16 ms·
The New TextSecure: Privacy Beyond SMS
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zx2c4 13y agoI'd like to see OTR implement some of the groupchat enhancements of this, or at least see a TextSecure implementation for the desktop.
- moxie 13y agoWe are also interested in a TextSecure implementation for the desktop! Right now the protocol includes multi-device support, so the foundation is there for developing desktop and tablet apps that work seamlessly in conjunction with your phone. Our first desktop implementation is likely going to be a browser extension, feel free to jump in and get involved with that if you'd like.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- neumann 13y agoHow does multi-device implementation work (for the layman). Are the messages only delivered to the 'logged in' clients? So if I am logged in on the desktop my message exchanges are also sent to the phone client? But any messages I send/receive from my phone while logged out of my desktop are synced through the server on login?
- acqq 13y agoWhere can I read how they do that? Some protocol explanation please!
- maxerickson 13y agoThere are lots of links in the words there. A likely candidate is the link from "TextSecure V2 protocol".
- higherpurpose 13y agoThere are some links in the article. Granted you could've easily missed them since the color is some washed out grey. Moxie should consider making the links a more visible color.
- acqq 13y agoThanks. Now I tried to follow the links and I still don't understand how they managed to achieve that "The new TextSecure protocol doesn't require a round trip key exchange process." I'd still like to know how actually their solution protects from MITM.
- jlund 13y agoYou can read about the key exchange here. "Prekeys" are an extremely clever idea: https://whispersystems.org/blog/asynchronous-security/ https://whispersystems.org/blog/asynchronous-security/ Fingerprint verification protects against MITM attacks. The application provides a nice interface where two users can scan a QR code to easily compare fingerprints. A hexadecimal fingerprint is also readily accessible.
- acqq 13y agoIt looks that the prekeys are stored on a server. How is the existence of the prekeys on the server (which can be compromised) not an issue?
- robryk 13y agoPrekeys are prerecorded responses to connection initiation: in the alternative world with no prekeys this is what you'd get when you've opened a connection.
- darklajid 13y agoOkay, it seems the server is open source? And the protocol supports federation? Could I just run my own server and it will just work™ with users on a different server? Are you basically presenting me with an option next to xmpp/otr?
- xnyhps 13y agoWhen I looked at it (which is already a couple of months ago), federation wasn't “just works™”. A new server needed to be explicitly permitted into the federated network by WhisperSystems. Every server has a full copy of the list of clients and on which server they are and servers trust other severs completely when they claim “we serve the user with phone number 555-123456”.
- aw3c2 13y agoAww, that is a shame. I was imagining something like the XMPP server "cloud" where everyone can easily setup their own server, eg for a more private setup with their closer friends (who would then be motivated to use that server).
- darklajid 13y agoThanks a lot (also: Hi, I regularly bugged you on prosody's muc I guess). So in that case I'll stick with xmpp for my use case - self-hosting is just something that I wouldn't want to give up.
- bildeman 13y agoThat sucks. Is hosting a separate, smaller and unconnected network feasible?
- sschueller 13y agoI would think it should be possible to make a decentralized back-end where servers don't need to be trusted.
- xnyhps 13y agoNot if you want it to be “SMS based”, by which I mean: use phone numbers as identifiers. A server can’t easily prove to another that it serves the user with a specific phone number. There’s no cryptographic proof possible, there’s no hostname part like in email. You can verify by sending a text message, but that gets expensive if you need to do it often. This is trying to combine 3 points on Zooko's Triangle [1]: You want human-meaningful names (which phone numbers are, because they map to existing things), so you have to make a trade-off between decentralization and security. WhisperSystems opted for security for some reduced decentralization. For something that’s aiming to replace text messaging, I can’t really blame them for that choice. [1] = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zooko%27s_triangle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zooko%27s_triangle
- jokull 13y agoAs far as I can tell Telegram doesn’t have end-to-end encrypted group chat. This looks really good!
- pspeter3 13y agoHow does this compare with Hemlis https://heml.is https://heml.is
- r0muald 13y agoHemlis is XMPP+GnuPG based, so (according to TextSecure developers - but most agree) bad for asynchronous communication (XMPP) and without perfect forward secrecy (GnuPG).
