18 ms·
The Day the Internet Didn’t Fight Back
- xerophtye 13y agoSo how many HNers actually did send an email or made a call to their representatives?
- nmc 13y ago> "how many HNers [...] made a call to their representatives" I believe you mean "how many American HNers". On the website, you were asked for an American ZIP code anyway... maybe should have been called thedayamericafighstback.org?
- VeejayRampay 13y ago"What is this 'rest of the world' you keep referring to?"
- davidw 13y agoThose are people who do not vote for representatives in the United States, just as people in the United States do not vote for representatives in other countries. Those people probably carry some weight with American companies with which they may or may not do business, so that's probably their most likely angle of attack to effect change in the US.
- nmc 13y agoI think — I mean, I am not sure, but I strongly believe — that VeejayRampay was simply being ironic.
- kolinko 13y agoYou may be getting downvoted because he was sarcastic, not ironic.
- davidw 13y agoYes, but it's that kind of facile sarcasm that doesn't really add much to the conversation, and is so overdone as to not be in any way, shape or form humorous.
- nmc 13y agoI personally found it funny, but I agree with you, it kind of kills the conversation.
- xerophtye 13y agoYep, thought of including that clause, then figured it was obvious. PS: I ain't an American either
- ElDiablo666 13y agoNo, it's good you didn't. It's like people who insist that you say "It's my opinion that chocolate ice cream is delicious" instead of "Chocolate ice cream is delicious" because it offends their ridiculous sensibilities that someone might actually perceive things from their own perspective. Best to ignore such worthless garbage.
- nmc 13y agoI disagree with you analogy. From my perspective as from xerophtye's, Americans have American representatives, non-Americans do not. There is no different perception involved. Thanks for the "worthless garbage" mention, always appreciate it. ;-)
- ElDiablo666 13y ago>maybe should have been called thedayamericafighstback.org? I believe you mean "It is my opinion and I do in fact have the perspective that it maybe should have been called thedayamericafightsback.org?"
- d0 13y agoWhat would be the point of sending mail to representatives that don't represent you any more? At best it's a Monty-pythonesque nod to the system that got us here in the first place. "I'll write a stern letter" or "down with that sort of thing". Internet activism is at a high level, universally total bullshit. Breaking things until businesses suffer is the only way people will listen because there is a financial consequence.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoPerhaps we should attack the system with a... Banana! (Or a handful of Logan Berries)
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> Internet activism is at a high level, universally total bullshit. I think that not just Internet activism, but political solutions in general are, at high level, universally total bullshit. As you say, the only way people will listen because there is a financial consequence (people are extremely good at selling themselves out of their values). And a way to reliably inflict financial consequence is through business and technology (and occasional media shitstorms, but that doensn't seem to do much anymore), by redefining the optimization landscape people hillclimb right under their feet.
- d0 13y agoAnd a way to reliably inflict financial consequence is through business and technology That's just another way that legislation allows stuff to be manipulated. Why do you think legislators are always all over business and technology? It's a short path to the goal. All that happens is more fuel is added to the fire. It's gone past "happy happy joy joy" now.
- einhverfr 13y ago> I think that not just Internet activism, but political solutions in general are, at high level, universally total bullshit. More specifically political solutions beyond a certain modest scale fit that distinction. All of our political issues are scale issues.
- synctext 13y agoEasy to do nothing, it's easy to be cynical (+get a headline). IETF Internet guardians say "pervasive monitoring is an attack": https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-farrell-perpass-attack/ https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-farrell-perpass-attac... $52.6 Billion yearly budget is feeding the attacker: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/national/black-budget/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/national/black-... Seems a political reform force is needed or nothing will change. SOPA/PIPA gave us the taste of blood..
- crassus 13y agoThe only way to be effective is to make politicians lose their jobs. This means coalescing behind single-purpose organizations meant to win reelection for anyone supporting a minimalist tech/privacy platform, and defeat for anyone else. Tech workers today are too caught up in mainstream political bullshit - "parental notification laws for abortion are basically rape" and etc. - to actually do this.
