14 ms·
Can This Web Be Saved? Mozilla Accepts DRM, and We All Lose
- EduardoBautista 13y agoHow about just ignore the websites that implement DRM and let the free market decide if those websites will survive? People treat DRM as if it was going to turn us into North Korea when it comes to internet access.
- svisser 13y agoYes, let's ignore the problem and it'll go away?
- EduardoBautista 13y agoNetflix has been using DRM for years, does it really make it worse?
- viraptor 13y agoDo you have a native and supported way to watch Netflix on Linux? No. So it does make the experience worse (it's one of the biggest missing components, not implying the only one).
- CamperBob2 13y agoHow is this question symptomatic of anything but a tool fetish? Watch the movies, not the OS.
- wolfgke 13y agoGive me the specs of the DRM system so that I can implement a tool for my OS to be able to watch the movies.
- CamperBob2 13y agoNo. Any other demands, while you're at it?
- woah 13y agoYou might want to try popcorn time. I have found the UI to actually exceed Netflix's while giving me pure piracy unencumbered by any DRM. I just read that they have added TV shows to the new version. If the content industry is going to keep doing this shit, they don't deserve our money. Don't worry about the artists, if these are the people they have chosen to sign their lives away to.
- wolfgke 13y agoThat's one of the reasons I'm not using Netflix (and I'm not buying Blurays). Additionally both don't work under Linux.
- stormbrew 13y agoIf you could make the choice of what content to watch and what to watch it with independently, this could be said to be a free market decision. As is, my decision to support or not support DRM dictates the content I can watch. That for most people the content is more important gives the false signal that people are choosing DRM (which, in reality, pretty much nobody would). That's not a functional free market. There is no market for non-DRMed content that's on an even footing with the market for DRMed content.
- rayiner 13y agoI feel like this is a rationalization. The fact that a market is free doesn't mean that producers can't sell on the terms they want. There is DRM-free content, just not the content you want. Content creators choose to use DRM because very few users object to it, and I bet with modern DRM most don't even know it exists. That's a perfectly functional free market. Its like saying that there isn't a functional free market for social networks because you want a subscription-supported site while Facebook, etc, are ad supported. The fact that a seller won't sell on the terms I want doesn't mean its not a free market.
- CamperBob2 13y agoAgreed. People whining about the loss of a "free market" are, in reality, whining about their loss of control over the producers' options. It doesn't make a bit of sense. In fact, one indication of a "free market" at work is when they're selling things you don't like.
- wolfgke 13y ago> The fact that a market is free doesn't mean that producers can't sell on the terms they want. Copyright laws stand in the way of a free market. If there was a free market anybody could make a copy of some content and sell it (perhaps they would have to pay parts of the profit to the original owners, but nevertheless anybody would basically allowed to sell what they want: that's what a free market is about).
- 13y ago
- higherpurpose 13y agoUnfortunately, the only "free market" for non-DRM movies/shows is piracy.
- themoonbus 13y agoCan some one explain to me why having, say, an HTML 5 based video player with DRM would be worse than one implemented in a closed platform like Silverlight or Flash? I'm genuinely curious, and not trying to make an argument here.
- EduardoBautista 13y agoIt wouldn't.
- 27182818284 13y agoI have the same feeling. Few people I know even use a browser to watch that type of content anymore. Frankly I think native apps on the TV, Nexus 7, iPad, etc won already and this isn't going to be used much.
- michaelt 13y agoThe whole point of replacing Flash with HTML5 video is to get rid of buggy third party plugins that crash all the time and have shitty cross-platform support. If HTML5 video is going to rely on buggy third party DRM plugins, we lose the benefit that was the whole point of HTML5 video.
- isomorphic 13y agoI run my browsers without Flash in order to avoid Adobe's exploit-du-jour crapware. This means, for example, that I don't run Chrome. If this binary blob from Adobe isn't presented with a similar UI as regular "plugins" (that the user can disable or uninstall), then I will look into writing an extension to disable it, or perhaps rely on a Firefox fork to give me a Flash-lite(tm) free browser.
- andreyf 13y agoYou might want to reconsider. Chrome sandboxes the Flash runtime [1], meaning a 0-day exploit in Flash alone doesn't get an attacker access to your machine. 1. http://thenextweb.com/google/2012/11/13/google-declares-flash-is-now-fully-sandboxed-in-chrome-for-windows-mac-linux-and-chrome-os/ http://thenextweb.com/google/2012/11/13/google-declares-flas...