- jlund 13y agoThey actually claim to be using NaCl now.
- devcpp 13y agoIt is released and 100% open source, unlike Hemlis, which is still under development behind closed doors and will be opened "as much as possible" (which tells us nothing about implementations, code quality, privacy features, openness or license).
- cgag 13y agoYeah, I can't see any reason to trust Hemlis.
- higherpurpose 13y agoFor starters, Hemlis is not open source. That should stop you in your track right there. If it doesn't, maybe the fact that they actually had to switch to another crypto system for Hemlis after much negative feedback from the community, should tell you more about their experience in this. But even that new one doesn't offer anything resembling forward secrecy. I think Hemlis will be more of a Threema clone, which also isn't open source. 1 - https://missingm.co/2014/02/fighting-dishfire-the-state-of-mobile-cross-platform-encrypted-messaging/ https://missingm.co/2014/02/fighting-dishfire-the-state-of-m...
- petsounds 13y agoWhisper Systems' headquarters is located in San Francisco, according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whisper_Systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whisper_Systems Doesn't that make them susceptible to a search warrant forcing them to give up the private keys (or equivalent) to TextSecure, ala Lavabit?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- privong 13y agoI'm pretty sure Whisper Systems never get any private keys, because the private keys are only stored on the end user devices.
- jpollock 13y agoLegal intercept legislation would likely require them to patch customer systems to allow the reporting of the key.
- anaphor 13y agoIf you're really paranoid then you should build the code yourself from github, not just install the version on the play store.
- bduerst 13y agoIn a compiler that was compiled by someone else. /tinfoil hat
- TacticalCoder 13y agoThat's why in the future we'll be using compilers which are open-source and using deterministic builds and double-compilation (or "n-compilation") : )
- dublinben 13y agoI'd really like to try their new app, but they only distribute it through Google Play. That excludes an awful lot of their potential users, especially those who most care about privacy.
- r0muald 13y agoIt is also part of CyanogenMod, and it is open source https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure so you can build it on your own https://www.whispersystems.org/blog/cyanogen-integration/ https://www.whispersystems.org/blog/cyanogen-integration/
- devcpp 13y agoYou should build it yourself if you actually care about privacy. This is excellent practice, instead of encouraging you to trust some third-party website like their own.
- aw3c2 13y agoSee https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure/issues/127 https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure/issues/127 for a detailed discussion why. You can built it yourself.
- 650REDHAIR 13y agoMoxie's quote really hits the nail on the head. "The thesis essentially being, if you aren't able to build TextSecure from source, you probably aren't capable of managing the risks associated with 3rd party sources."
- PilateDeGuerre 13y ago>moxie0 commented a year ago >The only secret is to [really] begin. Nice one Moxie ;)
- dublinben 13y agoTelling users without Google Play to "just build it yourself" is arrogant an unacceptable. I find Moxie's response to this criticism arrogant and condescending. This is a major reason why I'm not using TextSecure, even though I would like to be.
- orblivion 13y agoCould somebody explain why it was tied to SMS in the first place? And given that, why it's trying to undo its connection to SMS? Separately, what's the difference between this and OTR? Is it just trying to just be a better OTR (and I support this endeavor, competing OTR connections over one chat channel creates a hassle). And as such, why is it only on Android, you could just as well write a Pidgin plugin right?
- LoganCale 13y agoOTR doesn't work with asynchronous chat.
- higherpurpose 13y agoThis article should explain why it's better than OTR: https://whispersystems.org/blog/advanced-ratcheting/ https://whispersystems.org/blog/advanced-ratcheting/
- huhtenberg 13y ago> Does the padlock mean our messages are already encrypted? If so, why is the padlock open? :)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- forgottenpass 13y agoThe chat is referring to the padlock icons on messages, which are closed. The open padlock in the notification bar means that your passphrase is currently cached and anyone that picks up your phone can read your text secure messages. How frequently your phassphrase gets flushed and must be re-entered is a user setting.