- spenvo 13y ago"By late Tuesday, some 70,000 calls had been placed to legislators and roughly 150,000 people had sent their representatives an email." What was to be expected? The offices of my Senators and Representatives were swamped all day with phone calls. The author keeps paying lip-service to the comparison of this effort to SOPA/PIPA --- which was entirely different. Those bills were a direct challenge to the internet as we knew it, and everyone (including the big players) moved in to participate. That protest was about two game-changing bills with votes on the floor (all other paths for success had failed - if you're Google,Wikipedia, etc); this protest was about the status quo. Our elected officials heard us today - from seemingly nowhere, that the status quo isn't acceptable. The verbiage directly called the kettle black on the supposed "FISA Reform Bill," reminding politicians that the powder is dry if head too far off course. And that (IMHO) makes a big statement. I felt the post was unjustifiably negative[/defeatist] with a link bait title and lame observations. It would be great to see Google, Facebook, Wikipedia, etc. play a larger role and "see the bigger picture"-- especially given that companies like Microsoft have officially recognized dragnet surveillance as an "advanced persistent threat." [0] Again, it would be great, but it can't be necessary. We want their help, but we cannot need it. PS - It's defeatist to say the following: "internet protests will never change anything in Washington." "The Powerbroker," a Pulitzer-Prize winning biography praised by Aaron Swartz [1], conveys the following two lessons with regards to affecting change in government: 1.) the only thing which matters (from the perspective of a common man) is raising the political stakes in every manner possible, forcing the issue into the court of public opinion where politicians must pick sides in a very public affair. 2.) The other things which matter are in conversations which you are not a part of. . . ... dig in. This is a minor skirmish in a long war (of attrition) against the Est.. [0] - http://www.theverge.com/2013/12/5/5177554/microsoft-plans-server-encryption-against-nsa-snooping http://www.theverge.com/2013/12/5/5177554/microsoft-plans-se... [1] - https://zolabooks.com/list/aaron-swartz-reading-list/1 https://zolabooks.com/list/aaron-swartz-reading-list/1
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoThe fact that Google/Yahoo/Facebook/Wiki didn't promote or get involved with this REALLY hurt the cause... To many (read: The Majority) of people the above companies are the internet. In the same way the people who think this way used to think AOL was The Internet (Capitals important). It really is sad that this seems to be true and that a couple companies have so much influence on what the internet is and does. But it really did make it easy to downplay the whole thing by saying "If it was so important why didn't Google get involved?"
- danshapiro 13y agoThis will go down as the day the New York Times considered the number of Reddit comments a more important indicator of impact than phone calls to members of Congress.
- marshray 13y agoDo we know that there aren't members of Congress watching Reddit comments? I would at least expect political consultants to.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Suncho 13y agoI honestly don't care about the NSA stuff. There are real issues in society that I actually get fired up about (poverty, education, intellectual property, and the like). Government surveillance isn't one of them. Privacy isn't really one of them. SOPA and ProtectIP really mattered to me. This didn't.
- marshray 13y agoSurveillance is censorship.
- ZenoArrow 13y agoSurveillance isn't censorship, but it is an effective tool to aid in censorship.
- kyboren 13y agoMass surveillance creates a chilling effect on free speech; it causes people to self-censor. It's just as effective at censorship as requiring a license to print a newspaper--something our Bill of Rights was explicitly designed to avoid.
- vbuterin 13y agoNot by itself it doesn't. Google does mass surveillance on us all the time, and most people barely register that. What creates the chilling effect is mass surveillance _combined with power_. That's what people are scared of - not just that some magic oracle somewhere knows what they're talking with their friends about, what their job is, what microscopic laws they're breaking and who they're cheating on their spouses with, but the fact that the entity doing the surveillance is also the entity that has a near-unlimited capability to do essentially whatever they want to them. That's where the self-censorship comes in.
- marshray 13y agoYou've never thought to yourself: "Ooh I'd better not Google for that" ?
