25 ms·
I Got Myself Arrested So I Could Look Inside the Justice System
- tsaoutourpants 13y agoThe first officer had it right: "What are you, some kind of asshole?"
- PythonicAlpha 13y agoTo sad, there is no link to down-vote a comment.
- dsego 13y agothere is, you just need more karma.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 13y ago3 years of probation for a single graffiti tag? Talk about proportions here.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nealb 13y agoThe point of the 3 years seemed to me to be mostly making an example of the author to discourage civil disobedience.
- VLM 13y agoAnd they call it "justice"
- EpicEng 13y agoThis guy purposely wasted the time of the legal system, i.e., he wasted or tax dollars to prove a point. I think it's obvious why a judge would not be overly happy about it. I'm not surprised he got more than the usual punishment.
- jbooth 13y agoOh come on, you think the taxpayer dollars are the biggest issue on the judge's mind? So he throws 10x the taxpayer dollars at the problem by putting him on probation for 3 years? Have you ever met real people? Ever seen someone make decisions because they're pissed off? The guy basically took a shit all over the (immoral) way the justice system works, that's why he was singled out and made an example of.
- EpicEng 13y agoNot sure how you got the inside scoop into the judge's thought process, but yeah, I assume he was pissed for exactly the reasons I listed; his time wasted, police time wasted, money wasted. Who knows, maybe the judge is just a big jerk who is happy with the unfairness in the justice system, but you don't know that any more than I do and there are plenty of good judges and cops out there. You also don't know how this guy interacted with the police and the judge. He may have been a jerk himself. No one knows, but I do know that the legal system is not run by robots, and if your intention is to piss people off who have the power to screw with your life then, well... prepare to be screwed. This is in no way a commentary on the substance of the article, nor am I defending the judge's decision. There's plenty of unfairness in the legal system (I've been on the receiving end a couple of times in my youth) and it's not right.
- pessimizer 13y agoThe point was that putting someone on probation is expensive. If the judge was upset about tax money being wasted, and their response to that was to waste more tax money, then the judge >wasted our tax dollars to prove a point
- kkus 13y agoI can't help but remember Aaron Schwartz when someone mentions "making an example". What can I do to try to discourage this practice of "making an example"? Has anything changed since Aaron's death?
- shittyanalogy 13y agoYou know what I never understood? The concept of "making an example" out of someone in the justice system. How can we give one individual a sentence that is exceptionally harsher than the norm and not have that sentence be considered unusual as in cruel and unusual? The whole point is that their sentence is unusual for the circumstance. How is this in any way a just and equal, and legal for that matter, application of the law?
- SilasX 13y agoBecause you can't catch everyone. So the severity of the punishment has to make up for the improbability of getting caught (Not defending the specific magnitude, just the principle.)
- mindcrime 13y ago(Not defending the specific magnitude, just the principle.) It's a stupid principle. It totally fucking distorts the most basic idea behind a system of equal "justice".
- SilasX 13y agoSo, in the 5% of cases where you get caught, you just have to give back what you stole?
- mindcrime 13y agoSure, if you get caught, you compensate / reimburse the victim. If you don't get caught... well, sometimes you get lucky. But that's no different than how we do things now. Not everybody gets caught. It sucks, but it's reality. But the idea that we're going to "extra punish" a handful of people here and there to "make an example out of them" is totally incompatible with any reasonable notion of "justice" .
- rayiner 13y ago
- PythonicAlpha 13y agoNo, its because he uncovered how corrupt the whole system is.
- judk 13y agoOne tag, plus all the ones that don't get caught. And it's probation, not prison.
- axus 13y agoI thought you could only be sentenced for crimes you've been proven guilty of. Three years of not being able to leave NYC doesn't sound so bad, but if it were a city without job prospects it would be worse.