- nacs 13y agoTheres some irony in your mentioning having to reenter passphrases and your username being "forgottenpass" :)
- classicsnoot 13y agoBuckle up for a n00b query: is this going to be pushed as an update, or do i need to un-install/re-install?
- aw3c2 13y agoIt's a simple update.
- jevinskie 13y agoI'm very excited to see this for iOS! I never really trusted iMessages but the most painful part of iMessages is the vendor lock-in. Now I don't have to worry about the type of device that my friends use.
- apayan 13y agoWill there eventually be support for using your email address as your identifier instead of a telephone number? In a world of IP connected devices, the need to tether your self to the telecom cartel for an identifier is outdated. It would be ideal if future versions of TextSecure let you log in with just your email and then you could run the app on your tablet, desktop or any other devices without a SIM.
- ape4 13y agoIs there an country code for the internet?
- ultramancool 13y agoJust put 0s till you fill the text box, they'll know what you mean.
- peterwwillis 13y agoNo, but there's internet codes for your country. http://www.nirsoft.net/countryip/index.html http://www.nirsoft.net/countryip/index.html
- aw3c2 13y agoI would much rather like to be able to use an arbitrary identifier really.
- darklajid 13y agoSeconded. This and easy federation would make this a really viable and interesting xmpp contender.
- higherpurpose 13y agoMoxie, it's probably pointless to do it now, but right before or soon after Whisper is finished, you need to set-up some crowdsourcing of language localization for Whisper. Doesn't have to be anything complicated. Just arrange all the text nicely in a txt file and let people download it and then upload the file for a certain language. I think localization could give a great boost to Whisper in countries where English isn't the native language or that well known, and it doesn't cost you much to do this. But as I said, it's probably best to just wait until Whisper is finished, if it's coming out this year.
- moxie 13y agoWe agree that localization is super important. TextSecure is localized into 30 languages already. We use Transifex to crowdsource it: https://www.transifex.com/projects/p/textsecure-official/ https://www.transifex.com/projects/p/textsecure-official/
- 13throwaway 13y agoWho is paying for the servers this runs on?
- aet 13y agoNSA/CIA/etc..
- ancientworldnow 13y agoCyanogen runs one of the nodes. I'm not sure where Whisper Systems receives their funding from. At one point Twitter was involved with them, though I believe that is no longer the case.
- scott_karana 13y agoWay more appealing because of dumping SMS. :) Also a beautiful UI, and I can't wait for the iOS versions. Good work, Whisper Systems!
- rdl 13y agoThis is probably the most optimistic thing in security in the past year. Thank you! It's still tricky to get security due to the platforms on which software runs, but now users can make reasonable choices about which platforms to trust, and by not tying your messaging application to hardware with a black-box baseband, users actually have a decent chance. Hopefully there will be more progress on baseband-less mobile devices and reasonable networks for those users.
- tptacek 13y agoWould kill for the desktop version of this. This team is the gold standard of cryptographically secured messaging; what Colin Percival's Tarsnap is for backup, Whisper is for communications. Congrats on the new release.
- dmix 13y agoTelegram got 6+ million downloads in the first week: https://twitter.com/telegram/status/437743435395514368 https://twitter.com/telegram/status/437743435395514368 While TextSecure still only has 100k+ installs on Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.thoughtcrime.securesms&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.thoughtcri... Despite Telegrams known crypto failures: http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/1yrv46/after_getting_18_million_new_users_in_just_one/cfn9wro http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/1yrv46/after_gettin... Hopefully iOS and Desktop clients help TextSecure take off and beat out the weak crypto apps. Multi-platform is critical these days for messaging apps.
- zmanian 13y agoIt should be noted Textsecure is the default messaging app on Cyanogen which reaches 10 million devices. We really need to encourage folks to use these genuinely secure messaging apps rather encryption fairy dust like Telegram
- awda 13y agoIs it? I just updated to Cyanogen 10.2.1 and TextSecure is definitely a different app from Messaging. Or is this an 11.x feature? Edit: Oh, I see. Added as a silent feature in 10.2 messaging app. There is no visible indication that secure communication is happening (or possible). Ok. Better than nothing, and a good default.