- etiam 13y agoThe initiative has been criticised for lack of a clear call to action many times, not least here on HN. If the response was really lukewarm (the contacts to legislators and political representatives looks pretty good?) maybe it's a consequence of that. I personally have never really liked the framing of the campaign. "The Day We Fight Back"? As if anyone's going to solve this problem between breakfast and their evening snack? I realize it has a connotation of 'a day on which we start fighting back', which is clearly clumsier as a slogan, but I think building up the expectations on a single day is a bad move in this context. To me it seems that way the initiative gets more fragile than it needed have been. My respect to the people arranging it though. It's great to see activism protesting these crimes. Keep it up! Today Is A Day We Try To Take A Sliver Of Our Spare Time And Do Something About Mass Surveillance, and so is every tomorrow until success.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoOh please. HN had a header. What more do you want?
- junto 13y agoFinancial pain. We forget how powerful this is. We have shown that we collectively can protest by adding a bit of JavaScript to our webpages and some of you called you senators. Great start, noble, but I guarantee that nothing will change. What really hurts is loss of revenue to global companies. We need to collectively boycott firms until THEY resolve the problem. It is their tax write-down lobbying donations that keep these jokers we call senators in power. If we really want to protest against say, monitoring, then we should be building free tools for people to easily move their email away from GMail or building something better than email as an alternative. If we want to discourage Concast from throttling Netflix, then we should all collectively dump Comcast and move to a company that promises they won't. If we want to discourage the NSA then lobbying government as individuals isn't going to cut it. That horse has already bolted. That horse needs a bullet to the head. Corporations are the only entities powerful enough to stop government. We need to empower them to fix the problem. We think that protesting within the confines of the system will work. It doesn't. We think that protesting in the street will work. It doesn't (Iraq War protests anyone?). It works outside the western world because they aren't kept within what I call "the sheep bubble". Western governments know how to keep the people within a bubble that provides just enough comfort to keep the vast majority happy. Places where we have seen revolutions haven't maintained that bubble. Since we don't have direct control over the bubble in the western world, we have few options for collective revolt. I would like to see this (very cool) system that you have collectively put together for yesterday's protest, to be pivoted and used to actively boycott companies that we collectively see as damaging to the us sheep. Then we become the wolves.
- motters 13y agoI'm not sure that companies are the answer here, because companies suffer from The Levison Problem. Some goons show up with a gagging order and attach a "special box" to the server or implement some other kind of intercept in order to carry out "bulk collection". Or they simply demand copies of the private keys. This isn't a problem which a company can easily overcome. There isn't a simple solution to mass surveillance but one mitigating strategy may be to encourage more people to run their own web services, a la freedombox/freedombone/arkOS, and encourage a "friends host friends" policy. If enough people went down that route then it could affect the bottom line of various companies, and hence apply some pressure for meaningful change.
- ronaldx 13y ago> DuckDuckGo, which were listed as organizers, did nothing to their homepages. This is factually incorrect - the Duck was (is still) being watched by a surveillance camera.
- jjcm 13y agoI was one of guys behind sopablackout.org, one of the larger players in the sopa movement a while back. I think that the main difference between the effects of this protest and the sopa protests, is that for sopa, sites quite literally blacked out their pages for the day. You couldn't ignore the message. This time, the popup/message was less in your face. On HN it was a small piece of text at the top of the page. I didn't even see it on reddit. Yes a lot of call volume was made, but I think the general public didn't really know it was happening. With SOPA, sites went black. Content became unavailable. Users didn't get what they wanted, so they tried to figure out why. 70,000 calls are great, but the that makes up a minuscule portion of the elected officials' demographics. I think the largest problem here was that the campaign's objective was contacting representatives, whereas the SOPA's objective was educating the public. One lasts a day, the other is sustainable.
- this_user 13y agoI think one big difference is that the SOPA campaign had a very clear-cut goal of stopping that legislation while this campaign is "against mass surveillance" which is much more nebulous. Most people on the Internet seem to agree that they are against mass surveillance, but there is a lack of clear goals and demands that everyone can get behind.
- Ensorceled 13y agoWorse, they all have different levels of acceptable surveillance. Many Americans think that the current spying is ok, many more think spying on all non-Americans is ok, many other Americans thing ANY spying is bad. The vast majority of Americans could recognize that SOPA was just plain bad: bad for business, bad for users, bad for everybody.
- ChrisAntaki 13y ago85 thousand calls is pretty awesome, actually.
