5 ms·
>> While whites and Asians are making more money, blacks and Latinos are falling further behind. What is the author trying to say? The truth is blacks and Lat
by bluedino 13y ago
>> While whites and Asians are making more money, blacks and Latinos are falling further behind.
What is the author trying to say? The truth is blacks and Latinos need to step it up.
I come from a Mexican-American family, and have ten aunts and uncles. I'm constantly amazed (or is it baffled) with the disparity between each of the grandchildren, even within the same family.
My aunts and uncles all have at least 3, and at most 5 children. Some ended up in prison, some ended up pregnant at the age of 14, some dropped out of high school and some went on to finish college. Most are employed at various levels. But when it comes to which ones are 'successful' and don't have the problems the others have, it basically came down to personal choices they made along the way, and continue to make (the oldest is 42 years old, the youngest are just now finishing high school).
The worst-off grandchildren generally have parents in equally bad situations. But one family has two convicts, a do-nothing, but then a nurse and a teacher. The biggest 'help' seems to be from the parent marrying someone who's from a better situation, but it's not always the case. Only about 5 of the grandchildren are married.
My point is these kids all came from the same schools, same neighborhoods, same families, and some of them managed to make it through while the rest became statistics. Much of the problem is that the majority have all stayed put in this rust-belt city with no jobs and no future.
- Denzel 13y agoI know what you're trying to say, and I understand that you believe you have a set of individuals with upbringings that are relatively equal, for all intents and purposes, but as an African-American your comment rubs me the wrong way. Sometimes, even when people come from the same family, you have to realize that each person's situation is unique. Especially when you have such a disparity in age: from 42 years old to 18 years old. Allow me to present some counter anecdotal "evidence." I have two brothers. We're all 6 years apart; I'm 21, the middle is 27, and the oldest is 33. We've ended up in vastly different situations due to a series of personal choices affected and limited by the environment we were given. The environment that one grows up in, even within their family, is such an important factor. The amount of money and mobility my parents had, when my oldest brother was born, was an order of a magnitude less than what they had when I was born. As a result, my oldest brother's only option was public school in an underfunded district for grades 1-12. College was out of the qusetion, even if he could make it! On the other hand, my middle brother had the option to go to private school for grades 1-12, and graduated from University of Miami. For me, it was private school for grades 1-8, and when my parents were faced with the decision of sending me to the same public school my oldest brother went to, they moved instead to send me to one of the best public schools in the state. My oldest brother didn't have that option. So when you see my oldest brother unable to hold down a moderately well-paying blue-collar job, and me working a low six-figure white-collar job, you can't simply say that one of us needs to "step it up." We are largely a product of the totality of our environment.
- bluedino 13y agoI understand what you're trying to say. The youngest siblings can have the advantage of seeings their older siblings success/failure and then attempt to emulate, or avoid that. They can also fall into the trap of being taken care of by the older siblings. >> Especially when you have such a disparity in age: from 42 years old to 18 years old. You're making the assumption that the successful children are all similar in age. They're not. >> As a result, my oldest brother's only option was public school in an underfunded district for grades 1-12. College was out of the qusetion, even if he could make it! None of your brothers classmates made it beyond high school?
- Denzel 13y agoInteresting, I'd be all for hearing more about your observations. Feel free to shoot me an email: [HN name].morris1 'at' gmail. >> None of your brothers classmates made it beyond high school? I can't say for sure because it's difficult to find the statistics from back then. The difference in expectations between the schools is definitely palpable. (I tutored there throughout HS.) Even in comparison today, his school's graduation rate is 63% and is ranked 482nd out of 489 districts by state assessment scores, while my school has a graduation rate of 94% and ranks in the top 5%.
- goggles99 13y ago>Even in comparison today, his school's graduation rate is 63% and is ranked 482nd out of 489 districts by state assessment scores, while my school has a graduation rate of 94% and ranks in the top 5%. I am curious if you believe that this is because the schools was a bad school (under-funded, bad teachers and administrators), or because the parents of the kids that attended there were generally lower than average quality parents? (on drugs, welfare baby mommas, abusive, spend all their free time watching TV and not disciplining or spending any time with their children, non loving, single parent with 3 jobs to make ends meat, ETC.)
- bedhead 13y agoThe problem is that you cannot say whether your older brother is the way he is because of a lifetime of crummy public schooling or just because he's wired that way. The age old causation vs correlation issue. All else equal (in this case, primarily your family), I don't think school quality has much to do with whether you are relatively dysfunctional as an adult. Family values, work ethic, and god-given intelligence probably make up 95% of your outcome in life.
- NoPiece 13y agoAre blacks and latinos in silicon valley falling behind compared to blacks and latinos in other parts of the country? If your population includes Facebook and Twitter and Google employees, almost everyone is going to appear to fall behind them, but it doesn't mean they are doing worse.
- j_baker 13y agoAs a general rule of thumb, any organism's behavior is the result of a combination of its individual choices and the environment those choices are made within. I don't doubt that you have family members who have fallen behind as a result of their own choices. But as someone coming from a middle-class white family, I can tell you that I have many relatives who have made equally poor decisions and aren't in jail, didn't get pregnant at age 14, and didn't drop out of high school. Now put those same family members in a lower-income and higher-crime environment (as minorities are more likely to live in), and I don't doubt that members of my family would have ended up in much the same situation. People make bad decisions to be sure, but it's silly to say that what happens to people is solely the result of their own decisions.
- timr 13y ago"People make bad decisions to be sure, but it's silly to say that what happens to people is solely the result of their own decisions." Amen. I don't have to speculate -- I've seen it happen. My family isn't many generations out of blue collar, and I have a lot of distant relatives who fit the description. Circumstance matters immensely. People that I knew as normal kids veered wildly off the tracks once they got older and the consequences of their decisions were amplified by their surroundings.
- mempko 13y agoSo I suspect you believe in free will as the ultimate arbiter of success? Are you a scientific man? If so, where do you see where free will fits in the matter of physics?