- chimeracoder 13y agoFrom a comment by a Mozilla employee on another thread, it seems that the UI for this has not yet been determined[0]. It's possible that this may be presented to the user in a way similar to a plugin installation, except that the plugin happens to be provided by Mozilla (not a third-party). This isn't great, but to the end user, it looks the same as Flash and Silverlight. Especially if Mozilla were to add click-to-play for all such plugins, along with an explanation of what they are (think of the warnings that are currently shown for self-signed certs), they may still have an opportunity to do good with this yet. I'd really love for Mozilla to remain as true to its mission as possible. On the other hand, Mozilla's power to do good in the world is intrinsically linked to its marketshare[1]. If Mozilla ends up being the lone holdout, it's possible that they will just lose marketshare as DRM content becomes more widespread - that would be quite a Pyrrhic victory[2]. I share in the EFF's disappointment at the situation, though (saldy) this has been inevitable for some time. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7744954 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7744954 [1] Perhaps not 100%, but it's a major component of it. [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyrrhic_victory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyrrhic_victory
- farresito 13y agoWhat really worries me is the fact that now it's going to be way easier to implement something with DRM. A lot of users nowadays are not willing to install some third party plugin. The fact that it comes with the browser means that it's extremely easy to implement something with that DRM. I might be wrong, since I haven't read much about it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- evv 13y agoI doubt netflix looses much business because they require silverlight to watch. On the contrary, making DRM tech more accessible to developers will only help young startups build platforms that are "content provider friendly". This will promote competition in the online entertainment space and ultimately drive prices down. I'm no fan of DRM but I see the value it serves. Just like advertising. I don't see why everybody is making such a fuss about this when we already have a wide proliferation of plugin-based DRM. Why are people complaining that it is moving towards an even more open layer?
- suprgeek 13y agoMozilla had to be dragged into this acceptance kicking and screaming (metaphorically). They were faced with a hard choice, Not implement EME (HTML5 DRM) and risk users moving to other browsers (user loss) or implement EME and risk looking like they are contradicting their core mission (trust loss). They figured a little loss of trust is worth keeping most of the users on the Mozilla platform - which in my view is the correct decision. If users start to abandon Mozilla (FireFox) in droves then they lose their power to influence the development of the open web.
- wolfgke 13y agoFor people who want DRM there are already enough browser choices. On the other hand for people who refuse DRM there's only one choice - and soon zero.
- jgraham 13y agoThat isn't the case. You can choose to not install the CDM component.
- shmerl 13y agoIs there a way to disable all related code in Firefox itself? Just for the sake of it. May be Mozilla can produce clean and tainted builds for that purpose.
- azakai 13y agoThe code is 100% open source, so even if there isn't a GUI option for it, it would be easy for people to make builds without it. There are already many forked builds of firefox like iceweasel, etc.
- shmerl 13y agoYes, I expect such thing to surface, but it would be nice if Mozilla could provide such options on their own too. That would be some small positive gesture towards those who don't appreciate their move and see it as a betrayal of Mozilla's core values. It would as well make this issue more apparent. Doesn't Mozilla care about educating the public on such matters? It surely would be a positive thing for the Open Web.
- 27182818284 13y agoI must be missing something. I read the article and clicked the attached link to Mozilla's blog, and nothing seems radically to change for users other than a move sideways. Though I'm a little disappointed that there isn't a move forward, it certainly doesn't feel like a step backwards. Even Mozilla writes, "At Mozilla we think this new implementation contains the same deep flaws as the old system. " (emphasis mine) Right now if you want to lock something down, like watching Netflix on your browser, you install Silverlight. In the future, Silverlight is replaced and Netflix uses XYZ technology but maybe with DRM-in-HTML or whatever. And as a user, it doesn't matter because most people I know today use a tablet with the native app, a streaming device such as the Roku player, or a SmartTV.
- barrkel 13y agoIf I want to watch Netflix I use a different browser. I don't need to use the same browser for everything online, and I especially don't enable Silverlight in my primary browser.
- hidden-markov 13y agoMaybe it can be disassembled? Like it what was done with some proprietary blobs of Linux kernel.
- wyager 13y agoIt absolutely can be disassembled. It's information-theoretically impossible to have a video format that people can watch, but can't transcode.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- klodolph 13y agoSo what you do is you use the DRM API to negotiate a way to transfer a decryption key to a secure hardware module in the consumer's device. Having the source code to the Firefox component doesn't give you access to the firmware or keys stored in the module. (Yes, you can hack hardware. But it's way more expensive.)
