18 ms·
Depression is an inflammatory disease; where does inflammation come from? [pdf]
- hmhrex 13y agoCan't wait to read this. As a person who has dealt with severe depression, and has come through it alive, I'm always interested in new research on the subject.
- tannerc 13y agoSame. From what I've read so far (only partially through the paper) a lot of this is what we already know, but with more evidence for the claims. Really helpful for those of us who continue to combat depression on a regular basis.
- cpncrunch 13y agoActually, I think you might be better looking elsewhere for help with depression. In my own experience, and that of other people I know, psychological factors have always been the main cause of depression, and resolving them results in curing the depression. The problem is that it isn't always easy to identify the factors causing the depression. As for the science: we do know that both psychological stressors and infections both cause inflammation. Stress results in activation of the HPA axis and sympathetic nervous system, which screws up the immune system in various ways (including inflammation). Conversely, having a severe infection can make you feel depressed. It's really just a theory that inflammation causes depression. I think it's more likely that it's a result of cortisol and/or neurotransmitters (i.e. too much brain activity). Cortisol seems a more likely candidate for being central to depression in my opinion. The science here seems to be based on a desire to have a physical rather than a psychological cause for depression. Michael Maes has a history of that (see his CFS publications).
- saraid216 13y agoIt's legitimate to use a chemical response as a short-term solution, if it's safe and non-addictive. This walks straight into the "every case is different" territory, though.
- dhoulb 13y agoSeems like taking action in the real world and avoiding sources of inflammation would have a positive psychological effect. Giving the person a feeling of control over one area of their life. Surely that would be beneficial, whether or not the link between depression and inflammation is scientifically proven?
- cpncrunch 13y agoSure, anything can be a placebo effect. However I myself prefer to understand exactly what is happening rather than believing fairy stories, and I think it's fairer to patients as well. Unfortunately there is a lot of dubious science out there, and a lot of patients who prefer the fairy stories. Having said that, doing things like exercising and having a good diet will certainly improve health. Exercise has proven to be very beneficial for depression, although I don't think that inflammation has been proven to be what mediates the effect.
- jaggederest 13y agoI suspect there may be some posts here dismissing a lot of this as obvious - but it's actually really interesting to hear further evidence that a lot of lifestyle factors really do play a large role as we thought. The best part about things like this is that, as they say, they're amenable to change - you can affect them, so you can reduce the severity of the feedback loop that makes depression so insidious.
- dfc 13y agoIf a lot of depression's hows/whats/whys were "obvious" this article would not be included in the journal's "Current Controversies in Psychiatry."[^1] [^1]: https://www.biomedcentral.com/bmcmed/series/CCP https://www.biomedcentral.com/bmcmed/series/CCP
- lectrick 13y agoThis is actually a fascinating paper. Keep reading until you see the connection between inflammation, exercise and depression... Wow!
- pvnick 13y agoOmega-3 fatty acids, which are important components of many healthy foods, such as seafood, nuts, legumes and leafy green vegetables, act to reduce inflammation Score another point for fish oil supplementation, on top of the already enormous pile of scientific research showing it to be a miracle chemical (and I definitely don't say that lightly) [2]. Seriously, if you aren't getting enough omega 3 fatty acids, either from regularly eating lots of fatty fish or through supplementation, you're seriously missing out on some good stuff. Among supplement enthusiasts, it's consistently declared to be one of the only supplements that's actually useful. I prefer the liquid form [1]. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Now-Foods-Omega-Lemon-Flavor/dp/B001B4NFNS http://www.amazon.com/Now-Foods-Omega-Lemon-Flavor/dp/B001B4... [2] http://examine.com/supplements/Fish+Oil/ http://examine.com/supplements/Fish+Oil/ Edit: added [2], a well-written examine.com page summarizing fish oil effects
- derefr 13y agoIt's not that fish oil is an unalloyed good, mind; just that we get way too much Omega-6 in western diets, and it seems that Omega-3 "cancels it out." In cultures with balanced Omega-3/6 intake, like Japan, fish oil has no benefit.
