21 ms·
The New York Times Redesign is Live
- scotthtaylor 13y agoStill seems very busy to me.
- poolpool 13y agoIts a global newspaper. There is an extraordinary amount of information that needs to be shown.
- scotthtaylor 13y agoPlenty of newspapers cope with this; however, I have to say the individual article pages look great.
- ahoy 13y agoI got the same feeling, but it also evokes the feeling and look of a physical newspaper. I like it. It's much better than some other news sites.
- tysone 13y agoDetails about the redesign and technology overhaul: http://source.opennews.org/en-US/articles/behind-scenes-nyt-redesign/ http://source.opennews.org/en-US/articles/behind-scenes-nyt-... i.e. "… using Github instead of SVN for version control, Vagrant environments, Puppet deployment, using requireJS so five different versions of jQuery don’t get loaded, proper build/test frameworks, command-line tools for generating sprites, the use of LESS with a huge set of mixins, a custom grid framework, etc."
- mikemikemike 13y agoThe design is almost skeumorphic in its replication of an actual newspaper. I can understand wanting to do that for branding reasons, the same way Craigslist is successfully branded as anti-design. But the wall of information is just such a bad UX... if they want the site to look like the paper, they should redesign both to have a legible content hierarchy.
- ollie101 13y agoPretty underwhelming
- notzach 13y agoAnd it's not even responsive.
- xux 13y agothey redirect to mobile.* though
- Kartificial 13y agoSo they still hold on to the old train of thought of desktop users and mobile users. Shame really.
- venomsnake 13y agoAs a person that currently maintains separate versions for desktop and mobile - it is not shameful. It is just good sense. You are still constrained with a lot of low power devices on the mobile side and old versions of IE on the desktop side. So it is big PITA to reconcile all of this. In 5 year they will converge but right now it is too early.
- lmm 13y agoThe needs of both are the same: simple, readable design. Every time I see a site with these two versions I've found that I preferred one to the other, on both devices - either the desktop version's better even on mobile, or (usually) the mobile version's better even on desktop.
- talmand 13y agoJust because it's old doesn't mean it's no longer relevant. There are several instances where having two separate sites makes more sense.
- wtallis 13y agoThere will always be good reasons to design a site differently for touchscreens than for keyboard+mouse devices.
- antonius 13y agoThought I was on the Wall Street Jounal.. similar layouts.
- kilovoltaire 13y agoSeems like they increased the font size, at least slightly? Which would definitely be a positive thing in my opinion. Anyone have side-by-side screenshots?
- uptown 13y agoThis page shows older versions of the site in a carousel towards the bottom: http://www.nytimes.com/redesign/ http://www.nytimes.com/redesign/
- meleva 13y agoI prefered the 2012 version. The blue titles stood out more and made it easier to scan the articles of the front page in one go
- kilovoltaire 13y agoThanks. That makes it look like I imagined the font increase, at least on the homepage.
- josefresco 13y agoSeems like 2007 was the key year for change. Since then it's been more evolutionary.
- abrowne 13y agoThe font size on the article pages now seems better, but the homepage is still tiny. I zoom the homepage 120% (two steps in Firefox), but now I don't need to zoom the article pages. With a browser that remembers zooming per-(sub)domain, this works well since I read the international edition, which has it's own subdomain.
- janlukacs 13y agoi still zoom the browser to 175% on an HD display to comfortably read. was expecting more in this regard.
- psteinweber 13y agoVisiting the site not very often I think I wouldn't have recognized it as a "redesign". Feels more like "some tweaks". Was hoping for some whitespace, the elements are quite cramped together.
- ishener 13y agommm... not sure if the redesign is not available in my country, or it's just hardly noticeable
- mars 13y agolooks like the FAZ http://www.faz.net http://www.faz.net
- janlukacs 13y agoFAZ is better, easier to go through the homepage.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- k2enemy 13y agoI hope they find ways to speed things up. When I return to the main page from a story, I have to wait five seconds while items on the front page bounce around as things load. This is on a very fast connection and a mac pro.
- johnnymonster 13y agoThey have some extremely poor performance optimizations err NO performance optimizations on the front page. TONS of individual unscaled images loading. Someone might want to introduce them to a product called "Pagespeed"...
- philip1209 13y agoIt looks like they're running Varnish for caching the pages - is the main issue the images?
- samwillis 13y agoThe changes on the homepage a minimal, howserver they have made some big changes to the artical pages (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/08/business/international/asian-factories-see-sense-and-savings-in-environmental-certification.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/08/business/international/asi...). Note that you can now scroll through the entire article, no clicking next three times!