- xxs 13y agoYou can always screen capture the VGA port, DRM will never/ever work.
- takluyver 13y agoThis is a neat summary of an idea that always turns up on every DRM thread. If the best way to copy a movie is to buy some extra hardware to plug into your VGA port, and then play the movie back at regular speed while you record it, then DRM is working. Joe Bloggs isn't going to do that to give his mates copies of a movie he enjoyed. Of course, someone out there will go through that and put it on the internet. But Joe's mate is worried that the government will track his downloads, or his computer will get a virus from these dodgy downloads. And every few weeks, the source he's using shuts down and he has to find a new one. Before long, he'll just decide it's worth giving Netflix a few dollars a month to get movies the easy way.
- Mandatum 13y agoI'm not sure why they even bother trying, it'll be broken within a week. They're pointlessly adding to a spec which has enough bloat and hacked-together features.
- a3_nm 13y agoI would hope that rebranded versions of Firefox such as Iceweasel will strip the DRM support, so I guess it is not like it will be forced on people who don't want it. Of course, this is still bad news, because it means there is no more pressure on content owners against this DRM, which can eventually become painful for people who want to avoid the DRM.
- cbhl 13y agoIt is painful today for people who want to avoid the DRM legally. We already lost the ideological war with the media companies.
- snird 13y agoTechnology should never force it's users (the sites creators) to use one technology or another. Not implementing DRM is idiotic for couple of reasons: 1. The decision of whether or not to use DRM should be of the site creators. That's as "free" as it gets. forcing them otherwise by not letting them the option is bad. 2. Even without implementing it, DRM is available through flash or silverlight or any other third party plugin. The only result not implementing DRM gets is that of hurting the HTML5 video component.
- wyager 13y ago> The decision of whether or not to use DRM should be of the site creators. That's as "free" as it gets. Why does that mean that we should facilitate their use of DRM? If they want to use it, they can specify a third-party plugin.
- snird 13y agoBecause it's a need of the market, using third-party plugin is no harder, maybe even easier to implement. So it's not an overhead for the site implementing it. But rather it's an overhead for the user. you'll have to install a third-party plugin on your computer. Making it to your job now to make sure this plugin is not security vulnerable, that it is updated etc' etc'. And, it's probably closed. the web is open.
- wyager 13y ago> And, it's probably closed. the web is open. Do you understand that these new HTML DRM plugins will be closed as well?
- michaelt 13y agoSo by that logic, if a site creator wants their site in powerpoint 97 .ppt format instead of using HTML, are browsers obligated to support it?
- snird 13y ago
- chris_wot 13y agoSo time to fork Firefox?
- k__ 13y agocode base too big...
- jgraham 13y agoSo I've seen this reaction in a few places, and I'm genuinely interested in what people think that it would achieve. You take the code of a browser that allows, but does not require, you to use a DRM system* and change it so that you are no longer able to install a DRM system. What's the value proposition of the new browser? You won't be tempted to install the DRM component when you find yourself wanting to view media that requires it? That seems pretty weak compared to the difficulty of maintaining a browser fork. It seems to me that refusing to ship DRM makes sense if it gives leverage against the content companies, such that could be used to make them adopt DRM-free solutions. To get such leverage it would be necessary both that the reach of the unencumbered web was compelling and that requiring DRM would significantly limit that reach. Unfortunately plugins have historically provided a DRM-enabled way of distributing content via the web, so there was no compelling reason for content makers to forgo DRM in the past. This makes it significantly more difficult to change the industry today. It is possible that there was a chance to win back some ground with the decline of plugins on mobile. However, it's also possible that the prevalence of native apps on those platforms made the web itself a less appealing medium for distributing content to mobile users. In any case, the eagerness of Microsoft and Google to deploy in-browser DRM means that we didn't get to run that experiment. Instead we are in a situation where some high percentage of web users can get DRM encumbered video content in their current browser. For those who can't the barrier to switching browsers is typically rather small. Not shipping the capability to view DRMed video in this situation is, tragically, trying to hold a non-equilibrium position; it might be principled but it is going to end in a significantly sub-optimal outcome. I suppose the optimistic view is that video will follow the iTunes model and DRM will be a short term burden that we have to bear until technology and attitudes in the industry make it clear that there's a better way. I'm confident that Mozilla will continue to push to find that better way. * Assuming one that exists that is compatible with your OS + hardware + etc.; all the usual problems of binary blobs in general and DRM in particular still apply, of course.
