15 ms·
Tesla Can Topple the Car-Dealer Monopoly
- wil421 13y agoFord tried to uproot the dealers years ago and it didnt work. I did a case study in school on this topic, I cant seem to find my source again... Unions need to go...they hurt innovation and sometimes completely destroy it.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoHow on earth is this a union issue? It's capital vs capital.
- wil421 13y agoReally you think the dealer unions didnt lobby to get tesla banned from selling in that state? From: http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2014/03/chris_christie_blames_njs_controversial_tesla_ban_on_state_legislature.html http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2014/03/chris_christie_... "The state Motor Vehicle Commission last week unanimously passed a rule requiring franchised dealers to sell electric cars rather than allowing manufacturers to sell directly to customers as Tesla does at two showroom locations in New Jersey — at the Garden State Plaza and The Mall at Short Hills." >requiring franchised dealers And who is going to be franchising? The Unions will be. Maybe not in NJ but I gurantee other state's dealer unions are feeling the pressure that may come from tesla.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoThat's like calling the Chamber of Commerce a union.
- wil421 13y agoWho do think is putting pressure on these organizations?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoI'm going to need you to explain exactly why you think an association of otherwise independent and competing dealerships is a "union".
- wil421 13y agoThey may be called associations in some states. I don't think you can open a certain brand dealership in a state with going through them. Ford was trying to let customers order cars online and they would deliver it within a couple weeks or less to a Ford hub. Some states pushed them out before they could try it.
- njharman 13y agoBecause my anti-socialist upbringing taught me unions are bad. Therefor things I think are bad must be unions.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- vondur 13y agoWhat do unions have to do with Tesla and this issue in New Jersey?
- Bpal 13y agoThat's fascinating how people fear to take something new and better as opposed to old and traditional. The same has been with adoption computer. Yes, it has changed our lives and the world. But if this move hadn't been done, would we get better life? I don't think so. Getting info from Anywhere in the world in the split of the second is as good as breathing Clean air in big cities.
- beat 13y agoThis is something I think a lot of people don't get about Tesla's state-by-state fight with the dealer networks. It's not about hating on electric cars. It's about the threat that Tesla's model poses to their entire industry. Frankly, Ford doesn't need its dealer network any more than Tesla does now, or they shouldn't. They could go to the same shop-online and drop-ship model, and cut out a middleman. If any of the major automakers start killing dealers, the whole industry will die, and quickly. Why? Because they're parasites. The dealer network evolved to solve distribution problems from 100 years ago. It makes zero sense as a business model in the 21st century. "Ripe for disruption", as we'd say in these parts. All they have is inertia, deep political connections, and a century of regulatory mazes. But those are three very big things to have. Still, they're fighting a defensive war. They will lose. The question is only how quickly, and at what cost to consumers?
- rdudek 13y agoAgreed! Wish I could afford a Tesla car, maybe one day I will. But I always look forward to see what else they're doing. Got to hand it to Tesla for disrupting the standard industry.
- hardwaresofton 13y agoI agree -- I think this article should have been named "Tesla will topple the car dealer monopoly". The entire dealership system represents a market inefficiency that will correct itself. The only forces that are keeping the monstrosity around are broken political systems and force (physical or otherwise) paramount to coercion.
- bluedevil2k 13y agoI wouldn't be so dismissive of dealers by simply saying "They will lose." The most important thing in American politics is power, and power comes from money (sounds like that comes directly from House of Cards). The article points out that the car dealer lobby is well funded and powerful. It even points out that they are exempt from the Consumer Protection laws, meaning they don't have to disclose the awful interest rates they are offering (which surprised me). Look at the size of a company like AutoNation ($6.3B market cap). They aren't a local mom and pop car dealer. Never underestimate the fight of a wounded animal backed into a corner.
- Spooky23 13y agoA better headline would be "Tesla must topple the car-dealer franchise system". The retail side of the dealer network is really just a front door to the service department. Electric cars are supposed to have fewer service requirements, so if Tesla cannot defeat the franschise system, they are kind of screwed, as franchises will have to make more money on retail.
- protomyth 13y ago"Tesla must topple the car-dealer franchise system". That is a much better description. For example, Ford probably doesn't care if Tesla succeeds or fails. They are stuck with independent dealers currently and any attempt on their part to change that will start a "starve out" of their sales as most dealers have multiple dealerships and sell multiple brands. If Tesla doesn't break the franchise system, then Ford is no worse off than it is now and Tesla is blocked. If Tesla does win, then Ford can start selling direct itself.
