8 ms·
TorCoin
- chatmasta 12y agoI'm Miles Richardson, one of the authors. This research was my Yale senior project, in collaboration with fellow student Mainak Ghosh, Professor Bryan Ford, and Tor community leader Rob Jansen. I thought now was a good time to post, with the EFF initiative on the front page of HN. We will be presenting our research at the HotPETS 2014 privacy conference in Amsterdam, in July. Please come by if you can. :) At a glance, the point of this research is to introduce an alternative cryptocurrency, called TorCoin, that rewards relays with coins for transferring bandwidth. Relay operators can then sell those coins on any altcoin exchange. TorCoin is like Bitcoin, but it's bandwidth intensive, rather than CPU intensive. So in effect, relay operators "mine" TorCoins and make money selling them on exchanges. Let me know if you have any questions or want to discuss. The next step is developing a prototype, and/or a network simulation to run experiments. Anyone interested in helping, let me or any of the authors know. Email is miles.richardson@yale.edu
- rgbrgb 12y agoThanks for posting. It's fantastic to see a cryptocoin where the mining isn't just wasting cycles.
- isaacwaller 12y agoWhat would give "TorCoins" value? It is obvious relays would sell their coins on some altcoin exchange, but who would be purchasing these coins? It seems that the only people purchasing TorCoins would be people looking to donate to Tor relays (this is a totally valid use case, but I was wondering if you have something else in mind.) Looks really cool by the way.
- chatmasta 12y agoYes -- This is one of the open questions for discussion, and one of the most important. (HotPETS is a "workshop", which in Academia is the precursor to a conference... papers are meant to be early stage drafts ready for discussion. So we are curious how people would be interested in the currency.) You're right, one of the early reasons for purchasing TorCoins would likely be donating to Tor. But they are a totally usable altcoin, just like Dogecoin for example. What reason do people have to buy Dogecoin? Not much, beyond using it as a currency or speculating with it as an investment. I could see TorCoin working the same way.
- tribaal 12y agoAnother use you should consider is to follow the FON model - you can spend TorCoins to buy bandwidth from people operating networks. The more bandwidth you share for TOR, the more free wifi you get. If you only "sell" wifi to torcoin owners, you simply trade internet access time, but running a tor relay would be like "mining" in the traditional bitcoin world. EDIT: The point I'm trying to make is that instead of "just" the way to create torcoins, this would also create a way to spend it (and provide value to people by spending it).
- JimmyM 12y agoDogecoin is an example of excellent and deliberate marketing. From branding decisions ("Let's stop people talking about us as the joke coin, and start people talking about us as the community coin") to PR (Constantly reaching out to big news outlets, carrying out small-to-medium PR campaigns) to content marketing (the tools available for Dogecoin have quickly grown in number and sophistication - check out moolah.io for instance, which began on /r/dogecoin) to incentive marketing (they're constantly giving people small stakes in Dogecoin's success). Quite frankly, it's weird. I think of Dogecoin as the marketing coin now, which is most of the reason I've withdrawn from the community somewhat. I really don't want my day job getting mixed up with my free time. > What reason do people have to buy Dogecoin? No technical, practical reason. But you may find that without that consistent, sustained marketing that people won't use your coin so much.
- sathishmanohar 12y agoI thought miners get coins for transmitting bandwidth which they can sell at exchanges, and people who do not participate in transmitting but want to trasmit buy these coins to consume bandwidth in the network. It would make sense. Essentially miners would be bandwidth providers and consumers buy torcoin to pay miners. The monetary value of torcoin will be decided by free market.
- GrinningFool 12y agoExcept tor network is already available for free...
- GrinningFool 12y agoFurther thought: it would make sense in a new tor network, not an established one. But the context you've given is similar to the argument that *coins have value because of the electricity costs required for their creation. Unless I can trade those coins for units of energy, those coins are not a store of the value of their energy cost. Similarly, unless I can trade these coins for access to higher bandwidth on tor (and/or if the lack of them denies me access to tor ), they hold no value to anyone except as a speculation vehicle (as any other coin of the day).
- nullc 12y agoIt also appears to rely on trusted authorities who could simply lie to their own advantage, and appears to suggest no strong mechanism to make this process robust against sybil or collusion. E.g. I can just very cheaply claim to be running millions of nodes— 99.99% of the whole network, unless you pin the existence of trusted participants who could at least force my fake nodes to be reachable (and even then botnets make forgery inexpensive), but if you go the route of pinning certain trusted participants, why not just have them hand out the reward? While this might be an interesting resource allocation technology, and tor itself has strong assumptions about non-collusion of directory authorities (and their services like bandwidth authorities), it seems disingenuous to compare it to Bitcoin.
