5 ms·
Not that I'm disagreeing with this outcome at all... But if agreeing not to poach is collusion and conspiracy... Then how is it that it's legal for workers to
by crazygringo 13y ago
Not that I'm disagreeing with this outcome at all...
But if agreeing not to poach is collusion and conspiracy...
Then how is it that it's legal for workers to form unions and strike? Isn't that just as much "collusion and conspiracy" from the other side?
I mean heck, consumers organizing to boycott a product is a kind of "collusion" and "conspiracy" as well that is just as arguably "anti-market".
Is there anyone who can explain how the law differentiates between them? I have zero legal background/knowledge of these things...
Edit: To be clear, I think unions can be great things, and think the anti-poaching agreements are bad... I'm just trying to figure out a way to reconcile these in my mind! :)
- zasz 13y agoIANAL, but unions are highly visible, while this "agreement not to poach" was not.
- blazespin 13y agoAlso, none of these tech workers unionized. Though I guess this group action is a sort of union.
- oinksoft 13y agoIn the US at least, anti-trust laws seek to limit business practices considered anti-competitive. Sure, a "union" could seek to reduce competition/harm businesses, and that is a common accusation, but similar laws for unions are mostly a thing of a past, legacies of a time when state militias did combat with those despicable striking coal miners. Do you believe that businesses should have the same legal status as individuals? There's been a tiff over that for the last decade or so.
- redwood 13y agoI'm no expert but some thoughts: That's an interesting point: could people be accused of anti-trust violations by agreeing to collude and not work under certain circumstances? The difference boils down to what the purpose of laws are. Ultimately they exist to sustain a reasonably egalitarian free society. Obviously there are times and specific situations where we deviate more or less from the "ideal" society but the law shepherds us back toward an agreed-upon path. Basically the root of antitrust law is that concentration of power is anti-democratic and therefore must be controlled. In a situation of people colluding around work standards, there is a parallel to some extent but there isn't a clear power-player who emerges (except for the "Union" itself but that's made up of all the employees in a different way than the corporation is owned by its owners because individuals in a union are all essentially equally important to the union's strength, where in corporate ownership it's very clear that some individuals wield significantly (orders of magnitude) more power through wealth and control. http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/1239985?uid=3739560&uid=2&uid=4&uid=3739256&sid=21103343963393 http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/1239985?uid=3739560&ui...
- rayiner 13y agoUnions have special carve outs in the antitrust laws. Besides that, colluding to limit labor supply isn't necessarily legal either. E.g. The DOJ has threatened the ABA with antitrust enforcement if they use the law school accreditation process to artificially limit the supply of lawyers. This is labor side collusion, but is still considered illegal because it doesn't fall within union carve outs.
- zedshaw 13y agoYes, if you believe that you can reduce any use of a word down to its most abstract concept giving you the ability to equate anything to anything else. By those standards collusion is also a tomato, a pair of shoes, and my left ear. Very Zen. But, given nobody else thinks this way, then no, unions are not a conspiracy. A conspiracy is pretty much defined as such when everyone involved constantly tells each other "don't tell anyone" which is what these jackasses did (go read the emails). Unions are very public about going on strike and have big votes on it, thus not a conspiracy. Same with consumers organizing a strike, or just about everything you came up with. Collusion is also not bad unless it's illegal, and what we've decided in the US is that gigantic billion dollar companies are not allowed to get together and screw over poor work slobs who make maybe $100k/year with their collective MegaCorp trillion dollar might. In fact, any decent human being would be enraged at a giant corporation using its power to smash a little guy to make a few thousand more per employee a year.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoThere are many, many problems here. > Collusion is also not bad unless it's illegal Did it ever occur to you that laws might be passed despite those same laws not being beneficial? In your model of the world, where legal actions are all, by definition, good, how would legislators decide whether or not to enact a prospective law? If we repealed all our antitrust legislation, can I assume you would agree that employer collusion to hold down wages used to be bad, but was now good? > no, unions are not a conspiracy. A conspiracy is pretty much defined as such when everyone involved constantly tells each other "don't tell anyone" I have to agree with the bare semantics here, but... who's alleging that the harm from a bunch of companies secretly agreeing to hold down wages comes, entirely and only, from the fact that the agreement is secret? They do it in secret because it's illegal, and your parent is wondering why employees are legally allowed to do openly what employers must do in secret. Why is there supposed to be a difference? Is there a justification for punishing the companies, other than the fact that their conduct is illegal? Nothing can be bad because it's illegal; belief following that reasoning is religious, not valid.
