6 ms·
Health Care Doesn't Affect Health (on the margin)
- te_platt 17y agoQuick summary - from the article: "If you would not pay for medicine out of your own pocket, then don’t bother to go when others offer to pay." Overall a well argued article.
- jfornear 17y agoI would say the quick summary would be: "In the aggregate, variations in medical spending usually show no statistically significant medical effect on health."
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoI don't think the article went into the fact that most of people's medical spending happens in the last couple months of life. Per capita medical costs will just keep ballooning until as a society we change our attitude and approach to dying of old age. We simply can't afford every called for treatment for every dying geriatric. There has to be some rationing mechanism whether it's the market and individual wealth, insurance bureaucrats, or government death panels. "Old Age" isn't even a cause of death anymore for statistical purposes. Sorry, but when a 90 year old dies the cause of death is old age, regardless of whether it was heart failure or cancer.
- joe_the_user 17y agoGood article but your quote does not summarize it well at all - it's just a side point the author makes on the way to the main point. Real Summary: The author eloquently argues that an emphasis on medical spending has caused health care resources to be misdirected to the point that such spending is generally counter-productive.
- ivankirigin 17y agoThere are four levels of health: how healthy you are, how much health care coverage you get, how much health care coverage insurance you have, and what percentage of the population has insurance. We've been arguing that increasing the percentage of those with a certain level of health care coverage insurance would be good for aggregate health. My intuition is that removing corn subsidies would have a greater effect - and the aggregate health of the world would drastically increase if you consider the African sugar farmer who can't sell to western markets because of regulations and subsidies. Ohh, and it would make money, not cost money.
- tjic 17y ago> My intuition is that removing corn subsidies Heck, why not go ahead and remove tobacco subsidies!
- ivankirigin 17y agoCorn syrup isn't addictive. I think the cigarette market would be fine without subsidies. Of course, I agree completely to remove those limits. I find it's like solving global warming like painting a roof white, or working from home - extremely cheap and obvious ways to change things. That governments don't choose these options is likely because their goal is power, not progress. Removing subsidies, lowering regulation, legalizing pot, etc., would all be revenue generators and add to the public good.
- anamax 17y ago> I find it's like solving global warming like painting a roof white, or working from home - extremely cheap and obvious ways to change things. Except for the part that they don't work. For example, painting your roof white saves energy in some climates but not others. > That governments don't choose these options is likely because their goal is power, not progress. That's half correct. The goal is power but progress isn't something that govt opposes, it's something that doesn't matter either way.
- joe_the_user 17y ago
- mattchew 17y agoA quote from one of my favorite books. The speaker is a poet from about 500 BC: "Some of my best friends have been doctors, and excellent people they were, most knowledgeable about the minds of men, whom they see when the poets do not. But doctors are taught their laws, and they keep those laws if it kills you. Some of them here in Sicily come asking how a wanderer like me has kept such good health to past fourscore. I tell them this or that. It would be uncivil to say that whenever in my travels I get a touch of fever, I go quietly to bed and send for the local wise-woman." Pretty good advice today, too. I'd like to see Robin's point of view get a wide hearing. I'm afraid he's trying to paddle against a powerful current the other direction, though.
- kirubakaran 17y agoIs "local wise-woman" an euphemism for a woman of negotiable affections? I don't understand how a woman possessing wisdom can help your fever.
- MaysonL 17y agoRead "witch" or "herbalist" or "evidence-based medical practitioner unwilling to go by fads and humours".
- sethg 17y agoIt wouldn't surprise me if the health of the average person is not significantly affected by the amount spent on medical care. So what? The whole point of insurance is to protect the policy-holder from the risk of outcomes that are much worse than average. My seven-year-old son has a friend with hemophilia; if he didn't get regular infusions of clotting factor and similar treatments, he might live for another ten years--fifteen, tops. The quality of his health coverage certainly has an effect on his health. And he is exactly the sort of patient that the insurance companies will drop like a hot rock at the earliest excuse.
