13 ms·
Hacking Airline Lounges for Free Meals
- dmethvin 13y agoIn any airport I frequent, this would not be worth the money. Some garages offer free parking for 30 minutes for pick-ups, but by the time you park, go through security, eat, and return you would owe at least $4. Then there's the time/gas cost of getting to/from the airport. Even if you used public transport it could be expensive, it's like $16 round-trip on BART from SFO to downtown San Francisco.
- corin_ 13y agoThere are airports that are easier to get to (for example London City Airport that I use often) - though not sure how many airports that conveniently located have good first class lounges. But would definitely make sense if you live near the airport, or work at the airport, or if rather than going just for a meal you use it as office space (go there, eat breakfast, work using their free wifi, lunch, etc.)
- rch 13y agoIt's really not a problem for places with decent public transportation. There are parts of the world where it makes sense to have a monthly or annual pass. I've no idea what it is like in the area where this occurred though.
- geoka9 13y agoThe Skytrain in Vancouver goes from the downtown to YVR in about 30 minutes. It is possible to go to the airport and back on a $2.75 ticket (on weekends and holidays; the ticket is valid for 90 minutes).
- Gepser 13y agoHere in Guatemala you can take public transportation for about 0.125 USD, if you live near to the airport it could be worth the time.
- dsrguru 13y agoI don't specifically know about Xi'an, but I remember in 2012 subways in Beijing were a flat 2 rmb (about 0.35 USD) and in Shanghai something like 2 to 4 rmb depending on distance. Nanjing was similar, but I don't remember the specifics. So assuming all Chinese cities that have subways charge the same order of magnitude, this loophole would have indeed been valuable.
- aestra 13y agoThe city my sister used to live in had a free airport bus. Took you there for free. Might have been run by an airline. Saw many flight attendants utilizing it.
- Gustomaximus 13y agoFor people that work at airports this could be a very worthwhile hack.
- Uberphallus 13y agoI work in a pretty big GDS/IT company and that wouldn't happen in our systems. Virtually no airline asks for such a retarded business rule, flexible classes allow generally 1 to 5 changes in departure date/time(no questions asked), after that it requires manual intervention on a case by case basis.
- brador 13y agoIn that system, could you not buy a ticket, do 5 changes, then cancel the ticket and rebuy, repeat?
- anaphor 13y agoIt would be a lot harder to make back the cost of the ticket though.
- michaelhoffman 13y agoSince the ticket would be fully refundable, it would just increase the time and hassle involved, not the monetary outlay.
- Uberphallus 13y agoTechnically, if it's already ticketed it's a refund, not a cancel (at GDS level at least), but airlines use both the same at marketing level. You can try that but full refunds are unusual, normally there's a penalty fee. More than for preventing ripping off lounges, it's to prevent third parties from playing tricks on the seats' availability. Maybe it still pays off, have a look!
- _delirium 13y ago> full refunds are unusual, normally there's a penalty fee. At least on United (not too familiar with other airlines' policies), full-fare tickets (Y, J, F) are refundable without a fee. If it was paid on a credit card, they'll typically just reverse the charge.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- stupandaus 13y agoThe idea of having to go through security everyday for free meals sounds unpalatable.
- joezydeco 13y agoWhy? You don't need to carry anything and the guards probably know you pretty well by the 100th visit or so.
- shangxiao 13y agoBy the 100th visit they'd get suspicious that you're scoping out the joint for a terrorist act.
- joezydeco 13y agoNot if you tell them you're just going to eat. Seems like that's pretty easy to confirm. Why be sneaky about it? Obviously nobody at the airline lounge cared that this guy showed up every day, why would the guards care?
- tashi 13y agoImagine you're a guard there and I drop by every day for a meal. You're wondering if I'm a a terrorist looking for security holes while I eat, and your biggest concern is false negatives: you would hate to rule me out as a threat and then find out I blew up your airport. What questions would you ask me to figure that out?
- brokenparser 13y agoHello, do you happen to be one of those y'know... Terrorists?
- rhizome 13y agoCan't prove a negative. Next question?
- aquateen 13y agoYou could buy a first class ticket and hold on to it for a year, then use the lounges whenever you actually do travel. It doesn't look like this is possible in the US though. I don't see an airline that offers their lounge just for having a first class ticket. Alaska even requires a ticket for the day you're there.
- rguldener 13y agoIn the article it says he rescheduled his ticket more than 300 times so he might have just always moved it a day or two and basically flew every day... ;)
- DrSbaitso 13y agoMost US airlines don't offer lounge access for domestic first class tickets, but they generally do for international business/first. And sometimes for "premium" transcontinental routes (like JFK-SFO). Then again, the food in US airline lounges leaves a lot to be desired. The free meal would probably just be cheese and crackers and carrot sticks...
