6 ms·
Apple fined for price fixing
- Touche 13y agoIANAL and have always wondered why this practice is allowed in the U.S.
- pinaceae 13y agoyou mean a hardware vendor like Apple not allowing mobile carriers to set any price for its own handsets? why exactly is this bad?
- vidarh 13y agoBecause it drastically limits competition that would otherwise put a downwards pressure on the price of these devices.
- thedrbrian 13y agoSurely android phones put downward pressure on these devices?
- cbhl 13y agoThe idea is that putting a lower price floor on iOS devices differentiates them as a premium product, so that lay people aren't inclined to think that an Android Phone with a lower price is "as good as" an iPhone.
- keerthiko 13y agoI believe the understanding is that Apple is charging the carrier directly for each handset they obtain from Apple. However for market reasons, carriers normally futz with prices at their own will. Apple is preventing this, because it's in their interest to control the market price for iProducts. Not just that, but Apple is also making demands on the price window for the plans as well thus forcefully molding the kind of demographic that could be owning an iPhone.
- pinaceae 13y agoand again, why is this bad? marketing 101, price shapes the perceived value of a product. lots of examples here on HN were elasticity, etc have been discussed. locking down re-sellers should be perfectly fine.
- hahainternet 13y agoIt's bad because it's anti consumer. People in the US seem to have forgotten the fact that the whole capitalist system ostensibly exists to make things better for the consumer. I cannot understand people who champion anticompetitive actions like Apple's ebook conspiracy with stupid logic like "They can afford an extra dollar for an ebook if it makes the market fair".
- spiralpolitik 13y agoReally ? I though that capitalism was an economic system in which trade, industry and the means of production are controlled by private owners with the goal of making profits in a market economy. Clearly I need to phone up the Oxford dictionary as they say nothing about the consumer or market fairness so they must have gotten it wrong all these years...
- icebraining 13y agoThat's highly subjective. I'd claim that by being allowed to lower prices, the carriers will probably sell more iPads, putting more people in the hands of an abusive company like Apple.
- dragonwriter 13y agoThat's probably the short-term effect, however, a potential longer-term effect is hurting the iPad brand image as an elite product and status symbol, depressing demand for the particular brand. Another potential effect is less outlets selling the iPad, because if there is the potential for others to undercut the price on the same product, it becomes less valuable item in the lineup. Another potential effect is less sales through Apple's own retail channels if some other outlets are selling below Apple's price but Apple tries to maintain it, which could mean more sales but still less money going to Apple.
- octo_t 13y agocompanies are allowed to give terms stating how their products are sold. presumably the same laws that allow Apple to say that in-store displays must meet certain standards (i.e. no broken/smashed devices etc)
- michaelt 13y agoBut presumably there are some restrictions as to what those terms can be. If Apple said resellers can only sell iphones to white people that would probably not be legal.
- smackfu 13y agoIllegal for a completely different reasons though. Discrimination vs. fair trade.
- travisp 13y agoBecause if Apple said that, it would be requiring its resellers to do something they are not legally permitted to do . A contract to break a law is illegal and unenforceable. Refusing to sell phones to people because they aren't white would break the law. Selling a phone for $150, $200, or $250 is not breaking a law. So while the law may not permit Apple to require specific prices in its contracts, it's for an entirely different reason than why Apple can't tell the reseller to illegally commit racial discrimination.
- genericuser 13y agoAnd much like that Apple telling retailers they must sell at a specific price prevents those retailers from potentially competing with each other (not that they were likely to vary the price much due to the low margins left to them). The effect of Apple fixing prices like this is not different than if the retailers were colluding. Yes, the practice benefits the retailers and Apple, but its effect on consumers is commonly believed to be negative hence it is prohibited in some markets.
- bradleyland 13y agoThe article doesn't go in to great detail, but based on the information given, I would say that this specific practice is already prohibited in the U.S.. The relevant excerpt: "Apple Asia ... required carriers to obtain its permission before setting contract prices on iPhones..." This sounds like Apple Asia explicitly approved contract prices, but it depends on how you interpret "setting contract prices". If that literally means setting the price that the customer will pay, then this is not (to my knowledge) the exact mechanism used in the U.S., because the manufacturers cannot approve or deny the actual selling price. Instead, manufacturers rely on a loophole. Rather than saying, "You can't sell an iPhone for less than $199 with contract," Apple says, "You can't advertise an iPhone for less than $1xx with contract." The actual number isn't $199, as we regularly see advertisements for iPhones at discounts from retail, but not much lower. We haven't seen the agreements, so we don't know the actual terms. It may be that Apple has the ability to approve/deny all advertised prices individually. Keep in mind that a retailer is free to sell an iPhone at whatever price point they'd like. The problem is that they have no incentive to do so. Sale prices are a means to get customers in to the store. Imagine a ridiculous hypothetical situation where Walmart advertised the iPhone 5S at $99; that would draw in a lot of customers. However, their reseller terms prevent them from doing so, therefore there is far less incentive to do so. If they can't advertise the crazy sale price, then they can't draw in the number of customers required to meet their ROI requirements for an iPhone loss-leader. The inability to advertise props up the iPhone selling price. Apple doesn't do this just with iPhones, and this is not the only mechanism Apple uses to prop up their prices. We don't know the specific margins retailers make on Apple products, but everyone I know who has worked in the retail industry tells me that the margin on Apple products is much lower than every other PC manufacturer. I can't speak for mobile devices, as I don't know anyone in that industry. It's also worth noting that Apple isn't the only company who employs these practices. There are a number of "high-value" brands that support their pricing this way. Tempurpedic and Rolex come to mind immediately, but I'm certain there are many more.
