13 ms·
Stephen Hawking: 'There are no black holes'
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoTitle is misleading. This is simply more research on the very well known black hole information paradox, proposing that a commonly cited property of black holes may be wrong.
- codeulike 13y agoNot that misleading. Hawking goes on to say there would also be no singularity. That's quite a big change.
- Pxtl 13y agoYeah. It sounds like his theory is that gravity/spacetime eventually becomes "turbulent" as the energy level of gravity approaches C (I'm sure I phrased that wrong). My instinctive analogy is to compare it to how the ideal gas law or laminar flow equations fall apart in cases where individual particle interactions screw everything up... to the level that it's impossible for all the matter to get compressed into a single point. That's far more interesting to me than the idea that the "event horizon" is gone.
- Pxtl 13y agoJust making sure, the "fire" of the firewall is the Hawking radiation, right? That is, the event horizon divides matter from antimatter in the energy of space and spews it outwards. Or are they distinct concepts? I never understand how Einstein's concept of relativity and his discovery of an arbitrary maximum speed of the universe can coexist. I mean, how can everything be relative when there's an absolute maximum velocity? The event horizon and Hawking radiation/the firewall naturally come out of the speed of light. Physics confuses me ever so much.
- route66 13y ago> ... how can everything be relative when there's an absolute maximum velocity? The observations leading to relativity theory put this question differently: Apparently the speed of light is constant, no matter how fast it's origin moves [1] : so we have to interpret our measurements relative to the speed of the observer. I still find Einstein's explanation the most readable [2]. He stays close to the geometrical description of reference frames and avoids the pictorial freedom known from monad tutorials... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80 %93Morley_experiment [2] http://www.bartleby.com/173/5.html http://www.bartleby.com/173/5.html
- wlesieutre 13y agoThe short version of maximum speeds is that velocities don't add how you'd expect at relativistic scales. If a ship is moving at 0.5c relative to an observer and it launches a missile forward at 0.5c relative to itself, the missile is moving at less than 1.0c relative to the same observer. In fact, the missile could launch a smaller missile forward at 0.5c, and that missile would still be moving under the speed of light relative to the observer. If you just added speed up classically, it'd be going 1.5c. Really it always works like this, but at speeds we consider normal the error from simplifying to v1+v2=v3 is incomprehensibly small.
- Pxtl 13y agoI assume time-dilation accounts for that, since the ship perceives that it's launching something at 0.5C but its perception is skewed by time dilation... but that implies the reverse, since time dilation means that the ship perceives time traveling slower than the outside universe and thus the outside universe is faster and so the 0.5C missile should actually be moving faster than the sum of the accelerations... but relativity says that both sides perceive their counterpart as slower, and then you get the to the twin paradox. ow, my head.
- Retric 13y agoIt's not just time that get's distorted, but also distance. More importantly, there is no privileged viewpoint. As far as a spaceship is concerned it's everything else that's moving and it's standing still and the same physics predictions work just fine it's only the measurements that seem different.
- codeulike 13y agoBlack Holes, as originally posited, are quite extreme things to have sitting around in the universe (infinitely dense singularities etc). Physics seems to be tying itself in knots to figure out how they would work; alternatively the idea that they might not be possible in the first place is a much tidier solution. This reminds me of a competing theory that states black holes (as currently understood) can't exist: Instead they are Magnetospheric eternally collapsing objects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetospheric_eternally_collapsing_object http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetospheric_eternally_collap...
- acconrad 13y agoI think it's important to note that this paper has not yet been peer reviewed, so this is nothing more than an attention-grabbing title from Nature.
- samatman 13y agoActually the title is both accurate and roughly as big as it looks. Stephen Hawking is, in fact, saying that there are no black holes: no event horizon, no black hole. The fact that this statement has yet to pass peer review and enter publication is interesting but does not detract from the accuracy nor news interest of the article and title.
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoThe arXiv paper indicates he has no intention of submitting it to a peer-reviewed journal -- something that's becoming pretty common in some physics fields. On the contrary, I see the "yet to pass peer review" remark as a crass editorialization from the Nature journalists¹. This paper has already seen more, meaningful, peer review that most papers Nature publishes; informal review from people downloading the (free, open) paper from the arXiv, or listening to the talk at the Kavli conference. The institute Nature is defending is becoming an irrelevant middleman: what's the point of reviewers, if they barely read the papers, and then hide them behind paywalls from anyone who actually wants to read them, when there's whole social network of researchers who will read papers enthusiastically, for free, and share what they think of them? http://arxiv.org/abs/1401.5761 http://arxiv.org/abs/1401.5761 ¹ You should question to what extent they're journalists, when their employer is a for-profit entity existentially threatened by the subject they're reporting on.
