8 ms·
Ask HN: Skype, but properly peer-to-peer?
I've just had to talk my 80-year-old father through setting up Skype on his new computer. For some reason he had to create a Microsoft account, and it was encouraging him to store all his documents on some drive in the cloud, and it combined his existing Skype account into the new Microsoft account, and all the while I was thinking "it shouldn't be like this."
It shouldn't be the case that for what could be, should be, a single, stand-alone application such as IP-telephony, there is all this cross-linking, central registration, etc., etc., etc., ...
It's probably a consequence of Microsoft buying out Skype and forcing integration with their own universe. So I ask, is there now an alternative to the centralized, you-will-do-everything-our-way system? I've searched, but had no success.
Suggestions?
- binarymax 13y agoA long list to go through, but this might be a good place to start. Hopefully it has what you need: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_VoIP_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_VoIP_software
- adamantium 13y agoGreat list, just to save him and others some time and pain, I evaluated all of those in the list some months ago, and my conclusion is Jitsi is the only one multiplatform, encrypted voice, still under development, free open source and not unusably buggy. Or technical - grandfather has no idea what a NAT, ICE or STUN is. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6977463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6977463
- pant 13y agohttp://simplewebrtc.com/demo.html http://simplewebrtc.com/demo.html Webrtc is here with p2p transmission of the camera + microphone (or files of course). I think it's time for all of us to move to p2p solutions that will come.
- waps 13y agoActually it supports sending any byte stream accross. It amazes me nobody seem to have built a peer2peer network out of it yet. Seems like a shot for open goal.
- salient 13y agoWell there's P2P file sharing through WebRTC: https://www.sharefest.me/ https://www.sharefest.me/
- vr000m 13y agoYahoo bought PeerCDN, which uses data channels from WebRTC.
- mike_hearn 13y agoWhy would you do that vs just writing a normal downloadable app?
- jaggs 13y agoUse the Skype Desktop version instead - http://www.skype.com/go/getskype-full http://www.skype.com/go/getskype-full no sign in needed.
- benbristow 13y agoI know some people from 4chan's /g/ and some other people are working on an encrypted de-centralized Skype alternative called 'Tox'. You might want to help with the project.
- stoical 13y agoMumble is the only one that springs to mind: http://mumble.sourceforge.net/ http://mumble.sourceforge.net/ Its designed more for chat rooms but may be suitable.
- rakoo 13y agoMumble works very well, but: - It's not real p2p, it needs a server somewhere. OP can install one at home or they can use a public one, but it's required (and if you use a public server, you lose some privacy) - Mumble only does Audio, no Video. If you can live with those, mumble is the most straightforward Open Source voip solution to use, and I can't recommend it enough (been using it with my relatives, me on Linux, them on Windows: no problem)
- rb2k_ 13y agoIt also uses OPUS as the audio codec and has mobile clients, which is kinda nice :)
- phaer 13y agoSIP + ZRTP. Jitsi and SFLPhone are decent clients, the people at ostel.co are working on some infrastructure to ease the usage of encrypted, decentralized VOIP but most public SIP providers should work your use case.
- aurora72 13y agoThis reminded me Richard Stallman's notes about the newly emerged Cloud Computing. He defined the CC as untrustable and advised to avoid. I'd suggest IP Telephones. Most of them are capable of making direct P2P connections without even any VoIP server. They only need an external STUN server to arrange the NAT configuration if you use the IP Phone behind a NAT router (which is almost always the case) There are many free and realiable STUNS servers running on the Internet or you can construct your own.
- userbinator 13y agoSIP/SIPS is nice. You can just use your IP[:port] as your phone number, and forwarding the required ports isn't too hard either if you're behind a NAT.
- sneak 13y ago> SIP/SIPS is nice. You can just use your IP[:port] as your phone number You just contradicted yourself.
- donnfelker 13y agoThis reminds me of WebRTC and SIP technology. Chris Matthieu built something like this which is now http://www.Twelephone.com http://www.Twelephone.com. But here you have to log in with your twitter account. Not 100% "I own everything" type of model but a lot less invasive, IMO.
- tuned 13y agoYou can try http://appear.in http://appear.in It's a browser based video-voice-chat client.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThat looks really good but it's still a non-self-hosted solution.
- mikemoka 13y agoyou should keep track of this one probably http://tox.im/ http://tox.im/
- lazyjones 13y agoThis should work with WebRTC (http://www.webrtc.org/ http://www.webrtc.org/) using the reference app: https://apprtc.appspot.com/ https://apprtc.appspot.com/ It should enable you to connect 2 browsers (e.g. Chrome and Firefox), all you need is to transmit the ID of the chat ("r" parameter from the chat URL you will get) to the peer, or the full URL. It keeps amazing me that we do not have simple JS solutions for this, when projects like Chatroulette can be built in "2 days 2 nights" according to the author. (by the way, here is WebRTC support for other browsers: https://code.google.com/p/webrtc4all/ https://code.google.com/p/webrtc4all/)
- devilirium 13y agoGood suggestion. I was thinking the same, so I started working on something, but it's still pretty basic. Communication should be easy, just as speaking.
- pilgrim689 13y agoThere's this: https://talky.io/ https://talky.io/
- Muromec 13y agoWhole WebRTC technology stack is just SIP VoIP without actual SIP protocol. Same codec set, SDP offer-answer, SRTP(C), ICE and other old cool things nobody cared to implement in real SIP clients for decades.
- Aaronn 13y agoHere is a open source WebRTC experiment from Mozilla (Ryan Seys): http://tincan.im/ http://tincan.im/
- fosap 13y agohttp://palava.tv http://palava.tv
- frik 13y agoI am searching for an WebRTC server app (open source) that I can run on my webserver. All these WebRTC guys want me to use their pay-for-use web services. I found only EasyRTC that sort of worked https://github.com/priologic/easyrtc https://github.com/priologic/easyrtc Can someone suggest Node.js or PHP (with libevent) implementations of WebRTC server apps?
- kbrosnan 13y agoMozilla has a node project at https://github.com/mozilla/talkilla https://github.com/mozilla/talkilla
- vr000m 13y agosee hookflash.me, they have an open source implementation called openpeer. (https://github.com/openpeer/ https://github.com/openpeer/)
- malditogeek 13y agoI've been working on a Node.js server (signaling server in Node over WS, frontend built in Backbone) https://github.com/malditogeek/vmux https://github.com/malditogeek/vmux give it a go. There's a running instance at http://vmux.co http://vmux.co
- daveid 13y agoI am currently working on an in-browser peer-to-peer chat/audio/video application. It's a work in progress at the moment, but you can take a look: https://github.com/Gargron/baron https://github.com/Gargron/baron As a desktop app, there's Jitsi, which works with XMPP and SIP accounts.
- mbrownnyc 13y agoJitsi also has a Web RTC driven video chat when combined with an XMPP server: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-YGw3bgB_s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-YGw3bgB_s https://jitsi.org/Projects/JitsiVideobridge https://jitsi.org/Projects/JitsiVideobridge https://github.com/jitsi/jitsi-videobridge https://github.com/jitsi/jitsi-videobridge
- sitkack 13y agoThis has no license. _Any_ license is better than no license.
- stephenson 13y agoTry https://hu.tt/ https://hu.tt/ works great
- javipas 13y agoThis is a good alternative IMHO https://meetings.io/features https://meetings.io/features
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoSococo.com has a team communications app. Not exactly made for family calls, but works fine. Free. Disclaimer: I work at Sococo. And phone calls run P2P and are encrypted. Unless your bandwidth is exceeded; then it runs through a multiplexing 'media node' that operates like a router. Video, doc sharing, chat, multiple people sharing all that or splitting up into groups or pairs - all by clicking around a map.
- acd 13y agoI would suggest WEBRTC via premade service you make sure there are Firefox/Chrome browser on his computer and point to url. Properly peer-to-peer. http://appear.in/fathersfirstlastname http://appear.in/fathersfirstlastname
- lnanek2 13y agoI've used the webrtc project people link here as well, but it is worth pointing out that Skype has an API. I'm not even a Windows programmer in general, but it only took me an afternoon to write a tiny app for a Mom's five year old that just calls Mom immediately and automatically as soon as it is started and has a locked preferences page for setting everything up.
- falcolas 13y agoIt's worth noting that Skype's API is now deprecated. There's no guarantee it will be around in the next release.
- tommoor 13y agoI've been working with WebRTC for a year now building Sqwiggle (https://www.sqwiggle.com https://www.sqwiggle.com) - In my experience I can tell you two things, - It's not really possible to go entirely peer-to-peer as many networks do not allow for this communication to happen. You would have constant issues with calls not being able to connect. Some centralised service is required for signaling, STUN and TURN which costs money and uses significant amounts of bandwidth. - Even if you do go peer-to-peer with WebRTC the quality would still be improved by going through a central server (less upstream bandwidth required) [edit: when more than 2 participants] If you're interested in helping to tackle these problems, we're hiring ;-)
- wwwtyro 13y ago> Even if you do go peer-to-peer with WebRTC the quality would still be improved by going through a central server (less upstream bandwidth required) Why is that?
- tommoor 13y agoI should have prefaced that with when there are more than 2 participants... as you would only need to upload your audio/video stream once.
- saykou 13y agoyeah that makes no sense, unless there's is more then on participant, in that case a full peer to peer would have to upstream (n-1) streams
- viraptor 13y ago1. Possible saving on bandwidth for the clients if they know good codecs A and B respectively, so they can't use them between eachother, but a transcoding third party can help. 2. This doesn't help with the amount of bandwidth used, but sometimes due to peering (that VoIP companies really care about) you can get lower delay going via them rather than directly. This is not very common, but it happens (especially if your broadband provider is your VoIP provider for example). Maybe the poster above had another reason for it too. There's loads of edge cases in the ITSP world.
- throwawaykf03 13y agoYour title is different from your question. If you're concerned about direct P2P connections, last I checked, Skype still sends voice traffic directly to the peer. I had checked some months ago using a packet sniffer while talking with a known peer. I'm on a mobile device so I can't confirm now, but looking at my wireless router admin console, I still see the UPnP ports Skype has mapped for itself. However if you want to avoid integration with the Microsoft universe (which should be opt-out IIRC, though I haven't installed Skype on Windows in ages), you may need to look elsewhere. I was about to suggest Google Hangouts, but that's just inviting integration with another universe :-) WebRTC-based solutions may be a decent option long term, but I'm not convinced they'll work as well as Skype or Hangout, because its NAT traversal is somewhat limited, so some peers may be unreachable, especially if corporate networks are involved. Skype and most P2P software perform a lot of hacks to get past NATs. Hangout, AFAIK, doesn't have these problems as it is server-based.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- htilford 13y agoSkype but properly peer-to-peer was pretty much the theme of realtime conf this year take a look at this video: http://vimeo.com/77289728 http://vimeo.com/77289728 They demo a federated video chat.
- ShirsenduK 13y agoWith google's free STUN servers its quite possible to build services which do this. https://github.com/cjb/serverless-webrtc/ https://github.com/cjb/serverless-webrtc/ And the mozilla projects. But it will be some work. The price of privacy. :)
- coldarchon 13y agohttp://www.webex.com/ http://www.webex.com/ from Cisco
- ryanweal 13y agoI've had mixed results with Voip and reading some of the comments here just turned me on to STUN and TURN. See this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MWYw0fltr0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MWYw0fltr0 which explains the causes behind reliability problems. I have thought about running my own server to manage my NATted voip calls and knowing ice/stun/turn will help has now led me to this: http://www.rtcquickstart.org/introduction http://www.rtcquickstart.org/introduction I'm thinking I might try to implement this. Voip on my mobile phone would be great, but I've had my hopes dashed before...
- malditogeek 13y agohttps://apprtc.appspot.com/ https://apprtc.appspot.com/ and https://appear.in https://appear.in are probably the most KISS Skype alternatives out there. Of course, built on top of WebRTC. I've been working myself on an open source alternative http://vmux.co http://vmux.co (code: https://github.com/malditogeek/vmux https://github.com/malditogeek/vmux) but it requires a Twitter account to log in which my pose a problem to your dad. (The upcoming version will allow you to use it without an account tho) To the people that want to host their own "skype alternatives" have in mind that it's not just serving the HTML+JS. WebRTC needs a way to bootstrap the P2P connection, the so called signaling, vmux provides a signaling mechanism using websockets but you'll still need a STUN server (I'm using the Google's one) and optionally a TURN server to relay users behind crazy NATs.
- shervinshaikh 13y agoCheck out Hutt (http://hu.tt/ http://hu.tt/). No account needed and you can instantly start video chatting with anyone who has a modern browser.
- nsmartt 13y agoIt says I need Chrome.
- mknits 13y agoI use https://appear.in https://appear.in based on webRTC.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoDoes this look as good to you as it does to me? https://jitsi.org https://jitsi.org
- f_salmon 13y agoRetroShare has VoIP and is: - 100% distributed / peer-to-peer - public key encrypted - open source http://retroshare.sourceforge.net/ http://retroshare.sourceforge.net/
- cordite 13y agoI've tried it for awhile, but it's rather clunky (as of a year ago anyway for a few months) and is difficult to get others to use and share their keys and such.
- Sami_Lehtinen 13y agoWell, that's the price to be paid for security. Without key sharing and verification, you can't be sure who you're connected to.
- lakesta 13y agoWe use Oovoo, its still centralized but we like it more than Skype. Its like the poor mans skype but its honestly better for voip.
- gte910h 13y agosip does it peer to peer :D http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer-to-peer_SIP http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer-to-peer_SIP
- csense 13y agosudo apt-get install linphone
- tomtheengineer 13y agoAt https://vline.com https://vline.com we provide a free WebRTC-based video chat service. It doesn't require any registration or installs and is built on top of our developer platform: https://vline.com/developer/ https://vline.com/developer/.
- bitwize 13y agoJust use Skype. It's been my experience that the way to technological bliss is through reducing friction by using what everyone else is using. For voice and video over IP, that's Skype.
- ColinWright 13y agoHave you tried to talk an elderly relative through installing Skype on Windows 8 over a phone line when you can't see their screen and don't use Windows? It has to be easier - there has to be a better way.
- pasbesoin 13y agoHow about configuring and sending them an instance of TightVNC or UltraVNC (one or the other or both of those -- I forget), and then just using that channel to remote to their system? Downside (maybe): They can only talk with you, and there may not be a convenient mechanism for always-on and notifications. (Or, doesn't the Chrome browser come with some sort of remote-enabling plug-in, these days?) Otherwise, possibly configure your own server intermediary and use Jitsi or similar? Downside: They'll only be able to talk with people similarly configured (although you could set up several people this way). The later is what I mean to move towards, Real Soon Now... :-/ P.S. It occurs to me now that you could use the remote access to get them configured for something else, as opposed to just to push a verbal-visual/"talk" communications channel over.
- spazzpp2 13y agoTry https://palava.tv/ https://palava.tv/ It's open-source WebRTC.
- adamantium 13y agoCan't tell about WebRTC or browser-based. When it comes to software, I've tried everything from the Wikipedia list and some more. Most are either too buggy (Linphone) or closed source (many) or not multiplatform (so you can't talk to WindowsXP-user grandfather or vice-versa) or development stopped (Twinkle) or has no encryption (Ekiga). The only one who passed was Jitsi. It has more than 10 years of development, it's free / open source, very usable, multiplatform. It also accepts encrypted voice over XMPP, not only over SIP. Look here - https://jitsi.org/Main/Features https://jitsi.org/Main/Features
- adamantium 13y agoColinWright's question is about computer-to-computer calls. His question is similar to one I've asked recently: Skype replacement for phone-to-computer and computer-to-phone (Skype-in and Skype-out numbers). Can you please chip in if you know more? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6921672 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6921672
- songzme 13y agoI built a site for super simple video chat originally to demo our company's product to clients. Its made to be easily accessible and used with ease. The more we used the app, the more we've come to appreciate its simplicity and our company now uses it to communicate with each other and between our offices around the world. Hope you will find this useful: https://opentokrtc.com https://opentokrtc.com