20 ms·
It’s Time to Make OpenStreetMap Your Only Street Map
- reustle 13y agoI'm currently working on a project that uses google maps in a few places. The main reason I'm not using OSM is gmaps.js [0]. Ideally I will find / create my own simple wrapper like this on top of OSM in the near future [0] http://hpneo.github.io/gmaps/ http://hpneo.github.io/gmaps/
- quarterto 13y agoLeaflet.js[0] is pretty nice. [0]: http://leafletjs.com/ http://leafletjs.com/
- stevekemp 13y agoAlthough I stalled recently I had a great time using Leaflet.js on my Edinburgh pub-exterior site: http://edinburgh.io/pubs/ http://edinburgh.io/pubs/
- yaraher 13y agoHave you tried using OSM through it? We've got support: http://hpneo.github.io/gmaps/examples/map_types.html http://hpneo.github.io/gmaps/examples/map_types.html
- pothibo 13y agoI first encountered OpenStreetMap 2 years ago and was amazed at how precise it was. Moreover, the editor is simply awesome. I had a road opened last year next to where I live and it took me about 2 minutes to register, load the editor, make the change and save it.
- jaryd 13y agoDoes anyone use OpenStreetMap on Android with any success? I'd be grateful to hear of any maps/directions apps that I can use as a replacement in this category.
- milliams 13y agohttp://mapswith.me http://mapswith.me has become very popular recently. I haven't used it much myself so I can give you a proper comparison. Otherwise, OsmAnd is open source and can be found in the F-Droid repository.
- karl42 13y agoI'm using http://osmand.net/ http://osmand.net/ The UI is not perfect, but it has lots of useful features, like bike navigation and offline usage.
- justincormack 13y agoThe UI is horrendous! I would use OSM but it is so terrible I can't. I use it when I dont want to go online, but it is truly awful.
- okasaki 13y ago"Horrendous!" "truly awful"? Can you elaborate on what exactly is wrong with OsmAnd's UI to elicit such a strong reaction? I use it myself and don't have any problems with it. It seems about the same as any mobile app with comparable complexity.
- justincormack 13y ago
- pekk 13y agoCriticizing OSM is at least as hazardous as criticizing Wikipedia, but... Setting aside ideological purity, the actual rationality of switching solely to OSM depends on the actual quality and freshness of its data. And most of the world with money in play is more likely to follow rationality than ideological purity here. But with regard to data quality, OSM is encumbered its own policy. OSM cannot (or refuses to) make use of high-quality bulk data from outside, regardless of how that data was licensed. Automation allows more frequent updates with a lot less manual labor as input - but OSM requires contributors to manually trace shapes in their weird browser app. Even where plenty of excellent liberally licensed data is available, OSM insists on making an army of unpaid monkeys re-make the SAME data in perpetuity. That puts its pipeline at a permanent disadvantage to companies building proprietary datasets, which can take advantage of all kinds of automation. OSM simply isn't doing as much as it could to verify its data and stay fresh, and so it isn't doing as much as it could to end the status quo of proprietary data. Even if OSM reaches a usable state at a given moment, the world keeps changing to invalidate previously traced data, and OSM's policy ensures it will always be playing catch-up no matter who wants to donate data, because all the data has to come through this dopey manual process.
- milliams 13y agoThis is false. OSM contributors have used automatically imported data many many times and continue to the world over. There is however a wariness to use it too much since maintenance and community building both suffer.
- pekk 13y agoIs the purpose to make good data, or to make a community of people manually tracing things that were already traced in liberally licensed data? And how exactly does this help with maintenance?
- milliams 13y agoThe former. It has been found that encouraging a community around the data collection creates much better data in the long run. An involved community can go beyond what is provided by other datasets and do more than can be done with 'tracing'. There's more to OSM that road centre-lines and building outlines.
- yuvadam 13y agoI've completely migrated recently from using Google Search, and use DuckDuckGo exclusively, even if sometimes I get results of lower quality. I'm willing to compromise for better privacy. I have a sneaking suspicion that once finally I replace Google Maps with OSM there won't be any compromises to be made.
- Trufa 13y agoOut our firm, we do a Navigation system specialized for bikes, and TBH, for little side-roads and everything that is not the main roads, OSM seems to win. I would say that where some services are lacking in that regard is geocoding, the spelling correction at Google is pretty hard to beat, addresses are incredibly hard to parse and Google has definitely and edge in that sense.
