11 ms·
High protein diet not as bad for you as smoking
- himangshuj 13y agowas getting sick and tired of social media posts by militant vegeterians. NHS restores sanity to my life
- andyjohnson0 13y agoVegetarians eat protein too.
- andylei 13y agothis study was specifically about animal protein
- oneeyedpigeon 13y agoVegetarians eat animal protein too.
- mrfusion 13y agoAny thoughts on why the study finds one results for those 50-65, and a different result for 65 and older? Also isn't it possible teenagers and young adults could need way more protein than the middle aged?
- RyanZAG 13y agoProbably because the study was badly done. The difference in their results between 50-65 and 65+ is almost impossibly large and other studies done have never found those kinds of differences.
- bencollier49 13y agoIf there's a confounding variable, it's likely that it is affected by retirement. For instance, a high protein intake in someone who's fifty might signify junk-food lunches, whereas the same thing in a retired person might be a sign of a more affluent lifestyle in general. I suspect that there are confounding variables at work.
- bencollier49 13y agoAlso, given that they only chose one day on which to sample, it could be something as kooky as Catholics eating fish on a Friday and being regularly exposed to aromatic hydrocarbons from incense. The possibilities are virtually endless.
- dkrich 13y agoI once took a class in business school on medical pricing and the instructor said that if you look at a graph of life expectancy that a large percentage of the population dies in the 50-60 age range, but statistically people who live past the age of 60 or 65 (I can't remember the exact figure) will be likely to live to be over 75. In other words, once you make it past a certain age you are sort of screened out as somebody who is high-risk to die of certain ailments like heart disease or cancer. So if we take that to be generally accurate, then these findings make sense because I would wager that if you studied any diet or habit thought to be unhealthy, more people would die off between 50-65 than after 65. This also explains why averages don't make sense with regard to any conversation about life expectancy since the averages really need to be observed in bands.
- mikeash 13y agoThat has the dank stench of an urban legend. According to the CDC, death rates increase monotonically with age once you pass early childhood, and begin to increase dramatically at about age 65: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/dvs/MortFinal2007_Worktable23r.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/dvs/MortFinal2007_Worktable23r.... Here's another breakdown from the Social Security Administration that shows each year individually: http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/STATS/table4c6.html http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/STATS/table4c6.html The latest age where the death rate decreases is 27, and the decrease is extremely small.
- dkrich 13y agoI dunno the instructor was a surgeon and faculty member at the University of Michigan medical school. Not saying that makes him correct but I wouldn't be too quick to dispute him either. Besides, death rates increasing monotonically is not at odds with what I am saying. Once a person reaches age 65, their odds of reaching age 85 are higher than the average person at the age of 50. Many serious medical problems onset between the ages of 50-65. With each passing year, people who are susceptible to hereditary illnesses, for example, will die. This leaves people less likely to succumb to those illnesses. Yes, within the smaller group mortality rates will be higher than the previous overall group because more medical complications occur as you age. In short what I am saying is that even though overall death rates increase, the odds of each person in those groups of living to the age of 85, goes up after the age of 65.
- kybernetyk 13y agoWere there really people thinking that inhaling a mix of highly carcinogenic compounds would be less harmful than eating protein?
- Cless 13y agoThat's the world we live in. "You need to eat healthier," says a skinny person smoking a cigarette and drinking alcohol.
- codelap 13y agoDrinking alcohol has many health benefits. Even a beer a day, something that 'common sense' would lead you to think was unhealthy, demonstrates to be good for your overall health. And eating processed foods while smoking and drinking would likely be more detrimental than eating well, while smoking and drinking. The hard part is determining what eating well is.
- stdbrouw 13y agoPeople keep yapping on about the health benefits of alcohol, red wine in particular, but I'd be impressed if you could find me a single drinker who only ever drinks that one unit of alcohol a day. At that point it very quickly stops being beneficial to your health.
- apierre 13y agoHold on - are you sure this article wasn't XSS injected by meat eaters?
- cstavish 13y agoOr worse, you "self-XSS" injected it while in a fugue state.
- JoeAltmaier 13y ago"Among those aged 50-65, those who ate a high protein diet were 74% more likely to die during follow up than those who ate a low protein diet (hazard ratio (HR) 1.74, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.02 to 2.97). People in this age group who ate a high protein diet were more than four times as likely to die from cancer during follow up than those who ate a low protein diet (HR 4.33, 95% CI 1.96 to 9.56). The results were similar once the researchers took into account the proportion of calories consumed from fat and carbohydrates. Further analyses suggested that animal protein was responsible for a considerable part of this relationship, particularly for death from any cause. However, the opposite effect of high protein intake was seen among those aged over 65."