- corin_ 13y agoSure, but punishments generally take into consideration what the crime means overall. For example if you sold cocaine to a friend once in your life then all logic says there's no need to prosecute you as a dealer (not that it wouldn't necessarily happen anyway), but if you were caught that one time the logic behind a serious punishment is the assumption that you're doing it more than once and thus affecting society. So even though they can't charge you with any more, the crime "selling cocaine" takes that into account with its sentencing already.
- RogerL 13y agoA tag on City Hall, deliberately in front of the police. I would expect a more severe sentence if I keyed a cop car vs some random car on the street. While I'm uninterested in discussing the severity of the sentence (I have no experience or knowledge to be able to judge), it stands to reason that if you directly attack the justice system you will not be treated kindly.
- lucb1e 13y ago> I would expect a more severe sentence if I keyed a cop car vs some random car on the street. If everyone is equal, then so are the cops. It might not be... smart to pick a cop car, but I don't think it should make much difference in punishment.
- nate_meurer 13y agoThis is simultaneously the funniest and most tragic thing I've read in a long time. It's nearly unbelievable. It reminds me a bit of Eddie Murphy's skit for SNL where he dresses up in white-face so he can experience society on the other side. This is almost as funny as that skit, no exaggeration. The tragedy is that this story is true.
- stevenleeg 13y agoWhat part of this did you find funny?
- fragsworth 13y agoThe part where he got three years probation because the judge was pissed off about his shenanigans.
- nate_meurer 13y agoI hope I'm not remiss in perceiving strong dry humor throughout the first half of the story. My favorite part is where he looks at the cop in the car and keeps right on spraying: As I moved the can back and forth, a police officer in an Interceptor go-cart saw me, slammed on his brakes, and pulled up to the curb behind me. I looked over my shoulder, made eye contact with him, and resumed. As I waited for him to jump out, grab me, or Tase me, he sped away and hung a left, leaving me standing there alone. And in the next paragraph... I woke up the next morning and Fox News was reporting that unknown suspects had vandalized City Hall. I went back to the entrance and handed the guard my driver’s license and a letter explaining what I’d done. Fox News, unknown suspects... Maybe it's just me, but this had me laughing out loud.
- spinlock 13y agoI bet the police dispatch described the suspect as a young black man wearing jeans and a black hoodie.
- chadillac83 13y ago
- tokenizer 13y agoDo we really need to punish people with prison for non violent crimes? We might as well call in the Criminal Punishment System, or the Government's Justice System, as it doesn't engender my views of justice, and nor should it for you.
- rayiner 13y ago> Do we really need to punish people with prison for non violent crimes? No, and when it comes to white people in the suburbs we largely don't do that (except serious financial crimes). When it comes to the inner city and gang activity, that's not so clear cut. What are you going to do, issue monetary fines?
- norswap 13y agoThe point of the author is that non violent crime can get people jailed (or their freedom very severely restricted) if they are a certain skin color. Tagging hardly qualifies you as a gang member. Living in a city isn't a crime and shouldn't make result in you being treated differently than anywhere else.
- rayiner 13y ago> Tagging hardly qualifies you as a gang member. In a suburb, probably not. In a city, I'd bet it's statistically likely that a tagger has a gang affiliation. > Living in a city isn't a crime and shouldn't make result in you being treated differently than anywhere else. Policing strategies must take into account the realities of living in cities versus living in suburbs. At the end of the day, nobody wants to go back to the 1970's where New York or Chicago were dangerous places (which was a major cause of the suburban exodus to begin with). Just because you live in a city doesn't mean you should live in fear of getting mugged, raped, etc. When I lived in Chicago, there were flashmob attacks in my neighborhood: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/06/chicago-flash-mobs-appare_n_871924.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/06/chicago-flash-mobs-.... Shit like that just doesn't happen in the suburbs, and requires commensurate police response.
