11 ms·
What the Head of Hiring at Google Doesn’t Understand About Skills
- thathonkey 12y agoA quality education is a quality education. I'm sure he takes into consideration more than just the major and letter grade achieved though (obviously getting a B avg in MIT's CS program would not be the same as getting an A avg in Auburn's). Anyway I'm of the opinion that it doesn't really matter what someone's academic focus is. Smart, impassioned people can excel at any field that they take the time to become educated in. Not to mention that programming and computer engineering is much more about experience than we'd like to admit.
- nomadlogic 12y ago+1 from the systems engineer with over a decade experienceat cutting edge facilities - and a BA in philosophy (focused on recent continental thought, not logic). It comes down to the individual and their passion.
- joelgrus 12y agoIt's not that you can't learn rigor and critical thinking skills as an English major, it's that it's not all that hard to complete an English degree without learning those things. Hence the word "signals".
- michaelochurch 12y agoAlso, grades don't have a lot of signal in the humanities because there's such a wide spectrum of easy vs. hard grading. Some English professors give one A every 5 years. Others give 75+ percent A's. I don't think it's as common as people make it out to be, but there are students who game the system, and the crass pre-professionals (though a minority) fuck it up for the rest of the students who haven't yet been corrupted by the corporate world and genuinely want to learn. Gaming the system is a lot harder to do in, say, linear algebra or real analysis or quantum mechanics. The corporate world is deeply negative and anti-humanistic and will typecast you to the lowest calibre of person consistent with your resume. The issue in English is that the floor is lower. It has little to do with the ceiling. (Yes, there are plenty of English teachers from whom it's harder to get an A than it is to get an A in an advanced math class.) It's about what is concluded about someone when the worst possibility is assumed.
- dllthomas 12y ago"Gaming the system is a lot harder to do in, say, linear algebra or real analysis or quantum mechanics." To some degree, but I definitely recall some dramatic differences in difficulty from various professors or classes that purportedly covered similar material and met the same requirements. When someone gets all A's, I always wonder whether they were one of the students who said "Why are you taking the second compiler course? That's hard. XYZ is a much easier A..." Of course, someone who doesn't have all A's could still be someone who tried that and failed, which would be kind of the worst case...
- YarnBall 12y agoAs former English literature and philosophy student (I am studying computer science while working for a startup now) I can tell you at that at my university you would not get an A if your reasoning and critical analysis were poor. When I was studying it was not uncommon for STEM students to get 100% for tests and exams but such a thing was unheard of in the humanities faculty. If an undergraduate got 100% for an English essay that essay would be worthy of publication in a literary journal which only happened once while I was there.
- nhebb 12y agoAs the time of me writing this, it looks like you're being downvoted (which I don't think is fair), but I think your answer points to one of the problems. Grading in the humanities is more subjective. By analogy, Olympic gymnastic scores are subject to a lot more disagreements than 100 meter sprint times.
- YarnBall 12y agoLet them downvote me: let them bring their slings and arrows! :) I can't argue against what you have said. The humanities are subjective but that does not mean that they are not valuable but the greater problem is that there is very little demand in the global economy for essays on social contract theory and Tolkien's Lord of the Rings and anti-industrialism. The best thing we can hope for is that the humanities plays a complimentary role in education. i.e. studying a humanities major like philosophy in addition to a computer science degree. In my "subjective experience" when building consumer facing apps for my company having a humanities degree has helped to make these apps better. Being able to code well is not a guarantee that your app will appeal to a consumer but knowing what people want in a product for instance, is an enterprise for the humanities because it demands introspection, divergent and subjective thinking which is a different kind of thinking altogether. That is why I am irked when people from the sciences dismiss the humanities too readily because the humanities does have something to give to the world. In short, tech + humanities = better products/ideas.
- nhebb 12y ago
- mapgrep 12y ago> it's not all that hard to complete an English degree without learning those things. How do you know this? (You know, since we're talking about logical rigor.)
- joelgrus 12y agoBased on the English (and other humanities) courses I took as an undergrad, in which the key to getting good grades was not rigor but repeating back what I imagined the professor wanted to hear, and based on my friends who were English (and other humanities) majors, who were delightful people but (for the most part) not particularly rigorous thinkers in the sense that Google is trying to hire for.
