21 ms·
Textbooks Prices: Out of Control
- ibrad 13y agoI hope you succeed. When I was in school, I spent some semesters piggy backing over my classmates because I couldn't afford the $239 book. I did buy a 2 editions behind book for $30 only to find out that some of the home work were numbered differently or missing.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- christiangenco 13y agoI'd love to see a repository of problems from the back of textbooks. I think there's some law in education that says that you can copy <10% of a book and legally distribute it.
- ivan_ah 13y agoThat's an AWESOME idea. Does anyone have experience with the 10% copyright rule? Even more interestingly---students could peer review their solutions to the problems.
- christiangenco 13y agoHere's a link on the 10% rule I found: http://www.complexip.com/ten-percent-is-fair-use-for-educational-institutions-copyright-owners-disappointed/ http://www.complexip.com/ten-percent-is-fair-use-for-educati...
- jedanbik 13y agoThe prices may be out of control, but as a student, it was surely a delight to find that I could buy $8.00 chemistry books from the likes of Amazon and Abebooks and sell them to the Barnes and Noble on campus for a reliable $65.00 cash until they met their quotas.
- namenotrequired 13y agoCan someone upvote this comment for me? I accidentally downvoted. Sorry Jesse!
- jzelinskie 13y agoA buddy of mine was speaking with his professor during office hours and watched someone buy a stack of books from him for $500. That stack of books was given to the professor for free by a salesman in hopes that he integrate it with the curriculum and make sales for the publisher.
- beloch 13y agoI would have loved to have digital copies of all my textbooks on a tablet in university so I didn't have to haul 20 kilos of books around all the time. One has to wonder how many university students look at the prices being charged these days, download illegal pdf's online, and then go to the bar to drown their guilty consciences.
- LordIllidan 13y agoYou're assuming that we feel guilty about it!
- ryannevius 13y agoAs a recent graduate (for the second time), I'd estimate about 50% of students. Guilt? Funny...
- existencebox 13y agoLet me add another voice to the "yes that's what happens" pile with the statement that more than even just downloading the PDF as needed, the need for an expensive book is actually being included into the decision making process of "will I take this class." (which is certainly the logical way to approach this, but I think makes the important implication that it may in fact be motivating students away from certain otherwise valuable courses)
- omnibrain 13y agoHe forgets to mention the point that there are usually "international editions" of all textbooks that are sold for half the price or even less. And they are not only sold in developing countries but in virtually every market that is not north america. Coincidentally searching for them on Amazon.com even directly via the ISBN usually leads no results. I remember reading an article where publishers used copyright law against reimporters of such editions.
- sgloutnikov 13y agoThis was exactly what I used to do. The "international edition" is exactly the same book--1:1 content inside, maybe not printed on glossy pages with color, and a different cover + ISBN. A lot of these books are available at sites like abebooks.com, if you just search by the original ISBN. I was able to find current edition books that would sell new for $120 on Amazon, for $30 new on abebooks. The one (small) downside for me was the resell process, or even resell possibility. You can't sell them on Amazon. Most of the time I just kept the good books for myself, to maybe use in the future. At the end, a lot of the times it cost me less to go with the international edition and keep it, than buy the original edition and resell it.
- beedogs 13y agoThere's a Supreme Court case that just finished up, too, which affirmed that Americans have the right to import these books. So, import away!
- christiangenco 13y agoShameless plug: I built a textbook search engine in college that includes the international editions of books: http://textbooksplease.com http://textbooksplease.com
- jeza 13y agoIn Australia textbooks typically cost $100-150 a title so I'm guessing that is on par with America. I've also been able to source these international editions at a fraction of the price by purchasing online. However, tech books from the likes of O'Reilly can easily cost 2-3 times as much here, putting them in the same league as textbooks. I found it amusing when we had a representative from a publisher speak at the first lecture for a subject. He had a slide saying "buy locally" and was encouraging students to buy his ebook which was twice the price of the international edition I had already purchased but marginally cheaper than his print edition. The end result is that students are not buying textbooks anymore and those that do are importing them from overseas. The independent co-operative bookshop at my university went out of business last year as a result. The university opened their own bookshop with ridiculously high prices as well, but minimal staffing from what I could tell. I don't think they can sustain the high prices in the long term without the whole thing falling in a heap.
