10 ms·
Call of Duty's underlying message is becoming more troubling
- Rygu 13y agoI guess Hollywood started it.
- kbar13 13y agoyet another sensationalist article about a game that's on its way out
- exodust 13y agoThe article is not sensationalist. While it's too short, and only scratches the surface of the topic, his idea is valid and not unfamiliar to people who like or hate these games. I've played these games before and thought "this is American bullshit (for reasons stated in the article).... but kinda fun at the same".
- icebraining 13y agoThe thing is, anyone who plays CoD for a reasonable amount of time (and I know I did, until MW1) spends half the time killing Americans, because the single player is only a footnote compared to the multi player.
- BetaCygni 13y agoI haven't played the game, but doesn't a story line that warns about current (military) infrastructure being used against the population of the U.S. itself sound very dystopian and modern? Yes, it is troubling but that's not a fault of the messenger.
- dmazin 13y agoI agree with your first sentence, but what's being said is troubling is the message that American military power should be unchecked.
- neuroscr 13y agoArt can be interpreted in may ways. Just because the author reads it one way doesn't mean it was the intent.
- dmazin 13y agoBut kids aren't consuming COD as art. Maybe many many years from now we can appreciate it aesthetically, like we do some propagandic speeches, but right now it's very clear that COD drives a very certain message to the people who play it - but now I'm just repeating the article.
- Tohhou 13y ago"It's very clear that every movie you watch is driving a certain message. Also every book. None of that is art. You are so simple minded that these medias can tell you what to think just by existing and without you being able to make up your own mind. Let's ban entertainment that doesn't fall in line with our ideological tow."
- smtddr 13y agoJust leaving this here: http://exclaim.ca/Features/Comics/propaganda_hero-gi_joe_returns_when_america_needs_him http://exclaim.ca/Features/Comics/propaganda_hero-gi_joe_ret... >>"Not co-incidentally, G.I. Joe returned when America needed him most. It was re-launched in September 2001, with the battle against terrorists replacing its ‘80s communist foes.
- streetnigga 13y agoStreet guy with a marketing eye here. I wouldn't read too far into that, loads of others 80s material was getting re-licensed around that time due to us 20 somethings growing monies. This is evident in everything from comics to music. For instance here is a nice tune for you 80s babies, ActRazer - Kill Switch: http://youtu.be/_jhHRth-4qg http://youtu.be/_jhHRth-4qg
- mason240 13y ago[Insert popular video game here] might be just a game, but its underlying message is becoming more and more troubling
- Tohhou 13y ago[Insert popular thing here] might be just a [thing], but its underlying message is becoming more and more problematic. /r/conspiracy is leaking into HN /r/conspiratard would like a word with many here.
- aaronblohowiak 13y agoSpec Ops: The Line was a video game and the message was a good one.
- venomsnake 13y agoBut the gameplay was bad even for modern console shooter. And that says a lot. I loved the cutscenes but the other parts were terrible. It was - slaughter these people in gameplay - watch the cutscene how bad war is. They failed to relay their message with the gameplay.
- usingpond 13y agoThis is literally the laziest counterargument you could make.
- mason240 13y agoSorry, but this literally the same headline about video games we've seen since at least the mid 90's.
- qbrass 13y agoI'm surprised the Splinter Cell games didn't get a closer look. Especially when Tom Clancy's death, and anything NSA related being used for headlines.
- emiljbs 13y agoYou know "it's just a game" does have a lot of mileage left in it if you had to write an article on edge-online.com about the issue. I can promise you that none of those teenagers that play CoD ever even thought about that or even tried to interpret the story at all. In fact, the single-player campaign is just something you do when you get temporarily bored with multiplayer. If a teenage player did think of what the story implies then I am sure that he is also smart enough to think about it further and conclude that that's quite silly. I wouldn't be bothered with what one source tells you (if you look really closely at it) when there are so many other sources of information out there. Especially when that source isn't considered serious by pretty much everyone who plays the game.
- debt 13y agoWhile I agree, I do think this underestimates the power of a person's subconscious. The details outlined in the article might not be explicitly called out in the gamer's mind, but might set a subconscious expectation for it to be the case; that "America is a superpower". When this expectation isn't met in reality, then the user might find themselves defending the position that "America is great" without them ever realizing why they hold that position in the first place.
