20 ms·
The $200 Billion Rip-Off: Our broadband future was stolen (2007)
- msandford 13y agoI remember reading this years ago. It's just as sad today as it was back then.
- baddox 13y agoJust remember to resist the urge to think of this as corporations stealing money from the government. This is government stealing money from citizens.
- hbags 13y agoAbsolutely. Corporations do nothing but good. They bear no responsibility for their purposeful misuse of the funds. And government does nothing but bad. Swear on your stack of Ayn Rand books that the world would be better if we had more corporations, because they are perfectly ethical and never screw anybody over. Yes, that's right. Never blame the con artists^W^Wcorporations who didn't do what they promised. Instead blame the government for trusting them.
- chevas 13y agoCorporations can be evil, but if 5 corporations competed for consumer dollars, then there would be a lot less screwage happening to consumers. Government laws that disallow competition are the first things that need to change. Government should be there to protect consumers from price fixing, and that's just about it.
- ihsw 13y agoYou're taking what he said and swinging it so fully in the opposite direction it makes you look as crazy as him. Can't we both agree that corporations and governments abuse their power as a matter of fact?
- corin_ 13y agoWhy not tone down even more to get to the fact that not only can they both abuse their power, but they can both not do so too. Not all politicians and corporations are created equal.
- hbags 13y agoCan't we both agree that corporations and governments abuse their power as a matter of fact? All people and institutions that have power sometimes abuse the power. Sometimes the abuse is knowing, sometimes it's accidental. This is not terribly interesting. You're taking what he said and swinging it so fully in the opposite direction it makes you look as crazy as him. In my defense, I wasn't commanding the HN audience to place 100% of the blame on one party or another. I was just illustrating how insanely idiotic it was for OP to command us to absolve the corporations of their sins, and instead place 100% of the blame on the government.
- hoilogoi 13y agoI enjoy HN comments for their tempered, rational thought. I don't think diminutive hyperbole benefits your position here.
- hbags 13y agoFor future reference: there is a small downward facing arrow that can succinctly express your opinion.
- baddox 13y agoI made no generalizations. My claim was about this specific case, and I stand by it. I have never read or owned an Ayn Rand book.
- mzr 13y agoI have absolutely no problem with paying money to the government so damn near everybody can get decent internet service if they want it. Corporations have shown over and over that they are unwilling and actively hostile towards that idea. The only corporation that I have seen upend that view is Google. Whether competition from private enterprise, or government these companies scream that it is unfair. No, it isn't.
- smutticus 13y agoThere's very little difference between corporations and government these days. So it doesn't really matter what we call the people stealing from the citizenry. Corporations shower politicians with gifts, jobs and campaign contributions, which in most other countries would just be called bribery. The purpose of this from the corporation's viewpoint is to align the interest of the politician to that of the corporation. And once their interests are aligned they operate in concert. So as this process accelerates the border between government and corporation becomes less and less clear.
- superuser 13y agoYes. Less government, more free market. The government should be fighting anti-competitive behavior not granting monopolies. There is no reason for a government sanctioned monopoly in ANY market...it's just a breeding ground for corruption.
- catmanjan 13y agoI'm Australian, am I to understand that our internet quality and distribution is only just approaching what the American's had in 2007? WTF!? I wish poor internet connection was something I could really get upset about, but I guess the rest of my life is a lot better than most around the world.
- grecy 13y agoAs an Australian that lived in America for a long time, trust me when I say life in Australia with crappy internet is significantly better than life in America with fast internet. You don't want to live there, trust me.
- MichaelApproved 13y agoYou've got to be more specific when you say "there" or at least mention what you found wrong. The US is a large country with vast differences between the cities. Your experience in one area could be dramatically different from another area in the US.
