13 ms·
Jb’s story about how he nearly lost his Twitter handle
- philliphaydon 13y agoThese stories are starting to scare me... I've already started using 1Password but I'm now considering closed some accounts and calling some of these services to ensure they never give out my information for password resets and such... Scary stuff...
- robin_reala 13y agoIt’s worth setting up two-factor authentication on any service that supports it: Google, Facebook and Github spring to mind.
- philliphaydon 13y agoI've got it setup on facebook and google, didn't know GitHub has it.
- philliphaydon 13y agoAwesome! Github setup! Thanks.
- benjamta 13y agoAnd AWS! As the article said he got lucky that the attacker didn't twig that there was an AWS account associated with that amazon.com login. You should be using two-factor authentication for all your AWS accounts, especially the 'root' account that's tied to your regular Amazon.com login (I've always though this is a bit odd). You should also never use that root account and set up IAM accounts for yourself and any other user (which also use 2FA).
- eik3_de 13y agoDropbox and app.net also do 2FA. If the service you're using doesn't support it, ask them to implement it. If enough people did it..
- girvo 13y agoI'm currently building a framework agnostic Authentication module for PHP/Composer, that has 2FA baked in. I want to give everyone who's building web apps in PHP no excuse for not having it. It's painful, but worth it IMO.
- prophet_ 13y agoAnd I thought that dropbox had already lost their reputation with pretty much everyone around since those massive security flaws exposed a while back. Silly me.
- exhilaration 13y agoSo does Namecheap.
- andyjohnson0 13y agoI'd like to enable two factor auth on my twitter account, but I'm put-off by their SMS-based implementation. Does anyone know if they have plans to support TOTP, like Google, GitHub, etc?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- brown9-2 13y agoIf you have the Twitter app on your smartphone, you can get notifications through it. I have 2FA for Twitter but do not receive SMS messages.
- andyjohnson0 13y agoThanks, I didn't know that! That might be good enough, as I quite often have no phone signal (and therefore no SMS) but still have net connectivity via wifi. I'd still prefer the TOTP approach though because it doesn't require any connectivity on the phone.
- giantrobothead 13y agoDefinitely. While it's not a perfect solution, it provides an extra layer of protection for your accounts by making an extra hurdle for any attacker to clear. Needing two components to access/change your accounts is elegant and effective. Pay-as-you-go phones are advisable to use for two factor verification, as they are affordable and could be used only for this purpose. Don't hand out the number and you've got a nice disposable tool for protecting your accounts.
- Moru 13y agoMany providers shuts down the account if you don't use it for calling at least once per year. Some close it down if you don't fill up the cachpool with money every 6-12 months.
- jtheory 13y agoRight, pay-as-you-go phones are annoying that way, if you aren't actually using them. I've lost a few phone numbers because I didn't remember to top-up a phone I wanted for rare uses and/or only incoming calls.
- giantrobothead 13y agoAh yes, I hadn't thought of that. Probably because I have around two years worth of service built up on mine.
- dcaunt 13y agoI think a lot of it comes down to this: "4. Some of the biggest companies in the world have security that is only as good as a minimum-wage phone support worker who has the power to reset your account. And they have valid business reasons for giving them this power."
- jtheory 13y agoIt could be greatly mitigated by automating that power more. E.g., "No problem, I can reset your password! The system will automatically contact your registered phone number and email address -- if you confirm both, it resets now, and if you can't, it will send the reset to your new email 3 days from now."
- eric_the_read 13y agoNow all an attacker has to do is wait for me to go on a cruise, or camping trip, or basically take any action which means I'm out of communication for a week or more.
- coldpie 13y agoIt's a change from near-zero security like now, to having to know your routine, travel, and communication plans. Perfect? No, but what is?
- xenophanes 13y agoso that's better than before, right?
- jtheory 13y agoWell, yeah -- I said "greatly mitigated". I can't think of the last time I was completely cut off from both phone and email for more than 3 days. Can you? I travel around the world regularly enough (I was in Malaysia in November; I'll be in Rwanda in March), but never with breaks in connectivity lasting more than 3 days. I don't go wandering into the wilderness for more than a day trip, admittedly... but I'm also pretty sure most other people don't do that regularly, either.