- matwood 12y agoDid you take any high level literature or english courses? Repeating back what the teacher wants to hear is fairly standard across all disciplines in low level courses. The people who I know who didn't just complete english degrees, but excelled were all very critical thinkers. The classes required reading, understanding, and then writing critically about what was read. Thinking was highly valued, particularly about nuances of the language and meaning. Of course people who are not good can slide by and get through school, but that can happen in any field. See CS grads who cannot write FizzBuzz for example.
- MisterBastahrd 12y agoNot much different than CS classes where you're learning methodology and showing that you can regurgitate it on a test, really.
- MisterBastahrd 12y agoNot much different than CS classes where you're learning methodology and showing that you can regurgitate it on a test, really.
- pingswept 12y ago(I''m not the OP.) I have a degree in English, and another one in mechanical engineering. The 9 English classes that I took were uniformly less difficult and less rigorous than the 25 or so engineering classes I took. When I studied English, I already had a reasonably well-developed understanding of logic, but it was not used in my English classes. I would estimate that I could have earned a B average in English with 5-10x less time spent than in engineering. Standardized tests suggest that I have more aptitude for engineering (or at least math), so English should have been harder for me if the curricula were of the same difficulty.
- noblethrasher 12y agoI did a Math and a History degree simultaneously, and I believe that a 4.0 in history is much harder than a 3.0 in math with respect to critical thinking skills. At one point during the pursuit of my BA in History, I was reading about 1000 pages of primary and secondary source material per week. Reading primary source material is comparable to reading mathematical exposition in that you have to proceed slowly and carefully. Then, I had to analyze the material using the various methods of historical analysis/criticism. You are not going to get an 'A' if you just regurgitate facts. You're also not going to get an 'A' if the analysis/argument is sloppy. Math didn't really get that hard until the proof-based courses, and math degrees usually require only two of those (though I did four). The “computation courses” just consisted of exercises that are only difficult until you discover a small set of tricks. Now, I'm not sure about what it takes to be a very successful English major, but my anecdotal evidence indicates that the high achievers are pretty smart: One did a math double major, one went from being a LaTex whiz to handling most of the IT at a mathematics journal, and the other is a better-than-average DBA.
- vittore 12y agoFirst comment to the article by @skeptomycin sums up entire article. Not worth the time to read it really. >>I cannot believe how the actual statements by Bock were distorted and taken out of context by Prof. Raffa. It is beyond appalling.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- VikingCoder 12y ago@joelgrus really nailed it. When someone at Google uses the verb "signals," you need to pay attention. Nothing is black and white in search. It's entirely about pulling together multiple sources of information, and deciding which ones signal the strongest and correlate with the results you're looking for. Guy Raffa is welcome to make his own search engine company staffed entirely with English majors to prove his point.
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoDisagreeable or not, I find it amusing that he opens his piece with a rubric regarding what constitutes an "excellent" paper in his course, and your last sentence contains such a glaring fallacy that it seems entirely likely he'd dock you heavily for it (and rightly so). It's also incredibly ironic considering the context of the argument at hand.
- VikingCoder 12y ago> It sounds like he wants those topflight English majors after all: graduates adept at conceiving, articulating, and supporting their own ideas—not some “specific answer” the professor is looking for. Bock just doesn’t realize they are what he is looking for. Guy Raffa goes so far as to claim that those topflight English majors are what Bock is looking for. If that were true, then a team built on this core principal should clearly be better than one built without it. If you see a fallacy in the last sentence of my first post, please explain it to me. Calling something a fallacy is your thesis. Now it is your job to prove it. Irony, indeed.
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoNowhere does Raffa claim that a team built entirely of English majors would be better than one built of any other constituency. That's a strawman you erected. QED.
- VikingCoder 12y agoRaffa says, "they [topflight English majors] are what he is looking for." Topflight English majors are the constituency Raffa says Bock should hire. You have to purposefully misread what Raffa has written, in order to see it any other way.
- ThrustVectoring 12y ago"Guess the teacher's password" is a strategy that works for many English majors and few Computer Science majors. You can succeed at rhetoric by either learning how to make good rhetoric, or by learning how to tell people what they want to hear. It's significantly more difficult to write good programs by learning how to tell people what they want to hear.
