8 ms·
What Movies Get Wrong About Time Travel
- riffic 17y ago1) movies are works of fiction.
- Timothee 17y agoI would put a spoiler alert on this.
- cgs 17y agoFor a real mindfuck, check out Primer: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primer_%28film%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primer_%28film%29
- mattyb 17y agoThis is the only DVD I've bought in a store in the last 5 years. It's really an amazing film.
- TrevorJ 17y agoI agree! I Loved that film. Especially given the fact that it was made for so little. Huge fan. If you haven't seen it and are willing to put the intellectual effort in, buy it and watch it.
- ivankirigin 17y agoI highly recommend you stop recommending Primer when time travel is brought up. The movie is better viewed not knowing anything about it. It could be a character drama before the weird shit starts going on. By the way, this is an awesome timeline http://neuwanstein.fw.hu/primer_timeline.html http://neuwanstein.fw.hu/primer_timeline.html
- clistctrl 17y agoawesome, on another note i have a 30" computer monitor and i still had to scroll left
- eurokc98 17y ago37" and still needed to scroll. Who's next?
- ivankirigin 17y agopixels matter, bro. 30" mac display is 2560x1600
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- oneplusone 17y agoI agree. I went into the movie knowing nothing and it was the biggest mindfuck ever.
- dasil003 17y agoToo bad any synopsis you read pretty much blows the surprise.
- dkersten 17y agoTruely confusing :-D but excellent movie!! :-P Very cleverly done.
- dustmop 17y agoI'm one of those few people who completely hated Primer. I found it to be masquerading poor narrative as intellectual mystery. It's possible to present an intricate, complex logic puzzle as story without being totally incoherent, but Primer doesn't even bother. For a movie that matches Primer in everything it does right, but none of what it does wrong, check out Timecrimes (Los Cronocrimenes). It is far superior.
- shrikant 17y agoFully agreed! Well, I didn't hate Primer, but genuinely thought Timecrimes was way superior. Plus the latter scared the shite outta me :-)
- 321abc 17y agoPrimer is an excellent film, especially when you consider that it was made for a total of only $7,000. That's not a typo: only seven thousand dollars! Hollywood could really learn a lot from this movie.
- mattmichielsen 17y agoI'm really surprised that guy hasn't seen Primer.
- AndrewDucker 17y agoOh for goodness sake. Time Travel _does not exist_. Therefore you can't get anything wrong about it, except including it in the first place. If you're allowing them to have time travel then you can only quibble about internal inconsistencies, not inconsistencies with the real world.
- sho 17y agoYou sound awfully sure of yourself.
- ivankirigin 17y agoI think his point is that this is like having a debate about how hyperspace works in Star Wars, or how phasers work in Star Trek. The tech is a plot device best assumed to be far outside the reach of today's science. Part of that assumption is that the current version of physics we understand is incomplete and at worst wrong. There is little use quoting a source proven wrong within the world of the story. Besides, I came from the future to write this comment, so the article is prima facie wrong.
- dkersten 17y agoIf you could travel back in time (not saying anything about forward), would we not have seen evidence of it by now? If you can travel back to a different "time stream" of sorts, then I'd argue its not really the same "time", but rather another one that happens to mirror the one you intended to travel back to (except that you're there when you shouldn't be and any changes you make).
- blankity_blank 17y agoRTFA
- burke 17y ago> 2) You can't visit any time before your time machine was built. I think this is a very strange assertion to make. I find it more likely that one of the following is true: 1) Time travel is not possible 2) We'll wipe ourselves our before we discover it
- pmichaud 17y agoDismissing Everitt branches by saying "there is no evidence," is totally off base. There's a mountain of math that practically demands that it's true.
- TrevorJ 17y agoIsn't there a fair bit of quantum physics theory that's based in this?
- Kadin 17y agoTheory != Evidence "Evidence" is by definition empirical; it's generally described as 'the result of empirical observation' or something substantially similar.
- rw 17y agoIt's more of a gradient, not a strict inequality; cf. argument from parsimony, inference vs. deduction.
- TrevorJ 17y agoCan somebody clear this up for me? Relativity states that time slows down as you approach the speed of light. Given that fact, lets say I hop in a spaceship and zip around the earth at near light speed for several years (Yes, I know there are problems with this in terms of increased mass, energy needed, etc.) Ok, so after several years I slow down and land. For me, it seems as if I've traveled into the future becasue the people on earth have experienced more time than I have. How is that not time travel, at least in a functional sense? I get that by strict definition it may not be, but the result would be the same. It seems like in this sense time travel is not only possible but proven.