- brational 13y agoCorrect. The alternative to pounding fish oil supplements is simply stop eating so much refined seed and vegetable oils. A ratio can always be fixed in at least 2 ways obviously.
- teach 13y agoIt's harder than that. Our food supply has changed; sixty years ago when cows ate grasses, beef naturally had some omega-3s in it. Now that their diet is largely corn, beef brings virtually all omega-6s. Ditto for "shelf-stable" foods. Omega-3 fatty acids go rancid at room temperature, so many packaged products have had the omega-3-based fats removed so they'll last longer on the shelves. Source: my wife, who has a PhD in nutrition.
- derefr 13y agoI'm curious: does this imply that plain-old non-specific anti-inflammatory drugs combat depression? I'm aware that sleep-deprivation, cold-caps, and, oddly-enough, ketamine all have anti-depressant effects, and that these are mostly unexplained—would the link here be that these things have anti-inflammatory effects on the brain?
- jmhain 13y agoExcept apparently they do the opposite. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/04/110425153602.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/04/110425153602.ht...
- meowface 13y ago>Except apparently they do the opposite. Welcome to every debate on nutrition, supplements, and pharmaceuticals in history. Regardless, the study you linked says they reduce the effectiveness of SSRIs, not that they exacerbate depression.
- Lerc 13y agoI suffer from depression and a grab bag of auto-immune/inflammatory conditions. The drug that seems to have the biggest impact upon my depression is Etanercept despite it being primarily to treat my arthritis etc, Ketamine would be cheaper. hell, heroin would be cheaper.
- pantalaimon 13y agoKetamine is actually quite effective http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/article.aspx?articleid=1733363 http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/article.aspx?articleid=17333...
- Alex3917 13y ago> does this imply that plain-old non-specific anti-inflammatory drugs combat depression? Yes, but taking them doesn't solve the underlying problem, and they're not safe to take on a daily basis. If you were going to use an anti-inflammatory though then CBD or THCA would probably be better than, say, ibuprofen.
- courtf 13y agoPretty fascinating, I didn't realize there were any links between depression and inflammation. In addition to suffering from depression starting at a fairly young age, I also have allergic reactions that result in inflammatory responses to seemingly random environmental factors. This is something that appears to run in the family. I wonder if addressing the allergic symptom would suppress some of the depressive ones?
- marze 13y agoA diet described in a book titled "Perfect Health Diet" has been reported to help with allergies.
- manmal 13y agoI've suffered quite a lot from inflammatory responses to food (especially gluten and casein) and had mental symptoms similar to depression (not clinical though). Water retention, pain, weakness, the whole lot. It took some years until I made the connection and have since stayed on a gluten- and casein-free diet, adding fish oil and apple cider vinegar. I lost > 30 pounds since (inflammation seems to cancel out weight loss) and feel great mentally (most of the time). Whenever I have a setback, I become irritable and depressive - usually quickly revertable by two fish oil capsules and a glass of diluted ACV (moodiness disappears within 2 hours; water retention takes 1-2 days to disappear again - this seems to be associated with the lymphatic system).
- rtre 13y agoInteresting, just the other day I was listening to Joe Rogan's podcast with Dr.Rhonda Patrick (#459). If I recall correctly, they breifly discuss inflammation. She goes on to mention that elevated levels of "C-reactive protein" in the blood is used as a marker for inflammation. The podcast is worth a listen, they go into other topics such as nutrition, vitamins & minerals, etc. http://podcasts.joerogan.net/podcasts/dr-rhonda-patrick http://podcasts.joerogan.net/podcasts/dr-rhonda-patrick
- ivan_ah 13y agodirect link: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/11/200 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/11/200
- abdophoto 13y agoInflammation in the body has been correlated with a lot of diseases believe it or not. Gluten is one of the big contributors to inflammation in the body. A lot of people laugh at the whole "Gluten Free" thing, but there's a good bit of evidence that significantly reducing or removing it from your diet can make a serious impact.
- josephpmay 13y agoCould you point me to the "good bit of evidence" that shows this?