- 13throwaway 13y agoIf all major browsers support eme, every website will use it. Say goodbye to youtube-dl. Maybe next year eme will be updated to "protect" html. Soon the entire web may be a closed system. It doesn't matter what the FCC decides on Friday, today is the day the web dies, at mozilla's hands. There is always a choice mozilla, please make the right one.
- hadoukenio 13y agoUnfortunately your comment sounds about right. The bright side is that information wants to be free. If one day we have a closed web on a two-tier Internet, there will always be a group of people wanting to make it work like the old way. Unless they somehow made it illegal, the libre internet with an open ecosystem will always be available.
- woah 13y agoIt may be time for a refresh in any case.
- User9821 13y agoMozilla doesn't have a choice. Let's say Firefox has 30% of users. The argument is that sites will not use DRM, because they'll be losing revenue from 30% of their users, and therefore Mozilla saves the day. But, what happens if Google says they'll accept that challenge, and they're willing to lose 30% of revenue from something like YouTube in the short term. They implement DRM on YouTube, and Firefox users can no longer watch videos. What happens? Firefox users start converting over. Where to? Chrome, which falls into Google's best interest. Now, that 30% loss keeps getting smaller and smaller, and Chrome users start increasing. Fast forward a year, and Firefox only has 10% of the users. This continues to shrink until Firefox dies. Sadly, this is what happens when we give Google and Facebook too much power, and the ability to run the internet. It's our fault for giving them that position, and not developing or supporting alternatives. If you want to fight back, you need to give Mozilla a better position to stand. Sites like Wikipedia, Imgur, etc, need to run banners for browsers that support DRM, and block users, or encourage them to switch to a DRM free browser, like Firefox. Take the wind out of their sails, before they try to do the same to us.
- wolfgke 13y agoJust an idea that came to my mind: What about the idea to refuse support to any Firefox user that has installed a CDM component (for the same reason the Linux kernel developers don't give any support to users of "tainted" Linux kernels (i. e. kernels that have loaded non-open-source modules)).
- dviola 13y agoTime to fork Firefox maybe?
- acak 13y agoI liked Ubuntu's approach where they asked you on startup if you want to install/enable proprietary packages like Flash or some graphics drivers. Is it tough for Mozilla to prompt the user to do something similar with DRM stuff on first run? i.e. Telling them these are the features not supported by Mozilla in principle but are a) implemented to be in compliance with standards and b) required if you choose to use services like Netflix. That way I would still have the option to run a DRM free browser (and voluntarily not use websites that require DRM).
- mcpherrinm 13y agoMozilla has explicitly said the DRM plugin won't run without user consent. How this prompt exactly looks isn't clear to me, but it seems like you're getting the option you want today.
- higherpurpose 13y agoPretty sure it means it will run by default, and you'd have a to be part of a minority group on HN to know that you can even do that in Firefox.
- bzbarsky 13y agohttps://hacks.mozilla.org/2014/05/reconciling-mozillas-mission-and-w3c-eme/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2014/05/reconciling-mozillas-missi... is pretty clear: As plugins today, the CDM itself will be distributed by Adobe and will not be included in Firefox. The browser will download the CDM from Adobe and activate it based on user consent. The point being that you will be asked whether to download this thing, and if you say no it won't be downloaded.
- hmsimha 13y agoWhat does this mean for the TOR project? Will they have to bundle an old version of Firefox without the proprietary DRM component?
- rinon 13y agoForks of Firefox such as the TOR browser bundle can simply not include or disable the wrapper if they wish, since it is a standalone component.
- chris_mahan 13y agoThe web is finished. On to the next thing! (I'm sooo glad my web writings are in plain text files rather than in other people's mysql databases)
- jevinskie 13y agoHas anyone found where you can get the Adobe CDM binary blob?
