5 ms·
Wikipedia: We’ve won. Now what?
- jchrisa 12y agoQuoted from the last comment on the article: Wikipedia editing should be done within a set of work processes, which can be semi-automated (a “requested article” collects citations, then becomes a draft article, then is promoted to regular article status, with the software preventing duplicate efforts, for example).
- _delirium 12y agoThere's sort-of a process like that, but the in-progress articles are still articles, vs. being explicitly marked as drafts or not-yet-articles or something of that sort. The progression is something like this (from needs-most-work upwards): 1. Articles explicitly tagged with a warning at the top (needs references, might be biased, reads like an advertisement, doesn't represent a worldwide view of the subject, is out of date, etc.). Here the reader is warned that the article needs work and should be taken with a large grain of salt. 2. Default "regular" articles. These are supposed to be at least passable, free of the obvious problems in the previous category. Though sometimes they just haven't been properly marked. The reader should treat them with appropriate caution, looking for references for claims (especially any surprising claims), corroborating with other sources, and assuming that the article may be incomplete. 3. Articles marked as "good articles" [1]. These have been reviewed by one or more editors, and are considered to be well-referenced and reasonably complete. They're marked by a little green plus in the upper-right. A conservative use of Wikipedia could be to treat anything at a lower level than this one as a draft article, in various stages of draftiness. 4. Articles marked as "featured articles" [2]. These are supposed to be checked by multiple editors, including at least one expert in the field, and considered to be excellent examples of a Wikipedia article, with no obvious deficiencies. They're marked by a gold star in the upper-right. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Good_articles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Good_articles [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Featured_articles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Featured_articles
- im3w1l 12y agoAnyone can add a {{good article}}. I just did without even logging in. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Sandbox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Sandbox EDIT: permalink https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Sandbox&oldid=610077870 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Sandbox...
- kachnuv_ocasek 12y agoSlightly related: there's also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:FlaggedRevs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:FlaggedRevs
- wpietri 12y agoAs a software developer, I appreciate the urge to systematize processes. But I generally think that's a mistake for Wikipedia. The formalization and top-down control of work processes is an artifact of industrial corporate thinking. It can work adequately in that context (although there are other models, like Toyota's, that I think are superior). But there's very little reason to think it will work in Wikipedia, which has almost nothing in common with industrial corporations.
- tiquorsj 12y agoIf Wikipedia becomes/is the source. How do you get around the 3rd party primary source requirement?
- bsamuels 12y agowikipedia is an indexing mechanism for external sources, not a primary source
- davidgerard 12y agoThe model does presume that primary and secondary sources will continue to be created. These days, what actually happens is that people create third-party sources specifically to get things into Wikipedia. sigh.
- marcosdumay 12y agoBecause of its format, Wikipedia is not a good original research repository. Creating a source just to cite it in Wikipedia is a good thing, not a bad one, I think they are quite right on having that rule.
- davidgerard 12y agoSometimes it's good, more usually it's companies getting PR stories placed in news outlets as evidence they warrant an article. (This, by the way, is something that can sometimes not work out so well.)
- saraid216 12y agoIf only we had non-profit organizations getting fact-checking stories placed in news outlets as evidence.
- yiedyie 12y agoEncarta gave up arms, and Britannica is struggling. Wikipedia is more accurate and rapid than a random search, but it definitely should not be the last word on any matter but rather be a starting point to familiarize with terms and what to search for, and that is the best way any encyclopedia can be anyway, a starting point. I also love that there are at least 2 solutions for offline use: http://www.wikitaxi.org/delphi/doku.php/products/wikitaxi/index http://www.wikitaxi.org/delphi/doku.php/products/wikitaxi/in... http://www.kiwix.org/wiki/Main_Page http://www.kiwix.org/wiki/Main_Page
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoWikipedia has won. Wikipedia is the encyclopedia anyone actually consults, ever. In fact, it’s the first in history that everyone actually reads, rather than just having fond high school memories of. This is a curse. The sheer power that Wikipedia has over shaping public thought is disturbing. I'm curious if anyone has actually done studies on this, and whether it's feasible to shape public interpretation of history by making very subtle factual edits over long periods of time. People don't really "read" Wikipedia, either. Not frequently. They primarily skim through it, and very few actually follow the linked references, which, as it turns out, do not always overlap with Wikipedia's summarized content. As a practical example, although a minor one (it's the first that comes off the top of my head), take the Nuwaubian Nation. They're an underground new syncretic religious movements with some very colorful beliefs. For a long time, their Wikipedia article was titled "Nuwaubianism". There was no such thing as "Nuwaubianism," it was a completely made up term. Yet it has since memetically spread throughout places such as the SPLC and RationalWiki, despite Wikipedia long correcting it.