- huskyr 13y agoAh, nice pointing that out. Funny that the homepage is not responsive, but the article pages are.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dangoldin 13y agoLooks very similar to the NPR blog articles now. I like this trend - long, clean single page articles.
- agumonkey 13y agoYeah, this itself is very zen inducing. Very good step.
- geekowl 13y agoThey removed the Technology link from the main page...
- mandlar 13y agoGo to Sections -> News -> Technology. Quite a bit hidden.
- abrowne 13y agoI like the new article pages generally, but I might need to write a userstyle to remove the position: fixed on the floating top bar.
- username223 13y agoI like the clean typography, and appreciate that they were content with subtle changes rather than something "radical." But why, oh why, did they add one of those horrible floating bars at the top of the screen? Those things almost always break page-down, yo!
- nattaylor 13y agoPage down is working for me...
- username223 13y agoTrue, I can still hit the space bar, but it does something different and broken. Try paging down on HN, and you'll see that the bottom 1-2 lines are preserved at the top of the screen, so you don't lose your place. Now try it on NYT: at least for me, there is absolutely no context preserved. That's better than the all-too-frequent case where a line is missed entirely, but it still makes reading harder. Plus, I'm so used to lousy sites that skip a line on page-down that I don't trust the NYT's version not to do so. EDIT: They seem to do the right thing on articles, but not on the front page.
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoThe front page is working correctly for me in Firefox 26. When I hit page down or space the two lines that were at the very bottom of the screen move to just below the top bar.
- criswell 13y agoThe only time I dislike the top bar is when they're too tall or there's not enough height in the view port. I think this one is as good as they get, though. I do wish they only enabled it at a minimum height. Designers only seem to think about min-width, not so much min-height.
- _stephan 13y agoHow do you like the typography? I find e.g. the italic font for the headlines in the left column or the small all caps serif format of the bylines to be somewhat detrimental to readability.
- johnchristopher 13y agoI am under the impression that everything is smaller.
- Semiapies 13y agoIt's unpleasant to try to read the front page without zooming in, and last I checked, I have 20/20 vision. 10px Georgia is an abominable choice.
- ikt 13y agoI was just going to say the font sucks, there's a million free fonts on google fonts that look great... and they appear to have gone with times new roman for no particular reason.
- 3pt14159 13y agoThe mobile version is fantastic.
- lwsclrk 13y agoIt's OK. Tech isn't on the home page. Still prefer Quartz.
- tomelders 13y agoIf I may take a moment to whinge and whine a tad; Websites like this infuriate me because for all their "design", sites like Reddit and HN (which are basically just lists) are delivering news in a much more consumable fashion, better suited to the eating habits of the common or garden user. Who's to blame? The designers with their need to make their own mark? The suits with their demands that the business needs be met regardless of the way the world actually works? Probably both. Also, I think Digg deserves more credit for finding a successful mid point between lists and designed layouts. That's not to say there's no room for design, but this new NYT layout is anything but design. It's the same wall of information with sporadic and indecipherable levels of emphasis made to look mildly palatable for another couple of years. If the NYT has anything interesting to say, I'll wait for it to appear on HN, Digg or Reddit.
- sd8f9iu 13y agoI don't always want my news ranked in a list by upvotes and an algorithm, thank you very much. I find sites that rely on user input to rank stories are prone to spreading rumors and emotional, link-bait news. I trust the New York Times to present to me a variety of stories in what they think is the best way. What is it with this obsession with the idea that the view of the mob must be the best way?
- tomelders 13y agoI wasn't arguing for that, that road leads to gizmodo and TMZ. I'm talking purely about how the content is presented, and within that there is still room for hierarchy and emphasis, but what the NYT has produced is a muddy incoherent mess.
