15 ms·
How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with Malware
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bitsteak 13y ago“When they deploy malware on systems,” Hypponen says, “they potentially create new vulnerabilities in these systems, making them more vulnerable for attacks by third parties.” Really, how does that work Mikko? You don't even have a copy of any malware to make that statement. All the hyperbole about how this is somehow unique is really getting old. Exploit kit authors have had shitty PHP web applications that accomplish the same task for ages: manage thousands of bots by grouping them together with a point and click management interface. It sounds like, prior to TURBINE, NSA had a single person tasked to oversee every action taken by hand, which is kind of inefficient if you ask me, so it stands to reason they would try to manage that process with technology. How do you cool yourself First Look when you're reporting on this in 2014? Jeez.
- pkinsky 13y agoBotnets require remote management. This means adding hidden backdoors, with the assumption that they will remain hidden. If such a backdoor becomes known to bad actors, they will exploit it. Unless you're asserting that adding back doors makes a system more secure.
- jmcmichael 13y ago> Really, how does that work Mikko? You don't even have a copy of any malware to make that statement. Simple: every process running on a system is a process that can be exploited, especially those processes that involve network communication. The NSA's exploits are processes running on the system they are attacking. They utilize network communications. These processes are open to exploitation by third parties, just like all the other legitimate processes.
- jmcmichael 13y ago> All the hyperbole about how this is somehow unique is really getting old. The big news is that the most powerful people on the planet are now using the same script-kiddie techniques against the rest of the world, in secret, without oversight, on an industrial scale. EDIT: Judging from your github account, you appear to be a developer working on a open-source whistleblower platform. Given that the NSA's efforts would likely be focused on the users applications such as yours, do you not find these revelations to be directly relevant to your goals in developing this software?
- dTal 13y agoHypponen said "potentially" and it is an absolutely defensible statement. You go around poking holes in a system, don't be surprised if other people find the holes. You gonna trust the guy who hacked your machine to lock the door behind him on the way out? >All the hyperbole about how this is somehow unique is really getting old. The issue isn't that the spooks have developed some superweapon. The issue is that they've signaled intent and means to do mass espionage on citizens, not just at the network level, but at the machine level. This is as if your local law enforcement handed out burglars tools to all their officers so they could get into everyone's homes "to check for drugs". "Eh, burglars tools are nothing special" totally misses the point.
- gregsq 13y agoDefinition of the word 'potential' cited in the Oxford Dictionary. "Having or showing the capacity to develop into something in the future" Or alternatively "Having possibility, capability, or power." Or in Merrium-Webster: "expressing possibility ; specifically : of, relating to, or constituting a verb phrase expressing possibility, liberty, or power by the use of an auxiliary with the infinitive of the verb (as in “it may rain”)" I can see no difficulty in the authors expression of the idea of possibility.
- higherpurpose 13y agoRemember, Microsoft is part of this plot, even if they have "plausible deniability". Microsoft is giving NSA access to lists of vulnerabilities Windows has many months before Microsoft even begins to work on a fix. They are in effect helping NSA break into many computers, even if they are up to date. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-14/u-s-agencies-said-to-swap-data-with-thousands-of-firms.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-14/u-s-agencies-said-t... Every single one of these vulnerabilities could be seen as a backdoor, except Microsoft can have plausible deniability, since they are not actually putting a backdoor in the OS themselves - they're "just telling NSA about the vulnerabilities that exist". If something like CISPA passes, which NSA keeps pushing for, this capability will expand dramatically, as all companies will be forced to give these vulnerabilities to NSA, but not to "protect us" and for cyber "security", as they keep claiming when they try to promote laws like these, but for offense. They will hoard every single one of them, and then use them in such automated systems to infect millions of computers.
- Fuxy 13y agoAnd this is why I'm glad my main OS is linux. Not impossible for NSA to get in but a lot more difficult.
- romanovcode 13y ago> I use Ubuntu, take that NSA! You're cute.