- higherpurpose 13y ago> eliminates your fair-use rights This is true. I'd like to see a case in Court where the law about fair use is in conflict with the law that allows something that has been DRMed to be completely protected, legally. I assume fair use would win, but I'd still like to see that case, because then it could become a lot easier to break DRM in order to "excercise your fair use right", and circumventing DRM might become legal again, in effect killing DRM for good. Then even companies like Mozilla could implement DRM unlockers in their browsers and so on, since it would be perfectly legal to do so.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- DigitalSea 13y agoThis is most certainly the wrong choice, but people need to understand they essentially had no choice. Their options were rather limited: Option 1) Stick to your laurels and refuse to implement DRM. Other browser vendors implement DRM, certain parts of the web become inaccessible via Firefox as DRM is implemented into more and more web services (think Youtube, Vimeo, Netflix, Hulu). Firefox's lack of DRM means its users are being disadvantaged. Option 2) Implement DRM. Accept temporary defeat, don't lose browser share to Chrome and continue fighting from within against DRM. Which option do you think sounds more appealing to Mozilla? Die on your sword, keep the trust of your dwindling user base or implement DRM and retain most of your user base (minus the people that will leave because of this decision). I think someone needs to create a fork and build a DRM-less browser, that's the beautiful thing about open source, don't like something, change it.
- pdkl95 13y ago> Firefox's lack of DRM means its users are being disadvantaged. Firefox's lack of DRM would mean that users are being encouraged to used the services not encumbered with this nonsense, instead of all gravitating to whichever DRM service is most popular. Mozilla supporting DRM is a failure because of Metcalfe's Law[1]. By giving access to the network of people using DRM to their n users, they support that network by O(n^2) and make it that much harder to dislodge in the future. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law
- takluyver 13y agoI don't think Metcalfe's law applies here - people don't use encrypted HTML video as a communication network, it's mostly a channel from content producers to users. So its value only grows linearly with the number of users that can receive it. More importantly, though, content is more compelling than browsers, and browsers are easier to switch. If Firefox blocks its n users from receiving some content, some fraction of those will leave Firefox and get the content anyway, leaving Firefox with less strength to fight the next battle. In this case, it looks like that fraction would be pretty significant, and the impact on DRM not that great.
- 13y ago
- felipebueno 13y agoI'm done with Mozilla but I think the problem is not just the browser we choose anymore. The whole thing is compromised. We need a new internet, "new" ways to share and consume information. There are many people who think so as well. e.g.: http://electronician.hubpages.com/hub/Why-We-Need-a-New-Internet-and-How-to-Make-One http://electronician.hubpages.com/hub/Why-We-Need-a-New-Inte...
- nullc 13y agoWhat browser do you recommend I load that URL with? :)
- pjc50 13y agoRemember, the closed-source component is there because there has to be a place for the deliberately inserted NSA vulnerabilities (note the proposed use of Adobe). It's likely that this bizarre and unpopular decision is the result of some behind-the-scenes arm-twisting.
- paulrademacher 13y agoTLDR: Market share > Principles > We have come to the point where Mozilla not implementing the W3C EME specification means that Firefox users have to switch to other browsers to watch content restricted by DRM.
- rectangletangle 13y agoTime for a fork.
- kator 13y agoDRM is a fantasy that uninformed media executives cling onto with a dream that it will put the genie back in the bottle. It's sad to see this stuff but totally understandable considering the divide between the technology people who understand the reality and the people in charge of dreaming of a fantasy that gets them back to the '80s.. Yes I know.. I was an executive as a major record label, trust me it's hard to be on both sides of this argument and it's not as simple as everyone makes it out to be... I can't explain how many times I tried to help executives understand that the path between the media to the human eye or ear was vulnerable to so many attacks it clearly was a fruitless goal to protect media in that way. They hear some bright young person tell them they can protect their media like it was in the good 'ole days and they have the need to believe because without that belief they are out of a job.. And artists are on their own to figure out how to make money on their work...
- MichaelGG 13y agoIt really is that simple, though. Arrested Development was ripped from Netflix immediately after availability. There's nothing complicated about showing that it does not work. There would be zero impact if Netflix didn't have DRM. People would still have to search and install third party software to download streams. At that point, it doesn't matter if it comes from Netflix or from some random torrent.
- syntern 13y agoI'm wondering: what do you suggest to artists, how shall they make money on their work?
- loup-vaillant 13y agoCut out the middle men, rely on donations. Or still sell your stuff for a price, those who want it for free can reach for the Pirate Bay anyway —it's about the same. You won't be rich, but you may live off your craft. --- Other schemes such as global licence may also help. We also need easy, anonymous micro payment. Like, click a button to give 10 to 50 cents every time you feel like it when using something (song, e-book, software…). Oh, and, like, universal basic income. It's hard to get paid when we contribute to the commons, so basic income can help a great deal. (Seriously, if we had sustainable basic income —dunno if it's possible right now— we could probably abolish copyright and patent laws right away —and not worry about the massive lawyer lay-offs that will ensue.)