- dwaltrip 13y agoVery well said, thank you for posting this. It seems to me that humans in general have a hard realizing the powerful subtleties of the subconscious and how it can shape world views/thought patterns over time.
- walid 13y agoI remember playing Half-Life and finishing the game and only after I replayed the intro again did I bother to understand the premise of aliens teleported to us. I only wanted to wind the game. FPS are fun to me because of the speed I have to react and not because of the weapons detail. In fact weapons don't interest me if they don't have a sci-fi feel to them. So yeah, it's just a game.
- belorn 13y ago
- thisiswrong 13y agoThis article raises a valid point, but sadly doesn't fully address it. Are the same group of conspirators who illegally spy on us also pulling strings in Hollywood and at game studios to promote their agenda? This concept may seem hard for certain to believe. But a quick look at history clearly shows that oppressive and feudal rulers have actively promoted different types of story telling/theater acts or bible scripts that implicitly match their agenda. Some articles for your thoughts... http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2012/mar/18/video-games-propaganda-tools-military http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2012/mar/18/video-game... http://www.zerohedge.com/contributed/2013-01-17/government-pushes-propaganda-through-video-games-0 http://www.zerohedge.com/contributed/2013-01-17/government-p... http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2013/01/the-cia-and-other-government-agencies-dominate-hollywood-movies-and-television.html http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2013/01/the-cia-and-other-gov...
- mrxd 13y agoSee also the CIA's role in promoting abstract expressionism during the Cold War: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/modern-art-was-cia-weapon-1578808.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/modern-art-was-cia-w...
- mhurron 13y ago>Are ... [they] ... pulling strings in Hollywood and at game studios to promote their agenda? Only if they always have been. War movies are not a new phenomenon. Couldn't it simply be that the American public are war-mongers and game studios are simply giving the people what they wanted?
- thisiswrong 13y ago> The American public are war-mongers and game studios are simply giving the people what they wanted By that logic GW Bush was simply trying to get reelected when he helped start a false war in Iraq and Obama is simply appealing to his electorate (and perhaps the Nobel peace prize panel) with his assassination programs.
- deleted 13y ago
- benihana 13y agoDoom might be just a game, but it's underlying message that we should be killing demons makes me very uncomfortable.
- gamblor956 13y agoIt always did seem weird that all the demons were trying to escape from hell but we were trying to get to it...
- dwaltrip 13y agoGreat comparison, really provides extra insight into the issue.
- rl3 13y agoThere's far more than the plot lines that are troubling. For example, much is made of the fact that real-life Special Forces soldiers aid in the development of these games for the sake of authenticity. That's great, but that authenticity is then baked into products that paint a wholly misleading picture about the realities of war. The Medal of Honor franchise is also guilty of this. In a much larger sense, it just feels like there's a giant entertainment industry cash grab that's been taking place off of ongoing US conflicts, and it's being masked in soldier worship and flag-waving. In my opinion, this phenomenon only serves to obscure the real sacrifices made by service personnel. This is even more unfortunate when you consider the franchise is heavily marketed on the basis of its supposed authenticity, and its main audience tends to be quite a few years below each game's M rating. I don't even remotely care about violence in videogames, but messaging that resembles propaganda seems troublesome, especially with a younger audience. That said, I realize they're games, and the object of games is to entertain. Therein lies the second problem: Call of Duty games tend to be mediocre at best. The fact their sales are so strong is a testament to Activision's marketing powerhouse.
- saraid216 13y ago> For example, much is made of the fact that real-life Special Forces soldiers aid in the development of these games for the sake of authenticity. I'm really amused at the idea that there are veterans who have been through hell sat in a room debriefing for a bunch of artists and programmers. Also in complete disbelief.
- kyzyl 13y agoGotta pay the bills somehow. I hear most military pensions don't quite cut it.