- davidgerard 12y ago>This is a curse. The sheer power that Wikipedia has over shaping public thought is disturbing. I'm curious if anyone has actually done studies on this, and whether it's feasible to shape public interpretation of history by making very subtle factual edits over long periods of time. For anything important, the dialectic (i.e., edit-warring) produces something that at least covers everything, even if the resulting article has awful prose. >Nuwabianism Thankfully we killed "analogue disc record" before Wikipedia got popular.
- glenra 12y ago> For anything important, the dialectic (i.e., edit-warring) produces something that at least covers everything, even if the resulting article has awful prose. That's not really true unless you include the talk page. On any sufficiently contentious topic where there are two or more sides, what happens quite often is that one faction has more persistent editors successfully adding slant and sources in their direction and keeping out slant and sources in the other direction. You have to look at the talk page to see what facts and points of view are being actively omitted from the main page. A true NPOV is hard to maintain, because people often tend to think their own point of view is "fact" and the other side is "fringe". People also seem to fear that to allow a point of view to stand and be explained legitimizes it. I've noticed this phenomenon most in articles involving climate or medicine.
- VLM 12y ago"This gives a conceptual model to work to: Wikimedia as the sum of all university libraries." I can't imagine a concise concept designed to cause greater offense amongst the deletionists. That must be why I like it so much.
- davidgerard 12y agoWikimedia != Wikipedia.
- marcosdumay 12y agoIt will be funny if (not long in the future) Wikibooks had a more wide coverage of topics than Wikipedia.
- davidgerard 12y agoIt'd be a DAMN FINE THING! Commons is amazing. Its main problem in replacing Getty Images is that the search isn't so good. is that (This is something WMF is seriously working on, but I couldn't say the problem's cracked yet. There's also a cultural bias against treating categories as tags rather than a ridiculously-specifically-detailed twig of a category tree.)
- andrenotgiant 12y agoSomething that worries me - Checking facts in Wikipedia articles becomes more difficult as it gets more popular. An incorrect fact on Wikipedia can get picked up and dissipated out into articles and reports. That FIRST time it happens, the error is traceable: You can confirm that the error was published on Wikipedia BEFORE the external Article, and invalidate it as proof. BUT the external article never disappears. Years later a new Wikipedia editor may come along and re-insert the incorrect fact into Wikipedia based on the article.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- stephengillie 12y agoHow is this different from an incorrect fact being written in a research paper, then referenced again and again for centuries? The battle against incorrect facts is yet another struggle we're always facing. With this tool, people have at least some information. Which is worse, incorrect data or no data? With incorrect data, at least the mental framework gets established.
- pliny 12y agoIncorrect data that you think is correct is obviously worse than no data: a) You're likely to stop looking for better data once you have it. b) You're more likely to act on it than acting on no data, and the work you do based on your incorrect data is likely to be either be less useful than is acceptable (otherwise you would have acted on no data at all and gotten a similar result) or it could even be harmful/counterproductive, depending on how wrong the data is. c) Worst of all, you might help disseminate the incorrect data (and perhaps even argue against the correct along the way), compounding the damage demonstrated above.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 12y ago
- jballanc 12y agoWikipedia is, at this point, truly "encyclopedic" in that it covers all manner of topics, but I think it still has a loooong way to go before it can consider itself the universal reference. The primary problem, as I see it, is consistency of voice/target audience. For example, many math topics read as if they are the intro section of some Mathematics graduate student's thesis, whereas most biology topics read like some high school biology student's book report. Compare the article for "Markov Process" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markov_process http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markov_process), which starts with a nice introduction but quickly devolves into foreign symbology, to the article for Caspase 9 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caspase_9 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caspase_9), one of the most important components in the process of apoptosis, itself one of the most importent processes in growth, development, disease, cancer, etc...which has barely 4 sentences and a dozen references.
- beams_of_light 12y agoI'm guessing other encyclopedias have similar weak points. Wikipedia is a truly fantastic resource, not just for academia, but for the world, and we need to hold it up instead of beat it down.
- akozak 12y agoThe blog post invited feedback.