- mdturnerphys 13y agoInteresting aside about the author's accidental ability to elude two members of the NYPD counterterrorism division: "Two Intelligence Unit detectives arrived and testily walked me outside to a waiting unmarked police car. Court papers show that they’d staked out my apartment to arrest me, and that I unwittingly kept eluding them. In one dramatic instance, two officers had tailed me as I walked down Eastern Parkway. I’d entered the subway station at the Brooklyn Museum, unaware that I was being followed. One of the officers had followed me through the turnstiles while another guarded the exit. The report states that the officers then inexplicably lost contact with me."
- corin_ 13y agoNot that it's much less embarrassing this way, but... why would you assume they chose people from a counter-terrorism division to go after a graffiti artist?
- mdturnerphys 13y agoThat's what the Intelligence Unit is.
- enraged_camel 13y agoYep. You never know what kind of secret communist/terrorist intelligence you will find in street graffiti.
- reginaldjcooper 13y agoIsn't it more likely to be in graffiti than via Morse coded gnome hops? I hope the NSA is getting photos of all that graffiti it sounds dangerous.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>Isn't it more likely to be in graffiti than via Morse coded gnome hops? http://penny-arcade.com/comic/2013/12/11 http://penny-arcade.com/comic/2013/12/11
- rayiner 13y agoThis is a great article, and I really appreciate this paragraph: > But in between the important cases, I found myself spending most of my time prosecuting people of color for things we white kids did with impunity growing up in the suburbs. However, I think he ignores a really salient distinction: a lot of these "crimes" like the laws against graffiti, exist not because the acts themselves are particularly heinous, but because they're proxies for things that are dangerous, namely gang activity. In not going after the author, the police simply did the analysis they are required to do: is this guy a threat within the spirit of the law? Now, obviously there are shortcomings in the heuristics the police are using here. It's not okay to conclude that someone is a threat because they're a black teenager in a hoodie and aren't a threat because they're a white professional in a suit. But I don't think we really want a mechanical justice system that follows the mere letter of the law instead of the spirit. We don't want police to ignore the distinction between someone tagging a public building to make a point, and gang members tagging a private building to "make a point."
- brodney 13y ago> In not going after the author, the police simply did the analysis they are required to do: is this guy a threat within the spirit of the law? I don't think we know that. Maybe it's true, but I can't rule out other possibilities.
- rayiner 13y agoLike what?
- coldtea 13y ago>However, I think he ignores a really salient distinction: a lot of these "crimes" like the laws against graffiti, exist not because the acts themselves are particularly heinous, but because they're proxies for things that are dangerous, namely gang activity. Millions of people do graffiti -- and very few of them have anything to do with "gang activity". This "proxy" notion doesn't hold. Neither would such retribution to such "offences" be fair even if it was so. In fact, sending people to jail for such trivial stuff is a more effective introduction to serious crime than their initial offences.
- maaaats 13y ago> From Brownsville to downtown Manhattan, I would estimate that I passed more than 200 police officers, some from a distance, some close enough to touch. Wow, is police that common in NY / the states? That's more police than I have seen in my entire life.
- startupfounder 13y agoWe have over 35,000 police officers in the 5 boroughs of NYC. If you walk from Wall St. to Central Park you will see more than 200 easily.
- enkephalin 13y agohad the same reaction. in german citys police officers are quite a rare sight. usually only found near train stations, or the odd criminal hot-spot.
- rayiner 13y agoTo provide more context: in 1990, London and NYC were of a similar size (~8 million) though NYC was and is quite a bit more dense. London had 184 homicides. NYC had 2,262. This past year London was down to 86, versus NYC's 414.
- sliverstorm 13y agoYup. We might expect NYC's population of officers to begin declining, but they had serious crime problems not very long ago.
- grecy 13y agoTo put that in more context, the murder rate in America is 10 times that of the next developed country. The murder rate in NYC and Chicago is higher than Mexico City
- tptacek 13y agoThat's because Mexico City's murder rate was so bad that the country plowed an avalanche of money into it, resulting in the world's densest police coverage; it also assumes that murders in Mexico City are reported as reliably as they are in the US, which is a dubious proposition. Mexico's various other cities are world leaders in violent crime; Juarez has a murder rate over 147/10k, more than 10x Chicago's, and that again assumes that everything is reported in Juarez, which is extremely unlikely. For whatever it's worth to you, neither NYC nor Chicago makes the top ten for the US. Chicago witnesses an astronomical number of murders, and is for that reason a national disgrace, but the rate isn't anomalous for the population. Chicago is a huge city.
- blhack 13y agoI don't "get" this article. The beginning seems to be him talking about how difficult it was for him to get the police to think he was suspicious. The article was really interesting, and it seemed to be a point about racial/socio-economic profiling. But once he got into the system, he was treated terribly. Probation, not being allowed to visit his family, for a misdemeanor. -- Honestly, his conclusion sounds more like justice /is/ being applied evenly, it's just that it was harder for him to get the police's attention while he was wandering around in a suit and tie.
- DanBC 13y agoThe article describes the imbalance of policing white and black communities. It then describes the stupid sub-optimal workings of the punishments, allowing the reader to draw their own conclusion about how someone subject to those restrictions is supposed to move away from crime. It is stupid that a non-violent misdemeanour offence can prevent someone from travelling outside an area.
- corin_ 13y agoHe was making two points, the first that it isn't being applied evenly (just because it's applied evenly after a guilty verdict, that doesn't change the fact that the system is less willing to find certain people guilty in the first place). The second point is then that people are treated badly after being found guilty, regardless of race.
- mathattack 13y agoAnd that this is what he was up against as a suit wearing white person. Others get it much worse.
- moocowduckquack 13y agohis conclusion sounds more like justice /is/ being applied evenly He is one of their own who had gone out of his way to make them look foolish. Once that was clear he was treated more harshly than an equivalent first offender, not less. edit - and not equally.
- base698 13y agoWorks bombs, mixing Works Toilet Cleanser and Aluminum foil in a 2L plastic bottle were popular in my high school. I can't imagine the charges the children would get today if they were brown. Lucky for them they lived in rural NC.
- vph 13y agoThe author hypothesis is that criminal profiling is based on race. A simpler hypothesis is that such profiling is based on looks. Now, instead of wearing suits, if he wears baggy jeans that almost fall off his butt, puts on a few tatoos, nose rings to match, and starts doing seemingly illegal things. And if the cops still don't stop him, then maybe being white has something to do with it.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoA simpler hypothesis is that such profiling is based on looks. Are you trying to argue that the colour of your skin is not a factor in the perception of your appearance?
- vph 13y agoSurely, the color of skin is part of looks. How much is it? I don't know. But it is naive to say that skin color is the only thing.
- arrrg 13y agoWho argued it’s the only thing? You are admitting here that you think it’s plausible that the police profile based on race (i.e. they are racist). That they also look at other things isn’t really surprising (but should nevertheless not be left unquestioned).
- auctiontheory 13y agoI have two middle-class white friends who have told me that they were busted by the police for dealing cocaine (when they were young - before I knew them - SoL has expired), had their stash confiscated, and told not to do it again. And let go - scot-free. Two independent incidents. This small experiment doesn't have a control, but I believe that black drug dealers are given more than a mild verbal rebuke. In NYC, you can't even walk down the street while black.
- chimeracoder 13y ago
- enkephalin 13y agoWe avoided inner city streets because they were dangerous, and we relied on the police to keep people from those places out of our neighborhoods. Whatever they got, we figured they deserved. i find the last statement just as disturbing as the rest of the article. carrying this sentiment around plays a big part in the apathy we see all around us, towards most of the atrocities being committed these days.
- redblacktree 13y agoThat's exactly the point, of course. He changed his view by experiencing criminal justice in the city.
- kaffeinecoma 13y agoThe judge [...] ordered three years of probation, a $1000 fine, a $250 surcharge, a $50 surcharge, 30 days of community service, and a special condition allowing police and probation officers to enter and search my residence anytime without a warrant. Wow. Perhaps I'm naive, but I was unware that a first-time, nonviolent misdemeanor could be grounds for removing your 4th amendment rights.