- Fuxy 13y agoClose... It's Arch though.
- computer 13y agoSo the only thing the NSA has to do is hack/convince/rendition/break-into-house a single person who holds a package signing key, and then they can MITM your pacman updater and have you as well. And there's enough people with such a key to choose from: https://www.archlinux.org/master-keys/ https://www.archlinux.org/master-keys/. (I run Arch as well, but I have no such illusions of security.)
- r0h1n 13y agoAfter a while all these news items about the NSA and GCHQ can seem a bit too much, but not if we take a step back and really understand the enormity of it all. The NSA and its cohorts set up fake Facebook websites, spoof security certificates, secretly record webcam streams, vacuum up everything they can lay their hands on etc. Meanwhile the CIA coolly wipes hundreds of documents from the machines of those who are investigating it, and when caught, threaten their overseers with criminal charges. Given the scale of their operations, tens of billions of dollars in budgets and how many years they've been at it (this article essentially talks about what the NSA was doing in 2009), is it now futile to think that govt. agencies around the world can ever be expected to turn the clock back? I mean, really, is there any possible reality that involves the NSA/GCHQ deleting the mountains of data they have surreptitiously recorded? And unplugging or reversing the hundreds of traps, backdoors, viruses, intercepts, decoys that are aimed at common citizens?
- bananas 13y agoYes it's called a revolution at which point we storm the bases and burn the data centres and monitoring stations to the ground. But, as Huxley was so keen to point out, that's not going to happen when people are staring at Honey Boo Boo and Hollyoaks.
- JulianMorrison 13y agoRevolution is a tool of limited usefulness, and violent ones very often put something back in that is just as bad as what they ejected (see also: the KGB).
- bananas 13y agoIt's more complicated than that. ----->[ good times ]---->[ hard times ] ---> [fascism] --\ ^ | \-------------------[revolution] <--------------------/ Revolution merely starts the cycle again. We'll always end up with the KGB, Stasi, NSA, GCHQ, CIA etc so you have to deconstruct society regularly to flush it out. We're stuck in a pretty long loop at the moment just verging on hard times. Edit: the "good times" above is optional.
- AccountsBlow 13y agoPlan to? Hello! They already have infected millions of mobile phones, servers, and desktop computers alike with malware. You are delusional if you think otherwise, NSA malware is the very OS you are running.
- oskarth 13y agoAn implant plug-in named CAPTIVATEDAUDIENCE, for example, is used to take over a targeted computer’s microphone and record conversations taking place near the device. Another, GUMFISH, can covertly take over a computer’s webcam and snap photographs. FOGGYBOTTOM records logs of Internet browsing histories and collects login details and passwords used to access websites and email accounts. GROK is used to log keystrokes. And SALVAGERABBIT exfiltrates data from removable flash drives that connect to an infected computer. Will all the conspiracy theorists come out of the woodwork, please. We need your help.
- dhimes 13y agoAnd I can't even keep Evolution from needing my password every few minutes.
- saraid216 13y agoHi. My conspiracy theory is that Satoshi Nakamoto is the NSA. You're welcome.
- oskarth 13y agoHi, Michael. Both of us are now in a labelled graph database of identities, were the label signifies how strong the connection is. Right now it's 2/10, but by responding to you it's now 3/10. And if you (yes, you) are reading this comment, assume that you just got a 1/10 label to me [1]. You're welcome. 1: More efficient representations probably exist. Maybe we are all uniquely indexed in some database cluster in Utah. I'd call it BACON-BINLADIN.
- cloverich 13y agoPrediction: If this goes on long enough, NSA (and other entities) will accidentally create Skynet.
- Ygg2 13y agoThat won't happen, because SkyNet is already created. It's their management infrastructure. This proves once more management is evil. (this post is false)
- throwwit 13y agoProbably won't need the AI... all it takes is consolidating it into a bunch of easy to use push button setups. Then Milgram style situations occur.