- whyenot 13y agoI wonder how Mozilla would have handled this if they still were dependent on donations from users for funding instead of Google.
- mccr8 13y agoUsers like to watch Hollywood content in their browsers. That has nothing to do with Google.
- ep103 13y agoThere are so many people here claiming this is the wrong choice, and yet I wonder what percentage of the commenters here are using chrome? By most sources I've seen, Chrome has 2x the marketshare, and actively pushed FOR EME. Perhaps if FF had Chrome's current marketshare, they would have been in a position to say no, but its the users who made that impossible. Mozilla should be commended for fighting as far as they did. And if you don't like this decision, make sure you switch off chrome before commenting.
- jgon 13y agoThank you. Watching people on this site verbally fellate Chrome and Safari on the basis of incredibly trivial things like look and feel and "minimal UI", while ignoring the incredibly important things like the company building the products and it's positions is frustrating, even more so now that they are all crawling out of the woodwork crying alligator tears. The tech community brought this upon itself when it switched over to browsers provided by two enormous corporations fully beholden to their shareholders, instead of sticking with a browser developed by goddamn public benefit corporation. The tech community brought this on itself when it couldn't be bothered to test sites in anything other than Chrome and maybe Safari on their iphone. The tech community brought this on itself when it started making websites webkit only, without a thought for what vendor prefixing would do to web compatibility. The tech community brought this on itself when it decided that per-process tabs were more important than preventing the future of the web from being controlled by 3 enormous corporations. So I say that we stop complaining and start getting used to it. This is what we all wanted, and now we can reap what we have sown, while the gentle glow of the chrome url box lights up our screen.
- joaren 13y agoOh really? Mozilla brought this on itself when they took the epic lead they had with Firebug and utterly squandered it by thinking real dev tools were not something a browser should include out of the box, in favour of an utterly useless "3D" DOM view that is a made up diagram conveying no useful information about compositing or layering. Mozilla brought this on itself when they treated memory leaks and extension crashes as performance issues to be papered over rather than fundamental flaws in an architecture unprepared for how people wanted to use it. Mozilla brought this on itself when they treated OS X like the idiot stepchild instead of delivering the native experience users clearly loved in Chrome and Safari, thus alienating the Mac-dominated cutting edge of web tech. Mozilla brought this on itself when they provided incomplete implementations of CSS transforms, Web Audio and WebGL (an idea they originated!), and a bunch of other specs people actually wanted. Parts of WebGL are broken in the current stable release of Firefox, and yet Mozilla wants to go around claiming the high ground with Unreal and asm.js? If they'd spend less money on having their 'evangelists' show off trivial toys around the world, and more on actually solving real daily problems (like the Chrome developer tools team did), we wouldn't be in this mess, and they wouldn't think moves of desperation like asm.js are a good idea.
- skylan_q 13y agoFirst gender identity/equality is more important than free speech, and now DRM is more important than freedom from submitting to vendor demands. What's the point of Mozilla?
- pessimizer 13y agoGender equality is more important than free speech.
- Grue3 13y agoGender equality would not be even possible without free speech, so no, it isn't.
- discardorama 13y agoMozilla gets most of their money from Google. When Google says "jump", Baker says "how high?". They've become so addicted to the funds from Google, that they can't live without it.
- jasonlingx 13y agoFork it.
- aestetix 13y agoI am curious whether this would have happened if Eich were still the CEO.
- thrillgore 13y agoDespite his failings at leadership I will admit, Eich was pretty damn adamant against EME. If he was still at Mozilla he could have had led a lot of pushback at the W3C.
- rectangletangle 13y agoI doubt it. The media outlets who led the smear campaign against Eich, benefit financially from stronger DRM. If you follow the money and influence there are many suspicious coincidences.