- rarrrrrr 17y agoFor every patient like him, there's probably 10 or more being treated for conditions they could have avoided entirely through better diet and exercise. Nearly all cases of diabetes, heart disease, osteoporosis, and most cancers are preventable, just to name a few. I think the point is that if we focused more on health (i.e. long term preventative health) instead of on medicine alone, there would be far more available resources to handle the genuine medical needs.
- hughprime 17y agoMost cancers preventable? Lung cancers maybe (and only maybe), but on the whole (and as far as we know) cancer isn't affected all that strongly by lifestyle factors.
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoCancer types and rates have varied dramatically over time in populations and between populations. Ergo cancer is driven by lifestyle factors.
- abecedarius 17y agoSome sources: http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2008/07/cancer-among-inuit.html http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2008/07/cancer-among-i... http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2008/07/cancer-in-other-non-industrialized.html http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2008/07/cancer-in-othe...
- billswift 17y agoRobin's got a lot more on medical care at http://www.overcomingbias.com/tag/medicine http://www.overcomingbias.com/tag/medicine . You need to go back a few months or more to get stuff like this essay though; most of his newer stuff is on status signalling and medicine.
- anamax 17y agoIndoor plumbing matters, as does garbage pickup and food and water safety.
- Achorny 17y agoThis article reminds me a lot of conspiracy theorists and their "anomaly hunting" - throwing out as many anomalies as possible leaving little chance to consider/rebut them before moving onto the next thing, and claiming victory when no one bothers. I'm not an expert on many of the things listed, but many stick out as just not making any sense: First of all, holy special pleading batman! Pretty much right at the beginning he redefines health care to exclude things he admits work - diet, exercise, sleep, not smoking, etc. Who does he think figured out that smoking was bad? Or how much exercise and sleep is enough, and how much is too much? Or what foods are good for you and which are bad? He also claims that there are "dozens of studies of the aggregate health effects of medicine", but most of the studies he describes are very specific - several only studying the last six months of people's lives, ignoring how many cases of people living extra years because of medicine? He also admits that increased social status improves health while claiming that increased medical spending does not. But it's well known that the rich can afford better health care, and doesn't explain how to (or cite any papers that) control for this. Lastly, he only considers length of life and totally ignores quality of life. I take an antidepressant for my anxiety, and while it probably will not affect the length of my life, it sure as hell is worth every penny in improving the quality of my life!
- Zak 17y agoHe's talking about health care spending. It doesn't cost money to not smoke, to select certain more healthful food options or to walk five blocks instead of driving. All of these can and should be considered health care, but aren't usually measured in studies of health care spending or availability of health care.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI strongly suggest you read the article before commenting. Pretty much right at the beginning he redefines health care to exclude things he admits work - diet, exercise, sleep, not smoking, etc. No he doesn't. That was a bad choice of title on my part when I submitted the article. I should have titled it "Medical Care Doesn't Affect Health (on the margin)". But like most people, I use the terms "health care" and "medical care" interchangeably. The bigram "health care" does not appear once in the article. He also admits that increased social status improves health while claiming that increased medical spending does not. But it's well known that the rich can afford better health care, and doesn't explain how to (or cite any papers that) control for this. This is simply not true. He cites a number of cross section studies which compare rich/poor/etc people receiving more medicine to rich/poor/etc people receiving less. He also cites the RAND experiment which was actually a randomized trial addressing the same question. Lastly, he only considers length of life and totally ignores quality of life... False. The RAND experiment studied various health measures, not mortality.
- silent_tone 17y agoBad analogy. Most automotive defects lead to breakdowns, not serious crashes. Most serious automotive crashes aren't caused by mechanical defects. When your car DOES breakdown, you buy a new one. Preventative medicine and lifestyle practices extends life in lieu of the option of replacing your body