- aroch 13y agoOn first install when you're setting up the phone in the winzard, the last thing is WhisperPush
- tete 13y agoThis is extremely cool. One there is a desktop version, Pidgin or Web I won't stop until everyone switched over. :)
- trurl42 13y agoI have been able to compile it myself, so I could install it on my tablet. You can register an Account using any phone number. Just wait until the SMS verification fails, you then have the option to request an automated call, and get a verification code that way. So far it seems like it's working.
- aaronmarks 13y agoVery excited for the iOS version! Will install immediately
- rdl 13y agoThe biggest weakness of this kind of app is it still exposes lots of interesting data for traffic analysis. It's a huge improvement over what we have today, but I'd really like something where you can't see who is talking with whom (when, how frequently, etc.), as well as can't read the content. Unfortunately doing this with mobile is really hard, due to bandwidth and power. agl's Pond is probably the best effort in the space so far.
- r0muald 13y ago> exposes lots of interesting data [[citation needed]] Is there an in-depth analysis of what data is exposed with the current protocol?
- jagermo 13y agoDamn. I wish this was native on the blackberry. I could emulate it, but SMS support wouldn't work - and I am not sure if emulating a secure system really is the way to go.
- xmr 13y agoWhy will anyone trust something based/developed in the USA related to security? It's a compromised jurisdiction. For anyone creating security products who wants to be credible will need to be based somewhere that respects privacy.
- snotrockets 13y agoI don't think there's any place on Earth where you can escape government wrath. Better to design assuming the environment is already compromised.
- jlund 13y agoEvery single US citizen is complicit? Man, I would hate to be this jaded. Some of us are fighting against mass surveillance as hard as we possibly can. This is as silly as saying that all of the people who live in North Korea are brutal dictators.
- icebraining 13y agoThat's not what xmr claimed; what was said is that the US is a compromised jurisdiction, and of course everyone developing something in the US is subject to that jurisdiction. It was never implied in xmr's post that every US citizen supports mass surveillance, only that they may be legally forced to participate in it.
- firloop 13y agoEven as an Android user, I'm anticipating the iPhone release as the idea of a cross-platform iMessage replacement (seamless SMS/IM) that's also secure and open source is very exciting to me.
- rnovak 13y agoAre pull requests encouraged/looked at? Wouldn't mind contributing to such a worthy cause
- higherpurpose 13y agoYes. Read the bottom of the article.
- zoowar 13y agoThe TextSecure server is AGPL. Take that Telegram!
- darklajid 13y agoThat very well might be the case, but you cannot host it yourself it seems (as stated elsewhere in this thread, federation really isn't supported). So you have to hope that the server you're talking to hosts the code that you're looking at. Do I think Moxie etc are evil? Not necessarily. But the open source server doesn't help _me_ one bit here, unfortunately.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ZoFreX 13y ago> So you have to hope that the server you're talking to hosts the code that you're looking at. What could a malicious server do?
- sneak 13y agoAGPL is stupid and user-hostile. Imagine if all of the major cloud companies' code were suddenly AGPL and released; it does you virtually no good without massive amounts of infrastructure and data. The GPL and its ilk were conceived in a different era of computing. Most people couldn't even afford the ability to run Google's internal applications even if they were released with full source. There is a distinction these days between software and services provided with that software; indeed there is a lot of value and functionality added in that layer that the GPL virus people would love to get their hands on. Unfortunately the "infrastructure and configuration is required to make it work" value being locked up can't be solved with a license - so it can't actually deliver the usual upside of the GPL. At the same time, it _does_ deliver the downside in the disincentive to actually add that value (as then you can't use it as a competitive advantage). Don't wave the AGPL around as a feature; it's shameful.
- petermonsson 13y agoDid they solve the private contact discovery problem and if yes, how did it go? It sounded really interesting.
