15 ms·
Creative Cloud outage leaves Adobe users unable to work
- lotsofmangos 13y agoComplete non-hacked photoshop CS2 is freely available with serial - http://www.techspot.com/downloads/3689-adobe-photoshop-cs2.html http://www.techspot.com/downloads/3689-adobe-photoshop-cs2.h... It works pretty well in Wine as well, if you fiddle with the settings.
- taspeotis 13y agoIf you Google around Adobe released a statement saying that those CS2 downloads and provided serial number are for customers who bought CS2. Adobe switched off their activation servers but made the serial numbers available to mitigate that.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoThey are undoubtedly for those customers, but legally you have to enforce copyrights to keep them. There is no way that Adobe could argue that they are still enforcing copyright restrictions on the binaries of CS2.
- nandhp 13y agoYou're confusing copyright with trademarks. Trademarks must be defended if you want to keep them (this is logical: if other people are using them, they are no longer a mark of your trade). That doesn't apply to copyright; it's an entirely automatic process.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoYou are right. Thinking it through you can of course put a restrictive license on stuff that is publicly available, otherwise of course open source would not work. What Adobe may have done is confused their original license terms by posting a download with key, so a court is very unlikely to award more than nominal damages should Adobe get annoyed with it being used, but you are perfectly correct, their copyright still holds up.
- userbinator 13y agoAdobe's actions and disclaimer on the downloads is interesting - they seem to be using vague legal language, e.g. using "may not" instead of "must not", deleting posts on its forum that claim using those downloads without a license is illegal, etc. To me it looks like they're just trying to discourage it somewhat officially; given their rather lax stance on piracy, they probably believe it's better that someone uses unlicensed CS2 than something non-Adobe.
- dagw 13y agoIf you're happy using software you don't have a license for, why not grab CS6 off of the your favorite torrent site. People bitch and bitch about DRM (and god knows I do as well), but as soon as a company tries to release software without any licensing hoops or other checks, people jump all over it and shout "Hey everybody, this company isn't going out of their way stop me from using their software, it must be free!!!!" Just because you can download and run some piece of software from a companies website doesn't mean you have a license to freely use it.
- lotsofmangos 13y agoI am recommending this on a thread for people who can't use their paid for software from Adobe. Sure, some other people might use it as well, but seeing as Adobe have already calculated that they can afford the risk before they started offering CS2 plus serials for download, I don't think I need to worry too much. As far as downloading a cracked version, well there is no way I am going to recommend to people to try out random cracked stuff off torrent sites.
- x86_64Ubuntu 13y agoIt seems like you are ignoring the context in which this is happening. People aren't going for the CS2 or cracked CS6 because they want to, they are going for it because the service they have paid for is gone.
- johnatwork 13y agoAnd CS2 is more than enough for most folks.
- aeberbach 13y agoAnd this is why proprietary lock-in is wrong. Adobe seem to do all they can to screw up the computer their software is installed on. On a Mac you are supposed to drag an app into the Applications folder; to delete it, drag it to trash. Adobe software doesn't work like this. To install a trial of their software you have to install multiple apps, that can't be easily removed, and put up with their stupid Adobe logo in the title bar even when you're not using their software. You can't even use a trial without signing up for a "Creative Cloud" account. Adobe's "Creative Cloud" is a great example of how to alienate and annoy your customers. (Don't get me started on Flash)
- narrator 13y agoWhat's funny is this is what Quark did in the 90s and then they got their market share stolen by Adobe. The same thing will happen to Adobe at some point. There will be so much user frustration that people will pack up and leave to the first reasonable tool that comes along.
- shravan 13y agoOn the topic of reasonable alternative tools, Sketch[1] has started to gain a tremendous amount of traction within a short amount of time within the web design community. [1]: http://bohemiancoding.com/sketch http://bohemiancoding.com/sketch
- ary 13y agoAs a Sketch user myself I still recognize downside for some is that it isn't cross platform. There are still a lot of people that have to use creative tools on Windows for one reason or another. Data exchange is also a big deal. Sketch does make an excellent alternative to Illustrator for my purposes. I'd argue that alternatives to Photoshop and After Effects are the killer apps needed for getting most people out of Adobe's ecosystem. The OS X specific alternatives for Photoshop (Acorn, Pixelmator, etc) just aren't quite there yet. I really, really want them to be though because I've held off on upgrading from CS4 for about as long as I can.
- thejosh 13y agoWas just restored an hour ago apparently, with no compensation for the downtime of the people affected....