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoLooking at "animal protein" as a broad category is dumb. The interesting health questions are specifically about muscle meat. Eating a lot of muscle meat, to the exclusion of organ meat and collagen and dairy protein, probably provides too much iron and too much tryptophan in the amino acid profile. Furthermore, you can't just talk about "meat". The distinction between fish, pork, chicken, and ruminants matters. The question of quality matters enormously. Are we talking about really cheap meat fed on moldy corn slop and handled improperly after slaughter (aged, dyed, pumped up with water and chemicals), or totally fresh grass fed beef?
- bryanlarsen 13y agoThere's also a significant different between unprocessed and processed meat, which these studies don't differentiate. Processed meat also varies widely in the kind of chemicals used in the processing.
- rottyguy 13y agoIs there a good definition of processed food anywhere? All the ones I've seen have been made by examples (eg. Processed foods like hotdogs, bologne, etc.). Is it any food that have anything added to them for preservation or enhancements (eg is oj enriched with vitamin D considered a processed food). Many articles are confusing and seem to make processed food to be wholey bad w/o really defining what makes it bad...
- wprl 13y agoIt's not meant to be a precise definition as most food is "processed" in some way. Rather it is a reaction against the excessive, unnecessary processing that is basically taken for granted, and everything that goes with it: pasteurization, hydrogenation of fats, ammoniated "beef," "meaty" foods†, GMO, high sodium content, high pesticide content, synthetic estrogens leaching from plastics, decreased nutritional content, rancidity, hormones, dyes, synthetic preservatives, etc., etc., etc. People who are more conscious of the hyperbole often prefer the term "minimally processed." † There are legal requirements for what percent of a meat needs to be present to be a considered meat, thus we get things like "beefy tacos" which contain a meat-like product with so much filler they do not meet the already low standards of what the USDA considers to be meat.
- tjaerv 13y agohttp://www.proteinpower.com/drmike/statistics/observational-studies-2/ http://www.proteinpower.com/drmike/statistics/observational-... "Researchers doing observational studies have much the same problem. They try to think of all the differences between two large populations of subjects so that they can statistically negate them so that only the observation in question – the vitamin C level in the example above – is different between the groups. Problem is they can never possibly think of all the differences between the groups. As a consequence, they never have a perfect study with exactly the same number, sex, age, lifestyle, etc. on both sides with the only difference being the study parameter. And so they don’t really ever prove anything. In fact, we would all probably be a lot better off if all the researchers doing observational studies had followed my lead and fallen asleep mid study."
- raverbashing 13y agoThis is one important issue I'm wondering if there are better statistical tools to deal with it today. Give it the individual profile of each person and let it draw the correlations.
- retrogradeorbit 13y agoThe China–Cornell–Oxford Project ruled out population differences by using a very large monoculture, rural China. http://web.archive.org/web/20090223222003/http://www.nutrition.cornell.edu/ChinaProject/ http://web.archive.org/web/20090223222003/http://www.nutriti... And even though it was epidemiological (statistically based), it's findings were strong and it confirmed prior laboratory results and hypotheses.
- Evgeny 13y agoFor an interesting and deep analysis of China Study, one can look at http://rawfoodsos.com/2010/07/07/the-china-study-fact-or-fallac/ http://rawfoodsos.com/2010/07/07/the-china-study-fact-or-fal... She uses Campbell's own figures, but comes to almost diametrally opposite results. It's up to statisticians here to judge how right or wrong she is ...
- tjaerv 13y ago
- Evgeny 13y agoDon't forget that it is not easy to remove confounding with smoking, drinking, low physical activity etc. as, incidentally, those who eat most meat happen to also score worse with those factors. Of course, there are statistical methods, but there are reasons to believe that not all confounding may be properly removed. For those interested in statistics behind studies like this, I think this (not very long) video is a good explanation why it is not so easy to remove all residual confounding: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hnWaNThBFw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hnWaNThBFw The lector actually discusses a very similar or even the same study - mortality as a function of meat consumption. Not too complicated for a technical person even without a background in statistics, I believe.
- Dewie 13y ago> Don't forget that it is not easy to remove confounding with smoking, drinking, low physical activity etc. as, incidentally, those who eat most meat happen to also score worse with those factors. And those who aim to be healthy will probably try to be at least moderate w.r.t their meat intake because they have heard that meat is unhealthy, which further "proves" that meat is unhealthy, while in reality it might be because of other habits that they might have, like exercising. Things like paleo might make things a little less one-sided.