- throwaway89764 13y ago""Right now we are pretty stacked with consultants," the video-game man responded. "Thirty active and recently retired guys" for one game: Medal of Honor Warfighter. In fact, seven active-duty Team 6 SEALs would later be punished for advising EA while still in the Navy and supposedly revealing classified information. (One retired SEAL, a participant in the bin Laden raid, was also involved.)" http://www.esquire.com/features/man-who-shot-osama-bin-laden-0313 http://www.esquire.com/features/man-who-shot-osama-bin-laden...
- Houshalter 13y agoOh Jesus, it's an American war game, what did you expect? They have to make up fictional enemies in order to have something to fight. It's not realistic and it's not supposed to be. I think it says a lot about the current state of the world, how implausible world war scenarios now seem.
- mistermumble 13y agoEven Hollywood movies now have a global perspective, with storyline and characters that allow people in different regions to identify and own the experience. Wonder why CoD has not caught up with the times.
- dageshi 13y agoBecause people don't buy CoD for the single player campaign they buy it for the multiplayer. So long as the Single Player sets up some nice maps and environments for the multiplayer that's all that really matters in selling the game.
- psykotic 13y ago> Because people don't buy CoD for the single player campaign they buy it for the multiplayer. I assume 'people' means a majority. While I'm not privy to statistics specifically for CoD, one of the first games I worked on (Unreal Tournament 2004) was explicitly focused on multiplayer. It didn't even have a single-player campaign. You could play versus bots and that was about it. In spite of that, comparing sales with server data showed that only a small minority of our customers ever went online, let alone played predominantly online. I'd be surprised if CoD wasn't skewed even further in that direction considering its extensive single-player campaign.
- sliverstorm 13y agoHow about because CoD is a two-dimensional game, and doesn't need to be anything more? People watch movies for plot. People don't play CoD for plot.
- copx 13y agoCall of Duty is bad, not as bad as Harvest Moon though. That game teaches that love is something you buy, turning our children into prostitutes with its underlying message. We must eradicate this filth! http://gamezfile.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Download-Game-Harvest-Moon-For-PC.jpg http://gamezfile.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Download-Gam... And as if the promotion of prostitution were not enough, it is subtle PETA propaganda too! You cannot slaughter your farm animals! You run a vegetarian farm! Instead you have to pet them to make them happy, an act rewarded with better milk etc. Children who grow up playing these games will likely see bestiality as normal!
- pyre 13y agoI can only assume that this is satire, but: > You cannot slaughter your farm animals! You run a vegetarian farm! Instead you have to pet them to make them happy, an act rewarded with better milk etc This doesn't make any sense. You think that if Harvest Moon were more true-to-life that slaughtering the animals would make them happy, and produce better milk? Also, this: > Children who grow up playing these games will likely see bestiality as normal! does not jive with this: > it is subtle PETA propaganda too! As animals can't consent to sex, I'm pretty sure that Peta wouldn't agree with bestiality.
- copx 13y agoThe post was satire, my rant was meant to be nonsense. The linked article over-analyses a game and over-estimates the impact of games in general. If you did the same thing with Harvest Moon you could indeed classify it as pro-vegetarian propaganda and as having a very questionable message about human relationships.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoThere was a time when I believed that art was a reflection of the real world (i.e. art imitating life). But, more lately, I am beginning to wonder about that assumption. For one, the "real world" itself is becoming increasingly virtual, with people now spending hours each day "interacting" with others via technology. Are the lines between reality and the virtual world blurring? And, it's an age-old question as to whether the consumption of violent entertainment begets real violence. The debate started with film, then moved to video games. I believe there is a distinction betwen the formats, in that film is merely viewed passively, while FPS-style games involve the active engagement of the consumer in simulated violent acts. It is hard to imagine that hours of this type of activity has no effect on the human mind. So, while it has been argued that violent entertainment does not lead to a more violent society, I find it increasingly difficult to reconcile the notion of a complete disconnect between mass shootings and other forms of dramatic violence, with the proliferation of realistic FPS games. This is especially so, given that tactics used in the former frequently seem to mimic those of the latter.
- patrickg_zill 13y agoSupposedly, during WWII and before, the military had a problem: only about 50% of the guys with a gun in their hand, were shooting to kill the enemy. That is, about half of their troops felt morally bad about shooting at another human. I think that it quite possible that a side effect of CoD et al, would be that those who played it who later did join the military, would have much less reluctance in shooting at others. Whether this is deliberate on the part of the military or just an unplanned outcome, I don't know.