- michaelochurch 12y agoThere are English professors who are legitimately hard to game, people who are smarter than most or all of us but have chosen to focus on something different. Yes, there's more noise in the system in the humanities, but don't underestimate them just because they have a different skill set. However, the game-the-system students generally avoid those professors, who get a reputation for being difficult graders. So your point has validity. I just object to the idea that all humanities professors can be "hacked". Yes, there are some who grade highly any students who confirm their biases, but quite a few of them are smarter than any of us.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoYeah but in CS, the program works or it doesn't. So there's none of that wiggle room. CS degree definitely signals something - a minimum competency that is uncertain in a humanities student.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Yeah but in CS, the program works or it doesn't. So there's none of that wiggle room. CS grading is not the same thing as just programs working (and often that's not even the most important part of it), and, in my (obviously limited and potentially not representative, I'll admit, but there's not a lot of structured evidence being presented on any side here), the variability between institutions and individual classes within institutions in CS grading is more alike than distinct from that in any other field. The scope of the curriculum, OTOH, in CS is probably more consistent between institutions and individual students within institutions than is the case in most non-technical fields, particularly for CS taught within an engineering rather than liberal arts institution (e.g., at UC Davis, the difference between a degree from the College of Engineering and the College of Letters and Science), and, further, while there are certainly kinds of analytical skills that are central to most courses of study in English, its not at all unreasonable to expect that the kind of analytical skills that Google is more concerned about are more likely to be central in CS programs. But, overall, I think people are generally overplaying this. The stated preference for CS over other degree fields even with a slightly higher GPA in the non-CS field isn't anything like an absolute bar. Its saying that a degree in CS is one signal that is relevant to the Google hiring director that has some weight, not that it overwhelms all other information. As an aside, though, it is worth Google examining whether this signal is given more weight than it should, especially considering their recently-posted diversity numbers and their stated concern for diversity -- since their overall diversity matches fairly well the diversity of CS graduates but clearly doesn't meet what they want, they might want to consider whether part of their diversity problem is overemphasizing having a degree in CS in their recruitment material and selection processes. If it is overweighted -- and I'm not saying that it is -- that would be a lot easier for Google to fix than many of the other things they are trying to do to address diversity (not that those things aren't valuable to pursue even if addressing the weighting of CS degrees can address some of the problem more easily and in a shorter time frame.) Full disclosure: I am programmer whose only degree is in Political Science.
- jzwinck 12y agoThis article is ridiculous. While there are certain areas (e.g. pattern matching) where a typical English major is likely to do well, rigorous logical thinking of the sort needed when we program computers is simply not developed as well as it is in CS, EE, and various other programs. As a third-year undergrad I took a 400-level course on logic from the humanities department. I remember being blown away by how inept the average students there seemed at first. They were simply unprepared for the torrent of proofs, deductions, tautologies, De Morgan's laws, etc. The way of thinking required to get through that class easily was one which most second-year CS students had, but not the student body at large. I came to realize I had been groomed for this class for years already. In a 200-level CS course we learned to use Karnaugh Maps. This was not optional. There is a difference between analyzing digital logic and writing papers outside CS. Not that one is better than the other, but you don't hear CS folks claiming they're well suited for writing poetry.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bigdubs 12y agoYours is "oh noetry".
- radmuzom 12y agoI sort of agree with your overall sentiment, but the reason you found the average student from humanities inept is because the good students generally opt for STEM courses - presumably because these courses allow you to make much more money after you pass out. I also happen to believe that the world would be a much better place if a larger number of bright students study humanities subjects - especially history and literature.
- api 12y agoI'm not sure about typical English majors vs. CS majors, but in a cognitive sense there is quite a bit of overlap in certain areas. Writing and high-comprehension reading involves the deep understanding and manipulation of language. So does programming.