- ISL 13y agoDoes anyone have access to GIMP download statistics for the past ~10 days? Edit: Answering my own question... Not the main repository, but it's something. http://sourceforge.net/projects/gimp-win/files/GIMP%20%2B%20GTK%2B%20%28stable%20release%29/stats/timeline?dates=2014-05-01+to+2014-05-16 http://sourceforge.net/projects/gimp-win/files/GIMP%20%2B%20...
- thirsteh 13y agoToo bad GIMP is such a crappy alternative.
- timonovici 13y agoWell, you can change that in a way. Just use the money you would otherwise pay Adobe and fund the feature you need. You can easily contact the developers, there's a list of them here https://git.gnome.org/browse/gimp/tree/AUTHORS https://git.gnome.org/browse/gimp/tree/AUTHORS ; By browsing the source code, you can also find their emails.
- timonovici 13y agoAlso, check out Krita; it looks a lot like photoshop to me, but the last time I used photoshop was 7 years ago. https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-dBDHsjsOG4w/U1e8ubOrBTI/AAAAAAAAED8/EsvVsy5qkPE/w954-h597-no/krita-new-icons.png https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-dBDHsjsOG4w/U1e8ubOrBTI/A... There is a guy, David Revoy, that uses only free software to do it's job, and it seems successful at it. http://davidrevoy.com/ http://davidrevoy.com/
- hackerboos 13y agoPixelmator is a much better solution if you're on a Mac. Not free though...
- kuschku 13y agoI would actually pay 50€ or so for Pixelmator if it'd be available for Linux – but sadly it's not. I'd think, though, that the Pixelmator devs could port it to Linux quite easily, as most of the code already works with OpenGL/OpenCL/etc. so they'd only have to port the Cocoa-based UI to QT.
- kbatten 13y agoI have a hard time understanding why anyone would lease a service that is vital to their job, or at least without a backup. If your livelihood depends on something then spend your money appropriately. Even if you did sign up for CC you can still have an older version ready to go in a pinch.
- kevingadd 13y agoAdobe is increasingly forcing you to do it. EDIT: For example, can you figure out how to buy Photoshop from this page? I can't. I've been trying for a couple minutes. http://www.adobe.com/products/catalog/software._sl_id-contentfilter_sl_catalog_sl_software_sl_mostpopular.html http://www.adobe.com/products/catalog/software._sl_id-conten...
- WebSearchingPro 13y agoYou have to find it here, I've had this page bookmarked since they started pushing CC, just in-case. http://www.adobe.com/products/catalog/cs6._sl_id-contentfilter_sl_catalog_sl_software_sl_creativesuite6.html http://www.adobe.com/products/catalog/cs6._sl_id-contentfilt...
- thenomad 13y agoWow! I didn't even realise it was still possible to buy Adobe products the old-school way. This is extremely good news.
- uptown 13y agoYes - but it's old versions that will no longer be updated. You can usually find older versions directly from resellers at Amazon at prices below Adobe's direct prices.
- dublinben 13y agoThe older versions also will not accept files created in the newer Creative Cloud versions. This has been a constant source of frustration at my office. It's an excellent way for Adobe to encourage/force everyone to buy CC.
- l0stb0y 13y agoI wasn't a fan if CC at first but it's turned into an incredibly good deal for me at $30 per month. A little downtime from time to time can't be avoided. People just love to complain.
- kibibu 13y agoI'm sure your words are comforting to those graphic designers who missed print deadlines due to this outage.
- l0stb0y 13y agoQuite frankly, if a persons workflow doesn't include a potential for downtime then they only have themselves to blame. This whole 'down to the wire' and 'stop the press' mentality is a combination of drama-grade fallacy and unprofessional project management skills.
- aeberbach 13y agoThis hand-wave over designer's inability to build enough slack to deal with Adobe's failure into every project is a combination of unsubtle trolling and egregious sociopathy.
- l0stb0y 13y agoIt's called 'planning for the unexpected' and encompasses a wide range of scenarios, only one of which can be blamed on Adobe.
- ScottWhigham 13y agoWell, to play devil's advocate, 'planning for the unexpected' should also cover 'a client calls at the last minute with a rush job', shouldn't it? In that case, how is an Adobe outage the consultant's fault?
