8 ms·
Beam Me Out Of This Death Trap, Scotty (1980)
- fennecfoxen 13y agoThis is why we can't have nice space-things.
- acqq 13y agoThe most interesting discovery for me was to compare: "cost projections: The analysts assumed that the shuttle fleet would stage at least 50 flights a year" with now known 135 launches in 30 years total which gives less than 5 per year. The article is fantastically well researched and written.
- craftsman 13y agoIt's interesting that nearly everything that was wrong with the Space Shuttle was accurately predicted in this article. Both catastrophic breakups were essentially predicted (a booster failing and tile damage from falling fuel tank ice), as well as the huge cost overruns and performance shortfalls. I wonder what author Gregg Easterbrook thinks as he looks back on the Shuttle era? Having a quick glance at his article on Wikipedia, it seems he's written or said a bit more about space policy since the shuttle; I'll have to read up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregg_Easterbrook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregg_Easterbrook
- acqq 13y agoEven more impressive to me is that he wasn't an engineer but still made impressively technically well-informed article. I have no doubts one or more very smart and technically trained people helped him, still, it's amazing how much quality information is in one single article.
- hudibras 13y agoUnfortunately, Easterbrook is coasting on the reputation he built up from this one magazine piece from 34 years ago. It's basically impossible to read anything he writes nowadays without finding something either wrong or infuriatingly contrary-for-the-sake-of-contrariness.
- acqq 13y agoThe article I'd really like to read is about the "whistleblower" (or more of them) who gave Easterbrook all the info for that 1980 article. It would be very fitting to today's world.
- RachelF 13y agoThe problem was that NASA administrators would lose their jobs if they admitted the shuttle project was in such trouble in 1980.
- leoc 13y agoEven after the Challenger disaster people were afraid. Feynmann didn't discover the O-ring problem so much as learn about it through tip-offs from NASA insiders (something he freely acknowledged later). They'd got him onto the investigation panel because he was someone with the public stature, and of course the personality, to stick his head up and report it.
- lafar6502 13y agoGreat read. I wonder if the author realized the madness will continue for 30 more years before someone makes a rational decision.
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoFor reference, the amortized cost of a shuttle launch ended up being $1.45 billion ($196 billion / 135), with the recurring (per-launch) cost as $450 million of that (?). For comparing with the article's figures, $1.00 (1975) = $1.53 (1980) = $4.18 (2011). (So you could compare, e.g. the $22.4 million 1975 estimate with either $108 M or $347 M). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_program#Budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_program#Budget ftp://ftp.bls.gov/pub/special.requests/cpi/cpiai.txt
- fennecfoxen 13y agoYou're linking to the BLS's CPI data, but you really don't want to deflate currency figures for the Space Shuttle using the CPI. Use something like the percentage of GDP: http://www.measuringworth.com/uscompare/ http://www.measuringworth.com/uscompare/ "Putting a man on the moon: [...] How much would that be today? If we used the CPI, it would be $160 billion, but this would not be a very good measure since the CPI does not reflect the cost of rockets and launch pads. ... [as] a way to consider the "opportunity cost" to society, the best measure might be the cost as a percent of GDP, and that number would be $453 billion. "
- wtallis 13y agoUsing percent of GDP as an answer to the question of "How much would that be today?" is absurd, because our economy today is not only larger but more efficient at converting raw materials and manpower into working spacecraft. The question it really answers is something like "How daunting of an investment was that, in terms of today's economy?", though even that doesn't properly convey that such an investment made today would accomplish far more.
- fennecfoxen 13y agoOkay. To some extent that's fair, but on the other hand "opportunity cost to society" is just a fancy way of saying the same thing as "how daunting of an investment was that" so the quoted statement is hardly in disagreement per se :) Of course, there are also plenty of alternative measures available at the linked site which could be better than either percent-of-GDP or CPI. (I'm leaving their use as an exercise to the reader...)