- gexla 12y ago> In “Dante’s Hell and Its Afterlife,” an undergraduate course I teach at my university, students have to work hard to achieve good results (not to mention an A-level grade) on a research essay. The “excellent” paper will contain a substantive thesis that is appropriately focused, coherent, and interpretive, not merely descriptive; a detailed analysis of well-chosen examples to support the argument; a logical ordering of parts, each contributing to the whole, with transitions and topic sentences that advance and crystallize the main points; an effective use of information from credible sources, correctly cited and documented; and all expressed in clear, concise, grammatically correct prose. So true. Writing is highly technical and very difficult. Just before I started at my state university, it added a writing test that all students had to pass before receiving a degree because employers complained about the lack of writing skills. Several years in, most people were still failing on their first try. Unfortunately, writing doesn't have debugging tools, tests and output for feedback to let you know if what you put together works. Rather, you need someone who is a good writer to provide honest feedback. Also difficult is that developing good writing skills requires good instructors / mentors. I have had too many writing classes with instructors who would give praise for just about anything. All of my instructors in my first year of taking writing classes told me how great I was. It wasn't until I took a technical writing class in which my first paper came back a mess of red ink that I finally felt like I was learning something. That class was one of the most valuable I have ever taken. She told us at the beginning of the class that few people can write well, we probably won't ever be able to write well either (true for me,) but she would help us become passable enough to get through the writing test. Granted, most writing classes don't focus on the same items as technical writing. But with as much effort as this instructor put into every one of my papers, this can't be something many instructors are willing to do. How do you become a good writer and get good feedback? I don't know. Compare this to many other classes in which the instructor is largely a guide and you do most or all of your learning on your own. ETA: I think the instructor and the quality of the course is extremely important. Many subjects in college can be setup to be easy to coast through or rigorous. The name on the course isn't as important as the contents.
- frogpelt 12y agoFor me, the problem in English class was that "good" writing was very subjective. It always seemed as if the goal was to impress the teacher. I've only had one English teacher in my life who I felt gave me concrete instruction about how to write effectively (shout out to Dr. Cross!). The technical writing course I took in college was also somewhat beneficial. In mathematics, there are problems and there are solutions. That is much more logical to me.
- tsunamifury 12y agoIt's google's loss. And believe me it will be. A CS degree may be the best signal of a worker who will program all day, but it's not a good signal for the wide variety of other skills that are required to make a popular, well rounded and valuable product. For example, making a workflow that is general understandable for the average user requires a strong set of less defined soft skills, like empathy, clarity of thesis, interviewing skills and a translation of discrete systems into metaphors non CS majors can work with. And to be fair, google already seems to know this as they are trying to minimize the power of engineers in consumer facing product groups.
- TheCapn 12y agoI think its more feasible and smart of Google to find engineers with a subset of soft skills that you describe than hire on those soft skills alone and hope they have a subset of technical skills.
- tsunamifury 12y agoI think this is a false attitude that comes from a rather egotistical belief that engineers can 'do anything' -- so just be an engineer and then do other things too. Have you watched an engineer design an interface? Its not their speciality because they simply don't have the time to concentrate on such things. Have you seen them write marketing copy? Create HR requirements? Cast product visions? They usually aren't good at these things because it isn't their speciality. Why would anyone argue that engineers are good at everything and ignore the concentrations that yield very real and measurable value to the products.
- frogpelt 12y agoSo one of the very few English professors in the country with a computer science degree is offended by Google's hiring practices. The fact is most English majors don't enjoy heavy duty math or science as much and it's not that weird to expect a computer science major to depend more on logic and rigor when approaching a problem than it is for someone whose thesis was devoted to a literary analysis of the symbolism behind the pickle dish in Ethan Frome.
- kennymeyers 12y ago"The fact is most English majors don't enjoy heavy duty math or science as much" These statements need data to back them up, Mr. Science.
- learc83 12y agoYou don't think it's a given that, on average, students who choose a degree that requires "heavy duty math" enjoy it more than students who choose a degree that doesn't require "heavy duty math"?
- FLUX-YOU 12y agoI would change your assertion to "choose a degree that requires heavy duty math and succeed/graduate". Sampling after the choice is initially made is clouded by kids choosing what is popular and/or being forced to go to college because of social pressures and/or choosing only what will hopefully make them the most cash.
- matwood 12y agoGiven my science background, very little is a given until I see data. CS people get on their soapbox and talk about being superior in logical and rigorous thinking and then lead off with statements like it's a given.
- kennymeyers 12y agoI'm unsure of the motivations most people have in choosing majors. When I see generalizations of a very large group of people, no matter how obvious it may seem, I just like to see data to back it up.