- Touche 13y agoThis is exactly the type of response I was hoping to get, thank you.
- salient 13y agoThis is starting to become sort of trend with Apple.
- threeseed 13y agoIn what way ? Way too many people seemed to have rewritten the last 10 years of Apple's history. They have done a ridiculous amount of dodgy, illegal and anti-user things before, during and after Job's reign. They aren't perfect nor should any sane person expect 100K+ people to be. Just like Google, Microsoft, IBM etc.
- Moocat87 13y agoNo one should expect perfection, but I think most would expect any company with the means to follow the laws of every country they operate in, because that's their obligation. If they can't follow the law, they shouldn't be given a <$1M wrist-slap, they should be corrected. What about the Taiwanese businesses that are disadvantaged by this type of practice? Surely that's worth far more than $1M.
- icebraining 13y agoWhat about the Taiwanese businesses that benefit from this type of practice, by having less competition when selling their cheaper phones? I'm sure Acer, Asus and HTC aren't complaining that iPads aren't cheaper.
- Moocat87 13y agoThis is about contract price-fixing, not price-fixing of apple products.
- mitchty 13y agoBecome? Not really, now that they're bigger its just getting more attention. Apple has always tightly controlled prices of their product.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- leephillips 13y agoIn the living memory of many of us, Taiwan was essentially a dictatorship. Now its protection of free markets for its people exceeds that of the U.S., at least in some areas, where U.S. law tends to favor corporate interests.
- CaveTech 13y agoA dictatorship doesn't necessitate evil or corruption.
- Dylan16807 13y ago>A dictatorship doesn't necessitate evil or corruption. Still, a dictatorship implies central control, and there is quite a contrast between that and strong market-favoring. Edit: missed a word that changes tone a bit
- dublinben 13y ago>a dictatorship implies central control, and there is quite a contrast between that and strong market-favoring Not in Asia. Singapore is consistently ranked as one of the most economically free (pro-business and free market) countries in the world, yet they are essentially a one-party 'democracy.' Hong Kong is another example of an entity consistently ranked as one of the most economically free, but less democratic.
- jason_wang 13y agoTo be precise, the Republic of China was a republic government under martial law until the eighties. Today, it is as democratic a nation as the United States. More specific to your point, today, ROC has a free market economy like the U.S.
- jusben1369 13y agoI wonder if they meant to fine them the number of the beast as a way of sending a strong message.
- pliu 13y agoIf they wanted to send a message like that they would have fined them $444 000.
- eatfish 13y agoIs this for good or bad in the Taiwanese market? I can't imagine carriers in the UK trying to lower prices or give a better deal without persuasion from outside. When the first iPhones were introduced it had the first affordable data plan I'd ever seen in the UK. I think o2 we're asking around £50/month for some tiny data plan on my Nokia N95, on top of the contract cost(there was no data bundles). The iPhone was £35 month on contract, phone and unlimited data.
- smackfu 13y agoApple's usual strategy to "fix" prices is to not give retailers any room to work with. If they can't buy an iPad for much less than $499, they can't put it on much of a sale. Why sell it at all if the margins are so bad? Accessories and warranties! This strategy doesn't work very well with iPhones, since there is a lot of excess carrier profit in the 24-month subsidies, above the $700 or so cost of the iPhone.
- JohnTHaller 13y agoThere's not as much profit as you'd think. And a lot less than lower priced phones from other manufacturers. Plus, the carriers have to assume a ton of risk by agreeing to buy millions of iPhones whether they sell or not. Verizon had an estimated shorfall of $12-14 billion dollars as of July of iPhones they'd have to buy even though they didn't have the sales to warrant it. Not sure how that would up.
- huxley 13y agoThat shortfall was predicted by one analyst and it never occurred: http://www.mondaynote.com/2013/12/15/shameless-carriers/ http://www.mondaynote.com/2013/12/15/shameless-carriers/ http://www.verizon.com/investor/secfiling.htm http://www.verizon.com/investor/secfiling.htm
- JohnTHaller 13y agoAh, thanks. Wasn't aware of that.
- smackfu 13y agoI was thinking more like this... Currently, AT&T charges you $199 for an iPhone 5S, then has to cover $19 of subsidy over the 24 months of the $80/month contract. A new carrier could charge $99 for an iPhone 5S, and make a huge splash. That would require another $4 of subsidy per month, but it would be pretty easy to just raise their plan to $85. Since they aren't just a retailer selling a single product once, it's much easier to move costs around. Similar to how a car dealer can play games with funding to make a car cost less but not really cost any profit.