- frozenport 13y agoHaving submitted to a nature journal, the peer review process took several months with new experiments and new theory being requested. You are wrong to say that the paper went through blindly.
- weichi 13y ago"This paper has already seen more, meaningful, peer review that most papers Nature publishes ..." I really don't think that this is true. The useful bit of peer review is changes made to the original paper as part of the peer review process (both for accuracy and clarity of exposition). No feedback from arXiv readers has yet been incorporated into this paper; perhaps in a few months there will be an updated version that includes such feedback. Until then, people will have to search the net to get a feeling for how the wider field views his ideas. In terms of feedback from conferences, plenty of results are presented at conferences prior to publication in Nature and other journals, so I doubt there is any difference in the review level here.
- ssivark 13y agoI echo my comment from the other Hawking thread on the HN front page: The article being referred to seems to be a short piece where he summarizes his points and puts forward a (new?) idea. Maybe it's obvious to researchers in the field, but I don't see much argument or reasoning supporting his claim. It seems like he's just introducing a new idea for people to consider (brainstorming with the community). So please don't blow this out of proportion.
- Steuard 13y agoThis seems like a good way to read it to me. Hawking does put forth some meaningful arguments in there that deserve attention (or else it wouldn't be worth listening, even if this is Hawking), but he hasn't proven any new theorems or shown an explicit counterexample to previously accepted physics. This firewall issue is just complicated, and it has stubbornly resisted consensus from the physics community despite a year or so of intense interest. I think we're in the market for crazy new ideas at this point.
- josu 13y agoThis is very interesting, because: >Einstein denied several times that black holes could form. In 1939 he published a paper that argues that a star collapsing would spin faster and faster, spinning at the speed of light with infinite energy well before the point where it is about to collapse into a black hole. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein's_unsuccessful_investigations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein's_unsuccessful_investi...
- 3pt14159 13y agoI was always taught that black holes were actually disks due to angular momentum and the speed of light. The matter at the end of the disk is being pulled in by gravity, but its speed is so close to C that its mass increases to the point where the equations balance out (trade gravitational potential energy for mass potential energy + kinematic potential energy).
- mistercow 13y agoI'm don't think that's particularly relevant. Einstein's objection was wrong, and what Hawking is saying is pretty much unrelated.
- kissickas 13y agoIsn't he still saying that black holes exist in that sense, though? According to the article (haven't looked at the paper), it looks like Hawking's new "apparent horizon" could still trap light, and it would only escape as Hawking radiation, which sounds contrary to Einstein's above quote.
- alphaBetaGamma 13y agoWe have exact solution to spinning black holes (discovered after Einstein's death) which settles that question. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerr_metric http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerr_metric
- JacobAldridge 13y agoDoes this mean Kip Thorne has to return a year's worth of Penthouse magazines?
- omphalos 13y agoSadly I suppose this implies the impossibility of Malament-Hogarth hypercomputers.
- ck2 13y agoSo basically they took off three words of what he said to make a super sensationalistic headline? How scientific. there are no black holes with event horizons If you take the mass of a sun and squeeze it into a few miles wide, you are definitely going to get inescapable gravity no matter what you want to call it.
- VikingCoder 13y agoThat's the thing though - Hawking is saying it's not "inescapable."
- ck2 13y agoI think he is saying the gravity is not even enough to have that effect and therefore would be points that are escapable? I always wondered if a black hole could become completely visible again if it collected enough mass to spread its surface area out so that gravity would become thin enough for light to escape again. Kind of like how only the surface of a pond sometimes freezes.
- lmm 13y agoNo; adding mass doesn't make it less dense (well, it's a singularity, so it's always infinitely dense. But even if it weren't, normally when you add mass to something it becomes more compressed and gets denser, not less dense), just heavier. (Of course, singularities don't make any sense - which is part of what Hawking's talking about. But that's the classical model of a black hole)
- waps 13y agoIt's only necessarily infinitely dense from an outside reference frame. Inside you could have anything you'd want according to GR. One certainty is that the space inside a black hole is bigger than the size of the black hole observed from outside of it. So it's entirely possible that you could have a solar system or even an entire universe on the inside. According to GR the space inside a black hole should pretty much behave like the rest of the universe, as long as the black hole is growing. As for "not getting out", well it's impossible to approach the edge of the universe too, despite that border having a physical location. But it's expanding at light speed, so ... no way to get there. So density of a black hole is an entirely different concept from the outside and the inside. Seen from the outside it is infinite. Seen from the inside it is probably not infinite.