- mike-cardwell 13y agoMy only concern about this is the lock-in. Has that been considered? What happens when I decide to stop using TextSecure? Will I need to tell everyone to delete a key from their phone or something, so messages don't come through garbled? Will they not come through at all, because they'll attempt to use the data channel and my phone wont bother even attempting to pick them up anymore? What if I lose my phone and get my provider to send me a replacement? I guess I wont be able to read the incoming texts anymore? If some auto-negotiation takes place to change my key, then isn't that exposing a trivial MITM? Would I be alerted of such a key change?
- mayneack 13y agoI had this happen to me - where someone I was messaging stopped using it without telling me. One message came through as garbled, but then there's an easy way to "end secure session" and new messages go through in plaintext. For switching between textsecure phones, I just re-initiated a key exchange. This was months ago, so it may have changed
- ZoFreX 13y ago> If some auto-negotiation takes place to change my key, then isn't that exposing a trivial MITM? This was my primary concern, but I looked into it and you can do an out-of-band identity verification.
- acabal 13y agoOn my wishlist is some kind of basic Google Voice number integration. Since messages are encrypted then clearly we can't use the GV web interface, which is fine, since what interests me is the "one phone number" feature of GV. I've given out my GV phone number to everyone and they get confused when they get SMSs from my actual SIM number. But besides that, excellent work as always! Edit: after browsing some feature requests on their Github repo it looks like GV makes it difficult/impossible to do this. Too bad.
- herbig 13y agoOnce there's a desktop version of this, Google Voice would be obsolete for me. The best part of Google Voice is being able to send/receive texts from the browser.
- patrickod 13y agoI feel the same about Google Voice at the moment. It's killer feature for me right now is the ability to text and call people from my Google Voice account from OS X. I use GrowlVoice[1] extensively. It's easily one of my favourite menubar applications. If TextSecure could replace this functionality it'd cause me to seriously reconsider GV [1] - https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/growlvoice-google-voice-client/id413146256?mt=12 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/growlvoice-google-voice-clie...
- harshreality 13y agoI thought I read that CyanogenMod had middleware that enabled SMS apps to use GV number/service, as well as native SMS. Found it [1] (support began in nightly CM 10.2 builds in early December). [1] http://www.cyanogenmod.org/blog/whisperpush-secure-messaging-integration http://www.cyanogenmod.org/blog/whisperpush-secure-messaging...
- Neff 13y agoThe CM/GV integration is most likely going away. There was a recent post on G+[1] that called out May 15th as the end of unauthorized use of Google Voice > - Finally, we want to make Google Voice as secure as possible. There are a few third-party applications that provide calling and SMS services by making unauthorized use of Google Voice. These apps violate our Terms of Service and pose a threat to your security, so we’re notifying these app developers that they must stop making unauthorized use of Google Voice to run their services and transition users by May 15, 2014. [1]:https://plus.google.com/u/0/+NikhylSinghal/posts/MjyncJEbzxK https://plus.google.com/u/0/+NikhylSinghal/posts/MjyncJEbzxK
- miclill 13y agoThank you for your hard work on this! --- The sms fallback option is greyed out for me. Any clues why?
- ThatGeoGuy 13y agoThis would be because the app is your default messaging app (Android 4.4+). If you want to remove SMS fallback, you need to set another app to act as your default SMS app. There is actually an issue on github open about this: https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure/issues/639 https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure/issues/639
- codelucas 13y agoI am confused, why is there so much talk about WhatsApp replacements recently?
- 21echoes 13y agowhatsapp doesn't have end-to-end encryption
- Raphael 13y agoIt's appealing to some to have messaging that doesn't funnel into a major data harvester. Facebook just acquired WhatsApp.
- tabel 13y agoWhisper systems is owned by Twitter. I'm not sure how it's privacy record compares to that of Facebook.
- ThatGeoGuy 13y agoIn this case TextSecure has end-to-end encryption, and supposedly even hides metadata when using the push service (which is hosted on Google Push Framework). Feel free to check the source yourself, or take Moxie's word on it, but I think their "track record" is a bit cleaner overall, regardless of the acquisition of WhisperSystems by Twitter.
- foobarqux 13y agoI'm pretty sure ownership reverted back to Moxie when he left Twitter.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Raphael 13y agoGreat inspiration from Google Hangouts on integration of SMS and non-SMS, visual design, and even the icon. Exciting release!
