9 ms·
The U.S. Crackdown on Hackers Is Our New War on Drugs
- silveira 13y agoWar on Privacy is the new War on Drugs.
- gmuslera 13y agoIf US government were the world's leading producer of drugs for sale everywhere the analogy would be more fitting.
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoVoila: http://www.amazon.ca/Cocaine-Politics-Central-America-Updated/dp/0520214498 http://www.amazon.ca/Cocaine-Politics-Central-America-Update...
- jlgaddis 13y ago> It’s time for the government to learn from its failed 20th century experiment over-punishing drugs and start making sensible decisions about high-tech punishment in the 21st century. I'm not gonna hold my breath.
- angersock 13y agoNote that a lot of the work we do every day, in development or devops or normal administration, can probably be presented to a layperson as "hacking". Especially as we promote services which reduce the average person to a bunch of database records and take away their middle-class job and parade about in our buses and whatnot, we do not engender much love from the common person. This is a great way of the .gov getting the tech sector back under control, and reminding it of its place. Be careful folks. :(
- asmallfish 13y agoThe government gives harsher sentences to hackers than many rapists. This is because it is actually afraid of hackers. Hackers hold power that petty criminals do not. The sentences for hackers are completely ridiculous because they are created by fear.
- thaumasiotes 13y ago> The government gives harsher sentences to hackers than many rapists. This is because it is actually afraid of hackers. There's a simpler explanation for this. Hackers are getting harsher sentences because the crime is a more recent concept. The law prides itself on its trial-and-error approach to life.
- tptacek 13y agoThe case you're thinking of where a hacker got a harsher sentence than a rapist is... what? Did one of those cases perhaps involve juveniles, and the other adults? The base offense level for rape in the federal sentencing guidelines is far higher than that for computer fraud.
- sliverstorm 13y agoExamples?
- dobbsbob 13y agoThis guy got 5yrs for 2 rapes http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/11/21/ex-marine-serving-rape-sentence-says-hes-been-sexually-assaulted-by-female-prison-workers/ http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/11/21/ex-marine-serving-rape... Gary McKinnon was looking at 70yrs. The guy who made credit card fraud sites and was busted in the carder.su op got 7yrs after pleading but was looking at life. Rape and hacking are impossible to compare though because usually a rape happens once, whereas charges are stacked a mile high for computer fraud because nobody steals one login or card they steal a db full of them which means multiple charges, so technically rape on the federal books is a larger sentence compared to 1 charge of fraud or trespassing.
- sliverstorm 13y agoWhat does what they were "looking at" matter one bit? I don't understand why the 70 years he was "looking at" matters at all, if he wasn't sentenced to 70 years.
- 13y ago
- tptacek 13y agoThis article makes an important point about the brokenness of CFAA sentencing, but it (or Wired's editors) do the point a disservice by making an absolutely hyperbolic claim. The "War On Drugs" has imprisoned literally millions of people, and done so in a fashion that is both racist (minorities are far more likely to be imprisoned for a drug offense) and classist (wealthy defendants are unlikely to be imprisoned for casual offenses). Furthermore, persecution of drug users targets actions people take that cause debatable harm to society. If[f] Keys, who is accused of deliberately enabling Anonymous to vandalize the front page of the front page of one of the largest newspapers in the world, is shown to have done the things spelled out in the warrant, then prosecutors will have shown that he: * knowingly damaged the computer systems of Tribune Corporation * actually caused 5 figures worth of damage * did so by abusing a trusted position at Reuters Keys, who as we can see has exceptional attorneys working on his case, is far more culpable for his actions than a large fraction of drug offenders. It is indeed a very serious flaw in the CFAA that sentences can "scale with the iterator in your for loop" as your actions cause seemingly spectacular amounts of damage despite no change in your actual criminal intent. But it's worth pointing out here that that flaw plays a minimal part in Keys potential sentencing. The base level for CFAA crimes (like most larceny and fraud charges) is 6, which merits a 0-6 month sentence. The damage "accelerator" in Keys charges adds 4 points to that level, bringing him to level 10, which is a 6-12 month sentence where conditional probation is allowed. The damage accelerators aren't what's ramping up Keys' sentence --- it's the combination of damage (at any level), cost to remediate, and abuse of his position of authority. Here's Popehat with a fantastic post on how the sentencing guidelines actually work (I don't think they disagree with Keys' lawyer, except that Popehat goes into more detail later in the article on how sentences are reduced in practice) --- http://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentence-eleventy-million-years/ http://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentence...