- chatmasta 12y agoThis is our primary concern. Our goal for this paper is to maintain at least the status quo of anonymity in the Tor network. Currently, every Tor client uses a trusted group of ~7 "directory servers" to assign them to a circuit. Our implementation relies analogously on trusted "assignment servers" to assign clients to circuits. That's the purpose of the TorPath assignment protocol. In fact, it provides better anonymity than the status-quo, because each node on the circuit only knows the IP address of its neighbors, rather than the current situation, where the client knows the IP of every relay on the circuit. So yes, this assignment protocol relies on trusted servers. But so does Tor in its current state. Your point about botnets is a very good one, and one we haven't considered fully. We will certainly address this further in future versions of the paper. However, we do consider sybil attacks. Addressing them is the primary purpose of the TorPath assignment protocol. It ensures that, even if an adversary controls over 50% of the relays, there is a very low chance that (1/16 if I remember correctly) a new circuit will consist of three evil relays. Since we limit the number of coins that can be mined on a given circuit, we call this security a "good enough" margin of error for bad coins. Since it's predictable it can be baked into economic models. But you're right, these are important considerations that we are taking very seriously.
- kylebrown 12y agoI read the TorCoin/TorPath paper yesterday, and looked at some of the references including CoinShuffle[1] (a bitcoin mixing protocol) and Dissent[2] (implementation of a DC-net or Dining Cryptographer's net, 2nd great invention by David Chaum after RSA blinding/anonymous e-cash). I'll summarize what I learned here, hopefully someone will find it useful. One of the key pieces seems to be the Neff shuffle (verifiable random shuffling of an ordered list of public keys). The Neff shuffle builds on ElGamal pairs (which themselves are the core algorithm in the verifiable voting system helios[3]). Dissent looks to be the application of a Neff shuffling technique to ferret out the malicious nodes in a DC-net (a provably anonymous communication network). CoinShuffle is basically the use of a DC-net to anonymously pool together a set of bitcoin public keys, and the coinShuffle prototype is a fork of the Dissent codebase. The TorCoin protocol specifies using anonymous or mixed bitcoin transactions (such as by using CoinShuffle or ZeroCoin). And tying it all back together, in the TorPath protocol we again find Neff shuffling, used by the assignment servers to generate provably-random Tor relay circuits from groups of relays. 1. http://crypsys.mmci.uni-saarland.de/projects/CoinShuffle/ http://crypsys.mmci.uni-saarland.de/projects/CoinShuffle/ 2. http://dedis.cs.yale.edu/dissent/ http://dedis.cs.yale.edu/dissent/ 3. https://vote.heliosvoting.org https://vote.heliosvoting.org
- GrinningFool 12y agoProof of bandwidth is an innovate idea in the cryptocurrency space, but it seems a weak point is "make money selling them on the exchange". If that is their only value - if there is no economy built around them and they have no purchasing power on their own - then they'd only see a brief pump-and-dump rise/fall like any other new altcoin. Certainly it's an experiment worth trying, but if its sole value is in its potential for exchange, I don't see anything preventing it from becoming yet another short-lived altcoin. Then again, the same could be said of many coins out there now that have been lingering whole weeks* without dropping to 0 value 1. some have even been surviving for months...
- notastartup 12y agoAssuming that there will be more nodes on the Tor network as a result of a financial incentive for running such nodes, how will the TorCoin deal with over supply of nodes, therefore the drop in payout per node? Can TorCoin be used to subsequently purchase more bandwidth? How would this bandwidth differ from the free bandwidth? Lower latency?
- aburan28 12y agoMaybe this somehow be a away of rewarding bitcoin full-nodes
- facepalm 12y agoTL;DR: why don't you call your paper "TorCoin.pdf" instead of "paper.pdf"? Minor nitpick: what is up with PDF naming? When I "save" the PDF to my computer I don't even get the choice to rename it (I guess I could configure that but I am too lazy). So now I have a PDF called "paper.pdf" on my HD. If I ever want to find the paper on TorCoin again, it will fail. This problem seems very common in the world of academic papers.
