3 ms·
> It's clear these distinct developer teams have decided direct access to removable storage is some kind of risk (whether to security, usability, or ubiquity)
by MBCook 13y ago
> It's clear these distinct developer teams have decided direct access to removable storage is some kind of risk (whether to security, usability, or ubiquity)
I would argue usability. Having removable storage causes you to have to handle quite a few additional issues:
* Storage is removed (while app is off/in background)
* Storage is removed (while app is active)
* Users have to understand there are two places to put things (may still exist with this)
* Users have to understand the filesystem (decades of experience says... they don't)
Let's not forget that there are tons of 2.x, 3.x, and 4.x devices that probably won't get this update. This is only going to effect devices being actively updated and new ones.
As for new ones, Flash is getting cheaper and networks are getting faster. The fact is cloud storage is getting more and more practical (assuming carriers don't ruin it). This may be a bit early, but it would have been impossible a few years ago.
All in all it seems like a relatively sane decision to move the platform further. They could have just dropped SD card support. That would have also fixed the issues.
- Dylan16807 13y agoYour point is null because the removable storage is still there, and has to deal with even more sudden removal modes such as leaving reception. But it's suddenly more restrictive. So pretend the GP said > It's clear these distinct developer teams have decided direct access to a filesystem is some kind of risk (whether to security, usability, or ubiquity)
- pdonis 13y agoI would argue usability I would argue that usability is in the eye of the user. I don't care if most users don't understand what removable storage is and won't notice or care about this change. I know what it is and how to use it, so making it effectively useless impairs my usability. The fact is cloud storage is getting more and more practical (assuming carriers don't ruin it) Big assumption. Also not the only one: you're assuming cloud providers can keep your data private.