- bbosh 13y agoIs it necessary to buy books? At my university (in the UK), they have lots of copies of textbooks in the library. And if there's a book they do not have, you can ask them to buy it and they most probably will.
- suhailpatel 13y agoSame for my university in the UK (most of our prestigious universities pride themselves with the quality of their libraries). I think it's more a case that there are only a single/few copies of each required reading book in the library and on loan, others miss out.
- _delirium 13y agoYeah, this generally works for small courses but not large ones. The library can often come up with 10 copies of a book, but probably not 500 copies. It's how many grad students (who are usually in smaller courses or seminars) get their books, but undergraduates usually have to buy, borrow, or download their own copy, especially in the core classes that everyone is taking.
- pandler 13y agoThe part that vexed me the most as a student was the constant release of marginally different textbook editions. The one time I tried my luck with an older (and cheaper) edition was with a thermodynamics text that was only one edition out of date. The actual chapter text was almost identical, but the differences in exercise problems and corresponding look-up tables meant I ended up having to borrow other students' books on a regular basis.
- bsilvereagle 13y agoI'm amazed the steam tables had different values. The author had already paid a lot of money to use Company A's tables, I have no idea why they would then switch to Company B's tables.
- rikacomet 13y agoIn India, one of the reasons that most college textbooks cost $2-$5 on average, is that the colleges refer books that are reasonably priced (of course with content). Why would someone buy for example Product Design and Development 5th Edition which costs approx 190$ ? In West, it is a recommended book in most colleges. But in India, it is not the book our teacher/college refers to as the main content. By 'main content' I mean that even though on average 5-6 books are recommended reads but most teachers have read 1-2 books thoroughly, and others slightly for non-repetitive reasons. PS: I have read the above mentioned book in a library, its totally NOT worthy of that price.
- eitally 13y agoThe other reason is that a lot of the problem described here exists solely in the US market. Many publishers offer international editions, or even Indian domestic market editions, of the same books at drastically reduced prices. Searching for these has been one of the primary methods US students have been trying to save money the past few years. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/29/education/29textbooks.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/29/education/29textbooks.html http://www.abebooks.com/books/Textbooks/international-editions.shtml http://www.abebooks.com/books/Textbooks/international-editio... http://www.quora.com/Why-are-textbooks-so-expensive-in-Western-countries-while-the-same-books-are-cheap-in-the-Indian-subcontinent http://www.quora.com/Why-are-textbooks-so-expensive-in-Weste...
- Theodores 13y agoExactly why this situation persists in the age of the WWW is a mystery to me. I could understand expensive course specific texts back in the day, but, nowadays? If I was the boss at a university I would make all teaching staff put all of the content needed to teach their course material online in some wiki of sorts, with credits for researchers and undergraduates if they can add to that body of knowledge. In fact I would make it so that PhD. thesii didn't just sit on some shelf unread, such works would have to go into the body of knowledge created. Within one year something tangible could be created. Clearly it would not be possible to upload those 'Harry Potter' books studied by Media Studies stoodentz, however, for anything science there should be no need to run into copyright problems. With such a system any graduate that had maintained pages or added notable content could put the links on their CV for an employer to read. This could be a fully virtuous circle with better students rather than necessarily wealthier students attracted to the university. From those students there would not be an outflow of money to the textbook-scam-artists (or to the posh restaurants where they wine and dine teaching staff). The business of a university is to teach, not to sell text books.
- ronaldx 13y ago> If I was the boss at a university I would make all teaching staff put all of the content needed to teach their course material online in some wiki of sorts, with credits for researchers and undergraduates if they can add to that body of knowledge. You should understand that you're probably asking for a significant change in contract conditions which gives you Intellectual Property rights over your employee's work. By saying "in some wiki of sorts", you mean that the university would gain the right of distribution in the way that they (commercially) see fit, rather than the author being able to use their own work. Requiring that the work is uploaded in a particular format will also cause untold headaches. My employer insisted that I sign a contract like this (giving up my IP), I refused because it would have caused problems with my other work (I literally could not consider it), and I ended up quitting over this. Textbook authors are generally not scammers. They are people trying to make a living from their expertise - expertise both in their subject and in their ability to communicate, which are skills otherwise undervalued by society. Your beef is with the publishers, not with the content creators who you are punishing here.