- danso 12y agoThere's so much to say here about the incompetence of the OP that it's better to write a long blog post about it...so I'll just leave it at this. First of all, check out the source material, which is this Thomas Friedman column: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/friedman-how-to-get-a-job-at-google-part-2.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/friedman-ho... The OP is suggesting that the Google exec doesn't value the skills in the humanities departments. This is not even remotely true. Read the Friedman column for yourself: > Are the liberal arts still important? > > They are “phenomenally important,” he said, especially when you combine them with other disciplines. “Ten years ago behavioral economics was rarely referenced. But [then] you apply social science to economics and suddenly there’s this whole new field. I think a lot about how the most interesting things are happening at the intersection of two fields. So basically, the OP basis for argument is a little off-kilter. But where the OP is incredibly wrong is his interpretation of the following: > I told that student they are much better off being a B student in computer science than an A+ student in English because it signals a rigor in your thinking and a more challenging course load. The OP is aggreieved because he interprets Bock's statement as saying that English doesn't have the same critical thinking skills as computer science. Bock is not saying that at all, he is saying to a student that leaving comsci, because the courses are too challenging, is a bad idea, and that he/she shouldn't prize an A in an "easier" curriculum over a B in computer science, because the value of a grade is not the only measure of skills valuable to Google. What's really important here is the word that Bock uses: "rigor". I'll refer to the definition that Google's search engine brings up: > the quality of being extremely thorough, exhaustive, or accurate. The OP interprets "rigor" as being "hard" or "challenging." But Bock is more likely referring to the importance of accuracy and the more rigidly testable questions in a typical computer science curriculum versus an English curriculum. Bock does not at all talk about the intellectual challenge of English versus Computer Science. The fact that a professor has such a skewed, and in my opinion, wrong interpretation of not just Bock's statement, but of the English word "rigor" is itself a testament to the lack of "rigor"...or "stiffness" in how English is evaluated.
- zacinbusiness 12y agoI was an English major in undergrad and grad school and I see these arguments all the time. I learned a great deal in my university career, and much of what I learned in the humanities took real intellectual curiosity, hard work, and deep thinking. You're not going to put together a real, publishable work by copy and pasting work from Stackoverflow, not in a master level English course. And let's be honest, the majority of CS students are lazy and incompetent, just like the majority of all students in all majors. Sure, you get some truly brilliant students that come along, but most of them never really produce anything of value. And most engineers, talented as they may be at slinging code and doing the lambda calculus, are pitiful communicators and can barely write a coherent sentence.
- zacinbusiness 12y agoLet's see some logical refutations before we start with the emotional down votes, you purely logical genius gods of knowledge.
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoI wouldn't hold my breath waiting for that, were I you. My education is in science. My particular science is one in which I had to learn a lot of mathematics--everything from real analysis to quite advanced analytical geometry and a wide variety of other things. I forgot more math by the time I took my qualifying exams than most CS people I've known ever learned. So for my part it's just hilarious to see the unbridled arrogance showing its head here. CS majors like to think of themselves as being paragons of logical and intellectual rigor. I think the downvotes we've accumulated here shows that some, at least, ought not. That's not to excuse or defend the author of the article. I happen to agree with the argument he claims the Googler makes (even though the Googler doesn't apparently actually make that argument) in a very broad sense, based solely on my personal experiences. It's a sense broad enough that it ought not be applied to individuals.
- digitalsushi 12y agoI feel bad that I cant get a job at the New York Times with my cs degree. I might not know any literary composition or journalism techniques, but you can't tell me that as a computer scientist I am not as smart as an english major that learned all these skills in college. Ok. Now we both feel inadequate and offended, so it's all even.
- drivingmenuts 12y agoDrama major here. I can look or sound competent in any field. Well, except Drama, but it's not like there's any money to be had there.
- morgante 12y ago> I feel bad that I cant get a job at the New York Times with my cs degree. You probably can, actually. "Data journalism" is a growing field.
- svmegatron 12y agoBock and the author both miss the same point: the thing that helps you learn to think in a rigorous way is to study something that does not come naturally to you. I see it as the difference between learning a new skill and practicing an existing one. The former forces you to focus completely, while the latter tolerates inattention.
- nextstepguy 12y agoGoogle has such an arrogant culture for an ephemeral company built around the sole business to milk indirectly their customers with online advertisement.
- andyidsinga 12y agoHa! Last developer I hired was an English major ...I found out after I hired him ... the degree question didn't come up in three interview process ... just programming.