- michaelochurch 13y agoHe might have experienced our healthcare. Even if he had insurance, our system is a clusterfuck that makes everyone worse upon contact. Or, he might be older than 30 and therefore not willing to deal with the puny two-week vacation allotment that is still socially acceptable from US employers. Or, he might have children who will have to be educated someday, and see that a system that combines astronomical tuition plus fickle nonacademic factors in admissions ("extracurricular" criteria designed to give the privileged a huge advantage) is not good for their future. Or, he might have lived in the Red States and be gay. Or, pardon the "he", she might be a woman. Or transgender.
- ryanSrich 13y ago> He might have experienced our healthcare. Even if he had insurance, our system is a clusterfuck that makes everyone worse upon contact. I'm not disagreeing with you I just need help understanding. I get a job. My job offers health insurance coverage, which most do now. I pay a small fee (<$200) per month to get the coverage. If I get hurt I go to a doctor and the insurance covers the costs in full, so long as they accept that insurance. How is this not ideal? What would be better for the tax payer? > Or, he might be older than 30 and therefore not willing to deal with the puny two-week vacation allotment that is still socially acceptable from US employers. Outside of tech. I've found within the industry most employers have a flexible vacation policy. > Or, he might have children who will have to be educated someday, and see that a system that combines astronomical tuition plus fickle nonacademic factors in admissions ("extracurricular" criteria designed to give the privileged a huge advantage) is not good for their future. Can't argue with this one. I wholeheartedly agree. > Or, he might have lived in the Red States and be gay. Or, pardon the "he", she might be a woman. Or transgender. Eh. I'd say this is more based on location within a state. Go to Austin Texas and you'll have a better time than many other states that are "blue".
- JoshTriplett 13y ago> Then there were regulatory problems as the FCC tried to control deployment centrally while states and cities tended to view video dial tone as just another cable company to be taxed and regulated. That seems like the most egregious thing in the article: treating Internet-based video delivery as a cable company. The concept of local cable franchise monopolies is ridiculous enough to begin with, and the only possible justification hinges on not wanting to have multiple sets of cables wired everywhere. Content delivered over the Internet completely eliminates that justification, leaving no possible rationale for making such services subject to franchise regulations.
- 001sky 13y agoThey should be subject to regulation; they should not be granted monopolies. These are two entirely different concepts. The current system grants them monopolies, and fails to regulate them appropriately. This is exactly the wrong way round. But this is the problem with politicians: monopoly provides concentration of cash, and this can be tapped into far more efficiently from the perspective of political exploitation. Its much easier to garner a donation from a rich individual with concentrated cash, than many individuals. Likewise, its much easier tax a few firms or not with tax {X} in return for special favours. Its much harder to garner the support of the diffuse and middle classes (not to mention, even get/keep their attention). So, this is sort of a classic case of political economy in the instrumental sense...on both sides.
- rhizome 13y agoActually, campaigns nowadays run on the concept of "bundlers," who are rich people who act as a funnel for their rich friends. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_in_the_United_States#Bundling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_in_the_United_...
- Bud 13y agoYou mean they used to, until the limits on secret donations from one rich guy were gotten rid of.
- MBCook 13y ago[2007]
- huhalu 13y agohttp://www.theconnectivist.com/2013/11/the-worlds-cheapest-and-most-expensive-internet/ http://www.theconnectivist.com/2013/11/the-worlds-cheapest-a... Internet cost as part of income is more accurate
- maaku 13y agoWhy? The cost of providing Internet service has very little to do with wage differences.
- 9999 13y agoMore accurate than what? Cringely's claim is that various subsidies and tax breaks, totaling 200 billion dollars, were given to telco operators with the understanding that a 45 mbps symmetrical connection would be developed and offered to end users. The companies received those subsidies and tax breaks, but didn't develop the system they claimed they would develop and instead built a system that is nearly 27 times slower (I use the term built loosely there since the ADSL network sits on top of the same old copper wire infrastructure that has existed for decades and decades).
- TruthElixirX 13y agoAm I the only one who is pretty content with my internet service? Oklahoma City metro area. 25 Mbps down / 3 up for 45 a month. I feel like I get my money's worth.