- mberning 13y agoI like how people think one study is enough to upend an entire body of knowledge. Never mind the fact that there is an intense amount of bias in nutritional research. Never mind the fact that the results of many studies cannot be accurately reproduced. Never mind the fact that observational studies generally suck and cannot 'prove' anything. Nah, this new study, which happens to conform to my preconceived notions, this new study changes EVERYTHING.
- crusso 13y agoRead down toward the bottom: the study was based upon one self-reported day of each individual's diet extrapolated over 18 years. This study is even less meaningful than most. I'd go so far as to say that it's utterly devoid of useful information and quite probably is misinformation. I wonder how much was spent on performing the study?
- bunderbunder 13y agoI wouldn't necessarily be so quick to knee-jerk throw out that technique. Perhaps it's like BMI where it's an approach that's completely inappropriate for assessing an individual, but when applied to a population its shortcomings average out in a way that lets it serve as a valid statistical tool for certain purposes. I think the real story here is illustrated in the contrast between that last section that you mention, and how many folks are reacting to this study: The actual science is full of nuances and caveats which experts in the field are expected to understand, and like literally any scientific paper its results should be considered tentative unless and until it's been corroborated by further research, including research that uses different protocols. The public reaction, on the other hand, treats this as if it should be a cut-and-dry statement on a black-and-white issue.
- AnIrishDuck 13y ago> like literally any scientific paper its results should be considered tentative unless and until it's been corroborated by further research, including research that uses different protocols To expand, this study is interesting in that it opens an avenue for further investigation. It's like learning an extra person was at the scene of crime. It proves nothing, and doesn't even necessarily SUGGEST anything. It's just another "lead" that researchers should investigate. In this case, it doesn't help that the additional "suspect" is something sexy like protein-rich diets. > The public reaction, on the other hand, treats this as if it should be a cut-and-dry statement on a black-and-white issue. That's because the public as a whole usually wants cut-and-dry statements and black-and-white issues. And the news caters to the public.
- circlefavshape 13y agoIf The Telegraph reported this as the NHS describes then this strikes me as profoundly irresponsible journalism. I'm no fan of The Telegraph, but I'm actually a little bit shocked
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoKind of a low bar to hurdle, don't you think?
- pistle 13y agoSmoke your meat, my friends. A cross-sectional study of this type of data will yield crappy, linkbait-friendly results. For confounders, they didn't look at: income, geography, genetics (self-reported ethnicity is not a good proxy), etc. etc. etc. The time and sample scale for powerful epidemiological research often seems higher than publish! publish! publish! researchers are given time and money to do. Any morsel of truth to animal protein having a negative effect is lost in the structure of the study and data available.
- duncanawoods 13y agoThe NHS makes me very proud here. A well written next-day response to widely published bad science journalism of the worst sort. That headline was plastered across the front-pages of all the newspapers I read with no caveats. Both scare-mongering of unproven dangers and diminishing of more certain dangers like smoking & dietary excess. IMHO media outlets should be heavily fined for bad science journalism. Its a grave form of libel but poor injured science isn't able to sue them for it.
- cjg 13y agoI agree - I'm impressed with the NHS on their detailed and rapid response. I was pleasantly surprised.
- aaxe 13y agoEven more in-depth, very interesting: http://examine.com/blog/high-protein-diets-linked-to-cancer-should-you-be-concerned/ http://examine.com/blog/high-protein-diets-linked-to-cancer-...
- jokoon 13y agoThere was an article once with the title "sitting is as bad as smoking". I don't know why the bad health reference is smoking really.
- jrockway 13y agoI recommend a balanced diet containing equal parts high fructose corn syrup and monosodium glutamate. Note: this post was sponsored by High Fructose Corn Syrup and Monosodium Glutamate Industries, Inc.
- tuan5 13y agowho should I listen?
- antidaily 13y agoCheck out Wilco. Great band.
- Harj 13y agoThis is another good analysis of why this study was flawed: http://examine.com/blog/high-protein-diets-linked-to-cancer-should-you-be-concerned/ http://examine.com/blog/high-protein-diets-linked-to-cancer-...
- shittyanalogy 13y ago"Information on food intake was only collected for one 24-hour period... ...this may have changed over the 18 years of follow up" I wonder if the researchers' and USC's ploy to use sensationalist(though outright false) PR is going to end in them getting more funding. I hope not, but they do say no publicity is bad publicity.