- johnmertic 13y agoVery true, I can't imagine going thru the effort to do this to get some pre-packaged cheese and Bud Light. Probably better to just hang out in a hotel lobby which has the same amenities and less hassles.
- sleepyhead 13y agoCan people please stop using "hacking" about every little tweak, tip, or technique to gain something?
- rjbond3rd 13y agoComplaining about the usage of "hacking" is also very tired.
- ThoreauAway 13y agoso where do we go from here?
- pokpokpok 13y agokeep sharing and enjoying content
- sleepyhead 13y agoHacking complaints - blog post coming up.
- danielweber 13y agoIf we weren't on a webtube BBS called "Hacker News" I'd be much more likely to agree.
- nly 13y agoA hack is a novel solution using existing technology outside of its primary intended use case. Even though this is a 'social hack', a hack is nonetheless exactly what this is.
- corin_ 13y agoIt can be taken too far though. If I go shoplifting am I "hacking the shop"? If my shower breaks and I pour bottled water over myself to clean am I "hacking bottled water"?
- edwintorok 13y agoAnother interesting story in the comments of that article: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/02/hacking_airline.html#c4187941 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/02/hacking_airli...
- p4bl0 13y agoBe sure to read the comment left by "askme" on the linked page. It is a similar story but it actually made me laugh.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mcphilip 13y agoThe "hack" I've seen the most frequently is buying a ticket that gets you in the priority lane in addition to a standard ticket so that one can go through minimal security wait times and then cancel the ticket in time for a refund.
- scott_karana 13y agoCouldn't it get you in trouble? You'd have to check your bags under the standard ticket, but enter security under the premium one, and airport security might realize they have the same person on the flight twice. I thought that was a classic red flag?
- avn2109 13y agoBarring extraordinary circumstances, checking bags while flying is a textbook case of doing it wrong.
- Falling3 13y agoWhy is that?
- rtkwe 13y agoChecking bags adds a lot of time to your trip after the plane lands, you have to wait ages in many cases for the ground crews to unload and process your baggage. In addition the size for carry-on luggage is pretty large with a small amount of work you can pretty easily get all you need for a trip into the carry-on baggage.
- Falling3 13y agoExcept for a few bad days, I generally don't wait long for my checked luggage. It's sometimes already there by the time I make it to the claim area. Finding overhead space can be a hassle and I much prefer boarding and unboarding without dragging a ton of stuff. And carry-on obviously limits the items you can bring along on a plane. Your arguments are perfectly valid for some, but this is isn't a case of "this method is obviously right".
- awwstn 13y agoMost airline lounges in the U.S. offer free snacks, wine and beer – not meals.
- coolsunglasses 13y agoI haven't seen free meals in airline lounges lately either.
- yawz 13y agoNot saying it's the same everywhere but with British Airways you can access a better lounge if you're First Class (not sure if they have meals - maybe someone can confirm that).
- Roedou 13y agoBoth the Business Class and First Class BA lounges at LHR T5 have meals.
- ValentineC 13y agoFrom the guidelines: > Please submit the original source. If a blog post reports on something they found on another site, submit the latter. Should this submission be amended to the URL and headline of the original article? http://www.thestar.com.my/News/Nation/2014/01/24/Man-uses-firstclass-ticket-to-get-free-meals-for-almost-a-year/ http://www.thestar.com.my/News/Nation/2014/01/24/Man-uses-fi...
- revelation 13y agoNo, because the comments on Schneiers blog add value that isn't on the original source. Which is why there are now (two even) comments here that link to comments on the linked blog post. Schneier also found the comments on HN helpful, which is why he now links to this HN thread, even though the HN thread just linked his blog. (Quite the circle by now)
- mathattack 13y agoOnce upon a time the lounges in the US had unlimited free drinks. (I don't travel as much now, so I'm not sure any more) It might not be worth the commute to an airport for a mediocre lunch, but for all you can drink? The real issue is the time involved though. A few hours is worth more than a couple dollars saved.
- theuri 13y agoIt wouldn't be worth getting exposure to that level of radiation on a daily basis from the security process
- codex 13y agoThis is not "hacking." This is just scamming.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ableal 13y agoIn comments: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/02/hacking_airline.html#c4187941 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/02/hacking_airli... Good story about buying a suit at 6 am: "Upon exiting customs, I was greeted (by name) by a number of large men holding submachine guns (rare in UK)."
- AndyJPartridge 13y agoThey take it all very seriously! In January 2004 I took my mum to Disneyland Paris. Someone had accidentally left their luggage next to the belts below the customs booths. The airport was shut down and cleared on that level, whilst a brave man with a machete hacked carefully at the bag to discover sausages.
- United857 13y agoThis has already been debunked to be false: http://shanghaiist.com/2014/01/29/passenger-with-first-class-ticket-eating-free-for-a-year-myth.php http://shanghaiist.com/2014/01/29/passenger-with-first-class...