- andyl 13y agoMy broadband service is terrible. Far to expensive, it is slow and drops packets. And the competitive environment sucks. Comcast and Regulators: go to hell. I'll vote for any politician who is interested in improving the situation.
- gametheoretic 13y agoWe've tallied the votes, and it turns out it didn't matter who you voted for. Sorry. We hope it felt, for a fleeting moment, like you had influence over anything outside your immediate surroundings.
- dmix 13y agoI see the old 'representative democracy' fallacy is still quite prevalent in broadband talks. Maybe another decade of complaining on the internet might do it?
- gametheoretic 13y agoHEY BUDDY, if you don't think the country has come a long way from where it was in 2004, then I just don't know what to say to you.
- marincounty 13y agoI don't understand how Comcast charges differnt rates for internet speeds, but at around 5:30 p.m., when people settling in after a hard day of work--the rate is reduced? My hope is Comcast is eventually split up by the government.
- gametheoretic 13y agoDo you think the government would rather deal with more ISPs or fewer, insofar as surveillance is concerned?
- rralian 13y ago
- ams6110 13y agoWe need to remove the local legal monopoly protection granted to cable operators and telcos.
- zw123456 13y agoI have tried posting this idea a couple of times before and have been roundly scolded, but oh well, here goes again. I think... that readers of this forum are ideally equipped to find a way around this problem. What I mean to say is that it is universally felt by everyone that they hate their broadband provider, phone company etc. Why can't we, the tech community come up with a competing technology? I know many have tried to do "open source" types of mesh wifi networks, but I think something more robust than that is needed. Everyone agrees current companies are leaving their customers unsatisfied, hence there must be an opportunity there for someone clever enough to come up with a good alternative.
- warfangle 13y agoI wonder if an automatic peering arrangement could be built on top of a mesh infrastructure, to give incentive for running more robust nodes (not just for in-network traffic, but for uplink to the internet at large).
- zw123456 13y agoInteresting. I was thinking about some of the open source implementations of LTE that have been posted here but maybe the wifi mesh approach needs tweaking. Also, from a business perspective, I think it would be cool if there was a way to make it sort of like a "co-op" so people who host hot spots or base stations would get some profit sharing or something?
- triangleman 13y agoFON (https://corp.fon.com/en https://corp.fon.com/en) tried to make this work, I'm sure there were other attempts.
- icebraining 13y agoIt's not a mesh network, so it doesn't divorce itself from the last mile carriers.
- 13y ago
- paul_f 13y agowhat's the tl;dr please?
- dijit 13y agoISP's took lots of money to build better internets, then told politicians that the current set up is what they asked for.
- ojbyrne 13y agoThe first comment on the page sums it up: "America is the only country in the world where BRIBERY is legalized and stupidly called lobbying."
- betenoire 13y agoI laughed, but to be clear, of course that's not true.
- gcb0 13y agoand rather uninformed. lobbying may not be as efficient elsewhere as it is here, but it exists everywhere.
- rational_indian 13y ago>but it exists everywhere But it's not legal.
- Moru 13y agoLobbying is legal in the EU too. The organisation is one of the bigger employers in the EU. It's just not so known as in the US.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoLobbying <> bribery. There's a difference between buying a politician diner and talking to them and writing a big fat check.
- brownbat 13y agoIt took fierce competition to even get broadband companies to advertise what they are offering. I had to deal with a very small local monopoly in Western Maryland that just advertised "faster than dial up," had typical pings of over 200. It was thick on the local board, had a deal with local government as the sole authorized supplier in the county. Now I'm in a different part of the country, can get FiOS, but while Verizon's service always delivers over 50 Mbps on speedtest sites, it often chokes on Youtube or Netflix. When that happens, there's no simple way to determine if it's the provider or some random provisioner in the middle. This is the future of getting screwed by telecoms: worthless metrics and plausible deniability for service degradation. I happened to get a deal by calling all the providers in the area, then playing their offers off of each other. I recommend everyone does this every few months. But the fact that was so easy doesn't really make me feel very comfortable. If they can haggle, it just signals how much rent they're charging from all the unwary customers.