- PaulHoule 13y agoThe funny thing about black holes is that the classical story of the black hole never made sense, but the "old men" of the physics community always suppressed any real criticism of it since it's been almost impossible to get a job in physics since 1968. If you right down the equations for a simple black hole you immediately encounter a singularity at the event horizon, but this is swept under the rug by making a coordinate change. The trouble is that coordinate change breaks the warrantee on the space-time continuum because it will stretch a plank length out to something macroscopic. making quantum phenomena visible. A simpler paradox which has never been taken seriously is that an outside observer sees that it takes forever for something falling into a black hole to hit the event horizon. However, knowing about Hawking radiation, you know the black hole doesn't last forever, so an outside observer never sees anything fall into a black hole. Thus the classical black hole was always a pipe dream. In the 1970s the information paradox showed that a classical black hole (which makes information disappear because you can't tell the difference between a black hole that was made out of gold bars or feathers) makes information disappear, but information can't disappear in a quantum mechanical universe.
- wisty 13y agoSo, very dark grey pits might be more likely?
- arca_vorago 13y agoPerhaps I will show my ignorance in the realm of physics here, but a few weeks ago I was mulling the idea of quantum entanglement over in my mind, and I had an interesting idea that I have yet to bounce off anyone, so perhaps someone could correct any layperson inadequacies. Quantum entanglement in summary is that two or more particles are such that their quantum state relates them to each other, correct? In the big bang, all matter existed at a single point in "time", but we are confused about why there is more matter than anti-matter, correct? Would it be at all possible that perhaps at the big bang or prior, the universe was more balanced in it's symmetry or perhaps even anti-matter existed in greater quantities than matter, but at some point there was (again, forgive my lack of physics knowledge) some sort of a collapse or antimatter blackhole which generated the big bang, and as antimatter collapsed in on itself and was spewed out the other side it became matter, with a side effect of quantum entanglement (since the matter (previously anti-matter) had existed at the same point in time (or some groups of matter had at least)). Now here is the key part, what if anti-matter isn't the opposite of matter, but it is indeed the preferred state of matter (eg, matter seeks to become anti-matter) but the only way that it can do so is to mass together until it becomes a black hole and collapses back into the anti-matter universe? (which would explain the lack of anti-matter where masses of matter exist) Crazy lunatic layperson hypotheses: 1) Matter can become anti-matter and vice versa. 2) There is a natural tendency for balance in the universe. 3) Black holes are where matter goes to become antimatter. 4) White holes are anti-matter becoming matter 5) Gravity and many other observable effects are side effects of this process.
- tehwalrus 13y agoI never bought that humans could travel through an event horizon[1]. Say that your leg is inside the black hole, but the rest of you isn't. How can the atoms just outside the horizon detect the quantum forces from the atoms just inside? Electromagnetic forces are transmitted by photons, which are forbidden to cross this barrier. Thus, if you pulled back away from the horizon, you would have an event-horizon-curvature-shaped hole where your lower leg had just been. Similarly, for any matter traveling through the black hole, unless two atoms and all their electrons passed through the horizon simultaneously, no chemical bond could survive (since from the point of view of one atom, the other "blinks" out of existence.) Thus, anything that crosses an event horizon must be fundamental particle mush, no? Assuming gluons were also forbidden to cross back, even protons and neutrons would be torn apart. [1] I mean one around a very massive black hole - so that spaghettification is yet to occur. P.S. - This argument takes a very literal interpretation of fundamental particles; indeed, it would be interesting to test the quantum-ness of matter to see how this worked - i.e. whether "stuff" really is particles or waves - since waves could, potentially, exist on both sides of the barrier at once.
- splat 13y agoThere's a difference between hovering above an event horizon and sticking your leg through versus free-falling through an event horizon. The former is not an inertial reference frame, so you would feel enormous forces due to the fact that you were (somehow) generating enough thrust to counteract the gravitational force of the black hole. No human could survive that. But in the latter you feel no forces except for tidal forces because you are simply following the curvature of the local spacetime. If you were falling into a supermassive black hole you would not feel anything as you passed through the event horizon. You would still retain full control over your limbs until a few milliseconds (I think, I might be a few orders of magnitude off) before you hit the singularity.
