6 ms·
China mulls high-speed train to US
- Zigurd 13y agoThere was an almost as blue-sky story about a Chinese high speed rail link all the way to London. I wonder how worried the Russians would be about Chinese migrating to Russia. The population of all of Siberia is about 40 million.
- paul_f 13y agoHaha. Now we know what the Chinese equivalent to The Onion is.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoChinadaily? They are quite serious, but not very professional. It would take only "2 days" to get to the US via this train, and the Russians would have to cooperate of course. Heck, we don't even have a train from Alaska to Seattle yet. It might make sense for freight, in which case "high speed" is not really necessary (well, it does help increase bandwidth). But for people? It will still be cheaper and fast to fly...maybe even more efficient considering that planes can fly in straight lines, mostly.
- tomrod 13y agoPlanes don't fly in straight lines, especially in that corridor.[0] Example flight path[1] [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great-circle_distance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great-circle_distance [1] https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4030/4622898186_e71984d836.jpg https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4030/4622898186_e71984d836.jp...
- rosser 13y agoThe whole point of Great-circle routes is that they are (effectively) straight lines. They just appear not to be on 2d projections of an oblate sphereoid — you know, a "map" of a "planet". From Wikipedia, "The minor arc of a great circle between two points is the shortest surface-path between them. In this sense the minor arc is analogous to “straight lines” in spherical geometry." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Circle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Circle
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoThey do fly straight lines given a spherical coordinate system. All of my flights between Beijing and Seattle are via the arctic, but I doubt a train could achieve since it would have to cross the Bering straight between Asia and NA, and the topology is still extremely mountainous, unless it is completely underground or they drill through a lot of mountains, they will have to divert. Heck, the only way to drive from Seattle to Fairbanks or Anchorage is by diverting east in the Yukon to avoid the mountains on the panhandle (cities like Juneau and Ketchikan are not even connected by land for that reason).
- tempestn 13y agoAs mentioned by other comments, these are straight lines, which is why they take this route. What's interesting though is that it's also relatively close to the proposed train route, so the "straight line" advantage of the plane wouldn't be terribly significant.
- dredmorbius 13y agoOcean freight is almost certainly more affordable, and does have fuel flexibility aircraft don't have: both wind and solid biofuels (particularly pelletized biofuel) are possible. Oil is preferred to coal for ships for several reasons, among them that oil can be pumped, while coal has to be shoveled or otherwise managed -- and rebalancing a ship's coal bunkers underway was a significant operational concern. Recoaling is another -- it takes longer and is less convenient than loading up with even no. 6 fuel oil (which must be heated to flow). And there's ash removal to be concerned with, as well as the indirect power generation of steam as opposed to diesel engines (which at ship scale are truly impressive). Pelletized fuels address at least some of those concerns. They're not a direct substitute in existing powerplants though, and I've got my grave misgivings as to just how much energy can be derived from biofuels in any regard, though marine transport is very efficient overall in energy per ton-mile of cargo moved.
- tokenadult 13y agoThe China Daily is an official newspaper, and this article surprises me coming from such a source. That it is being submitted here and is being upvoted here illustrates how much gee-whiz value China adds to any news story, about ever so speculative a project. So one guy in his armchair has proposed an expensive, long-term project that may never happen--not least for political reasons ("cross Siberia to Bering Strait"). I guess the value of the article kindly submitted here is as a reminder that many news stories about China seem credible to readers who have never been to China, even if they are incredible to people who have been there. The Chinese saying "百聞不如一見" (hearing of something a hundred times isn't worth seeing it once) may apply here. For a long time, there were submissions here to HN about a guy in China who was going to build a pre-fab high-rise hotel building in just one day. That still hasn't happened. Predictions about the future are fun to think about--that's why I used to read science fiction stories--but we can best size up how a country is doing[1] by looking at current news and sustainable trends. (In the case of China, it is important to look at reporting from publications other than official publications of the one-party-dictatorship government of the country as a reality check.) Good luck with that high-speed train from China to America. I wonder if I will be able to ride that or ride a space elevator[2] first. [1] http://www.todayonline.com/business/chinas-property-bubble-has-burst-economists http://www.todayonline.com/business/chinas-property-bubble-h... http://blogs.wsj.com/chinarealtime/2014/05/05/chinas-property-bubble-has-officially-popped-report-says/ http://blogs.wsj.com/chinarealtime/2014/05/05/chinas-propert... [2] https://what-if.xkcd.com/7/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/7/
- anigbrowl 13y agoThere was quite an audience here for Elon Musk's pneumatic tube transit idea as well, which was at least as off-the-wall. I don't find this particularly credible either as it doesn't really solve any major problem, but there's no arguing with the fact that China has a taste for such large-scale undertakings.