- WalterBright 13y agoI hadn't known the Spruce Goose was damaged by its flight. That explains a lot.
- WalterBright 13y agoI've thought for 30 years that the shuttle design was terribly misguided. The terrible problem with space flight is weight. Weight, weight, weight. It takes an enormous amount of fuel and rocket to push any kind of weight into orbit. But the shuttle is not optimized for getting useful weight into orbit (i.e. payload, with the emphasis on pay). It's optimized for returning the rocket to earth. I.e. it has landing gear, wings, rudder, etc. All this is heavy, and therefore terribly expensive. Step back a moment, and look at what we really need to bring back from orbit - it's the astronauts. Nothing else. All we actually need is a tiny capsule to bring the astronauts back, i.e. a heat shield and parachute. The rest can just be left in orbit. Getting rid of all that weight then means the rocket can either be far cheaper, or it can launch much bigger PAY loads. As for reliability, likely the most cost effective solution is to build a smaller, highly reliable rocket just for pushing astronauts up into orbit. Use another rocket, a big, heavy, unmanned one, and one that needn't be so reliable, to push up the stuff the astronauts need to do their mission.
- WalterBright 13y agoBTW, weight is also the enemy of airplanes, which is why you don't see airliners ever flying around without a full load of passengers or freight (i.e. PAYload) on them. Only governments can afford to fly them empty. But it's a hundred, a thousand times worse with rockets.
- dingaling 13y agoHello again! There are actually many, many airliner positioning flights that move around empty. It's a wonder airlines make any money when you see how inefficient they can be. If you're watching FR24 or similar keep an eye out for callsigns ending in "P" for positioning.
- WalterBright 13y agoGiven the millions of flights, I'm sure there are many flying empty. But I doubt it's a lot, relatively speaking.
- 13y ago
- patio11 13y agoIt's great realizing, when reading a 35 year old polemic, that the chief issue with its criticisms was that it allocated WAY too little probability space to the outcome "worse than even we think it will be." For example, the debate in the article is between optimists who think the shuttle will hit 70 flights a year and pessimists who said 20. Nobody had their money on "four." The article also describes Challenger and Columbia in chilling detail in advance. Quote: "The plan is, you die."
- zachbeane 13y agohttp://idlewords.com/2005/08/a_rocket_to_nowhere.htm http://idlewords.com/2005/08/a_rocket_to_nowhere.htm is a nice overview as well.
- FD3SA 13y agoRequired watching [1], straight from Dale D. Myers (Deputy NASA administrator 86-89) himself. An extremely fascinating tale regarding the importance of engineering constraints in mission critical designs. 1. http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/aeronautics-and-astronautics/16-885j-aircraft-systems-engineering-fall-2005/video-lectures/lecture-1/ http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/aeronautics-and-astronautics/16-8...
- sien 13y agoIt's curious how little is written about the X-37B that seems to be a successful reusable space vehicle. It's unmanned, very much smaller than the Shuttle but seems to be of use for the US Air Force for something. It also stays in orbit for over a year at a time. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-37 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-37
- samplonius 13y agoI don't get it. The Shuttle project included a lot of things that had never been done before. So things didn't quite go to plan and some people died? But in the mean time, it performed useful tasks. Predicting failure is easy, because something will always go wrong. There hasn't been a perfect anything built yet. What is also surprising about these dredged up past articles, is that they all invariable criticize the engine (SSMB/SSME), even though the engine was never a major issue. Yes, the rebuilds between flights took longer than expected, but it was the first ever re-usable engine and is still an amazing achievement.
- gus_massa 13y agoFeynman explains the problems with the main engines in the report about the Challenger disaster. They were a good candidate for the 3rd deadly accident if the shuttle program had continued. Current discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7201645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7201645 (125 points, 1 day ago, 79 comments)
- codex 13y agoThe shuttle is representative of a class of problems that occur in almost every software project: uncontrolled complexity. It's easier to fix the symptoms in software than in other fields, so this issue runs rampant throughout all of IT.