- seanccox 13y agoIt doesn't surprise me that major internet brokers weren't involved; Google, Yahoo, and others are alleged to have had established relationships with the intelligence community – relationships that likely profited them. So, those firms shouldn't be relied upon to take a stand. To make a company an effective advocate for any change, you need to threaten their revenue stream. That's really the only factor a corporation can be relied upon to respond to, and it was a motivating factor behind much of the corporate defiance to SOPA. SOPA included provisions that would have barred advertising and imposed costly bureaucracy, and it was thus valuable to protest it. By comparison, any current relationships between such companies and government agencies, regarding their data, only makes them a party to pissing on the constitution and assisting in assassinations through the provision of metadata. That doesn't cost a thing.
- higherpurpose 13y agoThe whole settlement they made with the NSA/DoJ recently for "transparency" was a big farce, too. Even Twitter knows that. https://blog.twitter.com/2014/fighting-for-more-transparency https://blog.twitter.com/2014/fighting-for-more-transparency
- VMG 13y agoThe only reliable solution is secure end-to-end cryptography. It's painful, but it more effective than this kind of slacktivism.
- etiam 13y agoI'm all for secure end-to-end cryptography, but there are plenty of problems that doesn't solve (social graph building by traffic analysis being one important example). Most importantly, encrypting does little, if anything, to solve the deeper problem that the spy organizations blatantly ignore the law and try to deceive the public and the public's representatives to get away with it. You sound cynical about the likely effectiveness of the political campaign, I know I am, but the really big problem with this whole issue is about abuse of power and how we arrange society. In my opinion, any 'solution' that doesn't address the political side is not really a solution at all.
- staticelf 13y agoFrom a european perspective, this protest was unfortunately way to directed to the American public. When it comes down to protests like this, I feel like there is too much focus on the US government even if they are the most hardcore when it comes to world wide surveiliance. But when Europe came together on stopping ACTA (I helped organize an IRL protest) it felt like the world was much more united on the issue. Yesterday I did nothing mainly because I felt left out because my little country did not matter. The demonstrations were covered in the media in my country pretty heavily and I think a bunch of people screaming on the streets, giving out flyers and so on gives a much better impression on the general public than some websites having a banner or some telephone calls. Seriously, America should get together on the streets AND swamp their telephone lines.
- motters 13y agoAgree. Although a lot of the news is about NSA, and very American-centric, this is really a global problem. Not many people pay attention to blacked out web sites unless it's Google or Facebook.
- kefka 13y agoProtesting on the streets in the US doesn't work. Unlike much of Europe, where the streets are used for walking and small cars, we have these big roads and big cars. These roads are for driving. Even the town squares in all the cities I've lived in were optimized for vehicles. Now, we can take this to the streets. But all that does is piss off every man and woman trying to live their life and work and get groceries.
- pessimizer 13y ago>Unlike much of Europe, where the streets are used for walking and small cars, we have these big roads and big cars. Tiny streets like these? http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/oct/16/french-protests-airport-fuel-supplies http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/oct/16/french-protests... >all that does is piss off every man and woman trying to live their life and work and get groceries. That's the same thing it does everywhere else. The reason you have street protests is to disrupt what people are doing and have them focus on what you are saying. The reason street protests "don't work" in the US is because of a combination of the precariousness and conservatism of the middle class. It's too big a risk for middle-class people to participate in a protest, and the majority of them are racist law-and-order voters who have voted to eliminate most of the rights of the accused and to militarize their police forces out of their fear of black and hispanic people. Now that we're afraid of the Middle East, we've eliminated most of the rights of the unaccused. Europeans have a different history, and the development of civil rights there wasn't entirely born out of race-based fear, so their situation is different. Here, only poor people and students protest, and they are completely ignored by a monolithic media except to be taunted, confronted by police at a ratio of 10 cops to a protester, and carted off to jail if their permits aren't current or if they step off the sidewalk.
- varjag 13y agoWell this is 2014. Make likes, not war.
- tawaysick 13y agoWe need more terrorism. Not the kind of terrorism that hurts people, but the kind of terrorism that the US government engages in: using fear to control the population and influence opinion ("We need these percautions or planes will be hijacked"). Basically, if the government doesn't brand you a terrorist, you aren't a threat to the status quo and they aren't scared of you changing anything. If you aren't called a terrorist you've failed. To win the game you have to play the game. What we need is to hurt the bottom line of the biggest tax contributors, and we need to make it clear why their bottom line is receding (complicity with data rape).
