9 ms·
Silicon Valley workers may pursue collusion case as group
- lowglow 13y agoLiterally so much collusion in the valley it's insane. Maybe I should write an article about it.
- spamizbad 13y agoPlease do.
- blazespin 13y agoWhat collusion are you talking about?
- dclowd9901 13y agoMight want to brush up on your use of "literally" first.
- lowglow 13y agoWords change their meaning over time. I'm afraid this is something you'll just have to learn to accept.
- rrreese 13y agoLets consult the Oxford English Dictionary: http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/109061?redirectedFrom=literally#eid http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/109061?redirectedFrom=literall... "c. colloq. Used to indicate that some (freq. conventional) metaphorical or hyperbolical expression is to be taken in the strongest admissible sense: ‘virtually, as good as’; (also) ‘completely, utterly, absolutely’. Now one of the most common uses, although often considered irregular in standard English since it reverses the original sense of literally (‘not figuratively or metaphorically’)." Of note the use by Twain: "1876 ‘M. Twain’ Adventures Tom Sawyer ii. 20 And when the middle of the afternoon came, from being a poor poverty-stricken boy in the morning, Tom was literally rolling in wealth." You may not like this situation but it is way too late to complain about it.
- dmazin 13y agoThat's interesting. A company may see it as only fair not to poach, but in the eyes of employees it's (rightly) collusion. On that note, "Former Apple CEO Steve Jobs threatened to hit Palm with patent litigation if the company did not stop poaching valuable employees"[1] is not ethically defensible. [1] http://arstechnica.com/apple/2013/01/angry-over-employee-poaching-steve-jobs-threatened-palm-with-patent-suit/ http://arstechnica.com/apple/2013/01/angry-over-employee-poa...
- sdoowpilihp 13y agoIt wasn't about being fair on the companies part; not poaching each others employees was a form of cost control.
- dmazin 13y agoWhat I'm saying is that while it may seem wrong to poach employees, employers have a greater duty to the workforce than to other companies, ethically.
- blazespin 13y agoThis collusion was frankly beyond obscene and should be totally illegal. Like non compete clauses, they're put in place so corporations are basically given a way to work together to oppress their employees. It's just as bad as Unions, but for corporations.
- crazygringo 13y agoNot that I'm disagreeing with this outcome at all... But if agreeing not to poach is collusion and conspiracy... Then how is it that it's legal for workers to form unions and strike? Isn't that just as much "collusion and conspiracy" from the other side? I mean heck, consumers organizing to boycott a product is a kind of "collusion" and "conspiracy" as well that is just as arguably "anti-market". Is there anyone who can explain how the law differentiates between them? I have zero legal background/knowledge of these things... Edit: To be clear, I think unions can be great things, and think the anti-poaching agreements are bad... I'm just trying to figure out a way to reconcile these in my mind! :)
- zasz 13y agoIANAL, but unions are highly visible, while this "agreement not to poach" was not.
- blazespin 13y agoAlso, none of these tech workers unionized. Though I guess this group action is a sort of union.
- oinksoft 13y agoIn the US at least, anti-trust laws seek to limit business practices considered anti-competitive. Sure, a "union" could seek to reduce competition/harm businesses, and that is a common accusation, but similar laws for unions are mostly a thing of a past, legacies of a time when state militias did combat with those despicable striking coal miners. Do you believe that businesses should have the same legal status as individuals? There's been a tiff over that for the last decade or so.
- redwood 13y agoI'm no expert but some thoughts: That's an interesting point: could people be accused of anti-trust violations by agreeing to collude and not work under certain circumstances? The difference boils down to what the purpose of laws are. Ultimately they exist to sustain a reasonably egalitarian free society. Obviously there are times and specific situations where we deviate more or less from the "ideal" society but the law shepherds us back toward an agreed-upon path. Basically the root of antitrust law is that concentration of power is anti-democratic and therefore must be controlled. In a situation of people colluding around work standards, there is a parallel to some extent but there isn't a clear power-player who emerges (except for the "Union" itself but that's made up of all the employees in a different way than the corporation is owned by its owners because individuals in a union are all essentially equally important to the union's strength, where in corporate ownership it's very clear that some individuals wield significantly (orders of magnitude) more power through wealth and control. http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/1239985?uid=3739560&uid=2&uid=4&uid=3739256&sid=21103343963393 http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/1239985?uid=3739560&ui...
- redwood 13y agoThe problem with laws like this is they're very difficult to prove because you can create fairly arbitrary criteria for what you want in an employee and claim that one of those things you want is for them not to have been significantly molded by a different large bureaucratic entity with its own culture and processes. It's trivial to prove this is going on, but what I mean is: difficult to reach the legal burden of proof of collusion. Also ultimately a law suit like this will send $$$ -> lawyers more than anyone else.
