14 ms·
From "The Zen of Programming": ------ Hearing a disturbance, the master programmer went into the novice's cubicle. "Curse these personal computers!" cried th
by tzs 13y ago
From "The Zen of Programming":
------
Hearing a disturbance, the master programmer went into the novice's cubicle.
"Curse these personal computers!" cried the novice in anger, "To make them do anything I must use three or even four editing programs. Sometimes I get so confused that I erase entire files. This is truly intolerable!"
The master programmer stared at the novice. "And what would you do to remedy this state of affairs?" he asked.
The novice thought for a moment. "I will design a new editing program," he said, "a program that will replace all these others."
Suddenly the master struck the novice on the side of his head. It was not a heavy blow, but the novice was nonetheless surprised. "What did you do that for?" exclaimed the novice.
"I have no wish to learn another editing program," said the master.
And suddenly the novice was enlightened.
- Gracana 13y agoI think the first assertion is simply untrue, and without it the rest is nonsense. You don't need to learn how to use multiple editors to do anything. I suppose there are some languages/environments that are somewhat tied to certain editors (java and eclipse, C# and visual studio, objective-C and xcode), but that's not what is proposed here. It's a general purpose programmer's editor that anyone can use for anything. Are you really upset that it's being written? Why do you think you'll have to learn it?
- greyskull 13y agoI think it's also worth mentioning that Atom, like Sublime, looks straight-forward out of the box. You don't need to learn much to be productive. It doesn't have the learning curve of vim/emacs, but it's more powerful than Sublime/Notepad++/Gedit etc. Also, I don't think anyone needs more than one general purpose text editor like vim or Sublime or Notepad++, and possibly a full-featured IDE like IntelliJ or Visual Studio. If there's a counter-argument, I'd like to read it.
- rjzzleep 13y agotbh with you i've used both omnisharp and eclim with vim. you get full IDE features as well as refactoring inside of vim. for most things you can use vim as a full featured IDE these days. well for refactoring you might have a few issues on, say, c++ and objective-c [] http://eclim.org http://eclim.org [] https://github.com/nosami/Omnisharp https://github.com/nosami/Omnisharp
- dsilver 13y agoThe solution for n competing standards is n + 1 competing standards.[0] [0] https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- hnriot 13y agoI love learning new things! If it's better then I am more than happy to learn it, otherwise we'd all still be using EDT... This "master programmer" need to stop abusing his novices, stop resting on his laurels and get back to some learning.
- jshen 13y agowe all have far less time than it would require to learn all of the interesting things. Once you get good with an editor your time is much better spent learning a new data structure, algorithm, language paradigm, etc than learning a new editor.
- brodo 13y agoThats maybe true for the vims and emacses of the world, but these new editors come with a fancy pants thing called a GUI. These GUI thingys adhere to certain standards and customs that are set by the OS. I do some web development work from time to time and therefore I have multiple browsers installed on my machine. I can switch between them without having to dig through a manual! I have to learn hardly anything!
- vidarh 13y agoI don't know how long Emacs has had a GUI, but it's at least 20 years. I don't remember what the graphical capabilities of GNU Emacs are like, as I only use the command line version, but XEmacs at least also has extensive support for bitmaps graphics in buffers that far exceeds most of these "new editors".
- craigching 13y agoGNU emacs can show bitmap images. I'm on the latest version 24.x and just tried it out, so I'm not sure when it was added.
- vidarh 13y ago
- beltex 13y agoIt's a fair point, but by this rationale no new DBs or PLs should be made. Most of these die off or become niche, the ones that really become fundamental are few and far between. This idea that we have to drop everything and go "learn" this new thing is bogus. Folks in tech often seem to buy into the hype of some new technology all too easily, riding the wave of excitement. So their shouldn't be any concerns, of "yet another editor”. BTW, I'm not saying this won't be successful! It looks interesting and I am excited, GitHub does great work, but you keep it in perspective.
- gavinpc 13y ago> Sometimes I get so confused that I erase entire files OT, but just this week my wife did something that really got me thinking about how far computers haven't come in terms of usability. I heard her say "O crap" from behind her macbook, and out of habit I came to assist. For some reason unknown to both of us, she had pasted the text of an email into a document called "thesis.docx", and then saved it. The text was completely unrelated to "thesis.docx", which of course was not backed up. Now, I love my wife deeply. And she is no fool. On the contrary, she is a graduate student. Moreover, I completely understand how something like this can happen. We have two small children, and it was the end of the day. It is just too much to expect of the human mind that one should not say something one doesn't mean. I felt guilty on behalf of my profession that this was the best we had to offer. Microsoft word on a macbook, and your penultimate version of a file is not backed up. It truly is intolerable. So, while I have had some of my greatest highs using emacs macros, I somehow feel that the brilliant tooling made by developers for developers never quite percolates into userland.
- nhangen 13y agoCmd z?
- greyskull 13y agoShe probably had closed the file before the "o crap". Undo does no good there.
- unfunco 13y agoThen this really isn't a usability issue, if you replace the entire contents of a document with the clipboard, then click or shortcut to save, then click or shortcut to quit the application, that's really a human issue. It's too many steps to be labelled as a usability problem. ⌘-Z should have been adequate.
- sillysaurus3 13y agoIf the computer remembered every modification of every document, then users would be protected from incidents like this.
- ryanac 13y agoCould that also be interpreted as: ------ Hearing a disturbance, the master programmer went into the novice's cubicle. "Curse these search engines!" cried the novice in anger, "To find anything I must scroll through three or even four pages of results. Sometimes I get so confused that I just give up. This is truly intolerable!" The master programmer stared at the novice. "And what would you do to remedy this state of affairs?" he asked. The novice thought for a moment. "I will design a new search engine," he said, "a search engine that will replace all these others." Suddenly the master struck the novice on the side of his head. It was not a heavy blow, but the novice was nonetheless surprised. "What did you do that for?" exclaimed the novice. "I have no wish learn another search engine," said the master. The novice packed his bags, left and went on to create Google, which gives him exactly the results he's looking for. While his former master was left sifting through multiple pages of results on (insert other search engine here). One day the master stumbled upon Google and the master was enlightened.
- baby 13y agosomewhate relevent: https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- Wintamute 13y agoIf the master thinks that the human race has reached the absolute pinnacle of human/machine interfacing for text editing after just a few short decades of trying then he needs to go away and have a little sit down and a think about where he went wrong in life.
- Kluny 13y agoNah man, you're not enlightened. He's not saying don't build a new editor, just that you had better think long and hard before you decide to foist another learning curve on the world, and act like you're doing it a favor. Also, https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- Wintamute 13y agoNobody foists a text editor on anybody, they live or die on their merits as a text editor. And besides, where would the world be know without people trying to make things better? The master's wisdom is weak in this case! I strike him on the side of his head! Slap!