- samwisebaggins 13y agoWe need more tism. Not the kind of tism that hurts people, but the kind of tism that the US government engages in: using fear to control the population and influence opinion ("We need these percautions or planes will be jacked"). Basically, if the government doesn't brand you a tist, you aren't a threat to the status quo and they aren't scared of you changing anything. If you aren't called a tist you've failed. To win the game you have to play the game. What we need is to hurt the bottom line of the biggest tax contributors, and we need to make it clear why their bottom line is receding (complicity with data sniffing).
- Cthulhu_ 13y agoI put it up on my community site as well, and to be fair... the response was underwhelming. A few people found the site ending up being unusable (on mobile), others found it annoying, and others thought their computer or the website had been hacked / infected with malware. So yeah, on the one side, the big players didn't participate; on the other, the banner was ineffective or confusing for a lot of people, and finally, a lot of people simply either didn't get the message or simply didn't care. You know what happens when people do care? Open revolt, violent protesting, revolution. See also: middle-east. Whose people are a lot more emotional / angry than western countries are, and more inclined to take affirmative action for what they stand for. In the case of the US, this should be the gross violations of the constitution's amendments, and the lack of action from the higher legal courts to stop it in its tracks. That's when the amendment of the right to bear arms kicks in, allowing the people to overthrow their own government. In theory, anyway.
- davidw 13y ago> You know what happens when people do care? Open revolt, violent protesting, revolution. Like Martin Luther King Jr. and Gandhi?
- pessimizer 13y agoYes. Like Martin Luther King and Gandhi. If you don't see what they did as open revolt, I don't know what you're seeing. If you don't see their protests as violent (even though the violence was done to them), I don't know what you were looking at. These people risked their lives every day for their causes, and lost them. That is not comparable to banner ads.
- davidw 13y ago"Open revolt, violent protesting, revolution." written together, bring to mind much different images than what Gandhi and MLK were involved in. No, it's not comparable to banner ads.
- deviljv 13y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAVtWFwp0WY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAVtWFwp0WY
- higherpurpose 13y agoAh, of course his is coming from NYT. They've never been too supportive of the whole "anti-NSA" movement, and in fact lately they've started defending NSA quite a bit more than initially, with all the "leaks" they get from NSA now to make them look good. Shouldn't those leakers be prosecuted, too? Shouldn't someone call for the assassination of those leakers?! Funny how nobody says anything bad about the leakers when the leaks make the NSA look good, isn't it?
- johnpowell 13y agoHonestly. This was a joke. And the NSA doesn't care about money. They simply don't care. Their money isn't impacted. I didn't even notice what Reddit did. There was a blog post floating around the top all day. If that was all, great job.
- INTPenis 13y agoBeing involved in a hacker space in a very developed European country and leading workshops that try to educate the general public on online security this is my view on the belated public reaction of all these past years of leaks. There are two main camps visible to me, the indifferent and the frightened. I'm sure there are plenty of people in the spectrum between those two but I find observing these two camps rather interesting. Because one camp seems to be overwhelmed by all the revelations, usually this camp is not involved in IT at a professional or hobby level. The indifferent camp seems to either believe it's a problem but that they can't do anything about it, or believe that this is status quo and they need to go on with their lives. The other camp, the frightened, are usually IT enthusiasts. Even if they're not very skilled, they're now working on that. They're looking up information on Tor, GPG and PKI. They seem to be bunkering down to defend their privacy from their own government. Those are just my observations.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoI didn't like the protest. It was way too US-centric politically motivated anti-governement. The people behind claimed to believe in "privacy is a human right", but only addressed the privacy violations of the "Big Bad Gubernment". I'm all for a pro-privacy protest, not for a libertarian anti-government protest disguised as one. The SOPA/PIPA protests were about standing up to the copyright mafia as well as the authorities, something that was mirrored by the European ACTA protests. This protest was totally one-sided, ignoring 50% of the privacy issue, especially as it is perceived outside the US, where Google, Facebook e.a. stand shoulder to shoulder with the US government in their efforts to tear down privacy rights.
- hajderr 13y agoDon't worry. We'll be fighting back and reclaim the freedom online. It is time for people to wake up from their slumber!
- lurkinggrue 13y agoSorry I was looking at cat videos.
- insertnickname 13y agoI'm glad this thing is over. Those popups everywhere were really annoying.
- RamiK 13y agoIt didn't help having it coincide with Safer Internet Day ( www.saferinternetday.org ) which did make it to my local media. I only heard about the Day We Fight Back thing a day or two in advance so when I saw the evening news and they talked about that Safer Internet Day I wasn't sure if there was some mix up or just bad reporting...
- officemonkey 13y agoThe reason the big companies didn't mount much of a fight is because they benefit from the surveillance state. Facebook and Google hoover more private data out of my life than the NSA ever will. They may have less sinister motives (I don't think Amazon intends to kill anyone with their drones,) but whipping up public ire about on-line surveillance will blow back on them. So they go the Captain Renard route ("I'm shocked, shocked to see mass surveillance going on here!"): they put up token resistance, but they don't want to be too effective.
- mpyne 13y agoIndeed, Google is the one who came up with the idea that surveillance-by-computer was somehow more innocuous than surveillance-by-person. With GMail they tell you straight to your face that they will store all this personal data about you (i.e. your email, login history, etc.) but that it's OK, "a human never looks at it". Well, great.
- johncoltrane 13y agoThe day a few citizens of the Internet pretended to fight back against a vastly more powerful thing that doesn't give a flying fuck about them with ridiculous weapons.
- bhauer 13y agoFinancial pain is a proven way to affect companies, and in turn affect the government. But causing financial pain to organizations that are compromised by NSA action may not be feasible without a serious cost to ourselves of lost time and productivity. Although I have not been pushing the concept much, I would invite you to consider the model of my side project [1], wherein we use donations to charity to illustrate the importance of action. The donations can either be made immediately or pending completion of the task. This gives a bit of financial weight to the activism, if not direct and acute. It also benefits charities and in some cases gets the charities involved in providing pressure from another angle. To date, it's only been modestly effective with local tasks, but I've not been able to build the momentum behind the model to test it with something larger scope. [1] https://usa.brianstaskforce.com/task/386/stop-unwarranted-surveilance-on-us-citizens-by-the-nsa https://usa.brianstaskforce.com/task/386/stop-unwarranted-su...
- BrownBuffalo 13y agoIt's all about location, location, location. Good message or bad - you have to advertise. Ask the FB poster from this week about engagement. :)
- ArtDev 13y agoWhose idea was to call the Feb 11th event "the day we fight back"? Signing a petition or calling your congress-person is not really "fighting back". I don't think we can really "fight back" against the NSA in a way that is legal. We CAN pressure our representatives. Our representatives certainly can fight back. Next time there is an online protest on the NSA there should be a better name for it. There is a lot of lazy apathy out there on the interwebs. I think that this needs to be framed not around "our privacy" (while most of us are thinking we have nothing to hide anyhow) but around the "privacy of journalists, activists and people in important positions". What if you knew that every news article was written by a journalist who was afraid for their family from the NSA? In the age of the internet we are all journalists and activists of one sort or another.
- ninjac0der 13y agoSo the revolution wasn't televised? Wake me up when you slacktavist get as frustrated with your audience as I have with you guys. You don't just settle for indirect action after they've started sneaking around in front of us.
- gesman 13y agoEmails, banners and "click here to occupy" is a yawn. But 70,000 annoying calls to legislators that cannot be ignored and/or attributed to telemarketing spam is probably the most significant result that might actually been noticed.
- Shivetya 13y agoFight back? How? Sending email? Making a call. Tell me you had to even put such effort as standing up to do so. As in, its a meaningless gesture. The only way to get something done is to upset the apple cart. Meaning finding candidates who will pledge to fix it, this can mean funding people for the "other" party, something I know some will find any excuse not to. This can also mean creating a faction within both, the Republicans are already being whacked by the Tea Party its high time the Democrats had something similar, something not fake funded and orchestrated like OWS - a real movement within that strikes fear at sitting Democrats like the Tea Party did to Repubilicans Send an email, gee whats next, we fight back by flipping them off or talking around the water cooler?