- abdophoto 13y agoLess than 2 years ago, my wife was diagnosed with MS (Multiple sclerosis). As soon as we found out, I started digging like crazy to learn more about why this happened and what we could do to prevent it from progressing. I'm a big believer in that the body has the ability to heal itself by avoiding certain foods and intaking others. I mean, food is fuel we put in our body. After digging for a while, I came upon some staggering discoveries. First, there are people who have reversed their MS almost completely on diet alone. The diets consist of A LOT of high-nutrition fruits and vegetables along with Omega 3's, organic meats, etc. These Paleo-like diets also forbid gluten with the main reason being that it causes serious inflammation in some folks. This TEDx video by Dr. Terry Wahl was very helpful (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLjgBLwH3Wc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLjgBLwH3Wc). I read her book and it literally laid the foundation for which changed our eating habits entirely. A month or so after, we flew out to Massachusetts to a well-known wellness center where they performed various blood and stool tests. The Dr's (including a Nutritionist) sat down with us for the entire day and asked about daily habits from what our work days were like to what we ate. Without mentioning my own research, they also said that gluten is something we should completely remove from our diet. There's a ton of other stuff out there, but since removing gluten entirely, my wife has felt great. We just did an MRI and she has no new lesions. She no longer experiences blurriness or weakness which is great. It may not be completely because of Gluten, but removing seems to have seriously made a impact.
- 13y ago
- kingkawn 13y agoWhy is there an assumption that the inflammation comes from anything other than the mind state of depression itself?
- jonsen 13y agohttp://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/depression-re-examined-a-new-way-to-look-at-an-old-puzzle/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/depression-re-examined-a...
- cpncrunch 13y agoThat study is interesting, but doesn't mention inflammation. It basically says that depression is a result of stress.
- jonsen 13y agoExactly. Then maybe the order is stress -> depression -> inflammation.
- cpncrunch 13y agoI think that is likely. Or perhaps depression and inflammation are both a result of stress (through HPA axis and SNS activation).
- kingkawn 13y agoI guess my original point is that they're trying to look for the mechanism of the inflammation because they assume that by solving the inflammation that the depression will be solved, whereas it could be that the inflammation is a protective reaction against depression the same way that it is a in large part a protective reaction against other forms of illness.
- mattgreenrocks 13y agoThe link between depression and inflammation is news to me. Is it fully accepted, or still being worked on? I've had bad run-ins with both, sometimes, at the same time. A particular case was a bad burnout incident I endured a few years ago. I saw many doctors trying to figure out why my hands and wrists had enormous amounts of tension. MRIs, x-rays, and conduction tests showed no issues. I had to leave my job and rest for several months entirely to be able to use them again. Because of this, I've always suspected a stronger mind-body link than traditional Western medicine currently admits to (obvious caveat of n = 1). It seems that whatever state my mind is in, my body follows soon after. Mental anxiety begets physical tension. It's like my whole body downclocks itself to deal with things. The mind will get it's way, no matter how much you resist.
- aestra 13y ago>Because of this, I've always suspected a stronger mind-body link than traditional Western medicine currently admits to (obvious caveat of n = 1). It seems that whatever state my mind is in, my body follows soon after. Mental anxiety begets physical tension. It's like my whole body downclocks itself to deal with things. Um every western medical practitioner "admits" to this kind of mind body connection.
- dllthomas 13y agoI think western medicine is pretty on board with the notion that significant stress causes (or exacerbates) other issues. As just one random example: http://www.webmd.com/mental-health/effects-of-stress-on-your-body http://www.webmd.com/mental-health/effects-of-stress-on-your...
- mattgreenrocks 13y agoYeah, but no doctors asked about my stress, or emotional health, or anything that could have started me down the line of investigation. I treated it as an isolated physical problem, not a symptom of stress/mental issues. The response was always the same: "we don't know...sorry." Maybe I should've realized that stress was killing me, but I was severely depressed. It's not like I could see myself objectively.