- Crito 13y agoDrones fly around, listening to cell traffic and logging call data and the position of phones in the middle east (so called "metadata"). These logs are then fed into a computer, which attempts to find relationships between phones. Which phones regularly find themselves in the same location as other phones? Which phones called other phones? The computer is also fed imperfect information that correlates some phones to the identities of alleged 'baddies'. When phones are found to have close 'relationships' with phones that have at least at one point been used by 'baddies', sometimes the computer decides that the phone must be executed. It prints out an order, which is passed up the line to the President. The President rubber stamps the order. The order goes back down the line and eventually finds it's way back to the computer. The computer, using the before mentioned drones, locates that phone and informs a drone operator. The drone operator then tells the drone to execute that phone, and any people who may happen to be in the area with it. The drone carries out the execution. Nothing but a bureaucratic skynet.
- josephlord 13y ago> GCHQ cooperated with the hacking attacks despite having reservations about their legality. One of the Snowden files, previously disclosed by Swedish broadcaster SVT, revealed that as recently as April 2013, GCHQ was apparently reluctant to get involved in deploying the QUANTUM malware due to “legal/policy restrictions.” A representative from a unit of the British surveillance agency, meeting with an obscure telecommunications standards committee in 2010, separately voiced concerns that performing “active” hacking attacks for surveillance “may be illegal” under British law. Wow, finally a limit on what GCHQ thinks that they are allowed to do! Now can the NSA be prosecuted for these actions when done in the UK? #notgonnahappen
- innocentius 13y ago> By concealing its malware within what looks like an ordinary Facebook page, the NSA is able to hack into the targeted computer and covertly siphon out data from its hard drive. A top-secret animation demonstrates the tactic in action. Can anyone explain why they need to conceal it as a Facebook server? Why is that essential to infecting your computer? Why can't it just send you the malware, and then redirect you to the real Facebook (since their mission is accomplished anyway)?
- endeavor 13y agoIt sounds like they are going after a vulnerability in the browser. My guess would be that do a man-in-the-middle attack where they have a device that acts as a proxy so you get YOUR Facebook page, but with an exploit injected into the code.
- logn 13y agoThe NSA, breaking into US computers, is violating the Third Amendment, in my opinion. No Soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the Owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.
- mattlutze 13y agoI think this would be an extension of wiretapping, not soldiers taking residence forcefully in a home.
- infinity0 13y agoNo. Malware is way more intrusive than wiretapping, it can affect your software. Implanting a chip into your brain to control your thoughts would be the extreme version of it.
- mattlutze 13y ago"Way more" intrusive doesn't conflict with "extension". It's just a more spirited adjectival phrase. Seems to be that what's described -- fake servers to watch traffic, turning on a mic to listen, turning on a camera to watch -- are all in spirit extensions of an intel agent sitting at an AT&T operator's switch and plugging into a line to listen to a conversation. Particularly that mic one. My contention was simply that it doesn't track that malware on a computer is anything like a soldier demanding to use someone's home as a bunk house.
- saraid216 13y ago> My contention was simply that it doesn't track that malware on a computer is anything like a soldier demanding to use someone's home as a bunk house. I don't disagree, and IANAL, but there is a case to be made here that the spirit of the Third Amendment is to prevent military, or military-esque actors, from commandeering civilian property. On the other hand, in writing that, I realized there is something called commandeering and there are probably interesting relevant cases to go over to find whether or not that has any sense.
- pvnick 13y agoThe obvious solution is to run everything on Temple OS. I'm only half joking.
- chroem 13y agoToo bad God doesn't approve of a networking stack.
- tedks 13y agoThis is exactly why God doesn't approve of a networking stack. Wake up, sheeple.
- lucastx 13y agoI feel guilty of upvoting a joke on HN. My only comfort is knowing that this one will be buried, and this will be my punishment.
- kirubakaran 13y agoThat's a little dramatic, don't you think? :-)
- tedks 13y agoLooks like the comment-parent isn't a native english speaker; a lot probably got lost in translation.
