to a layman to violate several other rights.
- gesman 12y agoGovernment is the biggest middleman in existence.
- leorocky 12y agoMiddlemen implies no or little value derived from the middleman's place. A stable, powerful and secure government is required for value of any meaningful value to exist in the first place.
- diafygi 12y agoPlanet Money has a great podcast explaining the reasons why car dealers exist. http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-435-why-buying-a-car-is-so-awful http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-...
- kristopolous 12y agoI'd really like to know what the legal framework is for securing a market position by law. I constantly hear the argument that by codifying contemporary business models they've secured jobs. Using this logic we should still have manually switched phone networks where people move around cables on giant boards all day long and rooms full of people using typewriters who have to start over again if they have a spelling error. There should be artificial $1 taxes for emails to keep the physical post in business and other nonsense. I really don't see how the argument is valid. I'm just surprised that there isn't some landmark labor case that would invalidate laws which artificially perpetuate inefficient vestigial processes or explicitly ban a market from evolving.
- afarrell 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rodandar 12y agoCan anyone explain to me why Telsa should get an exemption from the law and not other car manufacturers? Seems to me - that everyone should have to play by the same rules. I'm a Tesla fan, and I'm not a fan of car dealers, I just don't understand why Tesla should get an exemption just for them? Nobody seems to want to talk about this....thoughts out there other than: government should support electric cars? Should GM be able to sell the volt direct, but not other cars? Someone please explain!
- esbranson 12y agoYes, that is what they're saying: GM be able to sell the volt direct, but not other cars. Every company would be treated the same ("play by the same rules"). They can all sell zero emission vehicles direct to consumers at a maximum of four locations in NJ. Why does Tesla get this exemption? Because corruption is only acceptable by the population is everyone is doing it. In this case, NJ is one of only a handful of states that is blatantly protectionist of this established industry.
- adventured 12y agoIs there data in the wild regarding how much less maintenance a Tesla S needs than a comparable gas-powered luxury sedan? Logically I believe the premise, and I know Tesla has discussed this numerous times over the years, but I haven't come across any comprehensive studies covering this aspect since the S went on sale.
- Ryel 12y agoSorry for being a bit off-topic but I'm fascinated by Elon's boldness in claiming that hydrogen fuel-cell tech is a dead end for automakers even though they are doubling down in it's investment. I would love to be knowledgeable enough to have a reasonable opinion on this topic. Could anybody recommend reading material where I could learn about some of what Elon is doing, what automakers are doing and what the pros vs cons are of both without getting too intimidated by the science behind it?
- esbranson 12y ago> ... would allow a start-up electric car maker, like Tesla, a reasonable period of time to ramp up operations (or sales volume) before they conform their business operations to the franchise model," [president of the New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers Jim Appleton] said. > "Should there be some kind of time limitations within the bill or are we setting the stage for a situation where the historic dealership model is going to be hurt 10, 20 years up the road?" [State Sen. Brian Rumpf (R-Ocean)] said. Proof positive that the "captured agency" in regulatory capture[1] is actually the entire government, or at least the entire Republican Party. Government officials don't even try and hide that they're opposed to hurting established industries. The only difference is that in the 21st Century its not a railroad and oil company they're constantly trying to shield from competition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture