12 ms·
I sometimes wonder if shopping for groceries is as frustrating for most people. I like Nutella, but when I see Palm Oil as the second ingredient I picture dead
by CalRobert 13y ago
I sometimes wonder if shopping for groceries is as frustrating for most people. I like Nutella, but when I see Palm Oil as the second ingredient I picture dead orangutans. I like beef, but I sympathize for a fellow mammal and think of the enormous amounts of diverted water and fertilizer runoff that goes in to producing feed. I enjoy fish, but thinking of this makes me sick to my stomach. I enjoy many beverages that come in plastic bottles, but that plastic, even if recycled, comes at substantial cost. Even veggies are largely wrapped in plastic anymore. Even though it's a small thing compared to everything else in life Keurig machines fill me with rage. And yet, I am guilty too. I love to travel, and this generally means flying since I live on an island. Therefore I contribute to ocean acidification, climate change, and of course the industrial processes that go into making planes.
When people ask why I prefer not to buy fish and I say it's because of concern over the world's fisheries (I'd rather not dive in a global jellyfish swarm) they look at me like I'm from another planet. Who gives a crap, after all? One person's actions will not stop the destruction of our only planet.
sigh
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- checker 13y agoI think it's a mistake to consider our homeworld disposable, regardless of what worlds we may eventually live on.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- _broody 13y agoThat sort of naive techno-utopian response isn't helpful at all in the face of reality. We lack the ability to stop the degradation of our current environment. That doesn't bring high hopes that we could undertake the exponentially more difficult task of building a new and better one in another planet, not before we run out of time.
- maxerickson 13y agoIs that true? The Great Lakes are cleaner now than they were in recent history (I guess if you consider zebra muscles, lampreys and the ongoing dangers of Asian carp that is less true). From the standpoint of industrial contamination things are certainly improving. Licensing programs have succeeded in increasing fish harvests (that is, given cooperation the number of fish in the ocean can be increased alongside increased extraction). There are all sorts of situations where the problem is that we aren't doing something we know would work.
- dredmorbius 13y agoLimited regions, mostly in advanced countries, where both environmental controls and offshoring of highly polluting activities has taken place, are cleaner. Many aren't. Within the US you have hog farms in the Carolinas, CAFOs in Kansas, the Mississippi river basin, Gulf of Mexico, and the great rivers of the developing world: the Nile, Amazon, Ganges, Yellow, Yangtze, and Indus, are in much worse shape. Licensing programs have succeeded in increasing fish harvests They're not doing a whole lot for fish stocks however. And that's the rather bigger problem.
- maxerickson 13y agoNo, I'm talking about fisheries management practices that do increase stocks. Overfishing is being reduced and harvests are increasing: http://www.oceanconservancy.org/our-work/fisheries/ http://www.oceanconservancy.org/our-work/fisheries/ The very likely explanation is stocks are increasing in response to the better management. I agree that it will be difficult to get people in the U.S. to push China to take a more expensive approach to industry. I think calling it 'offshoring' is awfully simplistic (U.S. is agricultural exporter and for energy only imports oil).
- dredmorbius 13y agoI'd still argue that the results of such programs have been distinctly limited. Fair point and links appreciated, however.
- Luc 13y agoIt won't make you feel better, but sadly the extinction of species is as much a part of nature as the death of an individual organism, with nearly all species that have ever existed having gone extinct. Given that, I think the small kindnesses you are showing towards your fellow biosphere inhabitants are about all you can do. IMHO.
- DougWebb 13y agoYes species have gone extinct, but they're also been replaced. We're not seeing the replacements these days, only the extinctions. Eventually the biosphere can redevelop from a very small core of survivors, but we'll be long-gone by then.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoIn fact the day will inevitably come when we've 'reformatted' the entire ecosphere. Why settle for whatever random collection of life-forms were here when we came to sentience as a race? That's all we really have; a snapshot of life on our planet, different from what came before and certainly different from what will come once we've had our way with it, for better or for worse.
- Luc 13y agoI'm describing the situation, not making a judgement. We, as a species, appear rather better at making other species extinct than in preserving them. Our pitiful attempts at preservation will not suffice to preserve current species, I reckon.
- pdonis 13y agoWe're not seeing the replacements these days, only the extinctions. Replacement can take a long time--millions of years.
- fromdoon 13y agoAs someone already said, we should not worry about our planet, for it is going to be here, long long after we are finished. We should be worried about ourselves. We rely on our planet for our existence and the current state of our planet hangs on a fine balance of its constituent elements. If we were to change the balance, the planet would not die, it would only enter into a new different state. But we would surely die or at least most of us would. Some of us think that sooner or later, humans would be able to colonize other places in Universe and then our survival would not wholly rely on Earth. That is certainly possible. But how far into the future would that be possible and whether we would be able to survive another hundred years of drastic pollution of Earth is anyone's guess.