- zedshaw 13y ago
- pron 13y agoThe reason is that the law attempts to balance power; when there is an imbalance of power, it helps the weaker side. A workers union in itself does not exploit employers. Its purpose is to force a fair distribution of wealth. A collusion of businesses is different, as its goal is to force an unfair distribution of wealth, as workers generally have fewer options than corporations. It's much easier for a corporation to find workers elsewhere than for a worker to move, hence this practice exploits workers' limited choice, and the law tries to defend against this kind of exploitation.
- blazespin 13y ago"A workers union in itself does not exploit employers." No, pretty much all unions exploit workers via forced due paying. Unions sucks in the same way corporations colluding suck.
- pyre 13y agoThe core purpose of unions is to create collective bargaining power, though in many cases, unions have out-lived their usefulness, and are nothing but bureaucratic inertia. I doubt that you would be complaining about the union if, for example, it was improving your working conditions.
- specialist 13y agoAll citizens are "forced" to pay taxes. Otherwise free loaders would cheat. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Collective_Action http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Collective_Action So it is with all organizations, such as unions, trade groups, etc. Very simple game theory.
- richardfontana 13y agoThe antitrust laws in the US were revised to largely carve out activities of labor unions. See: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/17 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/17
- rahimnathwani 13y agoIt's about the balance of negotiation power between the buyers and sellers in the labour market. Once jobs became standardised, and employees easier to replace, individuals had/have little/no negotiating power, so their response to low pay and poor conditions is 'suck it up'. Unions aim to redress that imbalance, and there are specific laws in many countries detailing what they can/cannot do. IANAL but AFAIK there are fewer and less strong cases where companies can legally collude in most jurisdictions. A couple of personal thoughts: - The impact of unions is different in different situations. It's easy for us to pick and choose examples based on pre-existing biases, but the details are more nuanced. - People often think of unions as being for low-skilled workers, or those where the choice of employers is limited (e.g. teachers in the UK). However, many professional guilds (like national doctors' associations) also provide many of the same functions (lobbying, collective bargaining, coordination of industrial actions, ...).
- blazespin 13y agoThe difference is individually, consumers have no power and neither do workers. Which is why unions form. That being said, unions suck as well.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- raganwald 13y agoIn theory, at least, the reconciliation is to side with the little guy. When there's a massive imbalance of power, there's an idea that you will be more restrictive of the powerful side. The theory is that this is in the public's best interests. So, in theory, if you have two giant companies that control 95% of the distribution of widgets, you might decide that they cannot merge into one entity. But if widgets are made by a bunch of tiny independents and sold to those two distributors, you might allow the independents to form a co-operative association. In practice, lawyers and lobbyists will say and do anything to get an advantage for their clients. But that's the theory, and that's why it's generally easier to form a union than it is to form a cartel.
- crazygringo 13y agoThat's a great explanation, in theory and in practice. :) I find it interesting that this would justify a union that represented 1000's of workers, working in just 1 or 2 companies. But that it would not justify a kind of hypothetical 'union of CEO's' of 100's of workers, working in 100's of companies. Which makes sense, of course.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoHow do you determine who is the "little guy"? Is there some arbitrary pre-specified list/heirarchy of little guys that must be taken as a first principle, or is there an underlying principle determining who is the little guy?
- pjc50 13y agoUse your eyes, sort by size. (More pragmatically, try to estimate who really has the power in a situation; who has other options? Who is dependant on whom? Remember that a company is not a person and does not have physical or emotional needs.)
- raganwald 13y agoMe, personally, I use my judgment. Others go by whomever has the cleverest lawyers or the most well-paid lobbyists. Or you can cop out and say that since there is no perfect way to write a law relating to this, there should be no law. Which is effectively the law of the jungle. Some people prefer that.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoApart from the obvious political justifications (people want the union vote) there are some sound reasons why unions are different from cartels like the employers in the article are alleged to have formed. A cartel is several companies colluding to raise prices above/below the market price. A labor union might be though of in the same way, but in practice is is very hard for a union to really control the supply of labor, because it is made up of thousands of people. It is only when they are tacitly allowed to use force/violence that unions can effectively prevent strike-breakers. So given how ineffective they are at permanently raising wages (perhaps they raise wages a bit, but not nearly as much as if they had a true monopoly), unions should probably be allowed since if people choose to join them, they must provide some other benefits, such as representing individual workers with grievances, etc.
- pyre 13y agoOne thing that you're also missing here is that (IIRC) employees of one of the colluding companies that applied for a job at another colluding company would be 'reported' and some may have been fired for shopping around for a job elsewhere. (E.g.) A Google employee sends his/her resume to Apple, then Apple tells Google that said employee is looking for work elsewhere.
