5 ms·
Google announces ban on "multi-purpose" Chrome extensions
- lauradhamilton 13y agoI am a satisfied Firefox user. Google just has too much power these days.
- evan_ 13y agoIt should be noted that this is just for the official extension listing, you can install any extension you want manually.
- thelibrarian 13y agoOnly on Linux and Mac though. Windows users can no longer manually install extensions, "for their protection".
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Windows users can no longer manually install extensions Windows users can manually install extensions; you have to flip the developer mode setting and unpack the extension to install it.
- salient 13y agoUnpack the extension, too? This process probably reduced the external extension installations by 100x, while they can still pretend that you can still technically install external extensions. First off, I think their original excuse was BS, because I very much doubt more than a marginal number of users were affected by malicious extensions this way. And second, there has to be a balance between what's safe by default, and what level of freedom/flexibility you have. If that "freedom" is hidden away in 10 layers of submenus, then might as well kill it for good, because it's not going to help anyone.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Unpack the extension, too? This process probably reduced the external extension installations by 100x, while they can still pretend that you can still technically install external extensions. Er, no, they say you can't, except for development (and the method that you can use, whether or not you are actualyl doing development, has always been the preferred method for development.) They aren't pretending that they making things available to Windows users, they are saying straight-up that, outside of development, Windows users cannot use non-Web Store Chrome Apps. Heck, even before they disabled the old, less onerous manual method, Chrome pretended that you couldn't -- if you tried to install extensions directly from the web without setting a command-line flag, Chrome would just tell you that you couldn't install extensions except from the Web Store (you could then drag the downloaded extension to the extensions page and it would install, but Chrome did everything to hide it from you.) > First off, I think their original excuse was BS, because I very much doubt more than a marginal number of users were affected by malicious extensions this way. I'm glad you think that. Is there any reason you'd care to share why anyone else should believe it? > And second, there has to be a balance between what's safe by default, and what level of freedom/flexibility you have. Any position you choose on the continuum is a balance between those things. > If that "freedom" is hidden away in 10 layers of submenus, then might as well kill it for good, because it's not going to help anyone. I think the flexibility retained for developers helps exactly the people it is designed to help.
- salient 13y agoNot anymore: http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57611380-93/google-to-ban-external-sources-for-windows-chrome-extensions/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57611380-93/google-to-ban-e... I agree with others - there's a trend here.
- gergles 13y agoThis is why I started using Chromium instead of Chrome -- Chrome forces you now to use (and pay for!) the web store (it's impossible to install extensions not hosted by Google, if you're running on Windows because "think of the users!"[1]) and if your extension doesn't get along with any of their policies (i.e. the extensions listed here), then Chrome users can't use it at all. Super-awesome, Google. Chromium doesn't (at the moment) have these restrictions. [1]: The post with this fucking Newspeak title: http://blog.chromium.org/2013/11/protecting-windows-users-from-malicious.html http://blog.chromium.org/2013/11/protecting-windows-users-fr...
- zobzu 13y agoI'm just using Firefox instead. Because the browser is just as good, and seems to genuinely push for http://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/manifesto/ http://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/manifesto/
- k-mcgrady 13y ago>> "Chrome forces you now to use (and pay for!) the web store" Huh? Seems free for me to use. What specifically do you have to pay for?
- tokenizerrr 13y agoI think he means for developers. There's no way to distribute extensions for free now, where before they could be self-hosted.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> There's no way to distribute extensions for free now, where before they could be self-hosted. Unless I misunderstand the blocking of non-web-store extensions, you can distribute extension for free, just not to Windows users.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- fhd2 13y agoI'm increasingly getting the impression that Google would just love extensions to disappear altogether. They probably just added them to get Firefox power users, now that Chrome is king and they're pushing it like crapware (large scale bundling), they probably don't care anymore.
- lukifer 13y agoThey're walking a fine line, though, because Chrome extensions are the cousins of ChromeOS apps, which is an ecosystem they obviously want to promote. While I've never released any of them, the extensions I've built on on the Chrome API have been a sheer pleasure, if somewhat limited in capability compared to Firefox plugins.
- emilv 13y agoMaybe they should just stop pay for Firefox development if they don't like Firefox. Google pays huge amounts of money to Mozilla.
- tyw 13y agothat's a little bit disingenuous. google pays huge amounts of money to Mozilla to be the default search engine because of the huge amounts of money Mozilla users make google by using google services on a daily basis. it's not like they're propping up a competitor just for the hell of it (or even to avoid anti-trust issues).
- mark_l_watson 13y ago+1 I donated to Mozilla a few days ago, thinking how small my donation was compared to Google. However, Google must make $$ on Firefox hosted searches.
- salient 13y agoWell I can think of at least one extension that they'd love to make disappear for good.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoKeep it simple, stupid. If you know what's good for you. AKA: the Unix philosophy by racket.
- serge2k 13y agohave you seen firefox/chrome/any modern web browser? I just wonder how long until google infects android with this BS. Sorry, sorry, android is 100% free I forgot. How long until they infect play services with this. iPhones are looking nicer.
- adamki 13y agoI think that Microsoft associated bloggers should try and resist the urge to "puntificate" on Google related matters and announcements in any professional capacity, it always comes off as though they are trying to take advantage of the situation and somehow spin it to the benefit of those who have them 'not quite on their payroll'. Avoid the spin, here's the original post: http://blog.chromium.org/2013/12/keeping-chrome-extensions-simple.html http://blog.chromium.org/2013/12/keeping-chrome-extensions-s...
- edbott 13y agoThanks for the career advice. But perhaps you didn't notice that, as I always do, I provided a prominent link to the original Google post (the same one you just provided) in my original write-up. I always make sure my readers have the opportunity to go to the original source. PS: I'm not on anybody's payroll. I am a freelancer and my compensation for this post comes from ZDNet, a division of CBSInteractive. You can take sides if you want to. I write for the benefit of my readers, a very diverse group. - Ed Bott
- matchu 13y agoAs I understand it, this rule primarily targets extensions that do sketchy things without their users' knowledge, like how HoverZoom recently started silently tracking their users. This feels like a good policy to me, and I'm not aware of any benevolent extensions that will suffer for it.
- OzzyOzbour 13y agoThe Ban Calendar July 20, 2012 - First step to ban plugins. NPAPI plug-ins in Windows 8 Metro mode October 31, 2012 - 2nd step to ban plugins. Smarter NPAPI installs from the Chrome Web Store November 15, 2012 - Banned packaged Apps v.1 Restricting extension APIs in legacy packaged apps December 21, 2012 - First step to ban external extensions. No more silent extension installs September 23, 2013 - Banned plugins. Saying Goodbye to Our Old Friend NPAPI November 07, 2013 - Banned external extensions. Protecting Windows users from malicious extensions December 19, 2013 - First step to ban all extensions Keeping Chrome Extensions Simple Next? When Chrome extensions will be disabled at all?
- jarnix 13y agoWell, it's great that they keep their browser the way they want it to be. We can download Chromium if we want so I don't see any problem here. Anyway, if they could think of the publishers and remove AdBlock once for all instead of giving money to their developers, I would be more than happy.
- dergachev 13y agoWhat about things extensions Tampermonkey, are those at risk by this?
- cratermoon 13y agoNo more startpage24? https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/startpage24-incl-video-do/idmjjnnadgpnniaebiicdndgjlgpadcb https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/startpage24-incl-v... How sad!
- loceng 13y agoI wonder if something like Reddit Enhancement Suite considered to be "multi-purpose."
- haberman 13y ago> It might have been helpful for Google to have created a sample extension as a “don’t do this” example. Bizarrely, Google chose instead to illustrate the problem using an infamous gag screenshot of the seven-year-old Internet Explorer 7 stuffed to the limit with toolbars and add-on panes. It's not bizarre. If you read the original blog post, the IE screenshot is there to illustrate the motivation behind Chrome's longstanding goal of making addons/extensions unobtrusive: "The name "Chrome" came from this principle as we wanted the browser to be about "content, not chrome." " > Google won't allow third-party developers to build toolbars for Chrome, but the company still makes its own toolbar for Internet Explorer and distributes that toolbar widely. As do Bing and Yahoo. Since IE has not put the same emphasis on minimizing chrome in their browser, and since all major search engines distribute toolbars for it, it is not hypocritical to follow the local conventions and distribute a toolbar for IE like everyone else does. When in Rome, do as the Romans do. > The real reason for the new policy might have less to do with user interface guidelines and more with Google's attempt to shut down extensions that intrude on its advertising fiefdown. Or it could have to do with the fact that an extension that unexpectedly starts injecting ads into all of your web pages is extremely annoying, and (worse) is hard to attribute to the unrelated extension you installed. The article itself shows an example of one star reviews from unhappy users. > In other words, images on the pages you visit, be they ads or content, can be replaced with ads from the Superfish network. Yep, sounds pretty seriously annoying, doesn't it? What sane person would install extensions if this behavior became commonplace? There is a lot of aspersion-casting here, but no mention of any innocent actor who is hurt by this. This seems like a pretty common-sense move that benefits users. And yet the article and some of the comments here are hostile. Google has become the company that people love to hate.