- queensnake 13y agoI still use Google maps and search, I just do it in my main browser (FF natch) which has a cookie whitelister that rejects Google cookies.
- blueskin_ 13y agoI wish I could. Google search and maps are the only google products I still use (well, plus youtube, but no account, and blogger, but only reading), and I use duckduckgo intermittently instead of google search, but OpenStreetMap just isn't good enough yet, primarily by nit having yet found a halfway decent mobile app.
- collyw 13y agoI did like Navfree. It wasn't perfect, but neither is Google maps. Usually if one was not finding things correctly, the other would. Now the application has gone to the trouble of upgrading itself on my phone, without upgrading the actual maps, so it was completely useless last time I tried to use it.
- Yuioup 13y ago"Why the world needs OpenStreetMap" "It's Time to Make OpenStreetMap your only street map" I think somebody is trying to say something here.
- junto 13y agoIf I could find a replacement for Google Maps that hooked into Google StreetView, I'd be a happy chappie. I find Google Street View and amazing tool, but want to move away from the maps part. I refuse to install Google Maps on iOS, because every time I've installed it on our FAMILY iPad, it keeps driving the user to sign in with MY account, which it appears to have weaseled out of the sandboxed Google+ for iOS. Sorry, but firstly I don't want to have a search history. Secondly I don't want the search history of the rest of family to be linked to my Google account. I understand that some people might want to switch this on as a feature, byt I don't, and Google have designed the app, so that it seems like it won't work without signing in. A very dark UI pattern if you ask me. This whole assumption of one-device-one-person is naive.
- cbaleanu 13y agoI was quite surprised to see there actually are a lot of competitors for Google StreetView: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_of_Google_Street_View http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_of_Google_Street_Vi...
- things 13y agoOn a recent project, I looked into using OSM alongside streetview but after digging through Google's license it appears google's own maps are the only ones you can use if you're also using streetview. Which makes sense, but I checked anyway as I had seen websites using other map services coupled with streeview.
- Vvector 13y agoMy home address doesn't exist in OSM. Actually it does exist, but in the wrong city. This is due to the use of TIGER data, which doesn't align with Post Office addresses. So using my address, no one can find my house. And while I can edit the map to move the road where needed, I cannot change the city. Google, Bing, Yahoo, etc, all have no problem finding my house.
- yellowbkpk 13y agoOur existing geocoders don't do a great job (geocoding is a hard problem), and have an especially hard time at guessing containment in situations like you describe. One solution is to map your house using iD (the default editor when you click the "Edit" button on osm.org) and add the full address, including the city and postcode. With that extra information, the geocoder should be able to find your address. Feel free to e-mail me if you've got more questions.
- latch 13y agoLearning more about OSM is something I've been meaning to do for a while, but I'll commit time and do it, because I think it's a great project. That said, every time I look at an OSM map, I find them uglier and far less usable than google maps. Here's the Sochi example using OSM's Transport layer (which is less cluttered): http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/43.5883/39.7263&layers=T http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/43.5883/39.7263&layers=... vs: https://maps.google.com/maps?q=sochi&aq=&sll=37.0625,-95.677068&sspn=58.294644,99.580078&z=16 https://maps.google.com/maps?q=sochi&aq=&sll=37.0625,-95.677... If I had to navigate Sochi, I would overwhelmingly prefer Google's version. It's cleaner, has better contrast and a number of subtle touches (english translations, one-way arrows, ...). When I travel, I always download offline OSM maps, in case, but eagerly get a SIM card with a data plan and switch to Google Maps (and I suddenly find myself better oriented).
- karl42 13y agoThe "MapQuest Open" layer seems better for a comparison to gmaps: http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/43.5883/39.7263&layers=Q http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/43.5883/39.7263&layers=...
- kozhevnikov 13y agoFor the sake of comparison -- Yandex (Russia's top search engine) http://maps.yandex.com/-/CVfuFU67 http://maps.yandex.com/-/CVfuFU67
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoI notice that they all (Google, OSM, Yandex) have comprehensive coverage of buildings and house numbers (though you might have to zoom to see them). I'm guessing this is open government data that's been imported, as I don't recall seeing them in the UK much.