- mikeyouse 13y ago> The problem with laws like this is they're very difficult to prove Not when the DOJ has subpoena power. After a Google recruiter reached out to an Apple engineer, Steve Jobs in an email to Eric Schmidt: "I would be very pleased if your recruiting department would stop doing this," Schmidt, forwarding that email to his team: "Can you get this stopped and let me know why this is happening?" Google's Staffing Director: "[The recruiter who contacted the Apple Employee] will be terminated within the hour." "Please extend my apologies as appropriate to Steve Jobs." http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/01/27/us-apple-lawsuit-idUSTRE80Q27420120127 http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/01/27/us-apple-lawsuit-i...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- smtddr 13y agoHmm... so while we have the whole gentrification thing going on, those on the outside of tech are watching us complain that maybe we don't get paid enough. Imagine what the outside-of-tech people think when reading this article. The recession and/or effects of it isn't over for a lot of them. If there was an article about bank or oil company execs complaining that they don't get enough money we'd probably all be exploding with rage. Just saying....
- yetanotherphd 13y agoOnly people who don't understand that wages come from the value a person produces. Lawyers, doctors, professional athletes, also get high wages and are entitled to them. If you want to adjust income inequality you have to do it across the board, through taxation, not by shaming individual industries. We get paid so much because we produce that much value. But if these allegations are true, we aren't getting paid enough.
- pravda 13y agoInteresting examples. Doctors are part of a cartel. Also lawyers. Although I don't think all lawyers get high wages. Professional athletes are unionized. They would be earning much less money if they weren't.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoyeah it's hard to find examples of high wage workers who aren't in some sense unionized. Not really sure what your point is though. After all, if their wages are in part due to being part of a cartel, then tech workers who earn that wage without a cartel are even more deserving of it.
- pravda 13y agoOk, first you write that "wages come from the value a person produces." Then you write "it's hard to find examples of high wage workers who aren't in some sense unionized." And then you again add something completely contradictory. But I do agree with you. I would say that tech workers are underpaid. Google has revenue per employee of $931,565. Most of that is profit. Is the average compensation per Googler anywhere near that? Why shouldn't Googlers form a union and take lets say an average $500,000 per employee? Right now, Googlers get paid free-market wages that are a fraction of the value they add to the company.
- ps4fanboy 13y agoIt is a shame Steve Jobs isnt alive to answer for his part in this.
- vinceguidry 13y agoI'd prefer him alive too, so he can keep making amazing products.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIts funny for me because on the start-up side of things it feels like Apple, Google, and Facebook are pushing up wages by offering up huge salaries to entice everyone to go there.
- randomdata 13y agoThat's what is supposed to happen. Supply and demand.
- arikrak 13y agoThey didn't say they wouldn't hire each other's employees, just they wouldn't actively recruit top talent from each other. I don't see what's wrong with that. Top employees can still apply on their own.
- mullingitover 13y ago> They didn't say they wouldn't hire each other's employees, just they wouldn't actively recruit top talent from each other. You've just described collusion. They colluded to prevent the wages of their top talent from being boosted by the normal process of competition in the labor market. Sure it's not like they stole money directly out of their star employees' pockets, but in the end the effect was the same.
- arikrak 13y agoOne motive for it was so they could work together on projects without worrying about the employees getting poached. It doesn't seem like such a clear-cut wrong.
- mullingitover 13y agoHow would you feel if you found out that your employer's competitor really wanted to hire you, and would've willingly tripled your salary, but your manager had a talk with the competition and they made a backroom no-poach deal?
- employee 13y ago(google employee here) One thing I have always wondered is if the raises Google employees received in 2011 were a result of the illegal collusion being uncovered and therefore no longer depressing salaries. The timing seems about right. For reference: http://www.businessinsider.com/google-bonus-and-raise-2010-11 http://www.businessinsider.com/google-bonus-and-raise-2010-1... (It was much more than 10% by the way, and by far the biggest raise I've ever received in my career) It's beyond dispute that the raises were given for competitive reasons. (No, we didn't all get a raise because we were doing such a great job.) There was an uptick in Googlers leaving. I suppose some of it had to do with Facebook, which was NOT part of the collusion. But I wonder how related the two events are, and if this issue will come up in a future class action lawsuit. It's a pretty unprecedented event to give all employees at an enormous company such a big raise. A sudden shift in the job market caused by this defunct agreement could explain it.
- puppetmaster3 13y agoThe software engineers salaries are way to low and artificially so, due to lack of free working market. Compare to how much you pay for a lawyer per hour. And lawyer do not have to train on the this years tech over and over. And they don't have to think hard for full day.
- mullingitover 13y ago"People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices." - Adam Smith
- miguelindurain 13y agoDo any of those workers still work for those companies, or did they have to quit before suing ?