- frankzinger 13y ago"As someone already said, we should not worry about our planet, for it is going to be here, long long after we are finished. We should be worried about ourselves." See, this is something I don't get about most people. Does nobody else feel sympathy for individual animals? We're inflicting immeasurable amounts of suffering and death and nothing will ever make that less of a tragedy.
- derefr 13y agoThat's a particular kind of scope insensitivity on your part, though: although we're inflicting suffering and death... so is the rest of nature, greater in most cases by enough signifiant figures that our effect gets lost in the noise. For every individual animal suffering at the hands of a human, millions die of starvation and disease in exactly their "adaptive habitat"--when they're not slowly chewed to death by predators, or hijacked by parasites to live horrible zombie lives. Perhaps we like to imagine that animal populations are, on average, as healthy as we are when left to their own devices... but we have society, and medicine. Life as a wild animal sucks. If you want to imagine a utopia, first imagine a world where both the lion and the gazelle somehow survive, without one dying to feed the other. This will probably take you a long time to picture, unless you've really given thought to problems like Friendly AI before.
- leobelle 13y agohttp://www.nutellausa.com/faqs.htm http://www.nutellausa.com/faqs.htm Nutella is "a member of the RSPO (Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil), Ferrero only uses palm oil which is extracted from controlled plantations in Malaysia." So you can enjoy your Nutella guilt free.
- pstuart 13y agoIf one also ignores the fact that it's mainly sugar frosting.
- BlackDeath3 13y agoWell, that's the primary motivation for the purchase, is it not?
- justinator 13y agoSee if Justin's Hazelnut Butter spread is available. Much less sugar, and less palm oil (more actual nuts) and Justin's also a member of RSPO. It will cost you about an arm and a leg, but it's oh, so good. http://www.justins.com/products.php http://www.justins.com/products.php Sadly, I don't there's a way to directly link to the product description, which is really silly, but allows you to explore some other things they have. Their Vanilla Almond Butter tastes like cookie dough. In a good way. (I am also not "Justin", of "Justin's"
- pekk 13y agoThe subject was that palm oil involves dead orangutans. Does sugar frosting do that too, or are we changing the subject to how sugar is bad? If you overeat sugar frosting, it's your diabetes, not a negative externality.
- dredmorbius 13y agoDiabetes in a modern technological society with socialized healthcare (and all modern healthcare systems are to some extent socialized) does impose negative externalities. As do many other diseases. TDR-TB is one of my, um, favorites in this regard: http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1wc86m/the_nasty_thing_about_tdrtb_is_that_its/ http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1wc86m/the_nast...
- sliverstorm 13y agoI can't think of anything at the grocery store that doesn't have some sort of negative implication. Heck, just driving to the grocery store burns fuel and supports the automotive industry. Biking to the grocery store burns food (of which all food has negative implications) and supports the bicycle industry. You can work yourself into knots over it; there is no way in which you can eat food and not have some negative impact. So, IMO, you either give up the battle entirely, or you can stop killing yourself over it but still make intelligent choices. For example, I eat fish because I believe fish farming could be a better choice for the future than cattle farming, and I eat chicken because the feed-to-meat ratio is better than beef. As not only animals but meat-eating animals, it's just a fact of life that our/your existence costs something, means some sort of sacrifice for another organisim. You can try to reduce your impact, but you can't not have an impact. Also, a little bit of my personal philosophy here- one way we could reduce our impact is by doing as little as possible, never moving about and burning more calories than absolutely necessary. Never performing strenuous activity that results in regenerative & anabolic processes, which require extra nutrients. But the way I see it, just existing costs the world "100 externality". If living to the fullest costs "110 externality", I feel like I am doing a disservice if I chose the first option, saving so little "externality" and spending my life miserable. For have I not then utterly wasted the costs I imposed on the world?
- pygy_ 13y agoThat's patent nonsense. The problem is not consumption/destruction per se, but the fact that we destroy more than what the planet can build out of solar energy. We're burning the reserves and the means of production.
- sliverstorm 13y agoWhat, precisely, is nonsense about my comment? Brushing something off as nonsense and saying vanishingly little else is not exactly a compelling argument. Also, did you read my parent? Parent was not talking about sustainability and burn rate vs. incoming solar energy or production rate. Parent was talking about mental anguish brought about by the costs his existence poses on the planet- at least, that's what I heard.
- aktbc 13y agoI agree with your sentiment about those Keurig machines. What a vile invention.