- mccr8 13y agoHe commented on this DRM thing on Twitter: "I supported this least-worst EME plan when I was at Mozilla. I'm still working on no-DRM solution w/ @OTOY + some content "bigs"." https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/466666103972696064 https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/466666103972696064
- Daiz 13y agoOh, so the web has given up and is now genuflecting at the altar of video DRM. Next up: picture DRM, because since we're protecting videos we should naturally protect still pictures too. You know what? We also have all this professional writing on the web, and anyone can just copy & paste that! That clearly shouldn't fly in our brand new DRM-protected world - authors should be able to control exactly who can view and read their texts, and copying is strictly forbidden. Screenshots should be blocked too. Browser devtools will naturally have to be disabled on the World Wide Web, as they are capable of hurting our benevolent protector, the almighty DRM. Eventually, we'll arrive at The Right To Read[1]. Or we could just not give the devil our little finger. [1] http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html Also, a reminder about the nature of this beast that everyone should be aware of: HTML DRM will not give you plugin-free or standardized playback. It will simply replace Flash/Silverlight with multiple custom and proprietary DRM black boxes that will likely have even worse cross-platform compatibility than the existing solutions. In other words, giving in to HTML DRM will only make the situation worse than it currently is. Especially since it paves the way to an even more closed web.
- shkkmo 13y ago>>Giving in to HTML DRM will only make the situation worse than it currently is Except if you use the new Firefox you may have better privacy and security than you currently do with flash and silverlight. I haven't seen anybody on here argue for DRM, so I don't see the point in this FUD. Instead, lets find more ways for Firefox to fight DRM and reduce it's negative impact. I particularly support one of Doctorow's suggestions: >Mozilla has demonstrated that it has some negotiating leverage with Adobe – after all, it was able to fend off the demand for details of users’ systems to be leaked to video companies. >It should demand that Adobe give it a covenant not to sue or threaten developers who report vulnerabilities in the Adobe decoder. Adobe does not need to give up the right to sue people who release cracks for their DRM or competing products in order to do this. >In an era in which vulnerabilities are leveraged to expose users to identity theft, sexual exploitation and government surveillance, no one should fear legal reprisal for warning people about flaws in the software they use. Additionally, we need to focus on ways to educate users about the risks of DRM and disincentive web sites from using DRM wherever possible.
- mkhalil 13y agoThey should keep their browser open. Most people that use Mozilla know why they're using it. They would also understand how to install an official Firefox plugin to get crappy EME websites to work.
- CHY872 13y agoI think you're overestimating 'Most' people. If Firefox has a ~20% market share, that's saying that there are hundreds of millions of Firefox users who use it for the freedom (as opposed to the competitive performance and the fact that it's not IE) - and that simply cannot be correct.
- Spooky23 13y agoThe EFF stance is a little shrill. Remember how FairPlay and Zune were going to create proprietary music forever? Didn't quite work out that way. End of the day, content is a commodity, and like any other commodity, prices are falling as the supply expands. Unless it's a Pixar movie, most films in DVD/Blueray are in the $10 range within weeks. Digital rights for new releases are as little as $3 when you buy with physicial media. Access to Netflix's catalog costs less than basic cable. So I don't care about this, I do care about the trolls under the bridge (ISPs) who want to extract a toll for transit.
- pessimizer 13y ago>FairPlay and Zune That's because they didn't sell. What if they had been every player in the market?
- Spooky23 13y agoiTunes has been the #1 music store since 2008. Back in those days, iPod utterly owned the mp3 market. I believe DRM went away after that happened.
- spoiler 13y agoMaybe I'm missing something, but what's so bad about EME? I think it's a great idea that copyrighted material will be protected. I understand that it becomes "closed web" in a way, but it's not a big deal for me. Frankly, I can think of a few places where it could be useful, even.
- dalek2point3 13y agoCan someone explain how DRM on HTML5 would work?
- tn13 13y agoThe article is written as if Mozilla is making a mistake. I think Mozilla's stand is perfectly reasonable and pragmatic. Mozilla must adhere to all the web standards. I think the war for an open web was lost when EME became W3C standard. We should have fought it at that time.
- dannyobrien 13y agoEME isn't a W3C standard.
- dangayle 13y agoI'm just sad that DRM is in the HTML5 spec at all. That's the real loss.
- pdeuchler 13y agoSeriously, who is building this DRM software/hardware? If you are a software developer you have no excuse but ignorance, and as someone who makes a living on a computer (where the Internet resides) that excuse is waning extremely thin. I harbor a hairs breadth more grace for the hardware engineers designing locked down chips, but that's no more than a rhetorical nicety due to the fact that I'm am not very familiar with the intricacies of their work. I honestly don't get it, you could make just as much, if not more, money doing something that's not 100% ethically wrong... especially in this job market! It's easy to work remotely, so you can't claim geographic entrapment. I'm sure if those who were especially financially encumbered could make a kickstarter page people would literally pay them to quit their job! As much as this stings, it stings even more that it's "our own" selling us out, that it's the people who should know better that are killing everything so many of us have worked so hard for.