- etiam 12y agoI would like to comment that while the intentions seem very good, I think it may be a severe mistake to use monetary compensation as a means to increase the number of TOR relays. Framing a situation as an economic transaction has been shown to interfere with other motivations. The classic research paper would be http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=180117 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=180117 where introducing a fine to make parents pick up their children at daycare considerably worsened the situation. The interpretation is that behaviour that was evaluated in a context of prosocial motivations such as being decent towards the staff, keeping a good relation with them, etc, were supplanted by a view that 'it's worth the cost of the fine'. It is worthy of note that going to an economic reference frame is often easy whereas going from an economic reference frame to one based on social values is frequently difficult - it certainly can't be expected to recover spontaneously just because the money is taken out of the picture again. Now, TOR is very much about prosocial values - liberty, free speech, the right to communicate without being unjustly surveilled, and so on, and because of that, I think it is potentially quite vulnerable to these kinds of effects. I think there is a substantial chance that running a TOR node is not going to be worth the economic profit in the long run, but that shouldn't matter, because running a TOR node is about something other and something more important than making an economic profit. If we start framing it as a business transaction there is a risk we hurt the (in this context) much more important motivations to operate a node. I think the TOR initiative should be developed on motivation based in the human rights values it naturally supports. And in this case I believe the option of monetary compensation is genuinely at odds with that. I'm somewhat sad to be saying this, because as I mentioned, it seems to me that the project is based in the best of intentions. Some components of the TorCoin system may be valuable for other service functions in the network. I summary, I think the psychological effects of introducing the compensation scheme really should be carefully evaluated before any attempts to introduce it in practice. My spontaneous impression is that it is the wrong method of motivation for growing and maintaining the TOR network and should not be introduced at such. If it is after all introduced, that should be done in a manner that is informed of the psychological consequences. As a preferred alternative we should emphasize the social and ideological benefits of TOR for core motivation and lower the threshold for contributing by making it technically trivial for the contributor and by making the situation as clear as possible about risks and benefits of operating a node.
- furyg3 12y agoSlightly OT... Assuming I'd like to 'donate' to TOR by just running a node myself, what would be a cost-effective hosting provider to use for this? This would be a relay node, not an exit node (I can imagine that hosting providers wouldn't be so happy about exit nodes).
- tech-no-logical 12y agoI've been running a small exit node for over 5 years, with three providers, none of which have complained (I'm in the netherlands, that might matter). there's one disadvantage though : a lot of sites refuse my ip because it's an exit node. which is no problem because all my own traffic runs through a vpn anyway...
- wcoenen 12y agoCouldn't a tor client establish a bitcoin micropayment channel[1] with each relay node instead? This seems much simpler than introducing a separate currency based on proof-of-bandwidth. [1] https://bitcoinj.github.io/working-with-micropayments https://bitcoinj.github.io/working-with-micropayments
- blahbl4hblahtoo 12y agoIt seems to me that bandwidth can't have the same proof of work properties as bitcoin. They spend a lot of time on it, but I'm still skeptical.
- jabgrabdthrow 12y agoOk, 90% of these "useful mining" projects get the economics backwards. Paying coins to miners does not generate demand for the coin! The miners (in this case, tor nodes) will sell and push the price to the ground. Who will buy the coins? Other altcoin enthusiasts who also don't get the economics? (And yes, this argument theoretically applies to Bitcoin, but you have to use bitcoins to pay the transaction fee to use the bitcoin network, which has value because of its network effect for use in value transfer).
- oleganza 12y agoYour last statement is circular. "Network effect in value transfer" exists only when there is "network effect in seeing value in BTC units". You can't transfer value before something has value. Also, act of transferring or fees does not generate value either. Bitcoin units are rare collectibles. Like gold coins or USD paper bills. They are scarce, hard to counterfeit and they are portable and fungible. They are easy to collect. Once you have a club of people who collect them and speculatively value them, this club can grow (or shrink). If such token is superior than others, then some people will likely sell their inferior tokens in order to acquire superior ones. This way the club grows. Plus, there is value in liquidity. People generally want to store wealth in something "secure" which means not only secure in terms of storage (personal vault, swiss bank account etc.), but also in terms of purchasing power. The more and quicker I can buy myself something I suddenly need, the more secure my wealth is. E.g. if my computer breaks and I need a new one, my cash will help me buy a new one better than a collection of postal stamps. So people will generally prefer to keep savings in money that is more marketable, i.e. valued by more people. This means that once a superior collectible starts to grow, it will drive the value of inferior collectibles down to zero. (However, if there are currency controls and banking regulation in your country, then you might be stuck with a less marketable local currency.) Nick Szabo explains how money evolved: http://szabo.best.vwh.net/shell.html http://szabo.best.vwh.net/shell.html I explained why we all want one universal money: http://blog.oleganza.com/post/54121516413/the-universe-wants-one-money http://blog.oleganza.com/post/54121516413/the-universe-wants...
- jaekwon 12y agoDoes this protocol use bandwidth to achieve consensus, or is there another consensus mechanism such as proof of work assumed to be available?
- chris123 12y agoWho is working on a "BittorrentCoin?