13 ms·
School ditches rules and loses bullies
- jotm 13y agoThe effect on bullying is likely minimal - in my school, everyone could do whatever they wanted and there were still plenty of assholes that made life hell.
- hrjet 13y agoIn the school mentioned in the article, there was a significant decrease in bullying. But we don't know absolute figures before and after (understandably, that is difficult to measure). Two thoughts: 1. Perhaps the effect of loosening the rules lasts only a few years. After that the playground gets boring again and the bullies resume their behavior. 2. There might be other factors too, such as the environment of the kids when they are away from school.
- dwaltrip 13y ago3. Measuring the amount of bullying that occurs is not an exact science? Not to say that letting the kids get their hands dirty is a bad idea.
- kenjackson 13y agoFrom a financial perspective there is a lot more downside to "no rules". Imagine a child dying from hanging in the "lynching game". When teachers are asked if they knew about they said yes, but there are no rules. Even if it underestimates the effect of bullying (which I'm skeptical about), it certainly puts the school at much more risk for easy lawsuits.
- lisper 13y ago> Imagine But that's the whole point: when you actually do the experiment, all these horrible things that you imagine might happen don't actually happen.
- anigbrowl 13y agoBy that logic there should have been no problems whatsoever before the creation of the rules that generally obtain at schools today. One has to ask what created the pressure for those rules in the first place.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoAbility to sue the school combined with increased assumption that if there's a problem with kid, it's the school's fault, and not kid misbehaving.
- smsm42 13y agoOne knows what created them. Moral panic and "we must do something" culture.
- lisper 13y ago> By that logic there should have been no problems whatsoever before the creation of the rules that generally obtain at schools today No, not "no problems whatsoever" just "fewer problems than there are now." Which is in fact the case. The problem is that people looked at the problems that existed before the rules were in place and applied an argument of the form: There is a problem. Something must be done about this problem. This is something. Therefore we must do this. I hope I don't have to explain the flaw in this reasoning.
- hobs 13y agoThat's the entire reason the rules were originally put in place, no matter what they say, it was to avoid said lawsuits, not to protect children. Nobody wants to see a kid hurt, but rules only get teeth when money is on the line.
- antipodean 13y agoIf you'd watched the video, here's a paraphrase: "We watch the kids play, then we talk and they decide on the rules. They respect the rules better then". Adult supervision at schools is pretty common, even in the deep South Pacific.
- johnchristopher 13y agoThere weren't any rules when I was in primary school either and there definitely were bullies and injuries on the playground. > Children develop the frontal lobe of their brain when taking risks, meaning they work out consequences. "You can't teach them that. They have to learn risk on their own terms. It doesn't develop by watching TV, they have to get out there." Weak argument for the no-rules position. Children get injuries all the time, whether you have rules or not :]. The fact that this particular school has no reports of injuries seems suspicious to me. And a (self reported) higher level of concentration in the classroom can't be related to the playground absence of rules (well, the article doesn't provide any explanations for that). Did they ditch the coke vending machines as well ? I could believe that. Disclaimer: I was raised in Europe and although there were no rules per se we weren't allowed to leave the school premises. The article doesn't give enough details to compare both situations.
- MAGZine 13y agoThe article doesn't give a lot of information, but neither does your anecdotes. >There weren't any rules when I was in primary school either and there definitely were bullies and injuries on the playground. I'm not sure that the article is saying that the removal of rules has lead to zero bullies/injuries--just a reduction. >Weak argument for the no-rules position. Children get injuries all the time, whether you have rules or not :]. This is an even weaker argument for rules. If children are going to get injuries whether you have rules or not, than why are you wasting time rule-making when nobody wants to follow the rules and nobody wants to enforce the rules? Furthermore, I'd say that the thesis of "less rules means more activity, means less time spent harassing and troublemaking," is very plausible. It's like getting a husky and crating him up all day, then wondering why he's irritable and destructive.