- tehwalrus 13y agoOK, orbiting rather than hovering. Also, whatever speed you cross the horizon there would still be some delta_t > h_bar where leg atom A can't see leg atom B. Similarly, the drop in blood pressure for the parts of blood vessels just outside the horizon (although, given the rest of the prediction, blood pressure is the least of your worries at this point.)
- TeMPOraL 13y agoOk, how did this happen? Yesterday black holes were there. Everybody knew about Schwarzschild radius, about Cygnus X-1, about black holes theorized to be occupying the centers of galaxies. And now everyone here is commenting like it was an obvious fact that black holes were never real and no one considered them seriously. What happend? What did I miss?
- jerf 13y agoThat what label we put on things does not affect what they actually are? Whatever it is out there in the real universe that are these really massive things, they aren't waiting for little humans a billion light years away to decide what they are or are not.
- krapp 13y agoThe map is not the destination.
- blueprint 13y agoPeer pressure, my friend.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoFirstly, he's exploring and developing theories, these aren't fully formed models yet. Secondly, and most importantly, in almost every way this new model of black holes is identical to the old models. From a macro perspective on human time scales we wouldn't be able to easily distinguish between a black hole with a real event horizon and one with an apparent horizon, as in this new theory. This is one of the dangers of popular science reporting, and here Nature is very much to blame. They've taken a theory which largely preserves the model of black holes and spun it into exactly the opposite.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoBecause Hacker News? :)
- 13y ago
- platz 13y agoI couldn't find the article, but there's a theory that states something to the effect that black holes are only 2D and the rest of the universe is a holographic projection. They back some of this up by noting that the size of the event horizion of a black hole grows as a function of 2D mathematical spaces rather than 3D spaces.
- differentView 13y agoIs there a modern day Feynman that can explain this to us not familiar with this but still interested?
- niix 13y agoI give up.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nikbackm 13y agoSad. The new terms do not sound as cool as "event horizon", "black hole" and "singularity".
- InclinedPlane 13y agoMy reading of this is that black holes still very much do exist and have almost exactly the same properties we thought they did before. The only difference being some slightly different effects on the quantum scale and on enormous cosmological time scales (well beyond gigayears). The editorialized headline here is wholly unwarranted and does a disservice to the process of scientific advancement, Nature magazine should be ashamed. This is barely one step up from "Hawking says black holes don't exist, the explanation will shock you."
- fargolime 13y ago"There are no black holes" was shown 8 years ago, much more simply than Hawking has posited: http://finbot.wordpress.com/2008/03/05/no-black-holes/ http://finbot.wordpress.com/2008/03/05/no-black-holes/ Black holes are a mistake of general relativity (GR), specifically their absolute event horizon is incompatible with GR's equivalence principle postulate, as the blog (which is not mine) shows. In software terms, black holes are a bug in the theory. Let's remember that Einstein disbelieved in black holes and for many years tried to prove they couldn't exist. Also there is no definitive evidence that they actually exist in nature. By their definition, such evidence can't be detected.
- gjm11 13y agoThe argument there looks wrong to me; in particular combining the equivalence principle with the proposition called (K) there seems wrong. EP in the form given there says that no test within the small region in question can distinguish it from a similar small region in a gravitation-free universe, but "seeing whether the small region can be extended to a larger region" is not a test you can perform within the small region and it isn't an EP violation if you can do the extension in the gravityless universe but not in the with-gravity one. Other articles on that blog claim to solve other major problems in physics, in every case giving an answer that disagrees with (what I understand to be) the consensus of working physicists. So I could trust the author of the blog, Just Because (which doesn't sound like a great strategy). Or I could trust my own opinion (which is that on the one point I looked at it looks as if there's a substantial conceptual mistake). Or I could trust the current mainstream consensus. I'm having trouble seeing reasons why I should believe what the author of that blog says. Do you happen to know of any?
- fargolime 13y agoI'm not concerned with trust or consensus, those aren't scientific concepts. If anyone shows a logical inconsistency with GR, then it's invalid regardless. > but "seeing whether the small region can be extended to a larger region" is not a test you can perform within the small region That law K doesn't apply in a frame falling through a horizon (a logical test within that frame, which is defined to be an inertial frame) indicates that physical tests can also show that the laws of physics differ between that frame and other inertial frames. The picture in the blog is an example of that. It's impossible to conduct a test where the cloud described there isn't splitting in two, unlike in some other inertial frame.
- brokenparser 13y agoSo, how does one poop?