- 13y ago
- e12e 13y agoAnd this is why I won't trust SaaS that doesn't provide a viable self-host solution (which for practical purposes tends to mean Free software, although I suppose "binary" only self-contained jars might be a realistic alternative). And also why I can't see myself selling/working on such a solution without providing some form of viable/realistic exit strategy/alternative. With traditional apps, you run the risk of eg: your laptop crashing/being stolen -- but if you need to work, you can just go and pick up a new laptop, burn an hour or so reinstalling your application(s) -- and hopefully get your work done by the deadline. With a self-hostable SaaS, you can spin up a vps/dedicated server and install, maybe even in less time -- but with "closed" SaaS -- you have no option. Of course, with all (high-bandwidth) SaaS-solutions, network access becomes a single point of failure.
- rtpg 13y agoI don't have the data to back it up, but (for example) data loss as a whole have probably considerably gone down with transitions to SaaS. Sure you can self-host, but who do you trust more: some guy on your team who has other things to do, or a team that does only that? And a team whose livelyhood depends on uptime/data protection. Here people can't work, but imagine the amount of work if there was a data failure on your machine? Your example (laptop being stolen) means you probably don't even have access to your data.
- x0x0 13y agotime machine in the event of a theft, I can walk into an apple store, purchase an in stock macbook, let time machine recover for ~30 minutes, and get back to work edit: just to be clear, I bet the vast majority of users will, even after this 24+ hours, experience less net downtime. Nonetheless, when I need to hit a deadline, with installed software, I have a viable plan b. The viable plan b here appears to be to grovel before clients whose deadlines you've blown...
- rtpg 13y agogood point, maybe the minimum for backups and the like have gotten so good that Toy Story-style "We have lost everything" situations don't really happen as much anymore. Design tools are definitely a different category than some other enterprise-y software though. At least Evernote still allows me to use it if the servers were down.
- Mandatum 13y agoAnd this is the sticking point for cloud-focussed systems. It's too early to implement an "always-on" attitude in so many parts of the world. I hope the backlash to this 24-hour outage (which in some cases will lose clients over) acts as the poster-child for would-be cloud-only services.
- rgrieselhuber 13y agoAs a result of this outage today, I found myself switching Pixelmator and Sketch. So far, so good.
- nnq 13y agoMy recipe for dealing with "cranky" proprietary software like this: Step 1. Buy CC subscription and install what you need. Step 2. Look for a good patch/crack that makes everything work ofline, and that still allows you to update. Step 3. Make peace with the risk of having installed some possible malware on your machine with the patch/crack (ie. do the sensible thing of doing you shopping and ebanking on the other dedicated machine you only use for this). Step 4. Stop caring that step 2 is illegal and get on with your life, you paid for the damn thing and nobody will really sue you for using it in a way that breaks the damn EULA anyway...
- asdfaoeu 13y ago> risk of having installed some possible malware Are you talking about the Creative Cloud drm or the crack?
- orware 13y agoBoth probably ;-). Most likely just the crack...sometimes they come with additional crap and people (who are none the wiser) click on it and get something bad installed.
- rangibaby 13y agoYou don't need a crack for CC, just to block Adobe's activation servers in your hosts after installing. (AFAIK)
- Fuxy 13y agoThat only work for 90 days though once the counter hits 90 you're screwed. You still code that can either crack the software or act is a server for it.
- mschuster91 13y agoNot anymore, this was valid up to CS5. CS5.5 and later need the amtlib.dll patch on Windows, dunno what's the state of affairs on Macintosh.
- girvo 13y agoI'm a developer, and I only use Adobes products to pull images and the like out of Photoshop/Illustrator files given to me by my design team. I don't want to use Adobes software, as its entirely wasted on me. But I don't think any of the other apps handle PSD's (a horrid file format) well enough to allow me to replace them :( Anyone in my position that has replaced them? What should I look at?
- e12e 13y agoI've had fair success using Gimp for similar use-cases -- with the caveat that that is mostly for design mock-ups made in photoshop (no vector graphics to speak of). There's definitely a learning curve, and Gimp still has a long way to go -- but it's passed into "usable" quite a while ago for my uses. [edit: if anyone knows of other alternatives (preferably that runs on Linux and/or under Wine, preferably Free software - but also closed source -- I'd love to hear about it]
- lucaspiller 13y agoI used to do this until somebody sent me an Illustrator file. GIMP or any other free alternative (e.g. Inkscape) I've found won't handle those correctly.
- schrijver 13y agoI recently had to open a simple Illustrator file in Inkscape and it worked well enough. But yeah I wouldn’t be surprised if it choked on more complicated stuff. You can of course always ask your clients to save as SVG.
- tripzilch 13y agoI found that SVGs between Illustrator and InkScape aren't fully compatible either. Sometimes objects wouldn't get filled in the same way. Most problems seemed to be on the Illustrator side, though, not InkScape. Or maybe the other guy didn't quite know what he was doing, but still that's a real problem, and he isn't dumb either. I bet you'd get all sorts of minor glitches and artefacts with even more complicated vector imagery.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- derengel 13y agoI just bought acorn and idraw but everyone here is recommending pixelmator and sketch :(
- DanHulton 13y agoFWIW, I moved from Pixelmator to Acorn and prefer Acorn immensely. Don't feel so bad.
- zimpenfish 13y agoFor what little I do that doesn't require spinning up Photoshop on the Windows beast, I use Acorn on the MBPr. It just feels nicer than Pixelmator to me.
- jawngee 13y agoYou can still use CC software, you just can't update or have access to their shitty sync software. But all the apps work, they don't require an internet connection (for 30 days at least), so it's not the disaster everyone is making it out to be.
- binarycrusader 13y agoNo, if you read the very fine article, you'd see that users specifically were encountering problems running apps. Some users were unable to run the apps getting unexpected errors when trying to do so despite what you say.
- LoganCale 13y agoTotally false. Many people are unable to launch the applications at all.
- girvo 13y agoNo, about a dozen designers here couldn't even launch Photoshop for a solid hour. Something really broke today it seems.
- rgrieselhuber 13y agoNot true. I couldn't launch any of the applications.
- vetrom 13y agoIt really is the moments like this when I look at my stack of Gimp, Inkscape, Scribus, and Darktable, and am glad that I invested in the alternate solution.
- schrijver 13y agoNot sure why you’re getting downvoted for this: I’d say you’re allowed your little moment of schadenfreude after having invested all these time in tools many designers won’t yet take seriously! The real catch though, is that design work is almost always done in collaboration—so that it’s not just enough to switch yourself, you need to find other people to work with who use similar tools.
- camus2 13y agoThat's what you get when a business has a monopole on a market.You're now free to go to competition... not.Put the industry itself is responsible for this.
- cageface 13y agoBohemian Coding has finally fixed the grid snapping bug that plagued all previous versions of Sketch so I will definitely not be renewing my CC subscription when it expires. CC feels like it has much more do with Adobe's needs than mine.
- peterkelly 13y ago"A distributed system is one in which the failure of a computer you didn't even know existed can render your own computer unusable." - Leslie Lamport
- pestaa 13y agoI consider this quote tounge in cheek. A properly distributed system will keep your system functioning even when remote components are down.
- codeshaman 13y agoCloud computing is a great theoretical idea, but extremely fragile in the face of serious crisis, like economic meltdown, wars, sanctions or even natural disasters. All the websites, always-on apps, mobile operating systems, etc will be worthless if (when) the shit hits the fan. In case of global economic meltdown, the companies would be unable to pay for the huge data-centers, the providers will go belly up and it would be next to impossible to restore or recover the data stored in the 'cloud'. Imagine waking up one day and not having access to the Internet. Try it and see how much you can do with your computer. And with Russia under KGB dictatorship (read: insane, evil people), that shit can hit the fan as soon as this year. That's why it is imperative to create an offline database of important things which would be available even when the clouds evaporate. By 'important' things, I mean open source code (eg. offline github), wikipedia and other encyclopaedias, scientific works, books, music, movies. From this angle, I consider thepiratebay to be the most important archive of art that humanity has collectively produced. I've even started working on some sketches of a distributed read-only filesystem based partly on the concepts in the bitcoin blockchain, but I guess a simple solution using torrents plus a distributed offline index, can do the job just fine. Anyone else thought about this ?
- rwallace 13y agoA simple solution that works now tends to beat a complex solution still on the drawing board. I'd say go ahead with the torrents plus distributed off-line index.
- abandonliberty 13y agoCould this be grounds for a class action? > Adobe had categorically assured users and journalists, when replacing Creative Suite with Creative Cloud in May 2013, that apps only needed to check in with the server every 30 days, telling MacUser in a written reply that products would continue to work for 99 days in the absence of a server connection.
- bitL 13y agoI find it funny that my graphics card is now faster than the world's fastest supercomputer in 1997, yet I am forced to "offload" stuff to cloud. I bought CS6 suite as it became clear Adobe is moving full steam ahead with CC. I think it is one of those examples where the move serves only company's interests and doesn't make much sense to users (except for continuous updates that might accidentally break things as well). The initial pricing might have been competitive for some packages, for many users however caused substantial increase if they used to skip one cycle for upgrades. I understand Adobe needs a predictable revenue stream though I consider this as a flop.