- rayiner 13y agoThe article goes off the rails with this sentence: "As a country and a criminal justice system, we’ve been down this road of excessive punishment before: with drugs." There's no particularly strong connection between computer crimes and drug crimes. As you point out, the comparison is hyperbole, and ignores the deep racial, cultural, and class conflicts at the heart of the drug war. None of those things are really applicable to computer crimes. Rather, the time Keys is facing is simply a symptom of the broader malaise of the justice system: felony enhancements are too quick to trigger, sentences are too long and the sentencing guidelines offer false precision while reducing necessary judicial discretion. The article's comparison to California's vandalism law highlights the issue described above: "Under California law, physical vandalism – like spray painting graffiti on a building — can be punished as either a misdemeanor or a felony..." That part is true of the CFAA as well, which is also a misdemeanor unless committed in furtherance of another crime. And the trigger for felony vandalism in California isn't high--above $400 in property damage makes a felony charge available to the prosecutor, as well as a sentence of up to three years in prison. In other words, I don't think it's fair to say that Keys faces more time for his computer crime than if he had physically vandalized a building to the tune of five figures of damage. Drug crimes are just in a whole different league. Possession with intent to distribute less than 100 grams of heroin can carry a sentence of up to 20 years, or up to 30 years on a second offense. Meanwhile, prison time for computer crimes is still relatively light, unless they are effectively some sort of fraud or theft: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_computer_criminals http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_computer_criminals. Something like this is much more typical: http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/crime/aspiring-medical-student-to-be-sentenced-in-mcat-hacking-case/2013/12/12/3e5e012a-6278-11e3-aa81-e1dab1360323_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/crime/aspiring-medical-s... (three months prison + 7 months of halfway house out of 10 months sought by the prosecution for hacking into AAMC computers with intent to cheat on the MCAT exam).
- Crito 13y agoUnless they figure out how to use hackers to justify frisking random minorities for the crime of walking on the sidewalk, then this is not really the new War on Drugs. The War on Drugs is a "solution" to a "problem" that white suburbia America, and their police departments, perceived. At the federal level it was driven by people attempting to protect their political interests by criminalizing the behavior they associated with groups that they felt threatened by. Hacker Panic is working at a different level. I think that it would be more accurate to say that it is our new War on Terror.
- hansjorg 13y agoThe original claim is outlandish and devoid of any perspective, but comparing this to the "War on Terror" is just mind boggling. You do realize that there's a world outside the US where the "War on Terror" has had some pretty devastating effects. Or was that a joke?
- Crito 13y agoOh fucking christ, I am not having the conversation in two places at once: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7110399 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7110399 My comparison between Hacker Panic to the War on Terror is not meant to imply that a few teenagers getting sent to prison for decades is equivalent in any respect to raining missiles down on wedding parties. It is a statement about the motivation of the people driving it. It isn't motivated by fear of civil rights movements, or a desire to continue segregation under the radar. Rather it is about using irrational fear to facilitate power grabs and justify pointless expenditures (In the case of hackers: any government program that has the word "Cyber" in it. In the case of terrorists: damn near everything else).
- dobbsbob 13y agoHacker crackdown been going on since the late 80s http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hacker_Crackdown http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hacker_Crackdown I remember when I came home from school to find cops going through my room demanding to know where I kept my copy of the cellular hackers bible because I had told somebody on fidonet I had it and it was deemed forbidden knowledge
- adamfeldman 13y agoThat's the first ebook I ever read. It's free online! http://www.mit.edu/hacker/hacker.html http://www.mit.edu/hacker/hacker.html
- r0m4n0 13y agoThis doesn't go into the statistics but I'm sure light has yet to be shed on the ridiculousness of countless settled cases and state statute/pc violations based on the CFAA (502c in CA and others).
- ihsw 13y agoThe comparison is fairly skin deep: * mandatory minimum sentences * lopsided plea bargains (you can go to jail for anywhere between 18 months to 30 years, depending on whether you take the bargain) * prosecutors pushing for convictions as a means of adding to their professional scorecard * rampant fear and paranoia (marijuana is a gateway drug! command line interfaces are scary!) * using that fear and paranoia to pass draconian (and oftentimes ineffective) legislation via door-in-the-face argument -- propose something obviously ridiculous, and when it's rejected then you propose something that's still overreaching but not enough to cause outrage * using the above-said legislation to funnel public funds to our congress-critters' friends Beyond that, the two are essential incomparable.
- tptacek 13y agoWhich of those attributes doesn't apply to pretty much every other federal crime?
- ihsw 13y agoYeah, you're right. It's a bit of a shitty news article, but it's good at grabbing your attention.
- agwa 13y agoActually, the CFAA carries no mandatory minimum. The judge could, though it's unlikely, choose to completely ignore the sentencing guidelines (which are advisory) when sentencing for a CFAA offense. In contrast, many federal drug crimes have specific mandatory minimums which actually do tie the judge's hands when sentencing.[1] And all the other attributes are true of practically every federal crime, not just drug crimes. The premise of this article is pretty terrible. [1] List of federal crimes with mandatory minimums: http://famm.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Chart-All-Fed-MMs-NW.pdf http://famm.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Chart-All-Fed-MMs...
- dnautics 13y agoso, you mean the comparison is apt in all the points of contact where it's an issue of law. There are fewer hackers than there are drug users, so the impact of the trend is going to be limited; but the point is that the drug war culture is fueling an expansion of legal abuse by prosecutors in other domains. I think this is an important point; and the only problem with the article, is the title.
- everyone 13y agoDo you not think this sort of thing may be ultimately caused by the prison industry? they need more patrons!
- coldcode 13y ago"Hackers" as a term is beginning to become too overridden to be useful.
- mtgx 13y agoAnd just like the War on Drugs, laws have been (CFAA) and will continue to be passed out of panic or cluelessness that will affect people for decades to come, unless we try to stop them today.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoThis guy's an attorney and he compares a local/county crime (vandalism) to a federal crime (CFAA) and expects the sentencing to be the same? I'm speechless. I'm not hacker, but even I know pretty much anything having to do with any unauthorized access to someone's computer is a FEDERAL offense. Regardless of whether you were the person breaking into that computer or not. Even Keys should have know what he was doing was a crime. It's the same defense people use when they're with someone in the commission of a crime. "I was only there, I didn't kill the guy, Jim did." which is not a viable defense. You're at the least an accessory to the crime, and at worst, helped in the commission of a crime like driving the getaway car, hiding evidence, etc. The whole premise of the article is completely flawed.
- radley 13y agoWar on IP/copyright is the new war on drugs. Attacking hackers is merely a byproduct.
- klez 13y agoCould someone please help me understand how can changing a headline on some websites cause five-figures damages? Honest question, really. Every time I see articles about computer vandalism or hacking I see these big numbers and don't understand how they are calculated.