- abjorn 13y ago>"The sensors, codenamed TURMOIL, operate as a sort of high-tech surveillance dragnet, monitoring packets of data as they are sent across the Internet." "TURMOIL", really? Honestly, is this just an elaborate setup for a new bond film or something, this is getting ridiculous.
- aasarava 13y agoAt some point, laptops, displays, and handheld devices started carrying built-in microphones and cameras as a feature. Perhaps the new feature is devices that don't have these things? To use a mic or camera, you'd explicitly have to plug it in and could physically unplug it later.
- hrkristian 13y agoBetter then, to have hardware switches similar to the iPhone lock switch. I'd welcome that in general! Make the switch open up the camera app directly, and a similar one for the mics; binding it to your phone or recording app, depending on what you prefer. Make each switch a LED which -if they are- signals ON-state as the screen is turned on or off. Edit: And incoming call screen would have to reflect the mic being off, in which case flicking the switch would accept the call.
- aurumpotest 13y agoAlready underway. See http://time.com/10115/google-project-ara-modular-smartphone/ http://time.com/10115/google-project-ara-modular-smartphone/ and similar projects.
- eliteraspberrie 13y agoDoes anyone have a good guess of how FASHIONCLEFT works? Has it been seen before?
- guest29572 13y agoGoogle reveals http://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1077764/vpn-and-voip-exploitation-with-hammerchant-and.txt http://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1077764/vpn-and-voip-e... which seem to be slides regarding it.
- Canada 13y agoLook, SSH clients are used as selectors.
- minimax 13y agoAll of this sounds like excellent operational technology. I don't understand all the outrage here. If you sit down and ask yourself, "What kind of technology would I build if I wanted to infiltrate government/military networks of technologically sophisticated adversaries?", this is basically what you'd end up with. This is exactly the sort of thing I would expect the NSA to spend their time on.
- akjj 13y agoExactly. So much of the article is about capabilities with little context for how broadly it is applied. Even the "millions" in the title is just about the server capacity for managing the infected computers, and later they admit that the actual number of computers is an order of magnitude less.
- summerdown2 13y agoI don't think the majority of people are outraged that a spy organisation spies. The things that have got most people rattled are: a) The breadth of the spying, including many, many innocent people. b) The long-term storage of data, likewise. c) Deliberate weakening of security standards we all rely upon. d) The fact it's all happening without democratic debate. If instead of the above, they threw innocent people's data away, targeted their intrusions, engaged with the democratic mechanisms, and used their expertise to improve internet security, a lot of people would be much happier.
- snake_plissken 13y agoThrough all of the news articles and the analyses I have read, I still don't understand how exactly all of this works. I understand the MITM concept, but the Man-On-The-Side parts boggle m: "When a target attempts to log in to the social media site, the NSA transmits malicious data packets that trick the target’s computer into thinking they are being sent from the real Facebook. By concealing its malware within what looks like an ordinary Facebook page, the NSA is able to hack into the targeted computer and covertly siphon out data from its hard drive." Where is the security hole? My network card? OS? Browser? But then there are so many layers in there. Is it a specially malformed ICMP packet? Or is it a vulnerability in the OS's RPC functions? It's one thing to exploit a vulnerability in Java or Flash, but just using "malicious packets"?
- Consultant32452 13y agoIt seems to me that they are sending out packets identifying themselves as facebook. If you're not using SSL this is expected to be possible. If you are using SSL to communicate with FB then it's likely that the NSA has the private keys for FB's SSL certificates.
- ds9 13y agoRight, I think this is referring to a technique described in some of the earlier info releases, where the agency intercepts requests and send a fake response before the real one arrives, and ditching the real response. I'm not clear on the details - it may rely on spoofing the server's IP, falsifying DNS replies and/or manipulating data in transit. What interests me more, and what the above poster may be asking about is this part: "By concealing its malware within what looks like an ordinary Facebook page, the NSA is able to hack into the targeted computer". This implies a true drive-by exploit - one not requiring any user interaction. Most of the Windows malware is actually installed by the user - they're tricked into clicking something, thinking it's anti-virus, funny video, "accelerate your internet" or some other innocuous thing. The no-user-action exploits generally have been workable only for plugins, particularly Flash or Java, which the user has allowed to run without any filters.
