17 ms·
The Internet Is Being Protected By Two Guys Named Steve
- dang 13y agoWe changed the title to be less linkbaity. If anyone can suggest a better one, please do.
- conroy 13y agodang, thanks for explanations around title changes. It makes the whole process less mysterious.
- jackalope 13y agoIMHO, the original title reflects the tone and content of the article. I didn't feel cheated when I clicked on it, so I don't really consider it linkbait.
- smacktoward 13y agoI actually liked the original title better, as it communicated the main point of the article -- that a ton of critical infrastructure is riding on the shoulders of a very small number of people -- better. Changing it to "Steve Marquess and Stephen Henson of OpenSSL" doesn't really get that point across, since it doesn't make clear that Marquess and Henson essentially are OpenSSL. EDIT: It is definitely refreshing to see editorial decisions like this being explained clearly, though, and the community being asked to provide feedback. So my thanks to dang for that, even if we disagree about the title :-D
- dang 13y agoOk, I changed it back. Cheers.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoDamn. Never thought I'd see a BuzzFeed article here. About as low as the web gets. This is surprisingly good from them, however.
- alternize 13y agothis was quite unexpected, indeed. the article is well written and has a good narrative.
- danso 13y agoBuzzfeed, AFAIK, was blacklisted from HN for awhile, but it looks like the new mod regime has taken off the blanket ban...and that's a good thing. The majority of Buzzfeed is still linkbait but they do have sections written by real reporters, with some of the best writing and research I've seen from online outlets. My personal favorite was this in-depth exoneration of MSG: http://www.buzzfeed.com/johnmahoney/the-notorious-msgs-unlikely-formula-for-success http://www.buzzfeed.com/johnmahoney/the-notorious-msgs-unlik... disclosure: one of my former colleagues is a Buzzfeed editor (http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/columnist/rieder/2014/02/03/buzzfeeds-investigative-unit-taking-shape/5084213/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/columnist/rieder/2014/02...), and he's been in charge of hiring an investigations team. He's a Pulitzer winner himself and just hired one of this year's Pulitzer winners, as well as a Pulitzer finalist (HN user jsvine)...the late Michael Hastings was doing investigative reporting for Buzzfeed before his untimely death. So the investment they're putting into non-listicle-journalism is non-trivial.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dublinben 13y agoIt's really too bad that they're mixing the in-depth coverage and the crap on the same domain. It indelibly taints their better articles with the stink of their low-quality drivel. On the whole, the site is a worthless spam farm that steals content from reddit and other sources. The existence of a handful of good stories isn't enough to overcome that reputation.
- 13y ago
- pronoiac 13y ago> In fact, a quirk of the U.S. legal system meant that cryptography was, until the late 1990s, placed on the U.S. Munitions List, alongside semi-automatic firearms and tanks. Should this be in the past tense? I thought crypto exports from the US were still restricted.
- alternize 13y agoit's still restricted, but not on the munitions list anymore: Legal challenges by Peter Junger and other civil libertarians and privacy advocates, the widespread availability of encryption software outside the U.S., and the perception by many companies that adverse publicity about weak encryption was limiting their sales and the growth of e-commerce, led to a series of relaxations in US export controls, culminating in 1996 in President Bill Clinton signing the Executive order 13026 transferring the commercial encryption from the Munition List to the Commerce Control List. Furthermore, the order stated that, "the software shall not be considered or treated as 'technology'" in the sense of Export Administration Regulations. This order permitted the United States Department of Commerce to implement rules that greatly simplified the export of commercial and open source software containing cryptography, which they did in 2000. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_the_United_States#PC_era http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_the...
- pronoiac 13y agoIt looks like most of the OpenSSL team[1] is outside the US, except Marquess, the businessman. It looks like OpenBSD is developed and released from Canada.[2] I tried reading the Wikipedia article you linked, and something from the Bureau of Industry and Security[3], and my eyes glazed over. I think the upshot is developing an open source crypto library in the US just won't work. [1] https://www.openssl.org/about/ https://www.openssl.org/about/ [2] http://www.openbsd.org/goals.html http://www.openbsd.org/goals.html [3] http://www.bis.doc.gov/index.php/policy-guidance/encryption/encryption-faqs http://www.bis.doc.gov/index.php/policy-guidance/encryption/...