- neltnerb 12y agoI think this is definitely a cool concept for the future. A goal of making it so that articles have sequential and mutually hidden content. Click on "introductory" and you see an article written using less jargon and more high level overview information. Click on "academic" and you see an article written for someone at a sophomore level in college. Some math, some jargon, but without an expectation of prior domain expertise. Click on "expert" and you see an article with domain specific jargon, appropriate as a reference for someone who already has a great deal of experience with the subject matter. It seems to me like that kind of end goal would also provide a better balance between editorial choice on how much detail is appropriate and providing a smorgasbord of information that potentially overwhelms the audience.
- finin 12y agoWikidata, a free knowledge base that can be read and edited by humans and machines alike: http://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:Main_Page http://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:Main_Page
- fredsted 12y agoI'm not part of the Wikipedia community, but a thing I don't understand about wikipedia is the excessive deletionism. Plain text is not that expensive to host. Keeping this in mind, if an article is not vandalism, spam or nonsense what reasons are there to deleting it? If there is actually a vote happening to delete an article, why not just keep it: there are actually people who care enough to vote on it. I don't think that form of authoritarianism belongs on a website like Wikipedia. It's very demoralising for new users seeing the article they care about and spent time on getting deleted by a single click from an administrator. Even administrators quit after working on Wikipedia for years due t frustration with deletionism and similar issues. In my opinion, "too much" information wins by default. Before wikipedia is "all information" and not "information others find notable", there's still work to do.
- redthrowaway 12y agoWikipedia isn't geocities. It's not there to give people a voice or let them write about whatever they want. The point is to keep the aggregate quality high enough that people trust it as a resource and are willing to contribute high-quality material. That means culling a whole lot of crap. I've participated in a large number of AfD discussions, and the vast majority of the articles that get deleted simply didn't belong there in the first place.
- wpietri 12y agoHosting cost is the very least of the concerns. One important one is impact. Most people treat Wikipedia content as "probably true", so any time where the truth of something matters, zero content is better than bad content. That's true for all sorts of scientific, medical, and commercial content. Another is impact on living people. The folks who wrangle the rules for biographies of people still alive [1] have put a lot of thought into recognizing the impact that Wikipedia articles can have on people. Having nothing is often better than having a bad article. A third is self-promotion and vanity. People are willing to write endlessly about themselves. Bands formed by teens in their garages, companies trying to promote themselves, blatant spam, subtle commercial manipulation: Wikipedia doesn't need that. A fourth is maintainability. The number of active Wikipedia editors is modest. Some sorts of content attract new editors. But quite a lot won't. I think it's often better for Wikipedia to have no article than a bad article that isn't going to get better soon. And that points toward a fifth thing: the value of the Wikipedia brand. Wikipedia won the reference race because of its quality. It is enormously valuable for the world to have a single, high-quality factual resource. The brand should be maintained. People can (and certainly do) disagree on where to draw the line between crap and not-crap. But almost nobody disagrees that there is quite a lot of non-encyclopedic material (e.g., [2], [3]), and that the Internet is plenty big enough to host that somewhere other than Wikipedia. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living_persons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Criteria_for_speedy_deletion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Criteria_for_speedy_d... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not
- troymc 12y agoI've noticed a phenomenon happening quietly on Wikipedia: articles are being copied to Wikia and then removed from Wikipedia. For example, there's an episode of CSI: Crime Scene Investigation titled "Unfriendly Skies". Once upon a time, there was a Wikipedia article for that episode. I know, because I contributed to it. Well, that articles is now gone from Wikipedia and the text I wrote is on Wikia. http://csi.wikia.com/wiki/Unfriendly_Skies http://csi.wikia.com/wiki/Unfriendly_Skies I'm fine with Wikia copying what I wrote. The CC-BY-SA license allows it. I am not fine with Wikipedia deleting it. Wikipedia needs to decide what it is. Is it the sum total of all knowledge or is it just the subset that the deletionists deem "worthy" (or "notable" in their jargon)?
- sparkzilla 12y agoActually, you need to decide what Wikipedia is. An episode of CSI should not be detailed in an encyclopedia. Do you really think that Wikipedia is the best possible place to display that content on the whole internet? I'm not saying that Wikia is much better, but at least it is targeted to the fans of the TV show. So much of this "It's information so it should be on Wikipedia" appears to be driven by ego, rather than what is good for the reader.
- hnha 12y agoI would prefer Wikipedia to have information on everything. Why shouldn't it?