- jggonz 13y agoYes, the judicial system can destroy your life once it touches you... even if you're innocent.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- skwirl 13y agoSo were you under the impression that incarcerated persons could not have their cells searched without a warrant, too? The 5th and 14th amendments provide that no person shall "be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law". He was convicted of a crime. The punishment can include random searches, drug tests, ankle monitors, etc., as long as it is provided for by law.
- kaffeinecoma 13y agoActually I have no idea why you think I'm under that impression. I know that (for example) convicted felons can lose their voting rights, but I did not know that committing a misdemeanor would cause you to lose protection against searches in your own home after your release, potentially forever.
- jggonz 13y agoThis was a total surprise for me as well. I did not know that you could even lose that right. I guess anything is legal as long as there's a law that says it is.
- blisterpeanuts 13y agoI'm sorry to be a curmudgeon but I don't like this guy at all. He wasted valuable city resources on an experiment the outcome of which he should have predicted, being a criminal attorney in Roxbury. Why were the police and the criminal justice officials apparently angry with him? Because while he was playing his little game, to "prove" that police profile people and to "prove" that getting arrested and jailed can be a violent and unfair experience, someone else was getting away with a purse snatching, or beating up an ex-girlfriend, or playing the knock-out game, or emptying a cash register. It's not so much that he prevented one of these other cases from being pursued, but that he seems so oblivious of the effects of his actions. Thus, it seems perfectly natural and reasonable for them to say, "OK, you make twice the salary we make yet you wanna be a petty criminal? Poof, you're a petty criminal. Enjoy sleeping in the bed you made, and here's hoping you will be permanently cured of f##king with us in the future, a##hole." The police are set upon from all sides. If they bend the rules, they are severely punished. If they don't bend the rules, and the rules don't always apply the way liberal suburban white folks might imagine they do on the street, then they get castigated for not "doing their job" i.e. catching the bad guys. At the end of the day, not catching the bad guys is the biggest sin in law enforcement, because it's the mission. If you fail the mission, you're facing demotion, punishment, deprivation of public support and sufficient budget, and the public will view you with contempt and disgust. I'm not justifying that that diabetic guy who wanted his sugar pills should be denied his pills. I'm not justifying that the police handle the lower socio-economic cases more brutally, giving them bruises and cuts that the suburban white boy somehow was spared. I'm not justifying racial profiling. Yet, to walk a mile in their shoes, both the police and the criminal justice system as a whole, is to see the world a little differently from the average Atlantic Monthly reader or Hacker News reader. Just my 2 cents.
- drzaiusapelord 13y ago>He wasted valuable city resources There's real civic value here that greatly trumps any sort of tax payer whining. Especially considering that internal anti-corruption mechanisms clearly aren't working and so many jurisdictions are hopelessly corrupt. We need more money spent on stuff like this and less "Police Department announces new SWAT military vehicles" whose maintenance and lifetime budget over whats essentially war machines in our neighborhoods greatly trumps what this man did. Also, he's white and educated and thus you're paying attention to him. See, its working.
- dragontamer 13y agohttp://www.courthousenews.com/2012/05/09/46357.htm http://www.courthousenews.com/2012/05/09/46357.htm Alternative take on what has happened here. >>> This reporter accompanied Constantino on one of those trips, watching as the lawyer handed a guard his passport and driver's license. After calling City Hall staffers from inside the guard booth, the officer told Constantino to come back the next day. >>> Instead, Constantino dramatically turned himself in at Manhattan Criminal Court that Friday, after the stop-and-frisk protesters were convicted of disorderly conduct. >>> "Your Honor, I refuse to leave this court," Constantino told the judge. "I am choosing in peace and love not to leave this court." ------------------ The purpose of getting arrested was to protest the Stop and Frisk laws in NYC. It seems like Bobby Constantino is milking the story for all its worth though, and turning it into something else. Not that it is a bad perspective or anything, but I think it is important to remember his original purpose for getting arrested.