- jerf 12y agoOf course you can teach a rigorous English course. The problem is that you can also not. I took an intro to philosophy course in which we were graded reasonably rigorously on our logic. But the prof also made it clear via both a bit of text and a bit of subtext that we were getting so graded because nobody really takes the old stuff that seriously anyhow, so there's no sacred oxes getting gored. You can write an essay for this class either endorsing or denouncing Descartes and as long as it is reasonably logical, you'll get a good grade. Don't expect such accommodations if you start getting into what is taken seriously. I also took a real-deal English history class graded primarily on essays, and both at the time and even now I'm pretty sure I got a 2.5 simply because I failed to correctly echo back what the prof expected, made harder by the fact that she did a reasonably good job of not telegraphing what she expected. However, I never got any other useful feedback on my essays; the facts were correct, the arguments were logical enough, they were to the expected length, they just got graded poorly. (And it's not as if I was going out of my way to write offensive political agitprop myself, I was just trying to answer the questions. But I'm quite sure my perspective was quite different than hers, in ways hard to explain in an HN comment.) The fact that you run a rigorous course grading logic and rhetoric (based on a computer science degree) is not proof that everybody else does. Yes, they all say that's what they do, but that's not proof either. In practice the humanities are pretty notorious for this sort of thing, and I'm completely unconvinced this essay with its one data point that is almost by definition an outlier (both coming from a computer science degree and being what is probably an early course in the sequence as implied by having a lot of non-English majors in it) provides any significant evidence against the original claims from Google, or that the field's notoriety is unearned in practice. (Incidentally, to the extent that I rather dislike the humanities we have today, it is precisely that they could be excellent training in logic and rhetoric, but they generally aren't. Postmodernism poisoned the humanities nearly unto destruction.)
- Spooky23 12y agoYour position can apply to anything. There are Computer Science graduates who cannot tell you what a linked list is. You need to look for signals that imply humanities majors that are smart. Do they have published articles in student publications? Were they active in campus organizations? End of the day, look for smart people who get things done. If you need specific, rigorous domain expertise, hire somebody with a degree in that discipline of engineering or whatever. Otherwise, you're better off with a smart person who knows how to think and communicate vs. someone with an engineering degree who cannot function.
- pixelmade 12y agoFor the most part, HR are a group that believes in data, but rarely uses it during evaluation and hiring decisions.
- Strilanc 12y agoI think of English courses as teaching you about being convincing to humans. Correctness is important, but secondary. This is probably best exemplified by anecdotes being arguably the most evocative form of explanation, and yet the weakest form of evidence. It makes sense to me that a technology company would downweight achievements in the humanities when hiring (for their technical positions). It's a noisier signal. Computers and nature aren't convinced or understood in the same way as humans are, so a lot of the English major benefits get lost in the translation to STEM. (Serious question: what are the best examples of people in the humanities contributing to science and technology? For example, Noam Chomsky basically invented formal grammars.)
- bproctor 12y agoSome of the best developers I've hired don't have a degree. When looking at resumes, I don't really care about their academics.
- theop 12y agoAre there enough diverse people to satisfy companies' diversity index goal?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- timdierks 12y agoDoing well in an English major at a good school is hard work, requires strong critical thinking skills, etc. But it doesn't reflect the level of analytical precision and rigorous correctness that doing well as a CS major does. The humanities as a course of study are primarily interpretive and creative, and most schools of thought will support the idea that many different interpretations have value. By comparison, while there are many different approaches and creative and engineering opportunities in CS, in the end the computer Does Exactly What It Is Told To Do And Nothing Else. And the level of precision, exactness and rigor necessary to support that environment is alien to most humanities curricula.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoIts like the author of this article never compared an English major to a CS major. Yeah, I'm sure the top 1% of English majors are pretty smart guys, but on average they are not very good at thinking logically. And yes, the bottom 25% of CS graduates are probably not that good either. But the fact remains, if you take a top 25% CS graduate from almost any program in the world, that guy can probably understand a business case quicker than a top 25% English major from an equivalent institution. Its just far easier to get a humanities degree than it is to get a CS degree, if you aren't a structured thinker to begin with.
- fancyketchup 12y agoThat's sort of a straw man, though, isn't it? The Google guy said he'd take a B-level CS major over an A-level humanities major. So you're not comparing top-25% CS to top-25% humanities. You're comparing second quartile (roughly) CS to top quartile (again, roughly) humanities. Now, I'm a just physicist with no skin in the game, but it seems to me that arguments on HN in support of the Google position (and yours in particular) all try to argue that CS is generically "harder," or that it's easier to graduate with a humanities degree, or that the xth percentile CS major is smarter than the xth percentile humanities major. So far I haven't really seen anyone address the assertion that graduating with an A-average in a humanities major is very difficult. Maybe it really is easy to get a BA in humanities with a 2.0 GPA (I don't know, but it sounds plausible). But that's not the issue. The issue is how a 3.5ish GPA humanities major compares to a 2.5ish CS major.