- uloweb 13y agoIt seems that now you should not only use different passwords anywhere, but also different logins and emails, different credit cards and may be even different names, addresses and phone numbers. Just to be sure.
- nfoz 13y agoI use different emails, for everything. I manage my own domain(s), so I have anything @mydomain.tld. I'll usually give unique email addresses that identify, to me, the organization or service that gets the address. Occasionally an address becomes the target of spam, and I just kill off that address.
- Nilzor 13y agoThat wouldn't really helped you in this case, would it? The attacker got the account reset simply by phoning the customer service and making them send a password reset link to a new email. Also how do you manage said X number of emails? Do you log onto each one of them, or do you forward all emails to one "master email"? If so, the master email is still the single point of failure.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- danso 13y ago> He then called Amazon with what little information he had gained and cried that he had lost his password and didn’t have access to that email address anymore. The representative caved and reset the password over the phone giving him full access to my Amazon account. His plan was to then gain as much information he could with Amazon (last four of credit card numbers, current and previous addresses, etc…) and use that as ammunition to do the same thing with Apple. And it worked. He had an email in his gmail inbox with instructions on how to reset my iCloud account. Whatever you think of the state of cybersecurity in terms of encryption, implementation, and user-interface (including 2-factor authentication)...it doesn't seem that the protections against social engineering have developed at the same pace as the increasing ease of accessing public records
- logicallee 13y ago>Whatever you think of the state of cybersecurity in terms of encryption, implementation, and user-interface (including 2-factor authentication)...it doesn't seem that the protections against social engineering have developed at the same pace as the increasing ease of accessing public records Yep. Around the same time I started using a randomly generated 24 digit alphanumeric password generated with an offline computer, I noticed a twin person who looked nearly the same as me nearly started living in my apartment, and asking an awful lot of questions about our supposedly shared childhood, wanting to "catch up". It was certainly nice suddenly having a twin, but it wasn't until he suddenly disappeared three years later that I realized I should have been just as wary about social engineering as I was about my encryption.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI am not sure I get this.... Did your brother move into your apartment? Did you imagine a friend? Are you being sarcastic in a way I have missed?
- logicallee 13y agothird (sarcasm). I don't think the bar with social engineering has moved NEARLY as much as cyber security has. It's practically impossible to keep a computer secure, but very easy not to be duped by strangers on a social level.
- eik3_de 13y agoanother bad habit are those "security questions". For me, the only proper way to deal with this is to have your mother maiden or pet name be cy4nEp7UtNsz and save that (along with the question title) in your (properly backed up!) password safe.
- frou_dh 13y agoAgreed. If I get to pick the security question itself, it'll be something like "What's the magic code?" to emphasise that the gibberish answer was set intentionally.
- privong 13y ago> and save that (along with the question title) in your (properly backed up!) password safe. To be fair, this could render the security question useless. If you lose the password (by losing the password safe), you've also lost the answer to the security question. So a properly backed up password safe renders a security question pointless (or the answers to the security question should be stored in a separate, equally secure, location).
- eik3_de 13y agoYou're right, it's not the intended use of the security question - and that's exactly what I want. I feel like entering my pet's name doesn't add to my account security but rather lowers it. My password safe is stored at many different location so that it's extremely unlikely to loose them all at once. And to secure against amnesia or being-hit-by-a-truck, you should give the passphrase to a person you trust 100%.
- PinguTS 13y agoThe security questions in its current implementation are useless anyhow. Because all those pieces of information are exploitable by your social life these days. "What's the name of your first math teacher" — Take a look into the years schoolbook, which are online. These security questions are made for us old farts, for days when there was no Internet like today and there were none of this information available online.
- 13y ago
- chris_wot 13y agoHere's what you do. Get a lawyer and sue them for all they're worth. Not just for you, but for every other person their pathetic security has and may cause problems for them in the future.
- da_n 13y agoIt amazes me that this type of social hack still works so successfully, I can understand Kevin Mitnick's success back when he was a hacker but surely the industry should have learnt by now. Resetting a users credentials should be treated like changing all the locks on their houses. If the user cannot verify their account credentials and is crying over the phone at least implement a 7 day delay and grace period before the reset takes effect, send emails which notifies the current email etc, or even send a pin to their postal address. I know these are not ideal security either but at least there would be some grace period.
- vitalysh 13y agoOr they could at least call back to the phone number stored on file.
- sp332 13y agoPhone companies really have learned from Mitnick. For example, if you call an operator, they absolutely will not tell you what number you called from.
- broolstoryco 13y agoHow would that be exploitable?
- sp332 13y agoIf you're exploring the phone system and want to know what circuit you've happened to sneak your way onto. It's very useful if you can have the phone company just tell you what part of their systems you're calling from :)
- lhgaghl 13y agoIf they're relying on such information for security, they aren't secure in the first place.
- brown9-2 13y agoIt would be useful if a date was given for this story.
- lhgaghl 13y agoAt the bottom in tiny text it says: "Published January 29, 2014" Also, in the source: <meta property="article:published_time" content="2014-01-29T01:49:03.309Z">
- Xdes 13y agoI'm gonna put an identity audit on my TODO list.
- Herald_MJ 13y agoWhy are all these attacks targeting Twitter usernames? Do these really have particularly significant resale value? It seems like much greater profit could be made with access to someone's Amazon account, but these seem to be used as merely a proxy in these attacks.
- shornlacuna 13y agoI'd imagine that the illegality of fraudulently using an Amazon account would be more clearcut and easier to prosecute.
- daemin 13y agoSame sort of thing targeting low numbered ICQ accounts back years ago. I had mine stolen from under me and while it doesn't actually matter anymore, it did upset and make me angry at the time. I guess if they can't resell it they do it for shits and giggles, and because grabbing a low numbered/low lettered anything these days is a decent trophy to have.
- jordsmi 13y agoThe problem here is usually the people doing this are just kids in the "scene". They go after original names on all different mediums like xbox live, twitter, instagram, etc. Usually the accounts sell from $100 up to $1000+, but they don't really realize the potential of what they could do with this. They could easily put their minor SE skills towards hijacking high quality information, but instead they use it to get known for stealing usernames.
- speshul 13y agoI thought I'd post to let some people know how I BELIEVE this is being done. Kevin Mitnick always talks about how social engineering is the key usually, ans it is. he used to make phone calls after dumpster diving and gaining employee names. There's no need for that now, we have all our information on the internet. let me explain a little better. Take your facebook for example. Most people have the email they use on their for everyone to see, same with linked in. Now once a hacker finds who they want to target, just start googling the person and collect as much data as possible through comments made by and towards them. usually they'll comment on their pets name and all the other info they usually use to reset passwords. adding the person on a fake account acting like one of their friends with a new account is typical. once they have all this info and the emails you use, time to take over what emails they can with your information. security questions are usually the route they go. once they have an email account, time to grab the others that are usually linked to each other for password resets. once those emails are taken over... it's all downhill from there. best thing to do is make everything private and don't use the same username or handle on everything because that makes it easier to link to you. just my thought about how this is done. pretty simple if you have some time to invest
- lhgaghl 13y agoJesus fucking christ. Stop making websites accept anything other than a username+password/token for authentication, and this kind of retarded shit would never happen. It's somehow still the status quo to make backdoors to recover your account incase you lock yourself out, which is why things like this happen all the time. You get what you deserve.
- jtheory 13y agoThis is great in theory, but in practice your regular customers are going to lose/mix up their usernames and passwords all the time. They need some kind of back door to recover their access (because honestly, even for the responsible and tech-savvy users, sometimes sh!t happens... e.g., my password manager generated a new password but my laptop crashed before I could save it), and they assume there will be a way to restore their account. I'm sure you could tell your customers "you get what you deserve", but not if you want them to remain customers.
- lhgaghl 13y agoGee, you're going to have a hard time with bitcoin, hidden tor services, etc. A) Customers locking themselves out of accounts B) Accounts being stolen by identity theft Pick one. > I'm sure you could tell your customers "you get what you deserve", but not if you want them to remain customers. I kill people for a living. You can tell me I could stop killing people for a living but then I'd stop having customers. Thus it's impractical to stop killing people.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoOne thing I've found handy is just to have little or no bio information on your accounts. If you absolutely must have bio info on your account, make all the information different from account to account. This way, if a hacker gets your LinkedIn profile, the information there is different than your Facebook info, which is different than your Twitter info, which is different from your. . Imagine a hacker with a handful of accounts and all the information is completely inconsistent. How does he decide which one is real and which one's are fake? It's essentially a dead end and will hopefully get them to move on to an easier target.