- wpietri 12y agoWhy shouldn't an episode of CSI be detailed? I'm an (inactive) Wikipedia admin, and that meets my criteria. I don't care at all about the show, but it's factual material that can be described neutrally from reliable sources and verified by anybody who cares to take the time. It's also the kind of thing that people provably refer to. More broadly, I think pop-culture topics are great material for Wikipedia because they serve as a gateway to deeper editing. Most people find editing Wikipedia intimidating. But if you ask, "Hey, can you improve something about the article on your favorite show?" that's a lot less scary, because a) they're comfortable with the material, and b) it's pop culture, so they're not as worried about getting it wrong.
- sparkzilla 12y agoPride comes before the fall. Wikipedia is in terminal decline because the software and design sucks, the number of editors is declining, and the core structure of how information is treated is unreliable. For those interested, check my series on the site's problems: http://newslines.org/blog/ http://newslines.org/blog/
- rsync 12y agoNo idea who this commenter is, on the OPs page, but he says it very well: "I don’t think that Wikipedia can be as comprehensive as you say unless and until the significance requirement is lowered. There are lots of interesting and relevant articles that are killed by exacting admins who think that Wikipedia’s scope shouldn’t be quite as, well, encyclopedic, as others. Wikipedia can be the place for well researched obscure knowledge as much as it can be an accessible place to find the famous stuff. Indeed, the more obscure information it supports, the more useful it will be in the long term as an accretive force for knowledge. Once someone has created a certain page for something obscure, over time others will add to that knowledge and make it more valuable." Inclusionism is something wikipedia needs to work toward. Deletionism is an admission of failure - an inability to reasonably deal with information. I hope they can find a way to fix this problem.
- tptacek 12y agoHere is the AfD page for April 20, 2014 --- I went back a random ways so that we could see an AfD log where most (all?) of the discussions had been closed. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Log/2014_April_20 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion... So, what I'd be interested in is a discussion that drills into specifics. Which of the deleted articles --- the ones headlined in red --- are "admissions of failure, an inability to reasonably deal with information"?
- dingaling 12y agoI spent some time reading through that list and it just depressed me even more about the current direction of Wikipedia. Other than the reasonable deletion of two promotional articles for books ( 'Formation of Postcolonial Englishes: Theories' and 'Secret Fantasies' ) that list consists of people arguing about 'notability'. That is begging the question, since notability is what Wikipedia defines and which is the core problem. What the outside World is saying is: remove the notability test. It has become so abused by the administators that they should forfeit it; they are not responsible enought to be trusted with it. ~~ Here's an example of one that was deleted for 'non-notability': Former minor league baseball announcer. Has not received any well-known award or honor nor has he made any widely recognized contribution to broadcasting. Which just illustrates how amorphous this 'notability' concept has become; it can be redefined at will to sataisfy any argument. So that individual was notable, but not notable enough on a global scale? Might as well rename 'notability' to 'is as famous as Tom Cruise' in that case. ~~ Here's another one, this individual had references in media but subjectively someone felt that wasn't good enough: The Plymouth article goes a bit deeper but its more of the "local boy living the dream" variety which isnt enough to satisfy GNG. There should be no opportunity for subjectivity. Was the individual referenced by independent media articles? Yes? Good enough.
- e12e 12y ago> In fact, it’s the first in history that everyone actually reads, rather than just having fond high school memories of. What an odd way of framing wikipedia. As a source of just information (the articles themselves) -- wikipedia is entirely unremarkable[1]. The fact that it is the first encyclopedia everyone can look into the editorial process of (history and talk facets), and contribute to (edit) -- is what makes it interesting. Sadly, I have the impression wikipedia has been largely unsuccessful in challenging people to be more critical of what they read, and more confident in what they observe -- than it by rights should have been. Everyone that has a passing interest in encyclopedia knows that even Britannica contains errors and that it, like any other text, is shaped by sometimes ulterior motives in its editing process -- it's just that unless you go crazy with glue and scissors, you'll have a really hard time "fixing" an error in Britannica. And if you did, it'll be hard for readers to compare "your" version with earlier versions. Consider the fact that Britannica has been in print since 1768 -- imagine how much many of the articles will have evolved since then -- and why. Now imagine wikipedia around the year 2200. You could go back an have a look at how the articles for "terrorism" and "surveillance" evolved from 2000 to 2050 for example. [1] Entirely unremarkable might be a bit strong, it certainly is very vast -- but so is the Internet.