- bunderbunder 13y agoYou can practically set your watch by the timing of the latest meme that purports to identify the One True Panacea for Clinical Depression™. Looking like it'll be time to pull the crown on mine pretty soon.
- yogi123 13y agoRecent articles have tied omega 3 intake to increased risk of prostate cancer. Got a lot of press last year. I took Omega 3 for the last 14 years. Spent thousands buying Nordic Naturals from Whole Foods at $25/bottle. Whenever I'd stop taking it, I felt a decline in mood so thought it had good systemic benefits. When I went off it this time, I felt zero change before or after (haven't taken since last summer). This study was the last straw. I'd already given up supplements and even a daily multivitamin as studies indicate no positive effect and possible harm. Now I take no supplements. The more I read the more I'm convinced it's faulty science and marketing. A healthy, varied diet of mainly plant based foods should provide all that most people need. If you look at links to omega 3 studies on Wikipedia I don't recall there being conclusive positive evidence, but maybe I'm wrong. Couple of links on prostate cancer study and whether it's accurate or not: http://www.cancer.org/cancer/news/omega-3-fatty-acids-linked-to-increase-in-prostate-cancer-risk http://www.cancer.org/cancer/news/omega-3-fatty-acids-linked... http://health.heraldtribune.com/2013/08/26/dr-oz-omega-3-cancer-link-pretty-fishy/ http://health.heraldtribune.com/2013/08/26/dr-oz-omega-3-can... http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2013/07/31/omega-3-fats.aspx http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2013/07/3...
- js2 13y agoStill, some vitamins may be worth supplementing depending upon your diet, exposure to sun, and activity level. For example: http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+D/ http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+D/ http://examine.com/supplements/Magnesium/ http://examine.com/supplements/Magnesium/ http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+K/ http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+K/
- meowface 13y agoIs there an effective way to know which vitamins you're missing? Can full blood tests help tell you which vitamins you should be taking daily?
- marvin 13y agoIt would be so fantastic if we could just have a chip implanted to continuously measure this stuff, then download it and analyze on a daily, weekly, monthly and annual basis. There's so much cool science to be done here, especially if this is done on a global scale.
- adammil 13y agoCan anyone acquainted with the hard sciences comment on whether this paper passes even a basic sniff test? The title of the paper and so many references to other psychiatry journals seem like potential red flags.
- stared 13y agoI saw some red flags as well (see my comment), so I asked a question: http://cogsci.stackexchange.com/questions/5841/is-it-universally-accepted-that-depression-is-an-inflammatory-disease http://cogsci.stackexchange.com/questions/5841/is-it-univers...
- LyndsySimon 13y agoAre you saying you find it... fishy?
- cpncrunch 13y agoIt seems to be mostly wishful thinking...see my other comment here.
- stared 13y agoSome premises of this article are at least sound, at least, fishy. Easy language, lot of promises, and a lot of plausible things but not necessarily with causal relation. It starts with "We now know that depression is associated with [...]", where AFAIK we are far from pinning down etiology of depression (there may be multiple mechanisms, etc). And it is one of reasons why antidepressant have relatively low effectiveness. The abstract ends with a longer list of things that make it flashy. Moreover, things like smoking are sometimes considered actually having mildly anti-depressive effect (though it is disputed). I don't say that the paper is wrong. Just a paper not listing doubts and promising a lot should be less believed that one making very humble observations (but the later one would not make HN frontpage, hence the bias).
- lutusp 13y agoI'll bet this new empirical scientific result will make psychiatrists and psychologists abandon talk therapy and their questionable anti-depression drugs, right away, in the public interest. Let's all hold our breath for that outcome. http://www.planet-science.com/media/24009/holding%20breath_91390615_316x295.jpg http://www.planet-science.com/media/24009/holding%20breath_9...
- benched 13y agoLook I'll just say it. This strongly matches the pattern of all the other hiding-in-plain-sight, simplistic explanations for complex bio-existential problems, that turn out to be bullshit.
- marcosdumay 13y agoYet, nearly all breakthroughs in medicine seem to follow that same pattern, at least for me, an outsider. I can't throw it away that easily, and by the way you phrase your comment, I think you can't either. Yes, the fact that it is in the oppinion column isn't a good indicator... I'm in the "waitting further results" mode.