- jacquesm 13y agoWhen I had to go out to buy licenses a few months ago for an intern at our company and found out that it is no longer possible to buy the regular Adobe licenses for the latest products we solved this by using competitor products and open source projects to give us a patched together set of tools. The money was not an issue, what was an issue is that I think that tools should not be shoehorned against all logic into a pay-to-play model, they should just work. Imagine your c compiler or your editor failing to work because some third party service is down. To me that is not an option. I hope Adobe learns their lesson and re-instates the licensing model they used in the past and gets rid of their 'Creative Cloud' nonsense asap. And if they don't then I hope some competitor will realize this is a huge opportunity and will jump into the gap opened up here. Adobe is good, but they can be beaten, especially if they shoot themselves in the foot (repeatedly).
- blueskin_ 13y agoMeanwhile, sensible people who don't rent their software are laughing from CS6.
- gagege 13y agoUntil CS6 stops being supported by some operating system or processor architecture in the future.
- blueskin_ 13y agox86_64 will never die, it's too pervasive, and as much as mobile fans think the future is underpowered ARM with the actual processing being done by a third party sifting through your personal data (who generally use x86_64 anyway), reality isn't following their expectations.
- gagege 13y agoI don't know about that. And anyway, I've had 2 expensive pieces of software meant for professional production, that just stopped working over the years for various reasons. "Old" versions of Vegas Video don't work in anything past Windows XP. Same goes for "old" versions of Pro Tools. Also, with the old Pro Tools, make sure you don't have a dual core processor, because that breaks it too. My point is, there are many factors which can suddenly render software obsolete. I wouldn't expect CS6 to run on anything but really old unsupported hardware in 5 - 10 years. One of the best things you can do for your career is to remain flexible about the tools you use. Always be on the lookout for alternatives.
- blueskin_ 13y agoThen virtualise it - by the time it doesn't, someone will have Linux-style containers working in windows.
- bane 13y agoOne of the issues with the move to the cloud with formerly desktop software is exactly this. I used to use the analogy of an army using guns, except instead of a magazine holding bullets they had a long hose feeding them rounds. It sounded great to the generals, because instead of carrying around 20lbs of munitions, the soldiers just needed to carry around their guns. Of course all it took is for somebody to put a kink in the hose to put them out of the fight completely.
- ShaneOG 13y agoWhat should happen due to this outage: Adobe Management: Oh no, our users cannot work. Let's remove the requirement for our software to phone home just to open/work. What will probably happen: Adobe Management: Hmm, maybe let's try to make our servers more available?
- mcmillion 13y agoThe phone home is apparently periodic. I worked in Photoshop and Illustrator multiple times yesterday with zero problem.
- theFletch 13y agoI have CC and was able to work fine all day. I wasn't able to sign in but that has no bearing on me doing my job. Was this something that affected the licensing servers and I just happened to be lucky?
- pasbesoin 13y ago7.5 hours worth of repeated (and I mean repeatedly explaining the situation to each new contact) tech support calls over a licensing issue that was, ultimately, a 10 minute fix (allowing for included administrivia) that was already sitting available for access/correction on the computer in front of a "supervisor". That left me swearing Adobe would never see another dime from me or people I advise. And it leaves me repeating this anecdote every time the news surfaces another story about their cr-p administration systems and support. And these are the people who are going to be involved in e.g. EME DRM in our browsers? I sincerely hope not.
- edj 13y agoHere's a list of Mac OSX alternatives to everything in the Creative Cloud: http://mac.appstorm.net/roundups/graphics-roundups/the-best-alternative-apps-to-everything-in-adobe-creative-cloud/ http://mac.appstorm.net/roundups/graphics-roundups/the-best-...
- Mister_Snuggles 13y agoNever outsource your core business. Never outsource critical infrastructure that your core business requires to operate, unless you have a backup plan. If GitHub goes away, you can switch to BitBucket. If Digital Ocean goes away, you can switch to Linode. If Adobe CC goes away, what do you switch to?
- lifeformed 13y agoWait, do you really have to have a constant internet connection to run Photoshop now?
- DrStalker 13y agoAustralian here. Using the subscription version of Creative Suite avoids the $4000 fuck-you-Australia markup they add onto the price of the full version. So yeah, we don't get to edit photos when the internet is down or Adobe's servers fail.