- BrandonM 13y ago> It's easy to work remotely Is it? I get a pretty steady stream of offers from recruiters and LinkedIn, and I can't recall a single one that offered remote work from day 1. Care to share all of these opportunities you know about?
- hetman 13y agoIt's must be easy to tell others what they must sacrifice. Or did you take this stance your self and quit your job on moral grounds?
- kosievdmerwe 13y agoIt's amazing how offended people get at other people for not martyring themselves. Especially in cases like the NSA scandal where they are demanding that people literally risk jail time for the ideals of the demander.
- quasque 13y agoI don't think it's necessarily unethical to write such DRM software, and I'd be interested in hearing your argument as to why this is the case. It's not as if the software causes harm; indeed it probably reduces the potential of economic harm to the content providers. Assuming it does exactly what it claims to do, i.e. decoding of video and audio content dependent on a provided decryption key - then what is the ethical problem with programming an algorithm for that?
- rectangletangle 13y agoReading between the lines here, I have a strong suspicion this and the smear campaign directed against Eich are related events. Only a few short months ago Mozilla was staunchly opposed to this. Then Eich gets forcefully removed, and Mozilla's stance turns a 180. In retrospect the "outrage" against Eich felt very artificial. It could have been a deliberate attempt at character assassination in order to further someone's goals of destroying our internet freedoms. The motive of course being heavy financial incentives. This likely had nothing to do with LGBT* rights (which I'm a proponent of, FYI). Instead it was all about someone lining their greedy pockets, at the personal expense of Eich and us to a much lesser extent. Keep in mind the same people who have a vested interest in strengthening DRM, are the same people who own the media outlets which propagated this story.
- camus2 13y agoFascinating how people accept handcuffs so easily.Because it' better than flash...not,you'll still need a plugin for the DRM and you're going to have to download a few different plugins because of course different vendors will have different DRM schemes,so back to 1999,realplayer,windows media plugin,ect...
- CHY872 13y agoSo I'm guessing that this will backfire. Mozilla say that Adobe will create the software, which will presumably be bundled with the browser. This means that if Adobe's DRM gets cracked, suddenly every site using that DRM is vulnerable. At the moment, one just updates the client to obfuscate a bit better, which is then downloaded on next launch of the software. If it's all client side, surely then the DRM will have to be updated every few days - which would be a nightmare for sysadmins etc.
- bzbarsky 13y ago> which will presumably be bundled with the browser. It won't be bundled with the browser. It'll be a separate download users need to explicitly opt into. In the sysadmin case, of course, the sysadmin could choose to preinstall it...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- knodi 13y agoCorporate attacks on all fronts on users. Revolt we must.
- hughw 13y agoDRM just won't be that useful in a web browser. I can share a link with you, but it won't work for you. If Mozilla omitted this feature, users would just fire up the Netflix app. I honestly doubt it would cause users to switch away.
- bsder 13y agoExcellent. When the plugin fails (and it will fail ... anything which is default deny will have lots of mysterious fails), more and more people who paid for the content will switch to pirated versions. Personally, I can't wait. Piracy was roughly at a balance point recently with all the mobile consumption. Now, the lazy-ass social media generation is going to discover the need for it. Welcome to Popcorn Time.
- prewett 13y agoI dislike DRM as much as the next person, but what do you suggest as an alternative way that content creators can protect their work? Movies cost tens of millions of dollars to make; I expect that you would not spend $10 million of your money to make something that everyone could just freely download. Would you invest a year writing a great novel if everyone could read it for free without paying you? Some people will, of course, say "yes" but I think most of us would not, and we would end up with less art. I think the tech community needs to come up with a better alternative, rather than just complaining.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- swetland 13y agoI don't get the hand-wringing over this. Don't install the plugin and only view non-DRM-encumbered video content. Seems simple enough. Just like you don't install flash because you don't want to support flash-based DRM, right?
- dredmorbius 13y agoDebian GNU/Linux ships with Iceweasel, not Firefox. Iceweasel is based on Firefox, but differs in some particulars (with which I'm unfamiliar). The question: will Iceweasel implement the DRM which Mozilla is implementing into Firefox?
- enterx 13y ago/me thinks its about time for these digital rights fucks to taxed for exploiting our common good
- enterx 13y ago...to be. taxed. :o