- johnchristopher 13y agoIt got stuck in the keyboard but I wanted to add in the disclaimer that I don't have any strong opinion on the subject of rules on the playground. Moreover, there seem to be significant differences between our countries on that topic. > The article doesn't give a lot of information, but neither does your anecdotes. I fully agree with you, I just wanted to point out that one school "without rules" is not enough to draw any conclusion regarding bullying as the article seems to imply. (I read "lose bullies" as "no bullies", my mistake). > This is an even weaker argument for rules. I don't really have an argument for or against rules. I don't even know what's in the playground rulebook.
- sunir 13y agoWhile ideologically I am more likely to agree with the study (hence the need for more caution), the results seem possibly (I bet, more) likely due to the Hawthorne effect. That is the kids and teachers felt they were special because of the study and so behaved better. Alternatively, fabricated data. The article is written like this is a silver bullet with hand waving pseudoscience justification which implies it is total bull.
- antipodean 13y agoI grew up in New Zealand in the 80s. Bullrush, 3-story high flying foxes on school property, huge trees, open farmland, unsupervised cross-country runs: no adults around were par for the course except if someone broke a bone (which I remember happening in my community twice in 10 years) and we managed ourselves. We like to think we're a good outdoor lot of people and many of us adults have been horrified to think our kids can't grow up like we did. What I saw in this video was like looking back 30 years and it made me happy. You're underestimating our kids to think we can't let them loose for a good game of bullrush and they are more aware that they are being watched than actually just playing the rules of the game. Also remember that Rugby is New Zealand's national sport and these kids grow up watching it and knowing the rules. I'd bet some of those kids end up in the All Blacks.
- ehmish 13y agoAnother New Zealander here, there's merit to encouraging safety consciousness in children. An injury like a broken back (That most people think will "never happen to them") can doom someone for life. Teaching rigorous safety consciousness in children should result in some of that safety consciousness sticking around into adulthood. That being said, I also think rugby is a silly game.
- antipodean 13y ago>Teaching rigorous safety consciousness in children Yes, watching the video reminded me that no-one taught me how to tackle when I was playing Rugby as a skinny 11 year old. Good to see the kids at the school have someone to help them avoid those common injuries and still get some decent play in.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoIn the actual video, the principal doesn't say there are no rules, but that they start off with no rules and create them collaboratively is the need arises. E.g. no high tackles in the game of bullrush
- dippyskoodlez 13y agoExactly. Kids don't want to hurt themselves or others, they just sometimes don't realize certain things like high tackles could be inherently dangerous. Teaching in this method is brilliant IMO.
- jimbokun 13y agoPretty much exactly the same thing happened in the NFL, with regard to high tackles (in an attempt to reduce concussions).
- thom 13y agoI look forward to them publishing, and will be interested to see the long term effects, especially with kids that have been exposed to only this regime from the moment they join the school. On the face of it right now, I'd be wary of the Hawthorne effect: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect
- ctdonath 13y agoOccurs to me that under the strict playground rules, the school was effectively being a bully: harmless natural behavior was being punished way out of proportion and with no sensible (to the kids) reason. Seems the bullies were just mimicking what the school was doing.
- ronaldx 13y agoAgree in principle: a great deal of bullying goes on in schools that is not pupil-on-pupil.
- doktrin 13y agoI grew up partly in the French school system, and this certainly holds true. Teachers were often prototypical bullies : humiliating kids, mocking them outright, verbally lashing out at them. No shocker that this behavior trickles down as a model to follow.
- Loic 13y agoI grew up partly in the French school system too, but never had such kind of teachers. I was both in private schools and ZEP (area with high level of immigration and considered schools with problems). This is just to balance your point of view with respect to the French school system.
- rsl7 13y agoA lot of new experiments like this are basically the montessori approach. our kids' montessori school has giant tree logs and boulders.
- 3rd3 13y agoI think, in order to work that well, this kind of "riot" school yard activity would require a teacher with certain character traits such as authority, playfulness and calm at the same time. That guy in the video seems to suit very well. But it certainly looks like a good concept.
