7 ms·
It's pretty clear they were doing this to harvest phone numbers of drivers (why does Gett give out their drivers' phone numbers?) rather than any attempt to act
by eridius 13y ago
It's pretty clear they were doing this to harvest phone numbers of drivers (why does Gett give out their drivers' phone numbers?) rather than any attempt to actually disrupt Gett's business. I would be rather hesitant to call this "fraud", as that's a very serious allegation.
- doktrin 13y ago> I would be rather hesitant to call this "fraud" How exactly is this not fraud?
- HillRat 13y agoI'd say it's more of "tortious interference." If true, this was -- to paraphrase Fouché -- worse than a crime, it was stupid. It seems that Uber is so blasé about the tidal flood of lawsuits it's facing that it is willing to court more.
- samolang 13y agoAnd they paid cancellation fees.
- enjo 13y agoWhat is Gett's cancellation policy?
- ryguytilidie 13y ago...after what they were doing was exposed.
- pc86 13y agoNo, they paid cancellation fees because you get charged when you cancel. This wasn't "Oh, sorry, here's $10."
- encoderer 13y agoIt's not automatic. I've had to legitimately cancel before and have never been charged a fee.
- pc86 13y agoHave you cancelled on the day of or within just a few hours of the scheduled pickup time?
- jaredsohn 13y agoThese rideshare apps usually have you schedule for ASAP rather than for some future time, so chances are if you cancel it would be much sooner. Not sure about this company, but for Uber the cancellation fee should only happen if you cancel after five minutes of scheduling a ride. I've seen Lyft and other rideshare companies have similar policies. http://support.uber.com/entries/22326831-Ride-Cancellations http://support.uber.com/entries/22326831-Ride-Cancellations
- ryguytilidie 13y agoThe fact that it said "they ultimately paid the fees...some of which are still pending" made me feel like these weren't immediate, automatic charges.
- techreporter 13y agoThey claim they paid cancellation fees. Gett claims the charges are pending. At this point it would be stupid of them to not let those charges through though.
- epipsychidion 13y agoIf drivers keep getting requests cancelled, they will be less prompt and enthusiastic about actual ones. The cancellation fee is calculated on the assumption that frequent orders will not be deliberately placed to be subsequently cancelled.
- samolang 13y agoI agree that they may have violated the spirit of the contract. But the contract specifically handles the case of cancelling an order (including some restitution), so I would hardly consider it fraud.
- epipsychidion 13y agoRunning into the path of a moving car isn't fraud? End result is the same for when it's an accident.
- samolang 13y agoRunning into the path of a moving car is only fraud if you claim the driver is at fault. If you admit responsibility and pay for any damages then it is not fraud.
- untog 13y ago(why does Gett give out their drivers' phone numbers?) Presumably so that the customer can contact the driver if they need to pass on instructions about a specific place to be picked up, etc.
- eridius 13y agoUber handles this by having a button in their app that initiates the phone call. You can't find out a driver's number without actually calling them. Similarly, they can't find out yours without actually calling you. Theoretically, if the company can get a bunch of phone #s, they could even completely anonymize it by assigning two temporary numbers (one to driver, one to passenger) and call-forwarding them for the duration of the trip. I havent' checked but I doubt anybody actually does this. And in the absence of this level of anonymity, I would at the very least expect a car service app to require you to place the call before giving you the phone # of the other person.
- aetherson 13y agoI work for Flywheel, an Uber competitor. We do not expose driver or passenger phone numbers to either party at all (the exact mechanism is a little different than what you propose, but the effect is the same). Driver can call passenger and passenger can call driver and neither will ever see the other person's actual number.
- eridius 13y agoGood for you. Since you're doing this, and according to yid, Uber is also doing something similar, I'm even more surprised that Gett is not only exposing real phone #'s, but doing so without even requiring a phone call to be placed.
- rahimnathwani 13y agoTheoretically, if the company can get a bunch of phone #s, they could even completely anonymize it by assigning two temporary numbers (one to driver, one to passenger) and call-forwarding them for the duration of the trip. You wouldn't even need a bunch of phone numbers. Assuming caller ID works correctly, you can use that to decide where to route the call. Customer A is calling? Route to Driver X? Driver Y is calling? Route to Customer B.
- avalaunch 13y agoThey were booking rides without the intent of actually taking or paying for those rides. How is that not fraud? The fact that they were doing it to mine for phone numbers doesn't make it less fraudulent. That'd be like saying it's ok to order a bunch of pizzas from Pizza Hut without the intent of paying for them because you were simply trying to figure out who the drivers are.
- eridius 13y agoThey're paying cancellation fees. If I order a bunch of pizzas from Pizza Hut in order to find out who the drivers were, and paid for them, then there's no issue. Even though I don't intend on eating the pizzas, I still paid for the service. In this case, Uber is paying the cancellation fees for the privilege of booking, then cancelling, a Gett ride.
- goldenkey 13y agoWith the intent to disrupt business. They can be easily sued for this practice. This isn't a consumer doing so, this is a company having their employees vehemently attack a competitor.
- yapcguy 13y agoExactly. Legit customers can't book cars because they're busy and when they do the drivers might bail because they think its yet another fake order. Screw Uber. Theyre not a tech start-up, they're an illegal car service masquerading as a tech company.
- brianmcdonough 13y agoThank you for making it clear why this practice is bad corporate practice for those who are not as moral in their perspective. Uber seems hell bent on becoming the only game in town and then raping their customers during peak periods.
- avalaunch 13y agoIf you order pizzas and pay for them, you're completely the transaction as expected. If you order a car from a car service and then cancel it, you're not. The fact that a cancellation fee exists doesn't give you the right to use the system in such an unintended manner. A better analogy than the pizza analogy might be a "customer" repeatedly buying clothes with the intent to wear and then return them. Despite the fact that there is a return policy in place, the fact that the customer never intended on keeping any of the clothes makes his behavior fraudulent.
- ryguytilidie 13y agoI don't feel like the fact that they defrauded the drivers/service because they wanted their information from them makes this any less fraudulent...
- pkinsky 13y agoI assume there's something in Gett's terms of service prohibiting what Uber was doing. If so, they're liable under the CFAA.