- mjklin 13y agoEveryone laughed when Beijing proposed the Qinghai-Tibet railway too. It would have to be built 1,200 miles over seasonal permafrost and the workers would have to wear special suits and breathing apparatus. It has been running since 2006. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qinghai–Tibet_Railway http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qinghai–Tibet_Railway
- varelse 13y agoAll kidding aside, they'd probably have this done before California gets High Speed Rail between LA and SF...
- dredmorbius 13y agoThis isn't practicable now, and quite possibly will never be, but it's an interesting exercise to sketch this out. Aviation will almost certainly become too expensive to be viable in the not terribly distant future. The US saw peak avaiation fuel in 1999, from the FAA's own 2000 projections and actual usage[1]. Steve Kopits has noted that peak departures (US) occured in 2005[2]. Total passengers miles remain up, but that's due to more efficient aircraft with higher load factors (a greater percentage of seats filled). Even if synthetic fuels (possible) or biofuels (exceptionally unlikely) are possible for aviation, fuel costs (already a major component of airfare) will almost certainly rise. The US Naval Research Lab thinks it might hit $3-6/gallon for production costs. I suspect that's optimistic and note that crude oil represents 72% of the final cost of refined gasoline, so this could translate to $4.17 - $8.33/gallon retail (present JetA price is $5.74 in the US NorthEast: http://100ll.com/ http://100ll.com/). Canola biodiesel has a production cost of around $1000/bbl, or (with estimated refining costs) about $33/gallon. A 3000 mile flight in a Boeing 777 at full capacity gets about 60 passenger miles/gallon, which equals 50 gallons of fuel per passenger. That's $287 presently, $415 at $8.33/gal, or $1650 at $33/gal, just for comparison, in fuel costs alone. So, yes, exploring ground transit alternatives might make sense. ________________________________ 1. http://www.faa.gov/data_research/aviation/aerospace_forecasts/2001-2012/media/Table%2022.pdf http://www.faa.gov/data_research/aviation/aerospace_forecast... 2. http://energypolicy.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/energy/Kopits%20-%20Oil%20and%20Economic%20Growth%20%28SIPA%2C%202014%29%20-%20Presentation%20Version%5B1%5D.pdf http://energypolicy.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/energy/... p. 37., citing US DoT.
- seanmcdirmid 13y ago> Aviation will almost certainly become too expensive to be viable in the not terribly distant future. You are assuming jet fuel as it is today will be the only way to fly planes tomorrow? What about improved batteries or even fuel cells? Even those trains will need power, and creating a lined system for that distance without many local power plants to drive it would be a logistical nightmare.
- TylerE 13y agoEnergy density of li-ion batteries is less than 1/50th that of jet fuel, and modern high-bypass turbofans are far more efficient at turning that energy into forward power than a gasoline engine is. A Boeing 777-300ER carries 304,000lbs of fuel fully loaded. This contains just under 6 terajoules of energy. The battery pack of a Tesla Model S is about 300 megajoules. So you,d need 19,700 Tesla battery packs to power your 777-equivilant jetliner. Problem is they weight over 15 millions pounds. So no, there is no magic bullet in aviation.
- aresant 13y agoThe Chinese govt has been building ghost cities by the tens of billions to pad GDP over the past decade. This train seems like a similarly colossal waste of money that could serve the same GDP purpose while building something of massive novelty value. I vote yes.
- anigbrowl 13y agoYou mean they've been spending tends of billions on ghost cities. As written, it suggests that they've built >20 billion ghost cities, although it fun to imagine that they have access to some extra spatial dimension we don't know about :-)
- ejain 13y agoThe China Daily? Is that the same paper that quoted the Onion when they ran an article about Kim Jong Eun being the "Sexiest Man Alive"?
- briandh 13y agoThat was The People's Daily.
- wluu 13y agoThey're also building a high speed rail network from China to Singapore - http://shanghaiist.com/2014/01/15/china_to_build_high-speed_rail_to_s.php http://shanghaiist.com/2014/01/15/china_to_build_high-speed_... And also: http://www.scmp.com/magazines/post-magazine/article/1318178/crossing-line http://www.scmp.com/magazines/post-magazine/article/1318178/...
- Involute 13y agoLast line: "The details of this project are yet to be finalized." Indeed.