- wbl 13y ago
- pmorici 13y ago"Marquess, a consultant for the Department of Defense" Maybe I haven't been following this close enough but has anyone questioned whether or not it is perhaps a conflict of interest to be a consultant for the "Department of Defense" while also being a principal contributor to a project like OpenSSL?
- exelius 13y agoI think it's about the only way to do so. Navigating a complex bureaucracy like the DoD requires an insider's knowledge. Not everyone who works for complex bureaucracies is evil; many are trying to help them be better (or at least direct its energies at things that are productive to the public). The bigger problem that seemed to surface through this article is the sense of the "ubercoder" who singlehandedly runs a major project because they can't work with anyone else. I don't know if it was sensationalized by the author of the article, but it does strike me as a major problem in a lot of open source software. IMO, something like OpenSSL is important enough that it should be run by a non-profit.
- ballard 13y agoDoes "ultimatum" and "raft of complicated last-minute changes" not raise anyone else's tinfoil paranoia alarms? Those commits should get significant scrutiny, because it sounds like US/CA govt were given an indirect opportunity to push whatever changes it wanted AND rushed code isn't necessarily the best either. (Also I'm glad FIPS mode is dead in LibreSSL.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jsmeaton 13y agoI read that part as the approval process required X changes that the OpenSSL team had to implement themselves. I don't believe the approving party was asking the OpenSSL team to commit code they were supplying.
- tragic 13y agoHmmm... Never ascribe to conspiracy what can be adequately explained by bureaucracy. The feds love them some standards.
- SeanDav 13y agoOnce upon a time I used to believe this. Post Snowden, I tend to believe the reverse.
- trevelyan 13y ago"a quirk of the U.S. legal system meant that cryptography was, until the late 1990s, placed on the U.S. Munitions List, alongside semi-automatic firearms and tanks." This was no quirk. The US government made deliberate efforts to limit the availability of encryption software, even adding it to international export control lists where it previously did not exist: http://cryptome.org/jya/wass-suks.htm http://cryptome.org/jya/wass-suks.htm
- colechristensen 13y agoI may be outspoken on this, but I think that it was an appropriate move to keep cryptography (or some kinds of cryptography) on such munitions lists.
- shard972 13y agoCan you explain why you think that?
- derefr 13y agoThe US makes a lot of money from the government allowing defense contractors to sell the stuff they design for it to its allies as well. The munitions-export provisions exist because, although we aren't too worried about our allies reselling the tents or latrines we send them to our enemies, we really don't like the idea of having the guns we've manufactured pointed back at us. A secure softphone implementing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSA_Suite_A_Cryptography http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSA_Suite_A_Cryptography is a lot more like a gun than it is like a tent or a latrine, in terms of what an enemy nation that gets their hands on it will do with it.
- shard972 13y agoSo, would that also cover citizens? As in, if I made my own encryption method and then supplied that to some friends overseas, would that be violating munitions exporting if crypto was still covered?
- zhte415 13y agoI find it a great shame that literally a handful of independent individuals take on responsibility compensated at a minuscule fraction those that directly benefit from it: ISPs, Certificate Providers (particularly certificate providers, absolving themselves of accountability for potential loss) and Hosting Providers.
- QuantumChaos 13y agoThat's a consequence of being open source. All the main open source licenses mean that anyone would be able to use OpenSSL without paying a cent to the creators. Advocates of open source often claim that creators of open source software can make money by selling services to users, like consulting services. As this article (and others) describe, this approach also didn't work that well for the OpenSSL team.
- pyre 13y agoAnother possibility is that CommercialSSL becomes a product that takes a page from the Oracle playbook and panders to selling to these large enterprises, with little care for the needs of smaller businesses.