- twelvechairs 13y agoUk have a bit of a legacy mess of systems. they use ordinance survey for mapping which is quite detailed for physical features (roads, fences, woods, buildings) but often doesn't provide actual property boundaries. they charge quite a lot (for reasonable reasons in some industries) to access this. the post office hold a separate database (also costly) of real addresses
- poopsintub 13y agoI need traffic data to switch, right?
- gchokov 13y agoThe map is still far from complete in my part of the world, so I can't really switch.
- dublinben 13y agoHave you contributed to make the map better?
- gchokov 13y agoYes I did :)
- yellowbkpk 13y agoWhere are you? Let's make it better for you.
- gchokov 13y agoVery nice of you. Here I am - http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/42.0331/24.3015 http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/42.0331/24.3015
- yellowbkpk 13y agoHmm. You've found one of OSM's many achille's heels. You're in a part of the world that doesn't have very good satellite imagery coverage, so the only way we can map is using recorded GPS data. You can help by wandering around with your smartphone's GPS turned on and uploading the traces to OSM.org for others to map with.
- gchokov 13y agoI will certainly do it. Thanks for the tip!
- ithkuil 13y agoIt's funny, for Ireland I found it far more complete than Google Maps.
- mwexler 13y agoCurious to understand just how Telenav will try to make money off of OSM: Will they be the "Red Hat" of OSM? Will they sell "custom add-ons"? What might they do to both benefit the community and make money from usage? Could be great improvements, or could become known as "that day that OSM started to die"...
- yellowbkpk 13y agoTeleNav sells navigations apps to smartphone users. They use OpenStreetMap data for some of those apps (and presumably want to use it in all their apps), so they're interested in seeing OSM prosper.
- officemonkey 13y agoSo they hope to outsource their QC to bring OSM's data up to Navteq? If that's the case, they need to Gameify this pronto, like Duolingo does with crowd-sourced translations.
- yellowbkpk 13y agoNo, they're adding their QC resources to OSM's existing 20k+ monthly active editors and not only improving the map for their own use, but for others as well.
- brudgers 13y agoI would use Open Street Map, except that I find aerial photographs are often an invaluable aid to navigation because they provide a more complete model of facts on the ground. Aerial photographs allow better recognition of landmarks - how wide is the road, how big is a building's parking area, does the address resolve to a football pitch? The level of geographic information just isn't there to make it a viable first choice for me because orientation is more difficult.
- Uchikoma 13y agoWhen in Tokyo lately I've used OSM and found it suprisingly good. What I did miss compared to the Google Maps app is the direction the device is pointing towards. Routing would also be nice :-)
- yellowbkpk 13y agoRouting is provided by external tools like http://map.project-osrm.com http://map.project-osrm.com and http://open.mapquest.com/ http://open.mapquest.com/. On a mobile device you can use OsmAnd to navigate.
- Uchikoma 13y agoThanks for the links, didn't know.
- Doctor_Fegg 13y agoRouting is coming to osm.org real soon now.
- jtth 13y agoIt can't even find my city given city and state, in a state capital! I'll switch just as soon as it learns where the United States is.
- yellowbkpk 13y agoCan you give the search string you typed? As I mentioned elsewhere, geocoding is a hard problem, and we've certainly not solved it. We can make it better by improving the data, though. I'd love to make your search better next time.
- legulere 13y agoThe data isn't the problem of Openstreetmap. What's missing is one go-to site with a nice rendering that doesn't try to show off all features and offers a similar feature set as google maps (searching for locations, shops, navigation).
- liotier 13y agoYou forget the essential feature of Google Maps: advertising - the reason for giving you the other features. Map data is free but serving maps is a service... Either you pay for it, suffer advertising or do it yourself - the first and last options are available from Openstreetmap.
- yellowbkpk 13y agoTry http://open.mapquest.com/ http://open.mapquest.com/
- canistr 13y agoThe map comparison tool is quite excellent. I'd love to use this tool for testing generic sites. http://tools.geofabrik.de/mc/?lon=39.7203&lat=43.58538&zoom=15&num=2&mt0=mapnik&mt1=google-map http://tools.geofabrik.de/mc/?lon=39.7203&lat=43.58538&zoom=...
- rburhum 13y agoI have been using OSM for 7 years and I really love the project. Nevertheless, the biggest issue I have when it is compared to GMaps is not the content nor rendering (those are relatively straightforward to change)... it is the geocoder + routing. There is not a good geocoder for OSM, period. Until we can put an address, like we can in GMaps, and get a pin in the right location, it will always be an option that is not a 100% replacement. Same with routing. Don't get me wrong, it has its uses, but those two components are too critical to ignore or even advocate for full replacement.