- brazzy 13y agoSo 10,000 children grow up happier and learning proper risk taking behaviour... and one dies from strangulation when going down a slide with a rope in hand (happened last week in my city)... and one is quadriplegic for life after jumping into a murky lake (friend of my cousin)... Do we really, really just want to accept those risks? I don't think that's easy to answer...
- argumentum 13y ago1. What about all the kids whose lives are ruined by bullying, some of which commit suicide? 2. Why not ban skiing (etc) because lots of people get paralyzed or die doing it? 3. Why not just ban everything even slightly fun, because fun things usually entail some risk?
- zzzeek 13y ago> Why not ban skiing (etc) because lots of people get paralyzed or die doing it? do ski resorts let schoolchildren onto the slopes without any kind of parental consent? I believe children aren't considered in the same way we do adults for a reason.
- argumentum 13y agoWhere did I say there shouldn't be parental consent? But it should be (as much as possible) on an individual basis (like ski slopes) rather than a collective one.
- vehementi 13y agoConsent? We're talking about the child's life, here! We can't just let parents consent to letting their child take massive risks! You can't "consent" that your child can jump into a murky lake or go down a slide with a rope in hand, so you certainly can't consent to letting them do something as reckless as skiiing.
- tomp 13y agoWhat makes you assume that those risks would be eliminated by more oversight, more rules or more control?
- forgottenpaswrd 13y agoAm I the only one that does not see anything special about those kids? We played with sticks and stones, football, skate, bmx biking, hiking all the time in Spain. You got hurt all the time too, but mostly scratches, you understood risk and knew the limits. There were also bullies, but the best thing you can do against bullies is fight them back. There are some places with rules like "no fighting" that ironically makes bullies rule.
- girvo 13y agoThat's the point, IMO. It's a return to norms. I don't know about you guys, but I was in school only a few years ago, and my brothers just graduated. We weren't even allowed to play ball sports during lunch/morning tea. It was crap, and so I decided to cause havoc on the school's network (although, 1) thats not a cause and effect, and 2) that ended up with me earning lots of money now...) -- anyway, I agree with you. Also, I fought my last bully back when I was 14, and the teachers let me off entirely. He, on the otherhand, got expelled, as he was constantly doing shit like that. (As a random aside, he's in jail for blowing up and robbing ATMs. Go figure)
- masklinn 13y ago> There are some places with rules like "no fighting" that ironically makes bullies rule. Especially with the usual idiotic companions of zero-tolerance and "it takes 2 for a fight".
- mwcampbell 13y ago> but the best thing you can do against bullies is fight them back. That sounds crazy to me. Doesn't fighting back just escalate things? And do we really want the next generation to grow up thinking that fighting is OK? Will they apply that same pattern when they're adults?
- DonGateley 13y agoI wouldn't mind at all if the next generation was more comfortable with fighting. It's a basic human instinct and when basic instincts are completely suppressed pathological behaviors will bulge out instead. The current state of "assault" law is appalling, especially in the U.S. We need to get more than a bit back to what we actually are.
- ausjke 13y agoI would like to send my kids there if there is a school like that at any state!
- rjd 13y agoI grew up in NZ, Swanson is one of the rougher and poorer areas in Auckland, and the school no doubt has all the issues that come with areas like that. I'd be careful that gains aren't skewed as its not a 'average' school or socio-economic environment.
- wepple 13y agoyeah, my thoughts exactly. The study is fairly biased in that if you did this to Remuera school, results may be significantly different.
- bane 13y agoI absolutely agree with this move, but I'll play devil's advocate for a moment on this >Letting children test themselves on a scooter during playtime could make them more aware of the dangers when getting behind the wheel of a car in high school, he said. Back in the days before all this modern child cocooning began, kids were free to roam and do pretty much whatever they wanted. But car drivers of the time routinely drove around without safety belts in what were essentially death traps. After safety belts and very basic safety equipment were introduced, it still took decades for people who grew up with the freer childhoods to really cotton on to them.