- abc123xyz 13y agoThere is a site out there on the underweb, which I will not name, that sells 1 million ebooks for $0.01 and another million at 1/20th the list prices (so a $100 text book for $5). The pirates as always are well ahead.
- christiangenco 13y agoI can't find it in 30 seconds of googling. Can you give us a better hint as to what it's called?
- pserwylo 13y agoI'm genuinely astounded that there is not more of a movement towards open source style text books, that accept contributions (e.g. chapters) from reputable academics from around the world. I understand that there is a huge amount of money involved, but surely the only stakeholders who benefit are: 1) The publishers, for obvious reasons 2) The authors, as they may get a healthy sum of money for writing a given text book. 3) (possibly) the teachers, if they get bribed into using a particular book in their curriculum. Lets forget about the publishers, because they are for-profit businesses who do not have the students best interest at heart. We'll also forget about the teachers, because this type of bribing is not common in my experience (teachers I know tend to go for what they already know, rather than the new shiny book which came to them in the mail). Also, we can presume that teachers are not in the business of squeezing every last dollar out of their students. As for the authors, I don't have an issue with people making money by writing text books. I know a few academics and industry people who are able to pursue more interesting goals because they have money coming in from books they've written. BUT THIS IS THE TINY MINORITY. Of all of the academics who would be capable of writing a chapter for, e.g. an introductory programming book, I would randomly estimate that only 0.1% of them have written a text book that is used in universities. If another 5% of them got together and contributed to an open source text book on the topic, that was liberally licensed and free for students to obtain and distribute, then why should we not embrace that? I understand that "getting your name out there" is not motivation enough for doing such things [0]. However, surely just doing it for the good of education and teaching is motive enough? Every now and again I see books come up on hacker news which seem like quite good resources (recently it was a cryptography book, another time it was a link to a github repo for a specific field of mathematics). It would be great if these projects could take off, and become the bibles for their relevant areas. And if a particular academic institution disagrees with the teaching of the book, don't go out and prescribe expensive text books to your students. Rather, fork the (e.g. CC-licensed) book that they are not happy with, and change it. Or better yet, submit a pull request, discuss the issues with the maintainers, and hopefully resolve the issue amicably. It just astounds me that this is not a thing. [0] - This occurs a lot in discussions about how companies such as Google try to get artwork from people at zero cost, citing that the artist will get "exposure".
- lebek 13y ago
- fekberg 13y agoPerks of self-publishing is that I can decide the price of my book myself. I believe that more people will buy my book if it is cheaper and hopefully everyone will like the book and tell their friends that this book is both good and cheap. It's a win win. I can price my book so that when someone buys it, after taxes and all that I can at least buy myself a coffee while working on the next project. I see it as a "Thank you for helping me, here's a coffee". I understand that books from larger publishing houses are more expensive because there are more people that needs a coffee to some extent there's just too large of a margin or too many coffees that needs to be handed out. Based on how many copies I've sold from self-publishing I've been able to get myself more than a coffee, but the individuals that bought the book didn't have to suffer too much economically as I don't price the book in the range of a new mobile phone.
- bsilvereagle 13y agoI think this article glosses over one of the key factors of the corruption in the textbook industry. Professors who write textbooks receive 15-40% royalties off the cover price. Then when new editions come out to block out the used market, the price on average increases 12%. Those same professors dictate which books students buy. Students are NOT the consumers of the textbook industry, professors are. At many large American universities a board of professors pick the books for the large Chemistry, Biology, Physics classes. If one of the board members has written or contributed to a book, you know that is the book that will be assigned to 1000+ students a semester. At near $200 a piece and assuming a 30% royalty that professor just made himself $60,000 at ONE university. Now imagine his book being used at 10+ universities. No matter how great the open textbook world gets, professors who have the option to net $60K are not going to select those books which gain them nothing. Once again, students are not the consumer of the textbook industry. One aside on new editions. I have a 2nd edition of a book, the 7th edition, and the 12th edition. The only thing that changes is the problems at the end of the chapters. The text on each page is near identical. The problem as a student is that I need the problems in the back to do homework, and in many cases exam questions are drawn straight from those problems.