- refurb 13y agoWow, I wish I could upvote this a dozen times. No surprise here, the guy painted the story in the most supportive light possible. This is not news, this is a political piece. He's free to publish such a thing, but people need to be more discriminatory when giving so much weight to his "facts".
- Eliezer 13y agoIs there anywhere on the planet with a functioning criminal justice system? Where should I live if I don't want to live in fear?
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 13y agoHe made eye contact; he didn't run; and he's surprised the policeman left him alone? Hasn't he seen any real criminal behavior or maybe a painting of it in a fine art gallery? I'm glad he got his wish though, but for a minute I was worried he wouldn't.
- tn13 13y ago"Simply carrying those items qualified as a class B misdemeanor pursuant to New York Penal Law 145.65." Are you serious ? And I make fun of Indian laws.
- alexhutcheson 13y agoIn a similar vein, I would highly recommend the book Newjack: Guarding Sing Sing[1] by Ted Conover. The author was a journalist who wanted to do a story on the prison system in New York State. The Department of Correctional Services froze him out and refused to give him any sort of access or interviews. To get the story, he actually took a job as a correctional officer officer in Sing Sing prison and worked there for a year. His account of the entire experience is fascinating. I think the whole discussion around these sorts of issues could really benefit from more accounts like this that introduce some transparency into the criminal justice system. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Newjack-Guarding-Sing-Ted-Conover/dp/0375726624/ http://www.amazon.com/Newjack-Guarding-Sing-Ted-Conover/dp/0...
- jebblue 13y agohttp://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon." There's nothing new in the article. He proved nothing other than dressing decent makes a good impression, we all knew that. Nothing of race or the justice system in general was proved one way or the other in my opinion.
- vog 13y ago> ... unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon Interesting new phenomenon: People doing an "audit" of the justice system by themselves arrested.
- thedrifting 13y agoSo, the author set out to prove how unfair the justice system is between races, and to some extent he did show that. But, didn't his experience also show that a white person was treated just as by the courts as any other person? Am I missing the point of this article?
- dragontamer 13y agoHe's just ranting aimlessly, probably because he's pissed off about his probation.
- LekkoscPiwa 13y agoThere is a lot of BS in the PC thing with profiling. I'm an Eastern European. Almost all Polish people I know work in construction or baby sitting, etc. However, none of them or us Polish immigrants blames the United States for that. Or the Government. They know they aren't educated very well, so they don't finger point to any type of discrimination for their fate. But somehow there are people there, like some Latinos I know who just don't even try. They just want to be illiterate all their life. One Lady I know who is from Mexico doesn't even teach her children English. Doesn't want them to speak English in the US. But blames US for her shitty job and standard of living. This is a little bit too much even for me (an immigrant) to stomach, you know? If they voted Obama into Presidency… what racism? Bunch of racists and secret Ku-Klux-Klan lovers voted for a Black President? Like really, some people have way too much time on their hands. If I can be consulting for 60-100usd/hr after 6 years of living here, why some people need to steal and deal drugs instead is beyond me. There is equality in Cuba and Canada. If these people are for real why don't they just immigrate there? I will be honest. I see a Pole in the US I think he is doing construction or picking up garbage or baby sitting, taking care of elderly. I see a Mexican I suspect he doesn't speak English. I see a black person I check if my wallet is safe. Everybody does that. Trying to change the way we think about Blacks without them changing their ways is never going to work. Not all Poles in the US are in the construction business. Not all Mexicans in the US are illiterate. Not all Blacks in the US are criminals. But big chunk of all these peoples are, so it's good to be opened minded and don't pretend that things like AIDS epidemic in DC being on levels with Sub-Saharian Africa aren't true. Because they are. And this isn't fault of anybody else but people who live there and make choices they do. I came to this country with 300usd in my pocket. I could have excuses to do nothing and portray myself as a victim too. But who does that in this country?