- smsm42 13y agoWhen I grew up I could roam freely (well, mostly, and I didn't always make as good use of it as I could, often preferring books to soccer) and I still have absolutely no problem with the concept of the safety belt. I know my safety is my responsibility, and if I have a device that can (and arguably already did) save my life - IMO only idiot won't use such a device. So I don't see any connection between rejecting belts and having freerange childhood.
- bane 13y agoWell, the article is positing the opposite effect is true, that cocooned children don't grow up with an appropriate respect for things that will hurt you, like driving your car safely. My devil's advocate argument is that the opposite is demonstrably true, that children who weren't cocooned did in fact grow up to not appreciate things that would hurt them. A 1950s car, for example, was basically a passenger mulching machine, yet people who grew up uncocooned (as was common at the time) drove them with quite a bit of abandon, flying all over the inside of the passenger area without even basic safety harnesses. I don't remember the statistic off the top of my head, but Ralph Nader brought to light one particularly brutal group of years where a large number of passengers were decapitated on the glove box door during accidents that were occurring at speeds under 35 mph.
- tod222 13y agoLenore Skenazy (Free Range Kids) blogged about this. [1] A commenter linked to a podcast with the school Principal. [2] [1] http://www.freerangekids.com/unsafe-playground-happier-safer-kids/ http://www.freerangekids.com/unsafe-playground-happier-safer... [2] http://podcast.radionz.co.nz/ntn/ntn-20140127-0909-free_play_at_school-048.mp3 http://podcast.radionz.co.nz/ntn/ntn-20140127-0909-free_play...
- smsm42 13y agoSo, kids can survive playing around without paranoid adults standing over them and monitoring them 24/7? Truly shocking news indeed, it's not like this is exactly what has been happening for millenia, until the current paranoid approach to minuscule risks took over.
- ansimionescu 13y ago> [...] until the current paranoid approach to minuscule lawsuits took over. FTFY. But, then again, I'm a helpless cynic.
- smsm42 13y agoLawsuits are the consequence of that. The concept is that if something happen, there must be somebody to blame, because they "should have done something to prevent it". And the lawsuits are in no way minuscule - they are actually huge and consist a serious drag on the economy, but the worst consequence, of course, is the behavior modification which emphasizes covering one's ass over all else.
- adamgravitis 13y agoSeems like there may be a correlation with: Corruptissima re publica plurimae leges (The more numerous the laws, the more corrupt the government) http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Tacitus http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Tacitus
- antipodean 13y agoNot in this case: http://www.3news.co.nz/New-Zealand-again-least-corrupt-nation/tabid/423/articleID/323818/Default.aspx http://www.3news.co.nz/New-Zealand-again-least-corrupt-natio... But I will say that New Zealand has a perceived problem currently as a somewhat 'nanny state'. Definitely a million kinds of by-laws but we try to resolve our differences with fairness in mind. Generally I describe New Zealand as a 'fair' country, as in, let's figure out what's fair for all involved.
- chrismcb 13y agoWhat rules did the ditch?
- antipodean 13y agoMany schools still won't let kids play Bullrush or play in the dirt. This is a low decile school so it seems particularly awesome for the kids to get some exercise as many parents can't afford after school programs. http://www.teara.govt.nz/en/photograph/26271/bullrush-2009 http://www.teara.govt.nz/en/photograph/26271/bullrush-2009
- argumentum 13y agoSince my natural preference (and probably that of many here) would be more freedom I think it's important to be wary of wishful thinking. Even though I think the link between authoritarian institutions and bullying is real, there are too many variables at play to make such a direct assertion. Regardless, I favor less rules and more freedom for kids for it's own sake. If there are social and/or developmental benefits, that would be icing on the cake. Where I grew up (near Charlottesville, VA), I had acres of wilderness in my backyard and the surrounding area to explore with my friends. We would build make play forts, climb (real) trees, make bridges over creeks and rivers etc. In the winter we'd go sledding, unsupervised, on real hills that we discovered ourselves .. age ranges from 7 to 10. Nearby there were a couple old plantation houses (ruins) near the scene of various battles from the revolutionary to the civil war. One even had cannonballs embedded in the walls. To be clear, these were just there, not maintained as museums etc. They were a rumor passed from older kids to younger ones, each mini-generation re-discovering them and the wonders contained. I bet if our parents knew exactly what we were doing they would have been horrified, that was part of the fun. We did these things without their permission. When I was about 13, we moved to upper middle class suburban California. Nice, safe, maintained parks. Pretend islands with pretend castles, slides and playground equipment with signs displaying instructions for "proper use." Frankly, boring, synthetic and alarmingly sad.