- mkesper 13y agoHangout eating SMS was really nasty. And trivial to enable, too. :(
- gcv 13y agoWill the iOS version require a jailbreak? Not sure how it can seamlessly handle plain SMS/MMS otherwise.
- virtualritz 13y agoAs soon as the iOS version is out, everyone in this forum should advertise and really /push/ this to all their friends via FB, twitter, PM -- whatever. Or just by plain asking them to install it, next time you bump into them in meatspace. Even better: throw a crypto party.
- runiq 13y agoFor those of us with a high number of Android users in their circle, we should probably try to advertise sooner, so we can (potentially) make use of the inertia.
- danieldk 13y agoOr since most people who did switch after the WhatsApp announcement already switched to Telegram or Threema and are not very likely to switch again, push these vendors to improve (Telegram) or open (Threema) their architectures.
- MWil 13y agoDoesn't work with Google Voice :( Just my luck!
- angelohuang 13y agoMulti-platform support is top priority for any messenger app today. This is my personal experience from working on an enterprise messenger recently. http://peer.im http://peer.im
- cylinder 13y agoThis looks exciting. When can I try it?
- angelohuang 13y agoLet me know your @ address. I will send an invite to you after our new UI is online (~1 or 2 weeks).
- cylinder 13y agoSigned up for an invite on your site; looking forward to it.
- ig1 13y agoI think their choice of GPL3 is a mistake; it's premised on the idea that people will only ever use one app to communicate and it'll be their app. In reality that's never going to happen; people are always going to use multiple apps to communicate whether it's via photo sharing apps, games or something else. We need a secure messaging infrastructure that transcends single apps - and that means it needs to be under a licence that can be integrated with both open source and closed source applications. It's not just a case of integrating with consumer apps but also business apps. You want your secure messaging system to be able to connect to every CRM, help-desk, shopping etc. system and again that requires a more liberal licence than GPL3. (Also it's not clear that you can legally distributed a GPL3 app on iOS)
- clarkevans 13y agoI think GPLv3 is perfect in this scenario. There's no reason why you can't integrate it with a proprietary application or distribute it on iOS -- just purchase a proprietary license exception from the authors.
- ig1 13y agoThey don't seem to have copyright assignment from third party contributors so they wouldn't have the legal ability to do that.
- skrebbel 13y agoWoa, that's a big big problem, then.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoHypothetically, if someone integrated this into their own proprietary app with hidden code under a proprietary license... how would you know it hadn't been compromised?
- hrjet 13y agoOpen-source isn't very different from closed-source in terms of security unless users compile from source. Even in the case of the original app, most people are downloading a pre-compiled binary from the Play store, which has a similar security concern.
- mseri 13y agoHow does it compare with Telegram (https://telegram.org https://telegram.org)?
- iamsalman 13y agoA few things we should be looking very critically in secure messaging apps are: 1. How are keys generated? PseudoRandomGenerator() used? What sort? This is one of the key break-in areas into a crypto framework. 2. Software based crypto used? It's prone to channel attacks where another app maybe inspecting the memory. 3. How are keys shared? 4. How are keys stored? "Security" would just be illusion, a flawed insurance policy if these aspects are not properly catered for. There's a reason why hardware crypto exists. The weakest link in any security system is the "key". Does not matter how strong the crypto algorithm is as long as key management is not rock solid.
- hepek 13y agoThis update broke my working TextSecure this morning. Couldn't access my messages. Had to reinstall. :(
- ilitirit 13y agoI belong to a WhatsApp group for common interests. I was about to recommend to everyone to switch over to TextSecure, but then I realized not everyone has an Android. This app would really benefit from a J2ME version like WhatsApp IMO.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- herbig 13y agoI installed this and the calling app Redphone. Installation and integration was quick and seamless, they simply replace the default text/calling applications and have a much better design anyway. I'm wondering, why NOT use this over the default applications?
- junto 13y agoBased on the old adage that 'if you aren't paying for it, you're the product', where do I find the pricing model for TextSecure? Are there plans to charge? If so, how much and when? If not, why is it free?