- tptacek 13y agoStraightforward. * Employees of the company spend X number of days responding to the incident, and you take their fully loaded cost and divide it out by the number of days they spent having to deal with the incident, and that's a big number. Plus: * If the site is disabled or degraded, you can often easily calculate outage costs based on the average volume of revenue the site generates during the outage period. Plus: * In a high-profile incident, outside professionals will often need to come in, first because insurance and contracts require a full investigation, and second because once a site is compromised you have to assume there are backdoors that will restore access for the attackers in the future. The cost of an external forensics investigation can hit mid-5-figures by itself very easily. Plus: * A high-profile incident is inevitably going to involve legal fees for the victim. That's before you get into things like reputation damage, loss of clients/customers/advertisers, &c. Like I said upthread, $10k-$20k damages for the defacement of one of the largest newspaper websites in the world sounds like a very low figure to me. I don't mean that in a normative sense. I mean, in the positive, descriptive sense, that sounds like less than what these incidents usually actually cost to their victims.
- _delirium 13y agoThat makes some sense, but is a little out of keeping with what people expect in part because losses in many "physical" kinds of crimes aren't usually reported in an all-inclusive manner, but just report the direct damage. For example, if someone vandalizes (or steals) $20k of goods in a Wal-Mart warehouse, both Wal-Mart and the media will typically report that as $20k damage (or theft), rather than adding to the $20k the cost of the security response, lost business or increased overtime caused by supply-chain disruption, etc. Theft statutes that include thresholds for different classes of theft also usually refer only to the value of the stolen goods, not other losses caused by their theft (such as loss of business, cost of security response, or supply-chain disruption). You could justify including them, but it doesn't seem to be that common.
- njharman 13y agoFor early history of this watch Freedom Downtime http://www.freedomdowntime.com/ http://www.freedomdowntime.com/
- snake_plissken 13y agoWhen we start locking up tens of thousands of people because someone Trojaned their computer and used it to run a LOIC node, maybe this could resonate. What makes the War on Drugs unique is that so many people are and have been locked up on felony charges for buying/possessing some type of substance that they willingly want to put in their own bodies.
- alanh 13y agoWritten by one of weev’s lawyers. Weev, the absolute cyber-douche who threatened Kathy Sierra’s family and precipitated her years-long avoidance of Internet and speaking appearances. Who absoutely deserves punishment. If the “crackdown on hackers” were remotely like the “war on drugs”, then should we suppose weev to be analogous to a mere user of crack cocaine who was racially targeted and unfairly handed an outsized jail sentence? No. weev is no victim.
- fleitz 13y agoIt's not a new war on drugs, its the same old war on critical thinking.
- Fasebook 13y agoI don't know why anyone here is even discussing it. They'll make the laws they want and they'll enforce the punishments they want. People's front pages are too economically viable to let reason into the courtroom.
- aaron695 13y ago> The U.S. Crackdown on Hackers Is Our New War on Drugs No it's not. Drug use is a personal choice where all actors are voluntary. (The 'war' bit then causes the damage we currently see to everyone) Hacking has victims that don't want to be involved. It might be a heavy handed approach currently but relating it to the war on drugs is insulting, millions die and are incarcerated because of that war.
- ivanbrussik 13y agonot even nearly close from a fiscal standpoint.
- NAFV_P 13y agoThe prime failure of the criminalisation of drugs is that it defines someone who is smoking a joint as a criminal. This scenario is closer to what happened to Robert Morris. Apparently the worm wasn't intended to be malicious, unlike the actions of Matthew Keys.
- Fuxy 13y agoIf this "War on Hackers" truly becomes an issue this could potentially be the most damaging war in the American economy. Hackers are nothing like drug dealer the same people that vandalize a few websites when their teenagers and part of anonymous could later become the founders of the next great company like google. By giving hacker overly hash punishments the US government is hurting their potential to do good by unnecessarily exposing them to a world (prisons) where the likelihood of them doing more black-hat hacking is higher.
- tsotha 13y agoThere's a big difference between putting a substance into your own body and breaking into someone else's computer and taking their data. Personally I think the punishments for "hacking", the way the term is used in this article, are too light.