- invalidOrTaken 13y ago>Even though I think the link between authoritarian institutions and bullying is real, there are too many variables at play to make such a direct assertion. On the contrary, the problem is that schools are insufficiently authoritarian. Low-level harassment by students goes unpunished, while outright retaliation (a well-deserved punch in the face) is punished. A lot of schools are in this weird uncanny valley between freedom and strict discipline. Both would create order, but choosing one in between will have the advantages of neither.
- kazagistar 13y agoI am not sure your ideal of perfect authoritarianism is possible. If you want to torment someone it is always going to be possible to do invisibly to casual observation. Restrictions merely determine the language of what harassment consists off, but those who are less well adjusted socially, who are unable to participate as effectively in whatever social maneuvering exists, will always be targeted.
- kudu 13y agoThere's nothing very new about this. Aboriginal societies have been exercising the principle of permissive education for hundreds for years. There is something very logical about the idea of applying the premise of learning from one's mistakes to even the most basic things in life, which are learned as children.
- johnny99 13y agoThat story is anecdote. Not surprising or a problem from a general news source. But as a few commenters have pointed out, it ignores the fact of high risk/low probability events, and our general inability to properly assess those. I'm surprised this crowd isn't more data-driven in its assessment. Surely studies of child safety trends exist, and could be correlated to levels of regulation? The closest thing a quick Google turned up is a study of mandatory cycle helmet legislation and its effect on injury rates. Those rates declined 45% after the introduction of helmet laws. Perhaps not a perfect analogy, but chalk one up for regulation. http://cyclehelmets.org/1106.html http://cyclehelmets.org/1106.html
- userpasswd 13y agoOh really? Sorry, I couldn't stop myself. From a standpoint of a person who was young not that long ago it's pretty much obvious. Children want, children do.
- memracom 13y agoIn my 7 year old daughter's gymnastics class the girls all play bullrush for fun during the last 10 minutes or so. Of course this is in a Canadian city where the schools don't have fences, doors are unlocked, no security guards, adults wander in and out all through the day. Americans would be shocked at the apparent permissiveness of it all.
- aestra 13y agoI'll raise this useless antidote with another. I was raised in a poor inner city school that had no playground. I went to an afterschool program that was heavily subsidized for poor kids that had a huge playground. There was no rules except the older kids and younger kids were segregated. There was pretty much no supervision. I was bullied tons. Hair pulled, harassed, excluded from the parts of the playground I wanted to go on.
- goggles99 13y agoSo lets ask the question. Why are some people bullies and some aren't? Is is because more rules are imposed on some then others? Is it because kids aren't allowed to play bull rush or play in the mud? Bullies usually have emotional problems or brain chemistry issues. A high percentage of bullies have fathers that are abusive to their mothers and are bullies themselves (vicious cycle). It is difficult to tell if this is merely learned or genetic, but I am pretty sure that it has nothing to do with playing bull rush. What is likely having an effect on the kids in this school's situation is positive peer pressure. The administration puts the kids in a position of judging other peers. This has been used for at least 20 years and was effective in a high school I once attended. It was no utopia, but I sure didn't observe much bullying going on.
- blueskin_ 13y agoThis is the complete opposite of surprising to me.