- lebek 13y agoI'd be interested to know the proportion of professors that write textbooks used in their own courses. I expect it's quite small. Certainly more common in humanities, quite rare in science and engineering.
- bsilvereagle 13y agoWell, I go to a large state school, but this semester all five of my engineering courses use books written by faculty or by the professor.
- singold 13y agoI had a statistics professor that used a book written by himself in a statistics 101 class. Also, as a pleasant surprise, the slides he used in class (and where available for students to download) were almost exactly the same content of the book.
- gambiting 13y agoI literally don't understand the concept of buying textbooks. I have just finished a 4-year Master course in Computing Science in the UK and never had to buy a single book. Every single book that was on the reading list had to be available from the library - the library had at least 50-60 copies,and then you could access the ebook free of charge through the university network. I know that it's the same for other courses at that university - Maths, History, Biology, Electrical Engineering.....thinking of it now, I can't recall a single person who bought a textbook, ever. And in the case when I needed access to some academic publications for my dissertation and our library didn't have access to them, I filled out a request and within a week they purchased all the books that I needed. Was our university unique in this regard, or is that entire textbook craze US-only?
- capex 13y agoIn Australia, a majority of business, accounting and many other courses have compulsory textbooks. Their prices are quite similar to what the OP quoted; $125+ apiece. That's why there are companies like Zookal renting out textbooks.
- bsilvereagle 13y agoIf you aspire to be a Professional Engineer (PE) you buy your books so you can take them with you to the exam. Sure, you could check out a stack of books at the library the day before but then you're not familiar with where equations are, what example problems exist, etc.
- glomph 13y agoThat is certainly not the case everywhere in the UK. Many humanities departments cannot afford to have enough copies of all the set texts. Also many Science departments insist on the newest editions of books which the library will not stock past one or two reference copies. Most university libraries will get you books on request, but that often doesn't cover set texts (they will ask you to wait for the reference copy).
- justin66 13y ago> library had at least 50-60 copies That strikes me as very unusual.
- ryderm 13y agoI'm about to graduate from a US college, and I've never paid for a text book. Very few classes use them for more than supplementary reading or for homework problems. With a combination of learning things online, recorded lectures, finding PDFs of them online, borrowing from a friend, and checking them out from the library, it's been easy to not buy them. I don't think I've actually done either of the last two, which brings up the question: are they even needed? Personally, I think they are largely useless with the wealth of information that is available online.
- mindslight 13y agoBack when I was in school, I had a plan to photograph (the quality was good enough) the pages of all my intro textbooks, burn them to a CD, and distribute a few copies in the freshman honors dorm before the term started (I figured they'd be more accepting of a weird format, and enterprising with recopying the cds). I never quite got around to it though, as the scanning took too long. It's too bad, even then it was obvious that the textbook market was a scam based on changing page/problem numbers so you'd feel behind or unable to do homework if you had a different edition. For most books, you should hold off buying as long as possible as the class might not actually even use them. Some you may only need for homework problems, which you can usually borrow from a friend in class. If the prices have really gotten this out of hand, students should just start forming their own sharing/copying groups and make that the accepted norm. Let the publishers reap what they've sown and extract their pound of flesh exactly once.
- jccalhoun 13y agoI'm just a grad student in the humanities but my experience as the instructor of courses has been nothing like the one described in this post. I don't know anyone in our department that has ever been called by a textbook rep let alone taken out for lunch. Hell, there have been a couple times when I couldn't even get them to send me a copy of the book I'm teaching. I also haven't had any choice in what version of the book I use. I've had the bookstore call me and tell me that there is a new edition and they won't order the old edition so i have to use the new edition or some other book entirely.
- rahimnathwani 13y ago"I've had the bookstore call me and tell me that there is a new edition and they won't order the old edition" Eh? How does a single phone call from a single bookshop prevent you from assigning a particular edition of a particular book for your students? Are you in a remote location in a country without an Amazon or Abebooks equivalent? This is not meant as snark. I honestly don't get it, and would like to understand the background to the situation you describe.
