11 ms·
Not even "in place of" but "in addition to". There's a reason that the script tag has a language attribute as part of the standard.
by lisper 13y ago
Not even "in place of" but "in addition to". There's a reason that the script tag has a language attribute as part of the standard.
- patrickmay 13y agoThis I would love to see. I'm not aware of any project working to enable Scheme or Common Lisp in the browser, though. Anyone else?
- ctdavies 13y agoClojureScript is a subset of Clojure that compiles to Google Closure-optimized JavaScript, so close enough, right?
- lgas 13y agoGoogling turned up several on just the first page of results: http://www.biwascheme.org/ http://www.biwascheme.org/ http://sisc-scheme.org/sisc-online.php http://sisc-scheme.org/sisc-online.php http://lisperator.net/slip/ http://lisperator.net/slip/ http://alex.nisnevich.com/ecmachine/ http://alex.nisnevich.com/ecmachine/ But the parent is really the right answer -- ClojureScript is actually targeted at meeting modern web development challenges and has a thriving ecosystem of powerful tools for the same.
- patrickmay 13y agoCompiling to Javascript isn't what I find interesting. I'd like support for <script type="text/lisp" language="common-lisp" src="web-ui.lisp">. Pure Lisp, compiled for the user's browser and OS. No Javascript anywhere.
- sitkack 13y agoYou can do this now <script src="biwascheme.js"> (console-log "Hello, world!") </script>
- patrickmay 13y agoYou see that ".js" in your example? I don't want it. I would like to know how to implement and deploy a scripting engine that has no dependencies on Javascript whatsoever.
- sitkack 13y agoThat doesn't materially matter. I know you don't want it, but it in no way effects the computation.
- pmbauer 13y agohttp://hoplon.io/ http://hoplon.io/ is a lot closer to the Hickey/Norvig/Anderson paper.
- Ygg2 13y agoI'm afraid you're browser doesn't support XScript, please download Chrome Explorer 310. On a serious note, JavaScript and the lack of fragmentation is one of the best features of Web. You don't have to download appropriate browsers (in theory and mostly in practice) to run your website.
- taeric 13y agoThis is one of the things that baffles me with the somewhat radical things getting added to javascript this go around. I mean, I can't argue that there are some things that will be nice to have. However, it seems that going with additions that are not addable as a library is contrary to the bloody web. Or, am I wrong and the new syntactical changes will be ok? Also... this pretty much exemplifies how/why lisp would have been awesome. Quite literally everything could be done "as a library."
- lisper 13y ago> I'm afraid you're browser doesn't support XScript, please download Chrome Explorer 310. But this sort of thing already happens all the time. You don't have the right flash player, or the right silverlight player, or the right version of Java. There would be very little difference in the UX between different scripting languages and the current UX w.r.t. media codexes, and the end result would be the same in both cases: there would be some repertoire of languages and codexes that everyone uses and become standard. The alternative is to forever have to deal with a language that by design cannot even handle integer math or unicode strings properly.
- randallsquared 13y ago> But this sort of thing already happens all the time. You don't have the right flash player, or the right silverlight player, or the right version of Java. That's exactly the point. Imagine dozens of them.
- lisper 13y agoDozens of what? Browser plugins? I don't have to imagine, that's the world we live in. Dozens of languages? I very much doubt that will happen. Just as we only have a small handful of codexes that actually matter (Flash, Silverlight, H264, maybe ogg) I predict that we will end up with a small number of languages that actually matter: Javascript, Python, Ruby, and Scheme. Maybe CL. IMHO that would be a better world than the one we currently live in. Javascript is serviceable for its original purpose, but for serious webapps it's broken beyond redemption. NOTE: This is not to say that it is impossible to write serious webapps in Javasceript. Obviously it is possible. What I mean is that at some point the aggregate cost of dealing with Javascript's design flaws becomes greater than the aggregate cost of dealing with multiple browser scripting languages.
- pekk 13y agoYou are right, I misspoke and would have said "in addition to"