- illuminate 13y ago"Yet, nearly all breakthroughs in medicine seem to follow that same pattern, at least for me, an outsider." Yes, the pattern of selection bias.
- Harj 13y agoYou can check your inflammation levels via a blood test called hs-CRP (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C-reactive_protein http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C-reactive_protein). I took it and was surprised to learn I was in the high risk range. I tried a vegetarian diet for just under a month, re-tested and I'd dropped into the low risk range (this was the only lifestyle change I made that month). I found that a full vegetarian diet isn't sustainable for me so now I'm trying out only having meat once a day (usually for dinner) and will re-test to see what result that has. I suspect that the absence of meat may have been less important than the increase in vegetables. The caveat is that hs-CRP isn't a perfect test because your result can be spiked temporarily if e.g. your body is recovering from intense exercise or a cold. That's why I think it's a good test to do more regularly and have longitudinal data for. I've been spending a bunch of time getting more comprehensive blood tests recently. If you've any questions feel free to ping me (harjeet [dot] taggar [at] gmail).
- mattgreenrocks 13y agoVery interesting; where do you get your blood tested? AFAIK, you have to be willing to pay the lab expense, which is tailored for insurance.
- Harj 13y agoYes unfortunately most insurance won't cover any tests beyond the basic ones in your yearly medical. There are a few options: - WellnessFX (http://wellnessfx.com http://wellnessfx.com) offers the nicest experience and display of your results, but it's pricey and the tests all come bundled together so you can't pick just one or two you're interested in. - http://health-tests-direct.com http://health-tests-direct.com and http://directlabs.com http://directlabs.com are other options that have more a la carte options. - If you're in the Bay Area, the cheapest (by some distance) option is to use a new blood testing lab called Theranos, which has a location in the back of the Walgreens on University Ave in Palo Alto. If you download their lab order form (http://theranos.com/Content/pdf/theranos_lab_form.pdf http://theranos.com/Content/pdf/theranos_lab_form.pdf), tick the tests you'd like and have an MD sign it (doesn't have to be your doctor, could be a friend). You can take it into the Walgreens and they'll draw your blood there and email you the results a few days later.
- tokenadult 13y agoIt took me a while to slog through that whole long list of references at the end of the end of the article, but correlational study designs don't impress more by being numerous, especially when most of them are published in middling-to-lousy journals. That's what isn't fun about reading about medical issues here on Hacker News: too many of the articles kindly submitted here are of much too low quality to be worthy of our attention. There are some intriguing ideas in this opinion piece, but basically hardly anything there is backed up by experimental studies, not in a human study and not even in an animal study. The title of the article reflects an attempt to come up with a One True Cause of depression that surely is not the one true cause (most doctors who are experts in depression, or in inflammation, do NOT characterize depression as an "inflammatory disease") and then the article goes off the rails from there. Check back when there is better established evidence about treatment. A better read about depression by a more informed physician would be a book review submitted recently to HN[1] that was hardly noticed when it was submitted. [1] http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/depression-re-examined-a-new-way-to-look-at-an-old-puzzle/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/depression-re-examined-a...
- jmnicolas 13y agoI suffer from depression for more than 20 years. Here is what should be done to fight it effectively : - take anti-depressants - wake up every day early and at the same time (6 AM from Monday to Sunday) - when there is not enough sun outside, sit 30 minutes in front of a full specter lamp - eat healthy (vegetables & fish oil) - have some physical activity (walking, standing desk) - socialize If I was able to effectively do the last 3 things I think depression would have no impact in my life.
- josh-wrale 13y agoI have a conjecture about depression. I believe that autoimmune conditions (e.g. hypothyroidism, MS, vitamin D deficiency) are sometimes a result of the self-hate associated with severe bouts of depression. The individual feels adversely about their existence, and so the body sets about deconstructing itself. I would be very happy to learn this is never the case, but I suspect that it sometimes is the case. (see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo )