5 ms·
I'm wondering: where is the new George Orwell? Why aren't all writers writing about this? Clearly we need a new 1984, because we didn't learn anything from the
by mcv 13y ago
I'm wondering: where is the new George Orwell? Why aren't all writers writing about this? Clearly we need a new 1984, because we didn't learn anything from the original.
- simias 13y agoI doubt a book would make much difference. Something with more mass appeal, like a movie or TV show maybe. But it's still a long shot IMHO. Or you know, we could vote those people out of office. We keep bashing those clueless politicians but we did put them here in the first place. We don't even have the excuse of dictatorship. This tendency around these parts to look for technical solutions (tor, bitcoin, etc...) for political problems is very saddening. Assuming most of the readers of HN come from democratic countries, we shouldn't have to fear our government. No amount of openSSL will fix that problem.
- Ntrails 13y agoMaybe the next series of Black Mirror will have something that covers these things more specifically? I think it's covered some very interesting concepts already.
- seabee 13y agoWhat more do you think can be said that the last episode of Black Mirror (fictional character as MP) didn't say?
- shawabawa3 13y ago> Or you know, we could vote those people out of office. We keep bashing those clueless politicians but we did put them here in the first place. We don't even have the excuse of dictatorship. The sad truth is that politics is basically a marketing game. Whoever pours the most money into ads and campaigning has the best chance of winning [1]. There aren't enough people who care enough to do their own research to make a real difference [1] http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2010/dec/02/conservatives-spent-twice-labour-election-campaign - In the last general election the results mirrored marketing budgets.
- triplesec 13y agoThe old joke: "Don't vote, it only encourages them" has been on the wall of London's Anarchist Bookshop for years. Sadly, the false dichotomy of American politics, the corrupt buying of candidates and parties there and in most places, a lack of desire of anyone who wants to be a politician to rock any boat and make lasting structural change means that sometimes you need to do more than just play the fixed game with already loaded dice, where the prize doesn't really do much for you anyway. I'm working on several strategies in this space. Perhaps we should gather some constructive conspirators. See, that sounds jailworthy already, even though it's in the spirit of opening up debate, discourse and emancipation...
- mcv 13y ago> The old joke: "Don't vote, it only encourages them" Problem is: if you don't vote, you're certain not to get the candidate you want. You're basically accepting their reign. Better to stubbornly vote for a small candidate who doesn't really have a chance. If enough people do that, he might accidentally get elected.
- stevejones 13y agoThis is why the established powers are fervently against proportional representation.
- collyw 13y ago>If enough people do that, he might accidentally get elected. Alternatively, if no one voted, the corrupt bastards couldn't legitimately claim power. This is a serious flaw in our current implementation of "democracy". If you don't vote for the two /three main parties (who are all neocons anyway), you are effectively ignored. People argue vote, or not to vote, but in the end whatever either of these options will be ignored.
- triplesec 13y agoIn some elections, inquorate elections do not stand, and a re-election is required. This would be a good idea, but is unlikely to happen. In some places (notably Australia) government feels legitimated by compulsory voting (even fr expats). I don't know the sanctions for not voting, but voting turnout there is high.
- nsns 13y agoBrazil? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brazil_%281985_film%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brazil_%281985_film%29)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mogrim 13y ago> Or you know, we could vote those people out of office. We keep bashing those clueless politicians but we did put them here in the first place. We don't even have the excuse of dictatorship. Yeah, but do you really think Labour would be any better? Both parties seem so scared of the Mail and the Telegraph that they'll do anything to look tough on crime. Thinking about it, is this the inevitable result of an aging population?
- simias 13y agoI'm not from the UK, I was talking in general. It's terrible that we come to consider the government the enemy when we're the one who are supposed to put them here.
- eponeponepon 13y agoHow sad that we've reached a stage in Britain where one can talk about "both parties", and not be misrepresenting the situation.
- mcv 13y agoThe problem with the UK is that it now has 3 major conservative parties. But aren't there smaller parties you can vote for? And if there aren't any, surely you can start a new party? Find enough people who agree with you.
- alinajaf 13y agoCharles Stross (cstross on HN), Cory Doctorow and Ken MacLeod off the top of my head. They're nowhere near as prophetic as George Orwell as modern governments are becoming totalitarian police states too quickly to keep up with.
- praptak 13y agoMax Barry: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jennifer_Government http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jennifer_Government
- TausAmmer 13y agoThe Departure (Owner Trilogy) Bright bright future :D
- return0 13y agoNot many are willing to go against the atomistic monoculture, as it would break many liberal ideals held since the enlightenment. There is a case against nanny-state policies in Nassim Taleb's Antifragile, but not sure if it's close to what you mean.
- Cthulhu_ 13y agoidk, what I'm reading in this article is that it's basically going back in time, i.e. before 1984 where the rich could afford having gated communities.
- andyjohnson0 13y agoOrwell's thoughts and writing were shaped by his experiences of the British public school [1] system, serving in the colonial police service, living as a homeless person in Paris and London, fighting on the republican side in the Spanish civil war, and (late in his life) seeing how the second world war played-out. These experiences honed his conscience and anger. It's hard to imagine people who have lived similar lives now (maybe a minimum-wage warehouse worker from South London who went to fight with the rebels in Syria and came home wounded) believing that society can be changed in useful ways by writing fiction. And if they did, and they became a threat to power, the daily mail would probably destroy them fairly quickly. Different times. [1] In the UK, "public schools" are mostly what everyone else on the planet calls private schools. Edit: s/tramp/homeless person/
- kroger 13y agoJust to clarify to our American friends, in the UK "tramp" means homeless, not prostitute ;-)
- kidmenot 13y agoThanks, I'm Italian, but I was really wondering why one would call Orwell a "tramp" :)
- andyjohnson0 13y agoThanks - I've edited to clarify. I originally used the word "tramp" because (from memory) that was the word Orwell used to describe himself in Down and out in Paris and London; corresponding to the meaning described at [1]. I was aware that it is considered pejorative, but not the different meaning in US English. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tramp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tramp
- spurgu 13y agoTo further clarify, a tramp is someone who travels around but works only if/when he has to, a hobo is someone who travels around mainly looking for work and a bum is someone who does neither.
- triplesec 13y agoThere's one coming this year. Can't necessarily claim Orwell's talent, but having taught with a professor who made this very point a couple of years back, I've been working on a sociopolitical novel on this specific topic (with bells on) since then on and off and now it's getting into shape. The autumn's events (Brand v newsnight, NSA) have for me been very encouraging in demonstrating that I've not just been barking up my own tree.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoI'm not sure the fault lies with Orwell rather than with us. Orwell showed us a world where rampant socialism, statism, lack of individual liberties, twisting of language for political means, and widespread unaccountable surveillance led to a horrific dystopia. People read the book and people agreed that it was something best to be avoided. But at every opportunity people have flinched away from the example of 1984. People have said "oh, but this socialism is the good kind, it's different", they said "this statism isn't that kind of statistm", and "it's only a small limitation of liberty in exchange for valuable improvements in safety", and "these changes to language are in service to a greater good", and so on, and so on. Then we get to widespread, unaccountable surveillance by the state and suddenly everyone starts shouting about 1984 and wondering how things could possibly have gotten so bad without anyone noticing. Lots of people have been noticing, but even more people have been ignoring, or excusing.
- makomk 13y agoThat's a very creative interpretation of Orwell's work. You do realise that he was very much a socialist and that much of his work was inspired by his socialism, right?
- 178 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cory_Doctorow http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cory_Doctorow