- blueskin_ 13y ago>computer servers I've been seeing this pattern a lot in nontechnical news recently, and have always been baffled as to what other kind of server there is (short of some basic network service implemented purely in logic gates, I guess).
- lutusp 13y ago>> computer servers > I've been seeing this pattern a lot in nontechnical news recently, and have always been baffled as to what other kind of server there is ... In this fast-breaking story, the expression "computer servers" has joined "software program" and "underground tunnel" at the Department of Redundancy Department.
- blueskin_ 13y agoDon't forget putting your PIN number into an ATM machine.
- ForHackernews 13y agoThere are servers at restaurants.
- BgSpnnrs 13y agoalso both in and on courts. :)
- fantnn 13y agoThis sounds like what I do with Metasploit already just with substantially more cryptographic muscle lol
- pistolpete20 13y agoAnyone else find the graphics in the slides as almost too bad, that they aren't believable?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- aspensmonster 13y agoThat's strange. If ever I tried to build a botnet with millions of nodes I'd surely be thrown in prison for years at least. Probably decades. But if I've learned anything in my short time on this planet, it's to always commit your crimes behind the corporate or government veils. Preferably both. Edit: https://prod01-cdn02.cdn.firstlook.org/wp-uploads/2014/03/hammer-vpn.jpg https://prod01-cdn02.cdn.firstlook.org/wp-uploads/2014/03/ha... Mirror: http://i.imgur.com/JbLqxAY.jpg http://i.imgur.com/JbLqxAY.jpg Fuckin' hell. I think we can consider the internet more than owned. More like bent over and pounded.
- clamprecht 13y agoI don't know about you guys, but to me, the NSA code names seem to be a great source for hostnames. "ssh hammerstein" has a good ring to it, no?
- sys32768 13y agoSince they see everyone as a potential threat, taint their data so that everyone appears to be that threat. Millions of us could increase the signal-to-noise ratio in their collected data by using a bot to perform random human-like web searches and visits. If 100 people are searching for <insert bad thing here>, the government has actionable surveillance data. If 100 thousand or 10 million are searching for it in ways that are indistinguishable from a human, then that data becomes unreliable and is no longer actionable. Adding email to this would strike a fatal blow. Someone could figure a way to create a secure layer to inform a client when a given email being sent was fake, and thus suppress it visually. Soon from the government perspective everyone would be cheating on their spouses and spouting extremist views and plotting this or that. This would result in an increase in liberty by proving to the government that it should fear its people, if only because its sophisticated surveillance tools now confirm that all the people are evil.
- mattkrea 13y agoHas anyone looked into doing this? Meaning has anyone started building anything like this? I would be interested.
- caf 13y agoI believe the money quote here is: “If we can get the target to visit us in some sort of web browser, we can probably own them,” an agency hacker boasts in one secret document. “The only limitation is the ‘how.’”
- adamrights 13y agoWhen I was in middle/highschool -- late 90's-03 -- using a mix of home-made tools, scripts I tweaked, some trojans I hex edited to make work for me...I had almost all of my schools home computers logging into an IRC room where I could use them to DoS attack and easily knock off (especially before few had broadband) anyone -- all my infected IRC clients could also upload, often around firewall/virus protection varying degrees of other trojans that let me print on their computers, watch them on webcams, open their cd-roms... I was young, told most people and really didn't abuse it: and finally learned 'hackers make things, crackers break things' -- but the point is: yes this isn't a surprise, and in many cases the sophistication is not even too deep, but ya like many said: we need this to keep being published so the open community as a whole can understand, and circumvent if need be.