- gxs 13y agoOne of the great things that has come of this entire ordeal is simply education. I usually take pride in doing my research well before buying something, but it had never really occurred to me that the dealers are forced middlemen. It had never occurred to me that it is ILLEGAL for Toyota to sell a car directly to me. I am rooting for Tesla now with even more fervor. It's absolutely comical to me how politicians will tote the values of a capitalistic society, then turn around and get on their knees for special interest lobbies.
- rayiner 13y agoHow many employees do dealers have in Texas, versus Tesla? Now do you get why politicians get on their knees for special interests?
- jfb 13y agoSee also: how much money in local taxes do car dealerships pay vs. Tesla? They are very big players in local economies.
- voodoomagicman 13y agoBut how many people buy cars? Dealerships profits / car salesmen's wages come at the expense of car buyers as much as car manufacturers.
- jfb 13y agoOh, I'm not arguing in favor of the rent-seeking of car dealerships -- I just think it's important to remember that not every legal regime is the natural end result of corruption. The car dealerships have this cozy arrangement because they pay loads of local taxes, employ lots of people, and have a strong and well organized lobby.
- Jtsummers 13y agoAside from property taxes on the dealerships' land holdings, most states have ad valorem taxes on cars. This is typically paid whether you bought the car in the state or not, often at the time you register the vehicle in a state. This is also, typically, an annual tax. So if I buy a car in FL and register it in GA, I'll essentially pay sales tax twice (once in FL and once at registration in GA, also depends on how much the ad valorem tax is). So GA tax revenue will be consistent whether I buy it from the dealership or from Tesla. Regarding employees, direct sales will reduce the number of sales people, yes. Or it'll change the nature of the salesman's job. From pusher on a commission to a salaryman. Now, Tesla and other electrics may not need frequent work done by mechanics (even the standard maintenance stuffs), but other cars still would. Just because I bought my Subaru from Subaru proper instead of the local dealership doesn't mean I won't need to take it in for service every 6 (or so) months. And if electric cars really do have an effect on employment of mechanics and service technicians, then that's the consequence. We can't legislate the cars away to preserve jobs anymore than we can legislate manufacturing robots away to preserve the jobs of the assembly line worker. (That said, a change in employment status of a large segment of the population will have to be dealt with. Either by charity, retraining, welfare or some combination of those and other methods I've not mentioned.)
- api 13y agoI'm with Tesla here, but this headline is weirdly almost Orwellian. Car dealers are not a monopoly. They all have different owners! But they are a state-mandated middleman, something I do not support. The reason I'm with Tesla is because I know why they're doing this. The automotive industry is for the most part terrified of EVs as they have far fewer moving parts, no oil changes, etc. They also have the potential to last longer and (eventually!) be easier to produce. Tesla is doing this because if given half a chance car dealers will sideline if not outright sabotage any EV that attempts to succeed in the market. They're going around the car industry because the car industry wants them to fail.
- venomsnake 13y agoOligopoly is monopoly in all but name.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoI've often been amazed the car-dealer industry has lasted this long. It's all too often based on deception, disrespect, intimidation, and rip-offs - from the showroom (overcharge as much as possible), to the trade-in aspect (under-charge using the same tricks ... go figure) to the financing (bury the overcharging in extra years of interest paid), to the garage (a skilled mechanic will often still charge far less than the dealership for the same service). No, not every dealer works this way. Just the majority. If Tesla can make a change to this phenomenon, then good riddance to bad rubbish. As an aside, this (long) story from Edmunds gives outstanding insights to how dealerships work, and what options are available to consumers. http://www.edmunds.com/car-buying/confessions-of-a-car-salesman.html http://www.edmunds.com/car-buying/confessions-of-a-car-sales... It's fascinating to see how racial profiling comes into the mix. An ethnic group - according to dealers - will be known to have bad credit, or to pay the overcharged price no matter what without a fight, or (as dealers claim of white people) chiefly car-shop online and come armed with information looking for the best price.
- chris_mahan 13y agoAgreed. Also very often within the dealership itself: Salesman lies to you, finance guy lies to you, other salespeople completely ignore you. The only person relatively nice is the receptionist.
