4 ms·
The US continues to puzzle me. China is seen as aggressor in Cyberwar, Chinese hard- and software is accused of having security problems, there are lots of dis
by lispm 13y ago
The US continues to puzzle me.
China is seen as aggressor in Cyberwar, Chinese hard- and software is accused of having security problems, there are lots of discussions about the more aggressive role of China in Asia, the US has a huge trade deficit with China, China is accused of spying, ...
But the US continues to sell its companies and its business to China and imports stuff from there more and more.
Does the US have an idea what to do to balance the relationship - besides sending the Navy or let bomber airplanes fly over disputed areas?
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/11/27/us-china-defense-usa-idUSBRE9AP0X320131127 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/11/27/us-china-defense-u...
Note the US government needs to approve such deals:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-02-14/make-it-easier-for-china-to-buy-u-s-businesses.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-02-14/make-it-easier-for-...
- sargun 13y agoUS companies operate as individual entities. Our government doesn't have end-to-end control over commerce.
- lispm 13y agoThe US government needs to approve such deals.
- kabdib 13y ago... and that's only a small part of the government.
- icambron 13y agoThe US government can't reject them for "we don't like that country" reasons, because that's outside of the scope of its regulatory powers. Regulatory approval of acquisitions is based on competition considerations, not trade war considerations. If they rejected a deal for improper reasons, they'd get sued, and they'd lose.
- canistr 13y agoIs this really the case in the US? Because in Canada, there have been numerous cases of the Canadian government vetoing purchases by foreign companies in the name of protecting Canadian interests and security (e.g. MDA selling to an American aerospace firm, Pot Ash Corp, BlackBerry to Lenovo, etc.) Or even the case of SEC approval or EU approval for major acquisitions.
- icambron 13y agoI'm guessing there are some national security rules too (and possibly some other specific rules), but the point is that they can't just say, "we don't like China so they can't buy our companies". The government simply hasn't been given that power.
- canistr 13y agoWhat I'm pointing out though is that their point about "national security" really came down to "we don't trust China"/"we don't trust america". And it passed through Parliament fine because it pretty much had the support of Canadians.
- icambron 13y agoYou're right that the legislature can pass any law they want; I was just talking about the executive branch's authority to veto deals directly. I didn't think that--at least in the US--there were instances in which Congress had actually done passed a law like that, and wasn't considering that a relevant possibility. But see Galaxity's comment below refuting that; so I'm withdrawing my argument.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoChina vetoed Coke buying a local beverage producer over national security concerns.
- PakG1 13y ago
- sidko 13y agoIBM is a private company, it isn't owned by the US Government.
- dredmorbius 13y agoUS government is one heck of a big customer of IBM though. Not sure how much in the low-end server market, but still.
- dagw 13y ago"The US" isn't selling anything as "The US" owns relatively few companies. An international conglomerate, with headquartered in the US, is selling of a small part of its business. It isn't up to IBM to unilaterally act against its own business interest to try to uphold US security policy.
- rayiner 13y agoWhat's irritating to me is that many of the people who claim to be pro-national security and defense cheerlead the whole process of outsourcing our sovereignty piecemeal to China.
- Gracana 13y agoThey do?
- rayiner 13y agoMany American conservatives, arguably the bulk of the mainstream conservative party, have elevated globalism above national independence by embracing libertarian ideas about the role of national governments with respect to international commerce. At one time, conservatives favored reducing unnecessary burdens on international trade, such as tariffs, as a means to the end of greater national prosperity. Today, they quite often deny the very legitimacy of the national government exercising its sovereign powers to manage or limit trade to maximize national prosperity. This represents a fundamental change in thinking with tremendous implications in light of the continued growth of international corporations.
- mindcrime 13y agoToday, they quite often deny the very legitimacy of the national government exercising its sovereign powers to manage or limit trade to maximize national prosperity. This represents a fundamental change in thinking with tremendous implications in light of the continued growth of international corporations. And that's a good thing. We don't need governments mucking about, artificially distorting markets with their heavy-handed intervention. Look at where that's gotten us in the past. National independence? Who cares, "nations" are an outdated idea anyway. I don't want "national prosperity", I want "everybody prosperity" with no regards for where in the world you live and work.
- rayiner 13y agoYou're entitled to your opinion, but it's a distinctly radical rather than conservative one. And that was the point of my post: to point out the inconsistency in purporting to believe in national independence while embracing radical libertarian and globalist ideas about international markets. Conservatives don't purport to believe that "nations are outdated" and that "everybody prosperity" is more important than "American prosperity."
- ams6110 13y agoGuessing the servers in question (X86) were already manufactured in China anyway.
- eitally 13y agoWhen we (Sanmina) owned the manufacturing contract for X-series servers we built them in Mexico and Hungary. When we sold the manufacturing contract for IBM PCs (Netvista), laptops (Thinkpads), and X-series servers to Foxconn & Lenovo in 2008, Lenovo was manufacturing in Mexico & China and Foxconn in Hungary (and probably elsewhere). No one has built any PCs or servers in the US since IBM essentially divested themselves of their huge presence in Research Triangle Park. Dell used to manufacture PCs in the US but moved the last of their stuff overseas in 2010. I'm not sure if there is any HP manufacturing in the US, but I suspect not. Dell, HP, Foxconn, Lenovo, Flextronics, and Sanmina all have a large presence in Jalisco, MX, in and around Guadalajara. ... and in/around Shenzhen, Bangkok, Shanghai, Singapore, ....
- mark_wagner 13y agoI believe the first 2 letters of a proliant serial number indicate where they are manufactured. I've seen CN, US, MX, and SG serial number prefixes.
- kyrra 13y agoThe US government will stop deals that they see as "bad" for them. See the canceled buyout of Sourcefire by Checkpoint back in 2006[0][1]. Though, Sourcefire was recently bought by Cisco. [0] http://www.securityfocus.com/news/11382 http://www.securityfocus.com/news/11382 [1] http://blogs.computerworld.com/node/1913 http://blogs.computerworld.com/node/1913