- quizbiz 17y agoI fail to understand how time can slow. So way beyond me as an HS grad. If two people program 60 lines of code per hour, one does so in a spaceship traveling nearly the speed of light and one does so on earth... after 1 year/365 days/8760 hrs they make a report on their progress and they don't have the same results? If a watch ticks every second, the faster you go the slower it ticks? Why? How? Will people be buying a 2100 model Bugatti, hiring a driver, and working in the passenger seat to be more productive?
- roundsquare 17y agoSo you got person A on earth writing code and person B going around REALLY fast (very close to the speed of light lets say) writing the same code. When person A finishes (say a week later) and comes back, he'll find that person B finished "a long time ago." That is, person B finished, and then waited till person A came back (say for a year, depending on how fast person B was going). What happened? Time went at different speeds for each person. They each took a week from their own point of view! Which one is right? Both of them. Thats what relativity says. There is not one thing called "time" but that its "relative" (hence the name). So, if your going to choose to hire one of them... you'd hire person B (assuming your business is on Earth).
- run4yourlives 17y agoYou got it backwards... person A's week is much faster than the dude in the spaceship. (Hence person B "travels into the future")
- jp_sc 17y agoI prefer the theory of the parallel universes over the self-correction of the time. Most movies go that way too, since otherwise, the plot would be fatalistic (eg: '12 monkeys'). So they aren't really wrong.
- dkersten 17y agoI'm too tired to explain it here, but I like the explanation of time travel in the book Cowl: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowl_(novel) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowl_(novel)
- run4yourlives 17y agoSounds like a good book... thoughts on the story?
- dkersten 17y agoI personally really liked the story. It had some interesting ideas and the author seems (IMHO) quite good. I'd reccomend it.
- rimantas 17y agoThe book on time travel describing model which made most sense to me for years: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Technicolor_Time_Machine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Technicolor_Time_Machine This novel presents a clear use of the restricted action resolution of the Grandfather paradox. The actions of the characters can not have changed the past because the past is what their actions brought about.
- ars 17y agoIt makes sense on a social level, but not on a physical one. No matter what you do, you change things - you ate, you breathed.
- danteembermage 17y agoThis is the time travel I like to think about: Suppose we actually are simulated ancestors of an advanced civilization. Then time travel can take all sorts of interesting forms. For example, suppose our simulation is run sequentially. Then someone traveling back in time would travel back to an earlier state in the simulation that is already out of "RAM" and stored. This agent is "dead", the simulator does not bother to re-simulate the past just for them, they just disappear. Suppose instead the simulator is more flexible; then there's no reason they couldn't "fork" the timeline and let the gal do whatever she felt like and change the past going forward on their own. Since this would take vast computational resources, it would only be worth doing if you changed something big so maybe time travel wouldn't work unless your plans were grand enough. This also resolves the grandfather paradox; your grandpa is dead, you are never born in this timeline, but your simulated agent is just fine since it was copied from a different code base. You live out your life, reproduce, share technology, do whatever you want to do and life goes forward normally. In fact, it'd be likely they wouldn't bother simulating the whole world but just pull a Truman Show kind of thing and only propagate the changes, and copy from old data elsewhere. I'm sure there are even more interesting kinds of time-travel you could come up with given a simulated universe. It actually could be fun to write some sci fi short stories with this in the background, unexplained.
- derefr 17y ago> I'm sure there are even more interesting kinds of time-travel you could come up with given a simulated universe. It actually could be fun to write some sci fi short stories with this in the background, unexplained. I'm actually working with this exact idea, more or less, for a [roughly proposed] series of books, the first of which I'm procrastinating upon as I type this. :) Time travel, though, is a rather small part of what is possible with my metaverse model. I assume that the simulations are infinitely stacked, and each one has a 0:1 time-passage correspondence, so that for a "parent" simulation, the "child" simulation runs instantaneously, no matter the in-sim execution time, thus making Hypercomputation and such possible. All sorts of fun-with-philosophy falls out of that: The protagonists are Star Trek-style "everything is science" types, who discover that magic exists (for "magic," read "simulation runtime bugs.") They go on "Hard Science-based Fantasy" adventures using said magic for ten or twelve books, before figuring out that it was (very complicated) science all along. They then care for their own sim for a while, hacking it to fix some kinks (such as the inevitable existence, given probability, of a malevolent entity who has the root password.) Bored of that, they proceed to "break out" of their simulation, repeatedly, visiting "higher planes" that each have radically different physics and sometimes even logic, but that all share the property that Turing machines can be constructed within them. Eventually, they get to the "root" universe (really just a chroot jail) and meet God—that is to say, an AI who was left to run for an infinite time on an analogue computer and thus became omniscient merely by evaluating all possible states of all possible universes (that it could detect from within the chroot.) And that's only the first half of the sequence. 's called "Infinity's Tale", by the way. :)
- rev_null 17y agoYou can kill your grandfather. You just have to make sure to impregnate your grandmother so that your parent will still have your genes.