- gcb0 13y agolol at calling all the providers. the free market fails if left alone, under shady regulations it is almost a joke. i found a aDSL number for ATT that was not advertised (and you reached a person on the first minute!) that was the result of some obscure regulation that they had to provide dsl without charging for a phone line if so i wanted. it was a very good service. as i was next door to their trunk. i moved, less than 20miles, but another city. called att to transfer service, the rep read something and the burst out a sad "ah, sorry, this is verizon territory". and that is exactly what i get here. verizon. nothing else. the 2nd or 3rd biggest city in los angeles, and i can choose, verizon.
- mindslight 13y agoSonic.net provides their "Fusion DSL" service in LA through resellers. It's worth to check if you are in the service area at http://www.dslextreme.com/ http://www.dslextreme.com/ . I ended up signing up through another company, Omsoft, because they were very down to earth. Yeah, the advertised throughput is a bit slower being ADSL2+, especially on the upload (although you can bond two channels for a simple twice the cost. and if you really need upload, inquire to see if they've got "Annex M" support yet). But it's fast enough, very predictable, and you won't be giving your money to assholes. Also FWIW, Speakeasy is also still around, they've just renamed to Megapath and raised their rates a bit.
- knodi 13y agoNothing will change until we get to the root cause. Get corporate money out of politics. Its really sad to tell you the truth.
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoMy Charter High Speed internet went from $60 to $40 a month on the spot just by threatening to leave them and go with AT&T U-Verse. And I did it all through their chat with a sales rep online without calling anyone. They even gave me a free cable modem. Moral of the Story: Shop around and make threats, you are the customer they need you and your money. They'd rather lose $20 a month than lose $40 so you can almost always talk the prices down.
- dangrossman 13y agoThat's because you have two options to choose between. Many have none, so it's either pay the price or have no home internet. Where the only choices are Comcast and Verizon, which offer near-identical packages and pricing in most markets, Comcast's retention department no longer negotiates. If you threaten to switch, they'll tell you to go ahead, and send a door-to-door sales rep to your home every 6 months.
- amjaeger 13y agofunny how this article came back today, I'm visiting my grandma, she has an ipad as her computer (first successful adoption of a computer for her btw, she previously had bought 2 computers and didn't take to either one) and I'm looking at her internet speeds and I can't deal with it. She is paying $28 for 3 mbps (max) speeds. It's dsl from at&t. I ran a speed test and she only gets about .5 mbps. I get about 300mbps(when plugged into ethernet) when I'm at school...
- jmspring 13y agoIn the bay area, if you can get our bandwidth needs at the level you need from them, I highly recommend Sonic.Net. They seem to be trying to do the right thing/build infrastructure/and bring better broadband speeds to people in the bay area. I recently left them to go from DSL to go to Wireless w/ a local reseller of some of Sonic's service. I gave up a few static IPs to get 20Mbps symmetric. I'm one of those where upload is just as important as down. Price is reasonable given I could get rid of my land line and some other costs.