- zhte415 13y agoOpen source > indeed, I agree. My perspective is principally the harmony or conflict of the open source -ness of OpenSSL, and the Tragedy of the Commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons of all using a resource while few feeling the need to compensate. It is interesting that open source has often found solutions around this 'tragedy' - ownership (contributing or forking) vs access (using) - but I feel a shame that those that work hard towards creating a public good (OpenSSL) only receive recognition when things go wrong, while those that have criticised (the possibly competing consultancies, perhaps) have themselves not forked or recreated a better solution, as it seems having the ability, confidence or willingness to carry the risk to credibility (for a better solution), or knowingly taken advantage of an exploit, is more profitable than giving back. tl;dr I admire these Steves and other contributors very much, and wish they get what they deserve. I guess the world of Star Trek is still somewhat way off.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- NamTaf 13y agoYou would've thought that after getting bitten by it, the Zucks, Brins, etc. of the would would've been happy to kick in a few million a piece to ensure part of the critical underpinning of their services is a bit more bulletproof. Without having any idea of the numbers otherwise, could this not be a reasonably cost-effective approach to security? Making sure the OSS projects you draw on are properly funded so they can shoulder some of the security responsibility must be easier than employing your own army of security savants to do the same thing internally? I'd love to hear more info on whether this is or isn't a good approach.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoI suspect that most corporates use FOSS not because of any philosophical support for it but simply because it's cheap and available. If it's going to start costing them money then it would raise the question why not spend that money internally where they have complete control of the direction of the project and where only they (rather than their competitors) will get the benefit from it. That's not to say that what you say isn't workable, just that it's not aligned with much default corporate thinking which makes it somewhat less likely.
- mattmanser 13y agoThat happened already, like 4 days ago: http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/04/tech-giants-chastened-by-heartbleed-finally-agree-to-fund-openssl/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/04/tech-g...
- ilaksh 13y agoRight but the amount 3.9 million to support not only OpenSSL but multiple other projects is so miniscule relatively speaking it is astounding. This "civilization"s priorities are so ludicrous. 3.9 million is probably a tiny fraction of the amount Google earned through ads selling blowjob videos last year.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- celebril 13y agoNo mention of Steve Jobs? Disappointed. Everybody knows that Apple's OS X is the most advanced and secure OS. If Steve Jobs isn't one of the people who are responsible for protecting the Internet I don't know who else is.
- socrates1998 13y agoHonestly, I don't get why super talented people work for free. I haven't worked on any open source projects, so maybe that's why I don't get it, but it just seems that developers often devalue themselves too much. You see it all the time. Business "idea" types come in and supply the "idea", while developers do all the work and don't get paid enough. I just wish as an industry, developers would stand up for themselves more. I see good, smart and talented people getting walked over too much.
- oxalo 13y agoI think being genuinely talented at something usually comes with an inability to sell oneself. The super talented types enjoy solving problems and learning complex things much more than they care about making money, and probably doubt their own ability.
- cmyr 13y agoThere are a lot of really interesting problems and projects in the world that nobody is interested in paying for. If you want to do these interesting things, you have to do it outside of the marketplace. Alternatively, there is a trade-off in selling your labour in the marketplace: you are no longer in a position to dictate the terms of your labour, and you potentially lose control over the product of your labour.
- hackuser 13y ago> Honestly, I don't get why super talented people work for free. In some cases it's a better way of accomplishing what you want than doing it for money. If you want to give people more security, for example, you'll probably get a wider audience and more impact with FOSS software. Should Tim Berners-Lee have charged for his new idea? You might not be reading this in a web browser if he did.
- hackuser 13y agoHave you ever tried inventorying the free software you use and paying a fair price for it? I looked into it for a small IT business. For one thing, the list was very long, longer than I expected; just consider browser extensions. For another, inventorying the free software and especially making all those small payments is very time-consuming. Finally, the costs add up. Given the money and especially time involved in paying, I wouldn't be using a lot of these programs (again, think of browser extensions). I know micro-transactions aren't a new idea, but our payment system is a debilitating bottleneck; transactions are far too slow for the speed at which I can obtain new products. What happened to micro-transactions?