- sanjiwatsuki 12y agoSome of the inflammatory statements have been taken out of context. The B vs. A+ quote was used in the context of students changing majors due to difficulty -- i.e. changing from a CS+English double major to Economics due to the difficulty of the double major. It is a discussion of the phenomenon described by "Students Pick Easier Majors Despite Less Pay." written in the WSJ. Bock further explains that analytic thinking skills, whether or not they were derived from a CS degree or another degree (Statistics in his case) or not from a degree at all, are the important factor.
- hellbreakslose 12y agoI don't get why you have to argue with a company on the way it does its recruiting. They feel that's the best for them and they have the right to. Yes I believe that a person that studies English could become an Engineer. But being an Engineer requires experience and time. It's not like you'll pick it up in a day. On the other hand a person that studies CS or Engineering has learnt the basics and its easier for him to become one. The way google is recruiting feels the right way for them (and for me) since they don't want to take in someone that has no idea and start teaching him on that. Also if someone wants to work for a Tech Company like google I don't see why he will go study English... if English is what he likes best then why would he pursue working under a tech company. I think you are trying to apply the logic that all the banks have that they'll hire whoever if he passes their tests. But they will train him into investments and guide them through. And also that person like everyone working on finance will have to undergo exams every-year to prove himself. (That's pretty much like studying finance if even more advanced). Well Google doesn't want to go with the paragraph above.
- qwerta 12y agoI think most humanity studies develop critical thinking, but at very shallow level. Mathematicians have to nest 100s levels of logical operations to get proof they want. Programming around 50 to 10 logical operations. Lawyers perhaps 10. Literature nests perhaps 5 levels of logical operations. There is simply no apparatus to manage this level of complexity in human language. Just try to describe 3th level integral or matrix operations with pure words. It is like analyzing complex program on TI programmable calculator with 5 line display. And I think English is not very logic friendly language, too many double meanings and context sensitivity. I like German for its logic and Esperanto for its simplicity.
- tragic 12y agoTo be instrumental about it, English (and the arts/humanities subjects in general) teaches the skill of decision making under conditions of uncertainty: we are required to make inferences on the basis of ambiguous 'data' (a literary text whose meaning will generally be slippery) and competing bodies of theory which cannot be proven against each other, of sufficient solidity that they can be defended in a logically coherent argument. This is a real skill. And if you actually apply yourself to an arts degree, it does develop it. (Before the emergence of national literature studies and modern historiography, the study of the Classics played this role, broadly speaking.) It does not have direct relevance to software engineering at all (speaking as someone with two literature degrees). But not all problems in development are strictly technical. Someone down there said: > Yeah but in CS, the program works or it doesn't. Indeed. Google+ works, right?
- jgwynn2901 12y agoGrowing up in housing projects I had a hard time realizing how many people internalized even the most egregious stereotypes as fact. Spent a lot of time in gyms with a lot of hypertrophied chest, shoulder and arms walking on crane legs. Thinks we don't really know how to measure each other when it comes to it. Never met a carpenter who didn't complain about the prior carpenter's work. Finds there's a lot of ways to describe things and some say more than they are designed and often leave a bitter aftertaste.
- phaus 12y agoIn writing, critical thinking amounts to having an opinion on something. I think the author is mistaking something that's tedious for something that's rigorous.