- kevinalexbrown 13y agoAnyone who comes up with a reasonable way of bypassing the natural local monopolies of cable companies is going to make a fortune. I would think dense wireless networks in urban areas could work. I'm not an expert, and would be interested in hearing from one, but I imagine that wireless networks could benefit from algorithmic advances in a way that might be more difficult in traditional copper/fiber networks. If you gave me (someone with very little wireless experience but used to be a cable guy) carte blanche, here's what I would investigate: Several routers in an urban area which require minimal installation and can be mass-produced and immediately interchanged - think roof access, and could be turned on and off remotely, maybe battery operated, flowing to relatively few fiber hubs. Infrastructure advantages: Network algorithms have come a long way, and the ability to dynamically add or scale nodes as needed could have great performance/cost balances that aren't possible with fixed nodes. And upgrades do not require new lines, just more and better routers. If a router dies, replace, and send the old one to a shop somewhere inexpensive. No midnight service restoration pay. Customer advantages: I connect to wifi the same way I do right now. Zero home installation (google Comcast horror stories if you need imagery). If I were to start, I would do it in an urban area with a landowner that had a monopoly. Hyde Park, Chicago is like that. There are basically two landowners: University of Chicago and Mac Apartments. You have to make one community love you to pieces before branching out, and that would require a lot of cooperation. Of course a danger here is if Mac suddenly decides that they hate you and removes access privileges. But if that worked, and you got more funding to expand, imagine the word of mouth: "Here's how installation works: it's a wifi network and you connect to it". A la "it's a folder, and it syncs" dropbox. Presumably something like this has been tried before, but that's true of many things that end up working (like search engines or social networks).
- thundara 13y ago> I would think dense wireless networks in urban areas could work You've basically described mesh networks. There are a number in cities across America, but are normally run by enthusiasts. The trouble is, in dense urban environments, there's a lot of noise to overcome, and if you don't work around that, your network will fall apart. Especially a problem with the coming 802.11ac routers which will crowd up the 5 GHz band that is current the target for backbone links in the wireless networks.
- zurn 13y agoThis is not really an American problem. In nearly all developed countries the delivered broadband "moore's law" has been abysmal compared to what technology allows. In an apartment building the cost of per apartment gigabit ethernet with a couple of trunked 10 gig ports for last mile would be very very low. (And we'd have much faster tech for same money, but development stalled due to lack of deployment - 10 gig ethernet is what 12 years old now?)
- dubcanada 13y agoIt's mostly a North American and maybe Australia thing tbh. Europe and Northern Europe and most of Asia/Africa is significantly better then NA.
- fulafel 13y agoIt's bad in Europe too, you get just ADSL2 or bad cable in cities for the most part. I'd say ADSL2 worse for >90% of the population and improvement is very slow. ref: http://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2013/07/average-global-internet-speeds-climb-to-3-1mbps-as-uk-tops-7-9mbps.html http://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2013/07/average-global-... (also shows that US bandwidths are better than Europe on average)
- EEGuy 13y agoI'm so glad the concept of "dial tone", video or otherwise, never crossed the demand for and rollout of content-neutral, flat-rate-billed, backbone-peering-supported Internet Service. Having worked in voice telecom billing for 11 years, it is my observation that phone companies adore detail billing. Imagine an ISP bill which details all the websites you visit, and bills each visit according to some value the phone company might opaquely ascribe. It might have gone that way with a thankfully unimplemented evolution of the amorphous notion of "video dial tone". Had this $200 billion boondoggle actually given us megabit access, then it would be... access to what, exactly? I can't imagine phone companies providing access to the flat-rate, always on, servers-allowed, content-neutral Internet we have now, no matter the bit rate. The thought of all phone companies collectively coming up with a service like Netflix is, to me, as unimaginable as the thought of those same phone companies coming up with the iPhone. Yes, $200 billion is a shameful waste of ratepayer funds and a regulatory failure. But thankfully, it neither collared nor crossed with the Internet. In my opinion, separation of ownership of content (and applications, and platforms, and end users) from the common carriers who own some of the "plumbing" which connects routers to routers to routers becomes fundamental to a free Internet. (Edits for grammar, clarity, tone)
- Aloha 13y agoPacBell had built one of these next gen networks, it was even in limited deployments, as soon as SBC bought them, they killed it. It was an HFC network (hybrid fiber/coax)and was a commercial ready product. I'm not in a position to find citations right now, but if you google Pacific Bell and Hybrid Fiber Coax, you'll find the cites.
- lukateake 13y agoLast-Mile solution: blimps.