- jessedhillon 13y agoHave you been the target of hacking attempts? This sounds the opposite of handy, so I'd be interested to know how well it actually works. Not sure how well it would pay but I'd be interested in a service that attempts to steal your identity in this way, and then tells you what you can do to plug the vulnerabilities.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoI have not been targeted, I just tend to think like a hacker so I take a lot of precautions to protect my identity.
- jotm 13y agoDamn, my passwords are crap (some are written in OneNote because forums make me change them every half a year), but then again I don't have any precious online properties besides some websites that I use stronger passwords for. Not like it matters since it looks like social engineering is alive and kicking (as they say, humans are always the weakest link in security). These articles really make me want to set up an automated system that would monitor any password reset events (and other suspicious activity) and automatically change those passwords itself and/or notify me by sms...
- drmarianus 13y agoIt really is worth it. It is a pain to first set up and change every password to some random string (which most vaults will generate for you), but after that it's smooth sailing more or less. I recommend LastPass, it's free (unless you want the Android app, but even then the premium account is super cheap).
- pasbesoin 13y agoWe are going to have to learn to -- effectively -- use compartmentalization, ourselves. (Us technophiles, certainly, but also the "greater masses".) - Separate, low-balance checking or similar bank account for "routine payments". Larger balances held in other accounts that cannot be accessed / drawn from through normal channels. - Separate contact address(es) for distinct and more public interfaces. E.g. I and some friends already have P.O. boxes for this purpose. - There are other instances/examples, but this is enough while keeping this comment brief. AND HERE IS AN IMPORTANT POINT: Companies that won't let us do this, or even just make it hard, will become anathema to our own best interests. THERE ARE LEGITIMATE REASONS I don't want all my services and access consolidated under a single user ID and password or other authentication. Services that push towards "one true name" and "all services lumped together", are -- from this security perspective -- not in my best interest. I learned years ago about the value of compartmentalization. It seems that many companies have yet to learn that this is a legitimate concern and feature for their customers. In the age of electronic recordkeeping and processing, it really is a minimal burden upon a business to support more than one account per customer. Customers have legitimate reasons for doing this. Get over it, and give them what they want and need.
- steven2012 13y agoThe problem is that different companies have different protocols on what information they use to identify users, etc, and hackers are getting smart enough to connect various partial information to get full information on a user. Every single customer-facing company needs to have STANDARDIZED security/information protocols. This includes taking in same information, and only giving out the same information. This should solve this problem.
- erichurkman 13y agoEven with standardized security protocols, you will still have issues with undertrained/underpaid customer support agents working to "help" one very smooth talking hacker using social engineer tactics.
- steven2012 13y agoSocial engineering is always a problem, and I think first-level support should NEVER have the ability to see any information or have the ability to make changes to accounts. This should get escalated to second level support. But regardless, a single account may get compromised, but at least you can't feed partial data from one social engineering attempt into another company, which is what apparently is happening more and more because of impedance mismatches with what everyone uses.
- duk 13y agoAmazon customer service folks should ask a caller to name some of items he/she has purchased last few weeks or so.
- mrtron 13y ago2 factor auth anywhere that matters. Google and Amazon for me. It is occasionally annoying, but worth it.
- wfunction 13y agoWhy the hell can customer support agents see the credit card number? Why don't they just have a box to type in and verify the four digits?
- biftek 13y agoHad this exact experience happen to one of my coworkers. We started embedding a secondary “password” in some of our email addresses, by leveraging googles username+tag feature. So something like johndoe@gmail.com becomes johndoe+1bayjdh1x91nj12e@gmail.com One less piece of guessable info.
- mcgwiz 13y agoI would love for there to be some regular program of independent security auditing of major web companies focusing on social engineering attacks. It can be government-funded or privately-funded (companies would pay to be audited in order to be included in a certified registry). I'm not 100% sure how the details would work (they'd have to maintain a huge number of dummy accounts all over the place), but the value of such an effort would be tremendous. The idea that these companies would rather cater to individuals who are careless with their accounts than uphold the sanctity of the majority of their users' identities is deeply troubling. The thought of a dispensable, minimum wage worker being all that stands between me and total calamity is terrifying.