- ris 13y agoUntil OSM _has_ all of the addresses, it can't geocode to them. So your comment doesn't make much sense.
- eurg 13y agoIt is usually also much more finicky with regard to address syntax. Google Maps does a good job handling spelling mistakes or ambiguous addresses. OSM is not on par with GM, yet.
- rmc 13y agoYeah, I've heard that. GM is better at lower qualitys. But then search is google's main skill, and addresses can be all over the place...
- rburhum 13y agoActually, "has all of the addresses" doesn't make much sense. The way most geocoders work is by having street segments that are split at certain points and have from/to ranges of addresses. Here is a SO questions I asked many years ago that explains the logic: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/10991330/how-does-the-google-geocoder-work http://stackoverflow.com/questions/10991330/how-does-the-goo... In the US, a big chunk of OSM is based on a Tiger ingest. Tiger already had the segments split with the ranges (albeit some areas are not that accurate). In theory, you could still have a nice geocoder for US (the same is true for other countries like Germany). The current crowdsourcing workflow of how people edit data in OSM makes it attractive for display (i.e. there is no need to split the street segments and add the address ranges for "pretty display"). But it also causes people to not edit the address ranges, snap the edges, etc, which just means that as a routing or geocoding dataset it is arguably actually worse. You don't need _all_ the addresses to geocode. In theory, you could start with a particular country, clean it up for that problem. But right now, that is not the emphasis of OSM. The emphasis is a pretty base layer. For that OSM is awesome. For routing and geocoding, not so much.
- Camillo 13y agoGoogle Maps's killer feature for me is public transit information. It would be nice if there were an open public transit schedule database that interfaced with OSM.
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoGoogle tries to do the right thing here and get the authorities to publish the info in an open format. As I understand it, the big holdup is the fact that a City can sell that data to a single supplier instead and get income (at the expense of citizen's getting fast, efficient and cheap transport info). http://code.google.com/p/googletransitdatafeed/wiki/PublicFeeds http://code.google.com/p/googletransitdatafeed/wiki/PublicFe...
- Vik1ng 13y agoWhich outside the US isn't that great. In Germany it only has the railway data, but no buses or trams, which makes up most of the public transport in smaller cities and even important connections in larger ones.
- prewett 13y agoI can't speak for anywhere else, but Google's public transit information for Beijing is excellent. Even has correct and complete information for bus routes. (Use ditu.google.cn for best location results, may require an IP address inside the PRC)
- nollidge 13y agoIt's way too slow for me. Taking 20-30 seconds to fill in map tiles while I'm panning around.
- tnuc 13y agoI want to like OpenStreetMap, I really do... If I see a place on the map.. Why can't I click on it? I can't get the address, telephone number, website etc.? And I see and picture of a shopping basket? What is it? I also see a cocktail glass, it's a fucking mystery.
- aw3c2 13y agoYou are confusing the map data with a website (probably openstreetmap.org). That functionality is possible, check out some PoCs: http://r2d2.stefanm.com/mapnik/demo.html http://r2d2.stefanm.com/mapnik/demo.html http://overpass.apis.dev.openstreetmap.org/ http://overpass.apis.dev.openstreetmap.org/ http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Top_Ten_Tasks/Progress/Clickable_POIs_on_the_frontpage http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Top_Ten_Tasks/Progress/Cl...
- mikegreen 13y agoCompletely agree. I posted nearly the same reply to the other "you gotta use OSM!" thread a few weeks ago. Completely unusable as a replacement to apple or google maps, for me. Might be OK for looking for roads, like, uh, a street map - but to replace gmaps functionality with the simple feature of "click on an icon and show me the details" it is not.
- bliker 13y agoThere is also http://www.openlinkmap.org/ http://www.openlinkmap.org/ But nothing really usable I agree
- morganherlocker 13y agoNot intuitive, but zoom in and hit the edit button. You should now see all the data as vectors. Click on anything and you will see all of the metadata.
- rmc 13y agoOr zoom in and show the "Data" layer
- nodata 13y ago> It's Time to Make OpenStreetMap your only street map I can't. Your new app is US only, and osmand is good but not good enough.
