8 ms·
That graph is a bit of a lie. Student debt is summed over all students, so it grows if the student population grows (which it has; 2013 saw a decline, but that
by Someone 13y ago
That graph is a bit of a lie. Student debt is summed over all students, so it grows if the student population grows (which it has; 2013 saw a decline, but that will not factor much in this data yet). It also integrates over many years. That makes the total debt look more threatening.
It would be more reasonable to show a per-year, per student debt (people graduating in year X had an average debt of $Y; people leaving without graduating had an average debt of $Z)
Such a graph probably still looks bad (median income has dropped, after all), but it will be more informative.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- afterburner 13y agoI agree; maybe this graph is a little better: http://www.npr.org/news/graphics/2011/05/gr-avg-student-debt-300.gif http://www.npr.org/news/graphics/2011/05/gr-avg-student-debt... (from http://www.npr.org/2011/05/16/136214779/college-student-debt-grows-is-it-worth-it http://www.npr.org/2011/05/16/136214779/college-student-debt... ) EDIT: Or this maybe: http://www.worldwidehippies.com/2011/08/29/tax-breaks-for-rich-has-lit-the-fuse-on-explosive-student-debt/ http://www.worldwidehippies.com/2011/08/29/tax-breaks-for-ri... (just doing an image search for student debt history)
- sjbach 13y agoThe NPR chart may also be misleading; it's unclear from the notes. There was ~60% inflation between 1992 and 2011.
- hdevalence 13y agoNote also that income is not shown on a zero-indexed scale, exaggerating its decline.
- frandroid 13y agoThe scale is in 2012 dollars. That's indexed.
- ianferrel 13y agozero-indexed means that the axis of the graph starts at 0.
- dredmorbius 13y agoIndexed and zero-based aren't the same. You're avoiding the distortion of inflation, but not that of starting the graph above the x axis.
- kaloyan 13y agoAgreed, comparing a median to a total is misleading. Even if it were an average-to-average comparison, it would not tell the entire story. There are more factors that determine one's debt situation in addition to money owned and money made. A much more telling graph would be monthly student loan payment -- at the prevailing interest rate and terms -- to disposable income. I imagine it would still be showing a worrying trend but, likely, not as bad as the original graph.
- spikels 13y agoWe can argue about the details but the underlying story is accurate: the cost of higher education has gone up a lot while the income of college graduates has been flat or declined slightly. This is not news[1a][1b]. The big question is will collage graduate wages rise in the future so that these debts become manageable - many are concerned they won't and these debts will consume many years of their earnings. And nobody is predicting college inflation will decline anytime soon so college may be even less affordable in the future. BTW - Undergraduate and graduate enrollment was up only about 25% (flat since 2010)[2] while total student debt tripled since 2003. Average student debt probably nearly doubled since 2003 (up 58% 2005-2012[3] do the math to estimate 2003-2013 - up about 92%). [1a] http://www.businessweek.com/the_thread/economicsunbound/archives/2009/09/earnings_of_you.html http://www.businessweek.com/the_thread/economicsunbound/arch... [1b] http://theatlantic.tumblr.com/post/24693728700/dont-fall-for-this-misleading-graph-about-college http://theatlantic.tumblr.com/post/24693728700/dont-fall-for... [2] http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2013/09/03/number-of-students-enrolled-in-college-drops/ http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2013/09/03/number-of-students... [3] http://www.forbes.com/sites/halahtouryalai/2013/01/29/more-evidence-on-the-student-debt-crisis-average-grads-loan-jumps-to-27000/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/halahtouryalai/2013/01/29/more-e...
- cperciva 13y agothe income of college graduates has been flat or declined slightly Except that's not exactly true either. The average income of newly minted college graduates has been flat or declining, but the set which is being averaged is expanding -- and expanding downwards. Unless you think that college education is the sole determinant of income, it is unreasonable to compare the "average" college graduate from 30 years ago against the "average" college graduate today -- who would very likely not have been admitted to college 30 years ago. The same fallacy is applied in the opposite direction by colleges who are seeking to increase their student numbers: "The average graduate earns $X more than the average non-graduate." True, but it ignores the fact that the average graduate is quite different from the marginal graduate.
- spikels 13y agoGood points! There must be a law of diminishing returns in education just like in almost everything else. As the opportunities to get more education have greatly expanded, the quality of both the students and that education have probably suffered. This at least partially explains the decline in the average income of college graduates. While we are probably better off as a society overall, it does mean the net benefit of education is narrowing. And the margin is where we should focus. A basic law of decision making (in economics, business, public policy, engineering) is to always look at the marginal impact of decisions as that is where the impact will be. Unfortunately this analysis is very difficult in this case (forecasts, discounting, preferences, controls) and the results will not be very comforting: for some people, some subjects and some professions the costs will not be justified by future earnings. I don't see our society rationally acting on this kind of information. So the trend will continue or even exacerbated with more lending and subsidies. This is similar to the problems we have dealing with healthcare or global warming. However the cost of college has increased by about 7% a year inflation-adjusted for over 30 years. This doubles the real cost every decade! Meanwhile median incomes of college graduates have been flat or declining since 2000. This clearly cannot go on forever and something that can't go on forever won't. But it is not clear to me how this will end. My hope is that technology like MOOCs can bring down the cost of education and that incomes increase as the benefits of both that education and globalization are finally realized. Then we would have both a better educated and richer society. Alternatively more people may decide higher eduction is simply not worth it - probably resulting in negative outcomes for some. Or something more messy such as mass loan defaults and university bankruptcies resulting in even more negative outcomes. This may take a vey long time to fully play out.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoProbably the right quantity for the graph would be CPI for education: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CUSR0000SAE1 http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CUSR0000SAE1
- Alex3917 13y agoTotal debt per student has substantially increased, and the number of students taking out debt has substantially increased. But actual monthly student loan payments for students with debt are only nominally higher, and perhaps largely due to jobs paying less: "In 2009 65.6% of first-time bachelor's degree recipients took out student loans, compared with 49.3% in 1994. Of those who borrowed, the cumulative amount borrowed was $24,700 in 2009, as compared with $14,700 (2009 dollars) in 1994. [...] Among first-time bachelor's degree recipients with loans and who were employed and repaying their loans 1 year after bachelor's degree receipt, the average monthly loan repayments were 13.1% of monthly salary in 2009, as compared with 11.1% in 1994. The median monthly loan repayments were 8.0% in 2009, as compared with 6.8% in 1994. In 2009 51.7% had monthly loan repayments that were 1-8% of their monthly salary, 17.1% had monthly loan repayments that were 9-12% of their monthly salary, 11.7% had monthly loan repayments that were 13-17% of their monthly salary, and 19.4% had monthly loan repayments that were more than 17% of their monthly salary." Source: Tables 1, 6, 7: http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2013/2013156.pdf http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2013/2013156.pdf So basically the macroeconomic view wildly exaggerates the situation; while it is a problem that students with bachelors degrees are getting shitty jobs, the idea that it's impossible for students to get an education without outrageous monthly loan payments is just wrong. The people getting fucked over by college debt are mainly the ones who enroll in scam for-profit colleges, rack up hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of debt, and then don't graduate. Getting an actual bachelors degree is only nominally to moderately more expensive than it was 40 years ago. The fact that college graduates aren't well-educated enough to get good jobs is an enormous problem, but the idea that college is suddenly unaffordable because of cost increases is complete BS. Consider also: "The net TFRB (tuition/room/fees/board sticker price minus total grant aid and tax benefits) at public 4-year colleges for in-state residents increased from $7,400 in 1990-91 (2012 dollars) to $12,110 in 2012-13. At private non-profit institution the net price increased from $18,330 in 1990-91 to $23,840 in 2012-13." Source: CollegeBoard - Tuition and Fee and Room and Board Charges over Time in 2012 Dollars, 1972-73 through 2012-13, Selected Years, Table 7 - Average Net Price for Full-Time Students over Time - Public Institutions, Table 8 - Average Net Price for Full-Time Students over Time - Private Institutions "The average net tuition (tuition and fees minus all grants) in 2007-08 was $4,900 at public doctorate-granting institutions, $16,400 at private non-profit doctorate-granting institutions, and $9,200 at for-profit institutions." Source: http://nces.ed.gov/datalab/tableslibrary/viewtable.aspx?tableid=8533 http://nces.ed.gov/datalab/tableslibrary/viewtable.aspx?tabl... http://nces.ed.gov/datalab/tableslibrary/viewtable.aspx?tableid=6800 http://nces.ed.gov/datalab/tableslibrary/viewtable.aspx?tabl...
- rayiner 13y agoYou mean its a total lie, axis numbering and all.
- auggierose 13y agoIf that is really Thiel's favourite graph, then I just lost an enormous amount of respect for him because of this obvious problem of the graph.
- gum_ina_package 13y agoReally? You lost respect for this guy because he decided to present a graph that shocks readers into realizing there's a bubble in higher education?
- Estragon 13y agoIt's certainly disturbing to see someone you respect misinform people in order to advance a personal agenda.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hbags 13y agoYes! The point could've been made honestly, but Thiel used several different 'how to lie with charts and statistics' techniques instead. My respect for people naturally declines when they've gone out of their way to deceive me. This happens regardless of whether or not I agree with the goal of their deception. The Bible doesn't say 'Thou shalt only lie if it helps you further your personal agenda', it says 'Thou shalt not lie.'
- saraid216 13y ago> it says 'Thou shalt not lie.' Derailing, but I bet you it doesn't. :P
- seiji 13y agoThe goal of the stateless elite is to manipulate the masses into following them. If all it takes is a graph to convince someone "hey, this rich person is right, I should do everything they say" they see that as a very small price to pay for brainwashing.