- Kiro 13y agoThe truth is that most people don't care about NSA anymore.
- michaelochurch 13y agoPersonally, I don't worry much about PRISM. Abstractly, yes, these are very important issues. I don't want to downplay that. However, since at least 1925 the US has always been in more danger from private entities than from its government, and this is even more true of individuals within the US. Private health insurance is a lot scarier than our government. Given the ease with which private entities can and do destroy an individual's reputation, often over petty slights, PRISM is low on my concern list compared to that. I know people who've been blacklisted by venture capitalists. I don't know anyone who's been personally affected by PRISM. I'm sure that some people have been; I just think it's rarer. Top software executives are pissed about PRISM not because of the legality or the ethics of the program. They're embarrassed that, although they make gigantic salaries and are darlings at the Silicon Valley ball, they got pwned by nerds in Maryland making government salaries. Don't get me wrong. There are principled civil libertarians who are raising these issues because they genuinely care about what is happening, and it's worth listening to them. But the indignation of the software execs and venture capitalists is just petty embarrassment and nothing more.
- mladenkovacevic 13y agoJust a little marketing/human nature insight that someone will hopefully find useful: "Fighting back" works as a slogan in countries where people are fed up or believe they have been abused long enough. Americans are very placated and have an over-inflated sense of privilege. Calls to "fight back" sound like hard work that someone who already enjoys a comfortable life shouldn't have to do. I believe a better slogan might be something like "The day we reclaim our privacy" or "the day we renew our dignity" ... or something along those lines as long as the implication is that we are simply taking back what's rightfully ours.
- chc 13y agoI agree that "fight back" was unfortunate terminology, but I thought so for a different reason: It sounds like juvenile blustering. We weren't actually fighting anything — we were just making a few phone calls. Those who aren't interested in violence will be turned off by the hostile name and those who are interested in violence will be turned off by the fact that it's just phone calls.
- mladenkovacevic 13y agoRegardless, I think the result was very positive. 70,000 phone calls is amazing especially for a first go at it. The Canadian openmedia.ca also had a campaign which is how I participated, so I'm sure the numbers are even higher globally. Experiment, analyze, tweak, repeat.
- latetext 13y agoIn my eyes, congress seems to be powerless
- coltr 13y agoDuckDuckGo did make changes to their page. Their logo had been changed to look like it was being recorded and then linked to thedaywefightback website.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pirateking 13y agoThese campaigns need to be more creative and fun. The majority of youth today (a demographic with the most free time and incentive to participate) do not like making calls or writing emails. Also, the emotion created by most of these campaigns is doom and gloom. Dark colors, threatening symbols, scary acronyms, powerful shadowy figures, walls of text. Raising awareness or gathering support through fear based campaigns is not going to work. The media has run that cart into the ground long ago. The majority of people I know will be turned away or further made apathetic by these campaigns. Those of us who aren't, live in an awareness bubble. Here is an idea I came up with just now (so don't take it too seriously) - organize a huge public BBQ at the park nearest your local representative's office. People only vaguely interested in the cause would show up for good food and fun, and may contribute to the perception of success of the event, while possibly learning more about the cause in a non-threatening environment. The representative's office is right down the street should they wish to support the cause in person. If these BBQs, were every Friday at lunch or something, I would be there for sure every time. Now I am hungry. Errr... hungry to end mass surveillance... right. Maybe that idea is ridiculous, but the basic idea is that if you want people to spend time for a cause, it's easier if you let them have a good time while doing so. For passive participation, I believe selling t-shirts specifically designed for different audiences is one the best options, way better than changing an avatar or creating an online meme. Donate the proceeds to the EFF and open source crypto and networking projects, and it is a solid campaign. The messaging should be simple and direct, but not overbearing. The key is for the design to stand on its own regardless of the message it carries. 99% of people don't care about the message, they want a sick shirt. If anyone here is interested in making a shirt related to this cause, you can email me about your idea and I will do a quick concept design for you for free.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Love-vivah 13y agoToday people live without food but not live without internet.