- mikeash 13y agoIt's interesting to think about how much of this crap is ultimately enabled by the ubiquity of car loans. Transforming the sticker price into a much lower (in terms of which number is absolutely bigger) monthly charge completely changes the psychology of it. How many people don't do as much research as they should because they're thinking in terms of $500/month instead of $25,000? How much BS can the salesman then get away with because of that? How often does a salesman successfully pitch some completely useless extra as being "only $20/month" when the buyer would never pay $1,000 for it if they actually sat down and thought about it? How often do buyers end up spending way more than they intended to because they don't properly factor in interest, or the added cost of extras, or down payments, or the costs of taking out the loan itself? I bought a car in cash last year and it made the whole process pretty nice. A whole fat layer of nonsense was just stripped away. I realize this isn't practical for everybody, but how much of it is that it's outright impossible for people, and how much of it is that Americans are conditioned to buy cars on credit, end up spending more than they should and buying more car than they should, making it harder to save up money, making the whole cycle repeat. In many ways, it's just another example of how it's expensive to be poor, and cheaper to be better off.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- vvvv 13y agoActually, Tesla is not the first auto company that is attempting to dispense of dealers. When Daewoo entered the UK in 1995, "their market research revealed that car buyers disliked dealers on commission, hard-sell, aggressive sales techniques, over exaggerated promotional campaigns and poor after-sales service" so "Daewoo set up its own dealerships with staff paid a salary rather than commission – trained, helpful sales advisors providing information rather than pressing for sales. Showrooms had crèches and children’s play areas and offered coffee. Cars were not serviced at the same location, but rather by the well-known retailer Halfords in their out-of-town service centres. The themes used by Daewoo to further differentiate itself included good value, reliable cars (3 year warranties, AA breakdown cover) with additional safety features (eg ABS brakes and side impact protection) and additional features and benefits that would otherwise be extra cost (eg power steering, no-fuss guarantees, courtesy cars or pick up and collection for services). The result was that in the first six months Daewoo sold a remarkable 14,000 cars in the UK." http://www.palgrave.com/business/ebm/lecturers/session4/4-daewoo.html http://www.palgrave.com/business/ebm/lecturers/session4/4-da... http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=33HpNgHUkb0C&pg=PA144&lpg=PA144&dq=daewoo+dealer+business+case+study&source=bl&ots=e7ROG6y03z&sig=J_cOGHSQizeFmyn-81db-aeTAgI&hl=en&sa=X&ei=Uh4rU8fINciQhQedyYDAAQ&ved=0CEAQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=daewoo%20dealer%20business%20case%20study&f=false http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=33HpNgHUkb0C&pg=PA144&lpg...
- nerfhammer 13y agoSaturn was similar in some ways http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Corporation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Corporation
- Theodores 13y agoYou have a good memory! If I remember... The original Daewoo cars in the UK were based on old Astra (and other Vauxhall) models, with body panels that were just not quite as well defined as the Astra originals. This appearance was a bit like the tacky Rover versions of Honda cars or how we imagine Chinese 'knock offs' to look. They were competing against Lada and other low price motors at the budget end of the price range. I don't think the service-by-Halfords arrangement worked out too well for them and other dealerships tried their hardest to do them down. Nonetheless they were a disruptive presence in the marketplace - at the time I lived in a rural part of Wales and those Daewoo efforts were quite common. In a UK context the Tesla dealerships are probably more akin to the McLaren dealerships (I think these are owned by M(a)cLaren, i.e. Ron Dennis et al., but they could be a franchise). McLaren are an up-market premium brand and, having a McLaren dealership in nearby Knightsbridge, probably isn't going to stress out the Ford dealers on the A5 (or rural Wales) in the same way that Daewoo disrupted things. I think our American friends are over-worrying about the 'threat' Tesla are to regular car dealers.
- mikestew 13y agoWith all the talk about money-driven politics, and how politicians listen to the car dealers over what you have to say, at the end of the day I'm the one that fills out the ballot. And I would defy anyone to point out an industry endpoint (at least in the U. S.) that has as much a reputation for dishonesty and obfuscated pricing as auto dealers. Lawyers at least come in handy from time to time, but I'd guess car salesmen will have a hard time finding a sympathetic ear. People expect car salesmen to just lie to their face. Seat protection spray and undercoating being a rip-off is so cliched it's the subject of comedy routines (and everybody gets the joke). Yet dealers still sell it, and we sit there saying "no...no...no...ask me again, and I'll buy the car elsewhere" because that's just the way it is, right? Maybe it doesn't have to be that way. If you live in NJ, TX, or another state that doesn't want to let Tesla sell cars, let a state politician know. Maybe you think your U. S. Congressperson won't listen to you, but at the state level they are much more likely to lend an ear.
- mikeash 13y agoIf just you filled out the ballot, I imagine this would be much less problematic. The problem is that you, and people like you, are not normal. Most ballots are filled out by slack-jawed yokels who choose their car because they liked the ad they saw for it on TV, and who choose their politicians in much the same manner.
