8 ms·
I thought the ruling said they didn't have the authority to do this without classifying ISPs as common carriers. If they're not going to do that (per the end of
by MBCook 13y ago
I thought the ruling said they didn't have the authority to do this without classifying ISPs as common carriers. If they're not going to do that (per the end of the article) then what changed that makes it legal this time?
- gtaylor 13y agoI was wondering that myself. It's going to be very disappointing if these rules are just "suggestions".
- lallysingh 13y agoI took "The commission will not seek to immediately reclassify Internet service as a utility. Mr. Wheeler said that the commission will retain the right to do so, however, if its new rules are approved and appear not to be working adequately." to mean that they'll be using the utility-classification as a lingering threat if the ISPs don't follow along.
- rhizome 13y agoIt's odd to see utility status classified as a punishment for industry. Shouldn't it refer to the technology (water delivery, electricity, possibly internet) and its role in the customers' lives?
- rayiner 13y agoIt is in a way a punishment. What makes a company profitable? Creating things people want and need. What makes them really profitable? Creating things people really want and need. But if you build something people really need, you get classified as a utility, which limits your ability to profit from what you're building and also drives out most of the spark from the industry. Our water pipes are mostly 100+ years old, our electric grid is ancient, most of our power is provided by plants that are decades old, etc. Chicago decommissioned a 110 year old coal plant in 2012. Our utilities are not exactly places bustling with innovation, new ideas, new technologies. Regulation has effectively killed the once promising nuclear industry, for example.
- lukeschlather 13y agoYeah, there are many things that killed the nuclear industry, but I've never heard anyone claim it was too little regulation. ( I mean, yes, the regulations outlawing new nuclear plants obviously, but those regulations came about because most people judge the previous regulations to be inadequate. I don't agree with them, but I don't think deregulating the nuclear industry would help anyone. )
- rayiner 13y agoToo much regulation. The process made it inordinately expensive to bring new nuclear technology to market. I'm not knee jerk opposed to regulation. But the best regulation identifies a market failure and addresses it in targeted way. Net neutrality regulation doesn't do that. It just implements some group's ideal of what the industry should look like.
- jbooth 13y agoHang on a second, in what way is "last-mile connectivity providers cannot selectively extort content providers based on business considerations" NOT identifying and addressing a market failure? I pay for the pipes on my end, I want the same data-rate regardless of whether the data originally came from a netflix server or a NBC-affiliated company's server. If netflix needs to beef up their peering arrangements in order to get the data to comcast's network, that's one thing, but they absolutely should not have to pay an additional fee to comcast to protect themselves from being penalized.
- rayiner 13y agoThat's not a market failure, but that's rather using a market failure as a hook impose a particular ideology about what the internet should look like. Hypothetical: say there was no last mile monopoly. The coax into your house was owned by the municipality, which allowed competing providers to plug in and provide the rest of the network. Would that eliminate the need for net neutrality regulation? No: companies could still pay ISP's to prioritize their packets all the way up to the municipally-owned coax into the customer's house. In other words, the regulation has nothing to do with the market failure ostensibly justifying it. Being able to pay other companies to give you better service is an intrinsic advantage to being big, and is not the product of a market failure. For example, Amazon works out a special deal with the USPS for Sunday deliveries. That still gives a huge benefit to Amazon versus smaller competitors who can't afford to pay up. Being small comes with penalties, and the FCC shouldn't impose an ideological view of the internet that artificially removes these disadvantages.