- emiljbs 13y agoIf they go to the military and act as if it is CoD then the only one that will die are themselves. It is an interesting question though, however cheeky my replies may be.
- angersock 13y agoSo, let's run down the list of some military shooters and observe some themes. Call of Duty--all iterations are basically varying degrees of "America, fuck yeah!". What's troubling (as the article posits) is that the series has basically focused on trying to portray America as an underdog despite the facts of today basically showing that in any knock-down-drag-out fight, we're basically on par with the Empire in Star Wars. We have all the toys and all the troops. Battlefield 1942/Vietnam/2--Not gory, fun gameplay, not serious, not America Fuck Yeah. All sides are represented more or less fairly, and it's more on the "game" side of "military games" than the "military" side. The games are about a level I'd feel comfortable letting a young teen play. Rainbow Six/Ghost Recon (original series)--Fairly brilliant and unforgiving tactical shooters under the Tom Clancy/Red Storm banner. Troops died and stayed dead, one-shot kills were the norm, and honestly anything other than like an hour of pre-mission planning would result in casualties on your team if not a complete failure. Hard. Operation Flashpoint/Armed Assault (Arma)--A brilliant series of military simulators, a slight rebranding of which (VBS2) is used to train actual soldiers. The games do a brilliant job of depicting realistic engagement distances, weapons fire, combined arms, the overwhelming superiority of American air power, and how much you will never ever ever want to be an infantryman. Seriously, my biggest impression playing the game was "Man, I hope to hell I never have to wield a rifle for my country, because that life is short." It's not particularly gory, but the impression of just how fragile people are in modern engagements is hard to shake. It's pretty solid. Spec Ops: The Line--A game which starts as a generic third-person America Fuck Yeah shooter, and then gets darker. And darker. And darker. It's interesting mostly for its story and gore in points; the actual combat is kind of meh. It kind of ridicules the entire AFY and military-shooter mindset, and explicitly mocks the player for participating. It's pretty intense, and I wouldn't suggest it for younger folks. Soldier of Fortune 2--This is what Call of Duty would've been if it was less patriotic, more mercenary, and much much gorier. Every shooter decides to optimize for something, and these folks decided "Hey, fuck it, what is the most accurate damage model we can use for people?". You can sever fingers, joints, render faces a pile of mush...it's quite unsettling, and is very much not a kid's game. ~ The biggest problem I have with the CoD series is that you basically are playing lazily-written and farcical missions, and that the combat is neutered set-pieces. Enemies respawn infinitely in most areas, and gameplay is very linear (levels do not lend themselves to meaningful exploration). The first modern warfare game was at least somewhat restrained in its AFY, but the later entries in the series are way too much "What's the next setpiece going to be? What's the next cool America Fuck Yeah moment?" If a game is going to portray war, it should decide whether it wants to be focus on the fun or on the tactics. Battlefield is a good example of the former, and Arma/Ghost Recon an example of the latter--Soldier of Fortune was fun and messy but not focused on showing war, Spec Ops was commentary over gameplay, and CoD is AFY and young male empowerment fantasies; that is to say, the last few are action movies and not war movies. ~ One of the interesting messages of CoD (and a message implicit and much better argued by example in Arma) is that you cannot challenge America and win. Nope. Can't be done--look at the overwhelming force. It's somewhat interesting to see this indoctrination going on at this point in our national history, especially when the .gov and .mil in the past decades have done so much to show their authortarian and anti-individual tendencies.
- drill_sarge 13y agoCall of Duty isn't even a good shooter. The franchise has become the example of a dull, repetitive and undemanding interactive experience - I don't even say game because most of it are scripted sequences with almost no player interaction or challenge. And the rest of it is uninspired "gun down 10000000 guys walking direct upfront to you who are too dumb to even hurt you". Also this "authenticity" is basically laughable. Because there is none. It is not a authentic war game (like arma) and it is even too dumb, easy and restricted to be a simple straight forward ego shooter (like serious sam). It's the Michael Bay of video games.