- RokStdy 13y agoI think there is a lot wrong with this comment. Perhaps since you're an immigrant you're not familiar with the concept of institutional racism[1]. Regarding Obama's 2012 Election: according to [2]and[3], 62 million of 221 million possible voters cast their ballot for Obama. ~28% of citizens voting for you does not really signal the end of racism in the US. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_racism#Institutional_racism_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_racism#Institutio... [2]http://elections.gmu.edu/Turnout_2012G.html http://elections.gmu.edu/Turnout_2012G.html [3]http://www.ropercenter.uconn.edu/elections/common/pop_vote.html http://www.ropercenter.uconn.edu/elections/common/pop_vote.h...
- scotty79 13y agoI think there should be kind of mystery shoppers for justice system. They'd commit misdemeanors and get arrested so they can report how they were treated to improve operation of police and justice system and to weed out personnel that doesn't obey the law or neglect procedures.
- 3am 13y agoThis reminds me of the work I read about Nellie Bly (Elizabeth Cochrane) doing around mental health and institutionalization in the late 19th century (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nellie_Bly#Asylum_expos.C3.A9 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nellie_Bly#Asylum_expos.C3.A9). It's not a complimentary comparison for our criminal justice system.
- drstrangevibes 13y agoi am so glad that intelligent arguments started to come out. I was about to think of the hacker new readership of comprising of entitled white closeted middle america , who can debug a complex graph of function calls, then plead ignorance to obvious positive re enforcement relationships such as: more black arrests -> more black crime statistics -> more black prejudice -> less black prospects on a slight tangent I've grown a little disappointed in the so called leaders of information age being completely dismissive of social responsibility, instead of using heads for social good or economic stability there seems to be and endless pile of bright young minds devoted to dross antics like delivering pizza by drone, or getting maximum ketchup out of a bottle.
- drstrangevibes 13y agoi am so glad that intelligent arguments started to come out. I was about to think of the hacker new readership of comprising of entitled white closeted middle america , who can debug a complex graph of function calls, then plead ignorance to obvious positive re enforcement relationships such as: more black arrests -> more black crime statistics -> more black prejudice -> less black prospects on a slight tangent I've grown a little disappointed in the so called leaders of information age being completely dismissive of social responsibility, instead of using heads for social good or economic stability there seems to be and endless pile of bright young minds devoted to dross antics like delivering pizza by drone, or getting maximum ketchup out of a bottle.
- anuraj 13y agoCriminal justice system as it exists has lots to answer 1) What is the purpose? 2) Is it getting achieved 3) What kind of people are administering the system 4) Why biases exist? 5) What should citizenry and political authority do? 6) Ultimately - what is the true conscience of the society?
- hawkharris 13y agoThe article's description of racial profiling brings to mind a statistic that the ACLU reported a few weeks ago (it was also featured on HN): in U.S. federal courts, blacks are about twenty times as likely as whites to be sentenced to life in prison for non-violent crimes.
- dmourati 13y agoTo me the whole problem comes down to one of discretion. The police officers in the beginning of the story had too much discretion. By not arresting someone defacing city hall, they trivialized a property crime. The author intimates this was because of his race or at least his appearance. Maybe so. Next the judge exercises his discretion to come up with a non-standard sentence for the crime. Any non-instigator first offender would have gotten the slap on the wrist. A minority, we are lead to believe, probably much worse. Same crime but the discretion is wide in the sentence. Later, the issue swings the other way. He has some real cause to go the rally in honor of the fallen student. Here, the discretion is taken away from the parole officer. Discretion is power. In some instances, society grants too much discretion. In others, too little. We know this is the case but it still shocks us and we like to second guess.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- adamzerner 13y agoPeople could be assholes. I'm sure this sort of mistreatment happens all the time, and I'm sure that the reason for it is because people behave as described by the Stanford Prison Experiment.