- orbitur 13y agoHonest question. Can someone explain to me what's wrong with this sort of "price fixing"? The contract is attached to the iPhone, and Apple doesn't want the contract sold for less than $X. If the carrier doesn't want to do that, they can choose not to sell the phone. What's the issue?
- bane 13y agoDon't always assume that the goal is to prevent the phone from being sold cheaper. High demand items may also merit a higher price and Apple may want to keep the price artificially low. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_fixing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_fixing "In neo-classical economics, price fixing is inefficient. The anti-competitive agreement by producers to fix prices above the market price transfers some of the consumer surplus to those producers and also results in a deadweight loss." It also send invalid signals into the economy about the value of an item that may create bubbles or unreasonable expectations for low prices that are unsustainable (and therefore anti-competitive). The Diamond trade is a very good example of price fixing where otherwise plentiful and cheap stones are controlled on the supply-side to keep prices artificially high.
- czr80 13y agoYour examples are talking about something quite different - they would be relevant if we were talking about Apple and Samsung and Nokia sitting down and agreeing to set prices together. But we're not.
- grabeh 13y agoThe specific grounds for the fine by the Fair Trade Commission are not made clear in the brief article however, if as is stated in the article the Taiwanese companies had obtained reseller rights to set a price and then this was being undermined by Apple then this is not particularly fair of Apple to then attempt to set those resale prices. I use the word 'fair' deliberately in reference to the Fair Trade Commission. At the same time, it is likely to be anti-competitive to allow an upstream manufacturer to fix prices with all retailers on the basis that customers are prejudiced and retailers are unable to compete on price. This is the main answer to your question. Also if only one retailer plays ball with Apple then they have a monopoly position again to the likely detriment of customers. The arrangement is however acceptable where the retailer plays the role of mere agent in the arrangement (i.e. takes minimal risk in the transaction as compared to a distributor) as here it is reasonable for the manufacturer to set downstream prices. However here if the article is correct, then the presence of a clear right for the distributor to set prices which is then subsequently ignored by Apple would seem to justify action by Taiwanese FTC. If anything this would be a breach of contract issue also providing another ground for the FTC to intervene. Perhaps in this case, Apple intended to make the contract transparent by granting the right to the retailer to determine resale prices (in compliance with local law potentially) but then behind the scenes exerted pressure. This is pure speculation of course.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- laureny 13y agoFirst there's that and then there is the eBook price fixing, and who else knows what we haven't found out about how Apple conducts business. I, for one, am thankful that Android rose to keep Apple in check, because a world where Apple would be a monopoly frightens me about as much, if not more, that when it was Microsoft pulling the same kind of dirty and illegal tricks.
- r0h1n 13y agoGiven Google's staggeringly broad, global and interconnected reach (Android, Gmail, search, advertising etc.), I'm not sure if they're exactly the alternative worth rooting for. And they've been found indulging in as many, if not more, monopolistic or questionable business practices as Apple.
- sirkneeland 13y agoIndeed. The ONLY guarantee against companies abusing their near-monopoly positions is to deny them those positions of power in the first place. Not to trust them because they seem nice and "don't be evil"-ish. Not to trust the government to stop them from abusing it (clearly). But supporting competitors. Competition is the regular individual's best weapon. And that is why, where possible, I strive to support underdogs wherever possible. I use a Windows Phone (with a Jolla on the way), read on a Nook e-reader, use duckduckgo for search, and avoid lock-in wherever possible (upload my music to your cloud? No thanks), etc. And I encourage others to do so, or at least give it a try
- _delirium 13y agoI'm also worried about their increasing move towards taking Android at least partially back proprietary. The original idea seemed to be an open-source platform, which is a nice way of spurring innovation. But they've slowly been replacing components with proprietary Google versions, which is making the core open-source OS less and less maintained. My guess is that the goal is to make it more like a Darwin/OSX situation, where the core OS is open source but lacks all the interface elements and is not really usable as-is by competitors. What would motivate that? One guess is that they're more worried nowadays about Kindle-type competitors than they used to be, devices that build on Android but hook into an alternative (non-Google) cloud ecosystem. Some examples: Messenger seems to be in the process of being phased out in favor of Google Hangouts; Gallery and Photos duplicate functionality to such an extent that I suspect one of them will not last; even the main keyboard is no longer open source, as Google has more or less abandoned the default Android keyboard and is rolling all improvements into the default-on-Google-devices Google Keyboard app.
- brandonbloom 13y agoThis fine is surely smaller than the ill-gotten gains. If the court is ruling that Apple was behaving with nefarious intent, shouldn't there be meaningful punitive damages?
- darrenkopp 13y agoSweet, Apple will make that amount of money in ~146 seconds. That will certainly show them.
- bitemix 13y ago$666k is a rounding error for Apple.