- blueblob 13y agoThe school that I attended rented textbooks to students. It was included in tuition ~$300/year and everyone had to pay it. I could understand how they would prevent you getting a particular edition because they effectively purchase new books about every 3 years (depending on the enrollment in the course). Unfortunately, I still ran into a problem like this article speaks about in that one of the professors wrote a book and charged about $25 for their book for the course and made it required. Granted $25 is not a lot but they were effectively skipping the system's rental program.
- sliverstorm 13y agoI believe there are often old rules from when there was no Amazon (which wasn't that long ago). Fifteen years ago if your teacher assigned a book that could not be had at the bookstore... where would two hundred students find a copy?
- jostmey 13y agoPerhaps the open-source model may be used to draft new textbooks. Free textbooks for the world containing up to date information. Call it WikiTextBooks?
- jimhefferon 13y agoI am the author of a text that has been Freely available for some time now so I've read this post with interest. I'm seeing responses both here and on the Reddit post saying things like, "If I was in charge I'd make the class professors staple together some pages and make a free text, dammit." I appreciate the sentiment, but developing a text is a great deal of work. For instance, in math developing a set of quality exercises is, in my estimation, 2/3 of the effort, so just putting beamer slides in a comb binding is nowhere near enough. At least part of the issue lies in the reward system. Lesson One of economics is that people do what they are rewarded for doing and at this point most faculty would not get professional credit for being part of an open text development effort (obviously the situation now with printed texts is that people get money, and obviously also people do things for a variety of reasons but generally ..). Since a quality text takes hundreds of hours of close work by experts, you can't be surprised that quality open texts are not thick on the ground. (I'm fortunate in that my institution has been willing to recognize my work in this, but such generosity and foresight is not common.) So it is not as simple, at least in math, as making an edict.
- ivan_ah 13y ago> staple together some pages and make a free text, dammit [...] a quality text takes hundreds of hours of close work by experts I totally agree that a meaningful text can't be created a la carte by mixing disparate sections written in different styles, and covering concepts differently. The value provided by the author is not just writing the words but choosing the order or presentation, carefully foreshadowing concepts in earlier chapters which will be presented in later chapters, and using spaced repetition in later chapters to review and solidify core ideas from the beginning. That being said, I think texts can be pretty modular if written with modularity in mind by the same (or a few) authors. For example, I was able to reuse the "intro to high school math" sections from my first book on math and physics in the followup book on linear algebra. <on topic plug>We at (http://minireference.com http://minireference.com) are building an apt-learn command for first-year textbooks. Get in touch if you want to write the Bo bullshit guide to chemistry and/or biology.</plug>
- untilHellbanned 13y agohave the students learn the stuff via the internet. ~$0.
- Beltiras 13y agoSome professors in the Uni I attended are enlightened and use open textbooks. One thou amazed me. He taught Discreet Math. He had every edition of the book for the last 10 years and told us to bring any one of them. He had a map for the homework shuffle between editions and alerted us to the little changes made in the text itself. Gem of a teacher.
- gergles 13y agoReally, textbooks aren't that big of a deal. There's other sources to get textbooks. The bigger problems, IMO, are "homework systems" or "virtual labs" where you are required to pay a superfluous charge to a textbook publisher because professors are too lazy to grade homework. So you either buy a brand new copy of your intro algebra book for $130 and get a 'free' "MyMathLab" code, or you can just buy the code for $115. (e.g.: http://www.pearsonhighered.com/educator/product/MyMathLab-Standalone-Access-Card-4E/9780321199911.page http://www.pearsonhighered.com/educator/product/MyMathLab-St...) You'll note at that point, they don't need to produce a new edition every year that renumbers the problem set, because they're going to get their pound of flesh anyway, and you can buy an old book - but you still won't be able to pass the course, because professors require you do the homework through this 'system'.
- j2kun 13y agoI'd say this is not as big a deal as textbooks, because you need textbooks long after you're done with the introductory courses that use these systems. For example, I have a few dozen textbooks on my shelf costing well over a thousand dollars in total, but after four years of undergrad I can count maybe three times I needed to pay to enroll in an online homework system, for a total of what, maybe $300?
- ivan_ah 13y agoOn the topic of free textbooks, I recently bought the OpenIntro to Statistics. For just $10, I received a soft-cover full-color 300pp textbook on statistics. I found the price to be simply amazing so I had to get a copy: http://www.openintro.org/stat/ http://www.openintro.org/stat/