- Ygor 17y agoThe point of this article isn't so much to prove some theories incorrect or impossible. As time travel doesn't really exist we cannot say anything about it and say its a fact. Its about logic. If you are making a movie about time travel, than do it the way it makes sense. There are to many movies this days that employ some kind of time traveling mechanics which make no sense at all. Instead of using time travel as a good plot device, it is more and more used as a deus ex. Writers aren't able to think of better ways to resolve the plot. Don't you just hate it when that happens. Oh, no, the main character died, its all over, the ship is destroyed and the world has ended. But no, wait! What's that? Oh, its OK. We managed to go back in time and prevent the tragedy, and now we can all go on with our lives forgeting that we just found a way to travel through time. Now that i think about it, there is not a single movie including time traveling that hasn't got some kind of a plot hole. But that's ok, as you said, its a movie and it doesn't have to be all real. But it has to have some sense and meaning. Using time travel as a main plot device where it is not necessary or even sane, is a serious crime. The actual act of time traveling isn't that important, or the science behind it. There are many theories and no one can say one is the best. A far far more important aspect is how you handle the story and the world after the actual act. Its easy to think of a functional super cool futuristic time machine, but it is hard to think of what to do with it once it is actually there.
- doki_pen 17y agoIs it just me, or does the concept of "near speed of light" not make any sense? I was under the impression that light travels at a constant speed no matter how you are moving. And also, since there are no absolute coordinates, the concept of moving only make sense in relation to other things. Isn't it impossible to move "near speed of light"? Isn't light always going to move C faster then you?
- evgen 17y ago"Near the speed of light" carries with it the implicit disclaimer of "relative to a stationary observer" (that is why the theory has the word "relativity" in its name :) Light travels at C (through a vacuum) regardless of your frame of reference, so it used as the comparator for speed/velocity among different frames of reference.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThe speed of light in a vacuum being [constantly and universally] constant is an axiom (ie assumption, belief) of special relativity so it applies to inertial frames of reference. So, strictly it is not "regardless of your frame of reference". Accelerating frames, eg rotating or accelerating (eg under gravity where General relativity applies) require special treatments.
- twilightsentry 17y ago> Isn't light always going to move C faster then you? Yes. > Isn't it impossible to move "near speed of light"? From your perspective, you'll always be slower than light by C. Your speed relative to another observer, however, can be arbitrarily close to C. In classical mechanics, your speed relative to the other observer could add to C, resulting in "your" light, from her point of view, traveling faster than C. To avoid that discrepancy, special relativity postulates that her (or your, depending on the POV) movement through time is slowed until you both agree that light is moving at precisely C.
- pronoiac 17y agoHe's arguing for a non-forking timeline, which is nice, but I like soft science fiction with stories rather than people spending much of the story monkeying around with technology so that it's consistent with what we currently know about science. I'll quote something I wrote elsewhere: The two major time travel literary views are forking & non-forking timelines: * The game Achron has forking with merges via non-instantaneous time waves, sorta like Back to the Future. * Lost is not forking. I think. * The original Terminator's non-forking, but the sequels & series have forking timelines. * Forking: Primer, The Butterfly Effect. * Non-forking: 12 Monkeys, Slaughterhouse Five, Bill & Ted, All You Zombies.
- ewjordan 17y agoIMO the simplest resolution of things like the grandfather paradox are obtained by including quantum mechanics in the equation. Usually in quantum mechanics we find that waves are quantized because they must be periodic over very tiny reaches of space, and the quantization comes about because only certain frequencies of wave can meet themselves over these distances. But if we have time loops, it's pretty much the same thing, except the consistency conditions can be experienced on arbitrarily large scales - the quantum state where I kill my own grandfather is not a self-consistent loop, and won't exist as a solution to the wave equations. In essence, the "wave" that describes me killing my grandfather will interfere with itself over the time loop, and will eventually (hopefully? I don't have a proof...) converge on a wave that does reinforce itself, and ends up consistent. This may require a pretty serious divergence from what we'd usually assume about classical physics, even at the macroscopic scale. So quantization is the real reason we shouldn't worry about the grandfather paradox; any solution to the equations of QM will have to be self consistent over a closed timelike loop, even if the results are ridiculous as far as classical mechanics is concerned.
- humbledrone 17y agoI always thought the moniker "time travel" was not specific enough. I'm traveling through time right now. I can't help but travel through time. Maybe a more appropriate term would be "time navigator."