- analog31 13y agoThe entire economy looks bad, for all workers. Median income has dropped for everybody. Household debt has increased for everybody.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoNot so sure about that. Chinese peasants seem to be doing quite a bit better these days, for example. Here's a graph for ya (stolen from elsewhere in the comments): http://cdn.static-economist.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/290-width/images/print-edition/20130601_FBC699.png http://cdn.static-economist.com/sites/default/files/imagecac...
- analog31 13y agoAh, of course. Nice call. I'd edit my post, but instead I'll leave it there to document the error. ;-) It would be interesting to know the impact of US college education on global poverty.
- aetherson 13y agoHow does "median income" drop for "everybody"? At any rate, it depends on the timescale. The upper quintile (and decile, and percentile) took a really huge hit in the 2008 recession, but before and since that, they've been doing a lot better than the middle deciles.
- saraid216 13y ago> How does "median income" drop for "everybody"? I believe the attempted claim is that "for these various populations that constitute 'everybody', their median income has dropped in each population". So if "everybody" is these 6 guys over here ("say hi, Bob"), and you split them into 2 groups of 3 guys, and then check the median income of both groups, the claim is that both groups have a lower median income.
- ronaldx 13y agoI knew that graph was misleading, but I still missed that it was total student debt vs per capita median income. I nominate it for worst graph of the year: if you set out to make a biased graph, you couldn't do much better. Drawing such an obviously bad graph undermines the point being made, in my view.
- VikingCoder 13y agoSumming student debt is actually pretty valid - it's showing how much we as a society have invested to date.
- Someone 13y agoNot in combination with an 'average income' graph. It would be valid if it were plotted on its own or in combination with, for example, summed marginal income (the total amount of dollars those graduates made more thanks to their education == what the investment older students made brought society). Of course, that is hard/impossible to quantify and it, ideally, should be done per cohort (hard to do, as we don't even know what graduates from 2010 will make 5 years after graduation), but it would be a telling graph, I think. Another way to show the issue in a honest way would be to estimate the number of years it takes graduates to pay back their loans. Again, hard to estimate (a student with $40,000 in income probably _could_ pay back a $20,000 debt in a year, but is it reasonable to expect that?) And, of course, it would probably be very useful to see the combined distribution of (debt,income) pairs. If all students have a debt of 20k, and income of 40k, there is little to worry about. It is more likely, however, that both debts and incomes show large variations, and are only poorly correlated. The data set will both contain that dropout with a company worth millions, a trained neurosurgeon with 100+ k in debt that gets into an accident that invalidates his/her hand just before (s)he has the money to pay for insurance, and a talented, but a bit slow art student with limited commercial talent.
- kenjackson 13y agoFirst, I agree 100% with what you note above. And furthermore, showing the salary of college grads in isolation is useless. You need to show the delta between those with vs those w/o college degrees. If the salary of those without college degrees is falling more than those with college degrees then it still may be a prudent financial decision. It would also be interesting to see this broken down by school. For example, I suspect that top tier public schools end up looking a lot better than bottom tier private schools.
- randomdata 13y ago> If the salary of those without college degrees is falling more than those with college degrees then it still may be a prudent financial decision. Do note that if you look at income data a little bit closer, you will notice that people with _only_ a bachelor's degree represent roughly 20% of every income bracket, which implies there is no significance to just having a degree as it relates to income. It is only those with post-graduate degrees who see a sharp rise in the upper income brackets. However, we tend to lump them all into a "college degree" category, which allows the latter group to bring up the numbers. Unfortunately, this leads people to believe that getting any college degree is a prudent financial decision, even though the data does not back it up. It is worth looking at the numbers, for sure, but be careful out there. There are a lot of traps that are easy to overlook.
- timr 13y ago"It is only those with post-graduate degrees who see a sharp rise in the upper income brackets. However, we tend to lump them all into a "college degree" category, which allows the latter group to bring up the numbers. Unfortunately, this leads people to believe that getting any college degree is a prudent financial decision, even though the data does not back it up." Incorrect: http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.gif http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.gif
- randomdata 13y agoHow are "weekly earnings" calculated? For instance, I get all of my income in lump sums, typically two or three times per year. Does that mean my weekly earnings are $0 (or some really large number if you get me on a specific week), or do they take yearly income and divide it by the number of weeks? If the latter, why bother breaking it down to per week? Also, given that the Bureau of Labour is the source, do they include non-labour income sources? It seems pretty important, at least in my mind, to include all income sources. The average high school-only graduate will have $100K of potential to invest by the time someone in college graduates. Even with a low 3% interest rate, that is $3,000 in additional income for high school grads each year. Educational Attainment by Annual Household Income: http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Production/Cms/POLL/glqwiblfrkemnu8b6ij8aq.gif http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Prod...