- sd8f9iu 13y agoWhat road are you talking about that leads to Gizmodo and TMZ? The one I described (ranking by upvotes) is used by HN and Reddit. And if not the ranking, what part of HN, Reddit, etc. are you praising over NYT? Do you like just the listing, without the ranking? I think the latter follows from the former. I don't like listing, because it orders articles and artificially gives the higher up ones more importance. NYT headlines instead assign things to levels and categories, based on page location and headline size. Also, in many of the sub-sections, news is organized roughly as its added (newest-oldest), and its assumed that it's important enough to read if it's in the NYT. Or do you just like the plain text presentation? Fair enough, but I like having more context on the home page. It may seem messy at first, but as a long-time reader, I love the NYT site for its rich and informational presentation (and content).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ghc 13y agoI'm underwhelmed. They should have hired the firm that did http://globe.com http://globe.com . I'm actually puzzled they didn't considering their ownership of the Globe at the time of that redesign.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- babby 13y agoThe design is overall asthetically pleasing. I just can't fucking take this trend of fixed bars molesting my vertical resolution and screwing with my habitual behavior of scanning from the top of the page down as I scroll. This site's top bar on single pages is so edgy that it's not even at the very top (a concept I've at least gotten acclimated to) and manages to blend into the actual article content due to low contrast. Please just stop doing this, everyone! We do not need a bar following us everywhere by default. As long as it doesn't cause render lag, fixed elements are fine when they're small buttony icons that expand. At least they've gotten the snap-back right. Some sites, when scrolled to the top, do this awkward infuriating stuttery clip-in nonsense where the scroll position changes as the menu fits back into the content. Just stop.
- Wilduck 13y agoI agree totally. This trend is infuriating. When I have to read an article on the site with a top bar I often go into the developer tools and delete that node from the DOM. There are sites that make even that measure impossible, like gmail, which is even more infuriating. I use a small screen most of the time, and it sometimes seems like the designers of these sites have never looked at their website on a monitor smaller than 30 inches. If it's so important that I be easily able to reach some navigation, put a tiny, unobtrusive, go-to-the-top button in a fixed element off to the side which will pop me back up to the nav bar.
- masterleep 13y agoTotally agree. Fixed position menu bars are ghastly - especially ones that animate in.
- asimov42 13y agoObligatory link to the the skimmer: http://www.nytimes.com/skimmer/?pagewanted=all#/Top+News http://www.nytimes.com/skimmer/?pagewanted=all#/Top+News
- mmuro 13y agoNot even attempting to be responsive?
- fderp 13y agoNot responsive.... why even bother redesigning today with a separate mobile subdomain?
- talmand 13y agoResponsive is not always the proper solution.
- Touche 13y agoThis is a really good redesign, and I don't want to be negative, but position: fixed should never be used on articles.
- 0A0D66 13y ago#000000 on all the text is quite aggressive isn't it?
- webwanderings 13y ago10 ghostery items and 23 Ads. Nice.
- moeedm 13y agoLooks great.
- count 13y agoWhy in the world would I want to add a web page to notification center, just by visiting the front page? That's SUPER obnoxious.
- Tepix 13y agoThe homepage is too wide to fit on a MacBook Air 11" (1368 pixels wide). It's kind of annoying having to scroll a bit horizontally. The article pages are great.
- philip1209 13y agoThe italicized headlines on the homepage look odd.
- ollysb 13y agoThe design for the page that they use to introduce the design seems vastly better than the actual redesign http://www.nytimes.com/redesign/ http://www.nytimes.com/redesign/
- brianstorms 13y agoI like the new design, especially the more iPad-friendly article pages. But what I am most happy about with the new design is that the NYT didn't break the backdoor into reading any article behind the paywall, if you're not a subscriber. If you run into the paywall that blocks your reading an article, just fire up whatever Twitter app you use (I use Echofon), type the text of the article's headline into the search, search for it, you'll find tons of results almost always, and just click on one of those links. Presto, you're now reading the article free and clear. TL;DR If you arrive at a NYT article via a shared social link, you can bypass the subscription paywall.
- donkeyponcho 13y agoThere's a browser extension called Gorbachev that makes this a lot easier. For Chrome: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/gorbachev/mfojdgdehneodbdffllmjmmklcojacoj?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/gorbachev/mfojdgde... For Safari: https://github.com/matthewleon/gorbachev-safari https://github.com/matthewleon/gorbachev-safari
- nnethercote 13y agoUse private browsing/incognito mode. Much easier.
- cynwoody 13y agoUsing Chrome, I configured nytimes.com cookies to "Clear on exit" from each browser session. Since I restart my browser at least once a day, and I only land on the New York Times as a result of links, I never hit the monthly limit of 10 free articles. Open Settings, search for "content settings", click the Manage exceptions button, and add one for [*.]nytimes.com.
- nnethercote 13y agoThe best thing is having the entire article on a single page. No more clicking through to see the second (or third, or fourth...) part, yay.
- joshnyc2011 13y agoThe NYT redesign is a failure, on the public editor column's comments section 21 people liked the new design while over 700 people are complaining: Navigation. layout, fonts and accessibility are all hindering subscribers use of the site.