- agorabinary 12y agoI used to be a philosophy major at a top 10 school notorious for its rigor. Now I am a CS major at my local university after transferring (for various reasons including cost). What the author doesn't understand is that when we says, "It sounds like he wants those topflight English majors after all: graduates adept at conceiving, articulating, and supporting their own ideas—not some “specific answer” the professor is looking for", you actually get much more creative solutions to CS problems because implementations may vary, but are still bounded by the problem. In English (and potentially moreso in philosophy), you are not really bounded by anything, so it's incredibly easy to get at least a "good" grade, while getting an A is entirely at the mercy of a subjective grader with no clear grading rubric to distinguish a B+ from an A. Further, there isn't any domain to learn, so you can fairly easily skim the cliffnotes of every assigned reading and produce at least a B essay. Thus, no work ethic. CS really forces you into a discipline because there is a domain to learn as well as projects to code, and you can't BS a program at the last minute. If an essay doesn't have a coherent conclusion at 4am, turn it in and get a B. But if your program doesn't compile at 4am... From my experience I consider CS to be far more challenging in terms of critical thinking, work ethic, and ability to solve complex problems. Also interesting is the camaraderie the students in these classes develop as we solve hard problems together, with the knowledge that if you've made it this far in the major, you're pretty capable. To echo the sentiment of another poster, you would be pretty blown away be the ineptitude of many liberal arts majors (apart from their complete lack of relevant domain knowledge) who are able to cruise through their classes for all the reasons mentioned above.
- methodover 12y ago> while getting an A is entirely at the mercy of a subjective grader with no clear grading rubric to distinguish a B+ from an A Huh? This is true in programming too. Getting something to compile can't be all CS professors are looking for, right? Programming is more about communication than anything else. You can write something a hundred different ways which will all run more or less fine -- but they all won't be equally readable and maintainable. I didn't get a CS degree, so I don't have experience on the matter. Do CS professors grade for readability at all?
- 12y ago
- klunger 12y agoI have one humanities degree (Japanese Studies) and one STEM degree (Aerospace Engineering), both from good schools in those respective domains. So, I feel in a unique position to comment on this. I enrolled in the engineering program second, after I was sick of the poor employment opportunities associated with the first degree. During my engineering studies, it sometimes felt like my brain was being rewired, making it more suited to meet the rigors of the coursework. I don't know if this was "in my head" or if something was actually happening on a neurological level. But, I know that the course work went from being ridiculously challenging in my first semester (pulled teeth to get B's and C's in the early days) to manageable and often fun in the last (mostly A's). I am eternally grateful to the research and writing skills that I honed during my first degree. However, it was definitely the engineering courses that made me into the "analytical thinker" I am today. So, I think there is something to be said about what a STEM degree signals.
- collyw 12y agoThe skills he talks about are useful, for lawyers, politicians, sales and other such professions. They are useful in STEM type subjects as well, but usually only if you have the "harder" CS / science / maths type skills as well.
- mcguire 12y agoI'm sorry, did Prof. Raffa really just admit to the First Great Sin of Dante Studies---taking the Inferno in isolation, separate from the Purgatorio and Paradiso? I do believe he did! And he's from UTAustin! Argh! And he's the Danteworlds[1] guy! Salvami! [1] http://danteworlds.laits.utexas.edu/ http://danteworlds.laits.utexas.edu/
- sharemywin 12y agoYour obviously missing the point he was trying to make. No one was saying that an english major can't make a well thought out argument with a valid point. In fact they can probably do it better than a computer scientist. But, that's not what programming is. Programming is taking the simplest thing and elaborting in mind numbing detail for the computer to execute. way past the point most people get bored and give up. Take a simple form first name great how many characters should we store. middle name same question address how many lines? should we break it out into number and street name? what about suites? State great..list them out... all of them. city..ok..find a database of the cities and tie them to zip code. Oh wait...this is an international ap..great..let's start over...ok now three screens back if they selected this option change the font to one size larger. Programming isn't about making an argument it's closer to mapping out all the arguments and figuring out how they all fit together. but usually for topics that people wouldn't waste their time arguing over. like how to fill out an insurance form. or which document to pick first from a list.
- mbubb 12y agoWhat I am saying here is anecdotal (but when did that ever stop anyone)... I have to agree with Bock. I was an English major at a solid school (Rutgers) and went on to do some grad work in Comp Lit at NYU. Years later I took CS/ Math classes at Stevens - there is no comparison in the difficulty. The only exception were the political theory classes I took which were grounded in Hegel - they were hard. I have met 10 times as many Science / Tech people who were relatively well versed in Literature and/or Art than the contrary. There tends to be absolute illiteracy in Math and hard Science in the Humanities. I remember years ago one of my profs got caught up in an embarrassing incident where a faked article which conflated Relativism and Relativity passed muster at a critical theory journal and was published with glaring scientific errors. (The Sokal Affair) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair Now that i am in a tech field I wish I had spent more time studying math instead of so much Englsh and Political Theory as an undergrad.