- jordan0day 13y agoOne thing I really like about OSM is the fact that it accepts pull requests from anybody. For example, I live on a road that ends in "Street", but for whatever reason, Google's online maps have it marked as "Lane". This results in delivery drivers and service people often going to the wrong address. The street name was wrong on OSM, but I submitted a pull request and saw the fix implemented immediately. Interestingly, Apple Maps, Mapquest, and Bing maps all have the right street name. After I submitted the PR to OSM, it's correct now, too. Only Google Maps is still wrong, which is unfortunate, since that seems to be the one most people rely on (especially w.r.t phone GPS's). I've had several instances of friends calling, confused on how to reach my house, after their Google Maps App took them to a house a few blocks away.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoHave you tried making the change in Google Maps? I've made 10+ changes in the last 2 years, and have found their QA team to be very responsive.
- jordan0day 13y agoYes, I just did earlier this morning -- for some reason it never occurred to me to try until I saw this article.
- bad_user 13y agoI tried making 2 contributions to Google Maps and both were rejected by overzealous moderators. So I gave up on trying to submit changes to Google Maps, plus, as the article correctly states - GMaps data does not belong to us, so why contribute?
- rmc 13y agoAnyone can edit and improve OSM straight away. It's like editing Wikipedia. There is no-one there to "accept" or "reject" "pull requests"
- nantes 13y agoSeems to be having load issues -- CoralCDN link http://stevecoast.com.nyud.net/2014/01/30/its-time-to-make-openstreetmap-your-only-street-map/ http://stevecoast.com.nyud.net/2014/01/30/its-time-to-make-o...
- virtualritz 13y agoTypical use case for me: hitting on Google Maps to find addresses via venue names; 99% of the time. I.e. I enter the name of the restaurant etc + some fuzzy data, like part of town or name of the city. This just works. Last time I checked (just now), this still didn't get me any useful results from OSM for the European capitals I frequent (Rome, Paris, Berlin). I guess it is even worse for smaller cities. Yes, there is some venue/business data. But it is too sparse, at least for most of Europe, for OSM to be a useful replacement for Google Maps -- even in the medium term. The question would be: how could this be rapidly improved? For example, I entered probably two dozen places that were missing on Google Maps, in the past. While this data is now Google's, I entered it, originally. What's more, if I would be adding it again, to OSM, I'd certainly enter the same data. I wonder what the legal perspective would be if everyone crawled "their" data (i.e. the data they personally entered) from Google maps and forwarded it to OSM.
- untog 13y agoWhat you're talking about is geocoding, not mapping. OSM doesn't even have its own geocoder, and I'm yet to find one that gets anywhere near to Google's results. Sadly.
- virtualritz 13y agoNot sure I get what you mean. The 'Edit' function on openstreetmap.org lest me add exactly this kind of information. So they do provide it, or not?
- maxerickson 13y agoSort of. The search box on the OSM.org site is more a data inspector than it is a search nearby box. So going to a place and searching for 'fastfood' returns objects from around the world based on the name matching 'fastfood'. A more structured input, like 'fast food, detroit, mi' returns something more sensible (but it is still searching the city limits of Detroit, not the metro area). So the machinery there provides information, but it is not set up for end user situations.
- DenisM 13y agoIt would be nice to have an app that pulls data from Google Maps (or Apple Maps), and at the same time sends location trace to Open Street Maps. That way I could use high-quality maps and still support the OSM project with raw trace data.
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoTangent for bored hackers: you can torrent the entire OpenStreetMap dataset right now. It's only 23 GiB, in a simple format stored as protocol buffers. http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Planet.osm#BitTorrent http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Planet.osm#BitTorrent http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/PBF http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/PBF (format documentation) http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Map_Features http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Map_Features (common tag strings) edit: This was my first render from this weekend, http://i.imgur.com/vD9d39W.png http://i.imgur.com/vD9d39W.png :D
- seagreen 13y agoSweet! This means you could have a complete navigation system without a dataplan.
- cbaleanu 13y agoYou would still have to roll your own offline geocoder. From my experience with OSM and Oracle's Spatial Geocoder, getting accurate driving directions can be a very 'interesting' process.
- ris 13y agoRoll your own? Why not use one of the existing widely-used OSM geocoders? http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Photon http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Photon http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Nominatim http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Nominatim
- SeanLuke 13y ago"Hardware Stores in Alexandria VA" * Google Maps: everything you'd ever want, and correct. * Open Street Map: a Home Depot in Riverside County, CA, and a Lowes which apparently resides inside the exact same building. It is not time for me to make OpenStreetMap my only street map.