- anigbrowl 13y agoEven the inventor has come out as saying that they're a bad idea and that he wouldn't do it now; he designed it as a boutique/niche product, never anticipating the problem of waste at scale. I've had several people offer them to me as gifts in the last few years and although they do make a delicious cup of coffee and I love coffee, I just can't stomach the waste involved. Not just the cups and so on - reusable containers are becoming available - but all the hardware and energy devoted to producing single small servings. Just maddening. There was an excellent article on the subject published last year: http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/waste-the-dark-side-of-the-new-coffee-craze/Content?oid=3687220&showFullText=true http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/waste-the-dark-side-of...
- CalRobert 13y agoYeah.. the weird thing is somehow this process is considered odd, or something fit for a "dirty hippie" 1) Grab a jar with a lid. 2) Get the store down the street to measure the weight of the empty jar 3) Fill the jar with roasted coffee beans, note the new weight, and pay for the difference 4) grind the beans and make some coffee in a French press. Is this so crazy? Of course, the coffee is hopefully shade grown (most isn't) so there's that, but even so. Why is something as simple as "using a glass jar or bottle more than once" so crazy? Why is it if I go to Latin America soda bottles are collected, washed, and reused, but in the US and elsewhere they make a brand new plastic bottle every time, at best downcycling the plastic?
- aestra 13y ago>Why is something as simple as "using a glass jar or bottle more than once" so crazy? Most people don't realize: "Reduce, Reuse, Recycle" That is actually the order they are supposed to go in!! First you try to reduce. Then, you try to REUSE what you have. When you can't THEN you recycle. People tend to skip the first two steps or don't realize there is an order to them.
- fleitz 13y agoThere are no sins to atone for, stop feeling guilty. Live life, mother nature isn't going to flood the earth and destroy everything if you don't accept the saviour into your heart.
- jaegerpicker 13y agoFar be it from me to tell anyone else what their conscience should be but to me it's not that we can be zero impact. Nothing living on this planet is zero impact. Sharks eat fish that eat krill that eat etc... The key is to be as sustainable as possible. We can eat fish but need to work to educate the uneducated about only supporting the responsible fishermen. When you quit and walk away from buying fish all together you lose your voice into the industry. People listen to the money and refusing to spend money will just leave the industry listening to those who do buy fish but don't care how it's caught. If you like fish but hate this kind of behavior then we need to make an effort to only buy sustainably caught/farmed fish. A very good resource is: http://www.seafoodwatch.org/cr/seafoodwatch.aspx http://www.seafoodwatch.org/cr/seafoodwatch.aspx You sound like you already have done some reading about this, if so I wasn't trying to be condescending, I just try and get the info out as much as possible.
- chaosphere2112 13y agoLeave me alone! I'm just an ordinary man / who loves strawberries / I love to grab the green fuzziness / in my gathered fingertips / and dip the seedy point in sour cream / and brown sugar / and into my waiting lips. Mmmm, that's a sweet kiss worth / repeating all night, / just an ordinary man / loving his strawberries. / And I don't want to have to think / who picked them with / what brown illegal alien fingers, / back bent under the California sun / that used to belong to his forefathers anyway. I don't want know that the price of cream is American decadence / that the rest of the world would never dream of spending. / Or that sugar is giving me an insulin rush, / or that strawberries are sprayed with EDB / causing me cancer. I don't want to know these things, so don't bother me. / I'm just an ordinary man who loves strawberries / that come to me past striking cashiers at Safeway / that come to me in green plastic baskets / that will not decompose / but fill the air with toxic fumes as they're incinerated at the city dump / polluting Hawaii's air and ocean. Plastic containers, a petroleum biproduct / that the Arabs are processing / to enable the rich to buy the homes of movie stars in Beverly Hills / to buy whole hotels in Miami, or LA, or New York / while the rest of their people / in poverty pray / bowing their heads to the ancient ground. While all of the oil flows out of the deserts / to America / to grease the great machine / that grows the strawberries that I love / sent by diesel trucks to the coast / and by jet to Hawaii / where I can sit in my bed / and enjoy the pleasures of an ordinary man / kissing that sweet kiss / all night long / without a care in the world. - Eric Chock / http://www.bambooridge.com/bluesun.aspx?bid=259 http://www.bambooridge.com/bluesun.aspx?bid=259 Hand transcribed, so there's a bit of error in there. Edit -- Formatting.
- snake_plissken 13y agoI can't tell if this is supposed to be sarcastic or not.
- CalRobert 13y agoIt is not.
- adamwong246 13y agoThe answer to the question of what to eat: Soylent.
- juziozd 13y agoSoylent contains fish oil. not good... Source: http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/drink-soylent-and-youll-never-have-to-eat-again http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/drink-soylent-and-youll-nev...
- livingparadox 13y agoI was thinking precisely this...
- snarfy 13y agoThe problem is too many people, not the stuff the people consume.
- amalag 13y agoToo many people living like they do now.