- loceng 13y agoTesla not only can but they will, and they are in the lead to do this, and will own the majority of this market. If I wasn't investing in myself I would be investing in Tesla.
- jrjr 13y agowhy not sell them through Indian Reservations ? then the 'laws' and special interests could GFY. it would be great for everyone involved. jr
- sixQuarks 13y agoThis may seem counter-intuitive, but an educated car shopper today can actually get a better deal because of this archaic franchise system. The truth is, dealers do compete against each other ferociously. Yes, they will rip you off if you come unprepared, but if you shop your deal around to enough dealers, chances are you will get a zero-profit or even below-cost deal on your new car. When the dealer franchise system has been gotten rid of (I give it another 15 to 20 years), supply and demand will be better matched and manufacturers will be optimizing their profits.
- randomdata 13y agoWithout access to the dealer's financials, how do you know what their profit/loss even is? There are many variables like land/rent costs, local wages, etc. that could have a dramatic effect on profitability between seemingly similar dealers. Also, having recently purchased a new car, I noticed that every dealer specced them slightly different, so you couldn't easily compare the vehicles one to one. Something as simple as the color of paint changed the price by hundreds of dollars. Not an insurmountable detail if you are careful, but you really have to do your homework. Not to mention that it becomes a massive time sink. Given a typical programmer's hourly pay, in many cases it would be more economical to pay out more money and get back to work than spend that time looking for the savings. So, I do agree that shopping around can net you a better deal, but for all the effort required, I question if it is worth it. I'm going to very sad if I can't buy my next car online (and I hope it will drive itself to my door).
- fancyketchup 13y agoSee, but this just shows that even those who think they are educated car shoppers actually aren't. Dealers never sell cars at zero or negative profit, unless you ignore things like holdback (a rebate on the wholesale price of the car when the car is sold at retail) or factory quota incentives (a "bonus" for dealers who sell a certain number of certain models of cars in a particular month). If you think you got the car for below cost, chances are you forgot to factor in holdback or you just pushed the dealer over the edge for a big fat manufacturer bonus check.
- 13y ago
- casca 13y agoFor more info on the how and why of US car dealerships, here's a good Planet Money podcast: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/03/14/290241292/episode-435-why-buying-a-car-is-so-awful http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/03/14/290241292/episode-...
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoThat episode was fantastic.
- radley 13y agoMonopoly? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2y8Sx4B2Sk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2y8Sx4B2Sk
- RankingMember 13y agoAnything that can bring down dealerships has got my backing. I don't understand why the auto manufacturers wouldn't want to lobby to distribute their own vehicles rather than have the frequently dickish/predatory/incompetent sales/service of dealerships be the local face of their company.
- hnriot 13y agoLike Saturn did...
- RankingMember 13y agoSaturn didn't. Those were still dealers, just more closely-watched ones since GM was really trying to turn over a new leaf.
- crabasa 13y ago"the initial benefits of the dealer franchise system have long since given way to rent-seeking, inefficiency and unintended consequences" This is by far the most interesting part of what is a rather short and fluffy piece with a strangely assertive headline. How exactly does a government/regulator quantify when the benefits of a granted monopoly (i.e. power, telecom, etc) has outlives its well understood purpose?
- wil421 13y agoThey will probably not topple the monopoly as long as we allow lobbying in this Country. Who's agenda do you think the legislators of these bans are following? The people who elect them or the lobbyist who fund them?
- sebnukem2 13y agoI truly believe that lobbyism is legalized corruption.
- wcfields 13y agoSigh... Guess I won't ever see Gene Simmons Tesla President's day KISS-A-THON sales event.
- puppetmaster3 13y agoUnless Tesla starts 'donating' to politicians, it won't go anywhere.
- tdiggity 13y agoWhy can't it be as simple as this: If you sell direct, you can't have dealers. If you have dealers, you can't sell direct. Are dealers afraid that manufacturers like Toyota or Ford would just go up and undercut them? I doubt it, that would piss off a lot of their customers (the dealers). The dealer decided to open a particular branded dealership, so if you're in a Toyota dealership they shouldn't give a crap about what anyone else is doing.
- tn13 13y agoCan someone care to explain me why the car dealers exist in first place ? Isnt it much more economical for Ford, Toyota etc. to simply start selling cars from their own retail store chains ? It is likely to make cars more cheaper and car companies more profitable. How can any legislation banning it get passed in USA ?
- krisgenre 13y agoCan't Tesla create their own 'Car Dealership' company and sell through it?