- cbaleanu 13y agoJust to clarify, OSM is a map tile data source, while they do have feature data like business locations these are usually added on top of the map, as an separate layer by other entities, not by OSM. Maintaining all those locations would mean a lot of work ( Moneygram for example has around 300.000 locations [0]) that usually involves some sort of revenue, ie displaying ads like Google does. [0] http://www.moneygram.com/MGICorp/campaigns/moneytransfer/index.htm http://www.moneygram.com/MGICorp/campaigns/moneytransfer/ind... edit: added link
- Doctor_Fegg 13y agoOSM!=osm.org
- ris 13y agoYou've now added the ones you know about, I trust?
- fab13n 13y agoI'm currently trying to switch from Google Maps for my smartphone, not because maps are more detailed in geek-dense areas (although they are), but because Google seems to have hired a bunch of drunken lemurs as its usability team. I mean, I value simplicity, especially on the go, and the OSM-based softwares I've tried are by no mean perfect. But with recent versions of Google Map, I have difficulties: * bookmarking my current location, especially when offline * getting a scale displayed on my map (a scaleless map was a mandatory Fail in geography classes) * giving itinerary boundaries through clicks * sharing a marker as a public URL * getting rid of research results once I've seen them And whenever I find a contrived way to do one of those things, more often than not, a couple of weeks later it's taken out by a new "simplification". I'll grant you that maps looks nicer and nicer, but it becomes less and less usable at an alarming speed.
- georgemcbay 13y agoI agree 100%. As Google Maps/Nav moved from 6.x to 7.x it got prettier but terrible to use. I'm still kind of shocked that they fucked up the usability of Nav so bad and still haven't fixed it a year later.
- sixothree 13y agoAre there any nicer OSM clients for Android? Because the one I seem to have tried was abysmal at searching for addresses.
- chrismorgan 13y agoIt's possible that the problem is that OSM lacks the data. For example, in Melbourne, Australia, only a handful of suburbs have any form of street number data, and the street/suburb mapping is overall moderately poor. (If you struggle hard enough you can probably get around it, e.g. in OSMAnd you can search for a street name and then "search in nearby towns/suburbs" and it'll tend to show the right one.)
- helicoidal 13y agoOsmand (https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdid=net.osmand.plus https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdid=net.osmand.plus) is pretty good at this
- hrjet 13y agoI like OSM and have also contributed to it. However, I would be wary of using OSM for navigation. It's very easy for someone to mis-edit (accidentally or maliciously). Also, it is difficult to revert a mis-edit because, unlike Wikipedia, the data is not chunked into pages and there are no simple textual diffs which a non-geek can review.
- sehugg 13y agoOSM data came in handy in Europe. Their public toilet database seems pretty complete. I'd love to have more complete metadata. No reason in 2014 I shouldn't be able to query pet-friendly hotels near brewpubs near bike trails.
- rmc 13y agoBrew pubs and bike trials are mapped. I dunno about pet friendly, but that can vary by country. IM(limited)E Austria is quite pet friendly (pets in hotels and all that), so Austrians mightn't tag that.
- rwmj 13y agoAs a small data point, I used Open Street Map [OSMAnd+] only when I was in Brussels at FOSDEM this weekend. I used it a lot and it was absolutely superb. Obviously this is a major city, but I've also used it in the wilds of the Japanese countryside and found it to be equally reliable.
- clarry 13y agoI've been wanting to become an OSM contributor for a long while now as I like the idea, and there's lots of low-hanging fruit as far as map coverage of my area goes (in osm, it's just plain bad). I also like geocaching, which seems like it would go hand-in-hand with mapping. But I still haven't found an OSM editor that doesn't suck. And right now I don't have the time to write my own, even though I've considered it more than once...
- maxerickson 13y agoWhat sort of things do you find lacking in the editors you have tried?
- stephen_g 13y agoI've found the iD editor on openstreetmap.org to be very good. It's been the main editor since May last year. Potlatch 2 was the main one before that, which wasn't as good but was adequate.