- mullingitover 13y ago> Then how is it that it's legal for workers to form unions and strike? Isn't that just as much "collusion and conspiracy" from the other side? Unions are a good thing for civilization, so much so that forming a union the very first purpose that is stated in the list of reasons for writing the Constitution. We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union...
- pmorici 13y agoI think it's kind of funny all the responses you your legitimate question are essentially people presenting their political opinions. There is a factual answer to your question though. In the early 1900's people tried to argue exactly that that unions were an illegal conspiracy under the Sherman Antitrust Act. This interpretation was against popular opinion at the time and in 1914 under the Clayton Antitrust Act the legality of organized labor was clarified making it specially legal. The short answer to your question as to why Unions are ok but collusion between companies is not is because there is an exception in the Antitrust laws. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_labor_law#Workplace_participation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_labor_law#Workpla...
- rahimnathwani 13y agoSeveral earlier answers (e.g. pron's) _do_ refer to the legal structure as to why unions can exist, without citing the specific act. It's totally fair that they also (i) discuss why the law may have to come to be and (ii) how they think/feel about it.
- lmkg 13y ago1) Secrecy. Both individuals and companies are allowed to openly band together for the purposes of bargaining power. It happens all the time with standards bodies, lobbying organizations, industry consortia, patent-sharing arrangements, etc. Doing so in secret is usually seen as market manipulation. One of the requirements for a market to be 'free' is equal access to information, which secret agreements prohibit. 2) Power imbalance. Others have addressed this already, so I'll let it lie. 3) This agreement in particular was an attempt to create and abuse a monopsony position, which is in itself illegal. Many markets are regulated in order to ensure competition, by e.g. blocking mergers. Secret negotiations are often an attempt to bypass pro-competition regulations, by having two entities act in concert while pretending to be independent. In short, ends matter. Collusion to commit a crime is viewed differently than collusion to ask for a raise or collusion to not by a product.
- squirejons 13y agoyouth thinks they are invulnerable. As you grow older, you realize what the world really is and how vulnerable we really are.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoYou ever heard of union-busting? I mean, since when did tech workers form unions without being fired en masse?
- dredmorbius 13y agoHow is it that it's legal for workers to form unions and strike? Isn't that just as much "collusion and conspiracy" from the other side? Employers have a natural organizational advantage, as well as advantages of capital and resources. Given that virtually any workplace has a 1:n relationship with its employees, the bargaining advantage is with the employer. Within a labor market as a whole, a small number of companies may affect a huge number of workers (the case lists a handful of firms and 60,000 or more employees). This was recognized by Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations: It is not, however, difficult to foresee which of the two parties must, upon all ordinary occasions, have the advantage in the dispute, and force the other into a compliance with their terms. The masters, being fewer in number, can combine much more easily: and the law, besides, authorises, or at least does not prohibit, their combinations, while it prohibits those of the workmen. We have no acts of parliament against combining to lower the price of work, but many against combining to raise it. In all such disputes, the masters can hold out much longer. A landlord, a farmer, a master manufacturer, or merchant, though they did not employ a single workman, could generally live a year or two upon the stocks, which they have already acquired. Many workmen could not subsist a week, few could subsist a month, and scarce any a year, without employment. In the long run, the workman may be as necessary to his master as his master is to him; but the necessity is not so immediate. We rarely hear, it has been said, of the combinations of masters, though frequently of those of workmen. But whoever imagines, upon this account, that masters rarely combine, is as ignorant of the world as of the subject. Masters are always and everywhere in a sort of tacit, but constant and uniform, combination, not to raise the wages of labour above their actual rate. To violate this combination is everywhere a most unpopular action, and a sort of reproach to a master among his neighbours and equals. We seldom, indeed, hear of this combination, because it is the usual, and, one may say, the natural state of things, which nobody ever hears of. Masters, too, sometimes enter into particular combinations to sink the wages of labour even below this rate. These are always conducted with the utmost silence and secrecy till the moment of execution; and when the workmen yield, as they sometimes do without resistance, though severely felt by them, they are never heard of by other people. And on for a number of paragraphs. http://www.gutenberg.org/files/3300/3300-h/3300-h.htm#link2HCH0008 http://www.gutenberg.org/files/3300/3300-h/3300-h.htm#link2H... Chapters VII and X of book 1 discuss labour, wages, and various differentiators among them. They're impressively comprehensive and informed, vastly more liberal than you might have been lead to believe of Smith (he really is quite the liberal philosopher), and still highly applicable today. I strongly recommend reading both sections, and more of Smith if at all possible.