- Semiapies 13y agoNot living in Sochi, the comparison is less convincing for me: http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=17/30.33393/-95.47847 http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=17/30.33393/-95.47847 https://www.google.com/maps/preview/@30.3339269,-95.4784644,17z https://www.google.com/maps/preview/@30.3339269,-95.4784644,... Not to mention that searching for "Conroe, TX" and taking the first, correct-sounding result got me ~10 miles south of city limits. Now, Google has a couple of oddities, here (those two businesses apparently on the median between the freeway and the access road!), but the road data is more accurate and detailed (including street names). I've done some editing on wikis, but I'm not going to try to jump in and correct that gap.
- rmc 13y agoNot to mention that searching for "Conroe, TX" and taking the first, correct-sounding result got me ~10 miles south of city limits. The search box on the OSM front page uses Nominatim, which also has it's own website. Here's the search results for that: http://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/search.php?q=Conroe%2C+TX&viewbox=-119.54%2C47.7%2C119.54%2C-47.7 http://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/search.php?q=Conroe%2C+TX... You can see the 2 results there http://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/details.php?place_id=42740484 http://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/details.php?place_id=4274... and http://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/details.php?place_id=98157421 http://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/details.php?place_id=9815... There's a "Report Problem" button to help debug issues like this. Feel free to submit a bug! I think Nominatim tries to rank things based on how long their Wikipedia article, the the item to the south (that was at the top), is the one that links to Wikipedia. TBH it looks like bad mapping whoever put that there
- agumonkey 13y agoThe 'future' google maps is also too taxing on my (2006) laptop. OSM UI is as good as the current google maps. Good reason to move.
- agumonkey 13y agoFor a reason I can't edit my comment. I forgot to mention that the future google maps doesn't seem to show a distance reference, the UI follows the shift from digital map to mapped services. ps: I wonder if there's an open, possibly smartphone/crowdsourced picture database to fill the lack of photographic/streetview data in OSM. Thinking about reconstructing algorithm as shown by Microsoft Research labs.
- xacaxulu 13y agoAnything that works towards resetting the balance of power against Google is fine by me. Not to mention I've found that Google Maps has given me erroneous directions more frequently than a few years ago.
- bad_user 13y agoThe article mentions that Telenav acquired Skobbler, the makers of a pretty sweet maps app that uses OSM. I've been using it on my Android for navigation for several months now: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.skobbler.forevermapng&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.skobbler.f... I do hope that this app won't die. It's polished, it's user friendly, it's based on OSM (which for me is a feature) and worked very well for me.
- csmithuk 13y agoWell when it works properly for more than a week at a time (export is currently randomly broken) and has turn by turn navigation, yes. So no.
- larcher 13y ago"I’d like it to get OSM to seven billion contributors in the next year or two." Surely that's a typo. Nearly all the world's population contributing to, not just using, OSM? Seven million maybe?
- ntoshev 13y agoI wonder if there is a way to integrate in OSM automatically gathered data from users smartphones, like Waze does. There seem to be incentives to smartphone app makers to provide that. Is there any nice description of the ecosystem around OSM data? How do all these companies providing routing or geocoding make money?
- hyh1048576 13y agoHow about this? Google Map is more detailed. http://tools.geofabrik.de/mc/?lon=110.7203&lat=24.58538&zoom=15&num=2&mt0=mapnik&mt1=google-map http://tools.geofabrik.de/mc/?lon=110.7203&lat=24.58538&zoom...
- zoomerang 13y agoI live 10 minutes from the center of the third largest city in Australia. OpenStreetMaps still doesn't have street numbers. Where data is good, OpenStreetMaps is a fantastic tool. But for the rest of the world - it's utterly useless.
- stephen_g 13y agoThere are lots of street numbers around parts of Brisbane (probably some of the most comprehensive are around Fairfield to South Brisbane). It's pretty easy to add - I traced my neighborhood and added address data in a couple of hours. If you want to make the world a better place, you could do some around your house as well!
- zoomerang 13y agoI certainly could - and might - but the lack of such information is why OSM s still not a viable replacement for commercial maps. (Yet).
- _ZeD_ 13y agoA thing I don't about telenav it's the fact they only release us-only applications. Why can't I use their app? The OSM maps are global...
- truncs 13y agoThe problem with OSM (as compared to wikipedia) is that there is less awareness about the project and contributing to OSM has to be made a lot easier. Also it needs to have enough eyeballs per sq. mile to verify that the changes made are actually good. In some places like Melbourne (and someone mentioned this earlier) OSM is horrendous.
- HarveyW26 13y agoIt is so non-intuitive as to be totally unusable !